Jimmy's Pizza

I live in Laguna Beach, CA and Mom lives in White Plains. Whenever I'm back East, Sal's is always a…read moremust and well worth a visit. The amazing white pie is nothing like we have back West, the friendly vibe, fast service and a classic pizza shop everyone should try. RIP SAL and thanks for your tasty legacy!

Tough to review just a quick stop by the slice. I heard Sal's outdoes everyone else in this part of…read moreWestchester, so I accompanied my pizza fiend - oops, friend - down to Mamaroneck to check them out. And this is a place worth checking out. Old-school vibe inside, not at all like the new-wave joints around. You can tell Sal's has been here for generations, which means they do it right. You walk in, there's a pizza counter to the left, a few tables to the right, some more in the back... and a hidden whole other room! So there will be room for you to enjoy your meal. This review is divided for now. My friend got cheese slices. They're big, thin, covered just right in cheese - win. Crust just the right toasty to hold the slice up. Classic NY pizza we got here - everyone in Fairfield County should visit. I peeked over at the other table and they had Sicilian slices that also look legit, if that's your thing. Plenty of cheese, soft crust, all that. Then there's my side. I had looked at the BBQ place next door and decided "nah, too contrived", so when I discovered the neat-looking slices on their platter were BBQ chicken, I went for them. Well, they actually didn't come out that hot. The thickness of the meat probably got in the way. Then there's the fact they were white slices (since BBQ sauce gets in the way of tomato sauce), but not hepped up with ricotta or other white cheese inside. I'd make those suggestions for improvement. There are also some other bizarre slices on offer - they're not afraid of variety! I'd steer clear of the salad pizza though. So based on just the one visit and everything I saw and tasted - 4 stars. I would want to get a whole pie next time for a fresh-baked experience, see how quickly that goes and if it's done just right. I doubt my review will drop, but it could rise up to 5. To be continued... ... So, I came back a second time with my friend. This time, I wasn't even feeling the pizza vibe, so I went with a meatball... wedge. Which is a sub if you're not from the area. Don't be scared by the name. It was tasty, but as I expected, just meatball, cheese, and some sauce. Actually a better balance of sauce to cheese than the pizzas, I thought. I was a little perturbed that our visiting friend's white slice is just pure ricotta, no white sauce below, no mozz on top. From my second experience, I'm keeping it at 4 stars.

See all

Frankie & Fanucci's Wood Oven Pizzeria

3.7(220 reviews)

0.5 mi

Always a good, plentiful meal in this casual restaurant. They have expanded their offerings…read moreconsiderably and all are delicious. Service is attentive and friendly. The ambiance is that of a reasonably busy restaurant. Worth the trip !

Have been here a few times. Nice venue. Clean, inviting, friendly staff…read more BUT I just had the single worst Chicken Parmagiana ever. The thinnest breaded "cutlet" that was over-cooked and harder to cut than steak. Honestly, I've never seen a thinner slice of chicken anywhere. Even fast-food McDonald's and others have better chicken than what I was served. Further, I specified linguini and got penne. Throw enough goopy mozz and sauce and it passes, huh? I'd have posted a photo here if I could. Not sure that I'll ever return.

See all

Spicy Sausage & Caramelized Onion Pizza

Emilio's Brick Oven Pizza

4.1(60 reviews)

0.4 mi

My go to pizza spot i've been going here since i was like 4. always loved their pizza I never have…read moreany complaints. Customer service is great!

I went here one day for a slice after my doctor's appointment. Although it was only 11am they had…read morethe over fired up with pizza everywhere. I got a cheese slice and a grandma's and it was so delicious that I returned a couple of days later and ate in. That time I ordered a large sausage, onion and green pepper pizza with a house salad. It was so delicious.

Two slices of pepperoni

Emilio's Brick Oven Pizza

See all

Went to Emilio's for some quick cheese slices and amazing!! I recommend if you are on the go and need a quick slice.

Pizza Gourmet Restaurant

3.9(69 reviews)

0.7 mi

Great Family Casual pizza restaurant! Great Pizza but Also Excellent Menu with nice variety and…read moreEvery Meal comes out Delicious and Plentiful!

The mozzarella sticks were a bit limp lol the breading was not as crispy as I'd have liked and…read morelacking a bit of seasoning but the PIZZA! I love a penne alla vodka pizza where they actually put pasta on top! And the vodka sauce was amazing. I think the crust was a bit overdone but I was just happy about getting to eat a solid penne alla vodka pizza with a good sauce and pasta on top.

Broccoli Rabe and Chicken Francese

See all

Jill’s Bar & Restaurant

4.6(49 reviews)

0.7 mi

My family and I spontaneously came here for brunch around noon on a Saturday, and it was stellar…read more Let's first talk about the chairs. I'm still talking about how comfy they were! The menu has some classics as well as twists on standard brunch dishes. I loved my avocado toast, which had some unusual texture that made it very memorable. I was surprised it wasn't too busy for brunch. Don't let the secret out!

I am a little torn on what rating to give Jill's and wish I could give 3.5 because while I think a…read more3 is a little low, I don't think a 4 is the right rating. I also want to preface this by saying that I think this place is a solid choice and it is not a bad place to grab a bite or a drink. I have been a couple of times now. While I would go back again, I wouldn't go out of my way to go there. The ambience is good. It's a nice space and it does have space for both larger and smaller groups. The wait staff is also very nice and I have zero issue with them. The food is good enough, although not spectacular. They are definitely going for a high end bar/brunch/dinner spot. A step up from a local pub, a little bit more of a shine/elegance to them. The vibe is actually great for a larger group. The most recent time we went, our table got steak nachos, a burger, the sweet potato and rice bowl (with shrimp added), and a steak sandwich. The steak sandwich was reportedly really good (I didn't try it) and looked nice. The nachos were fine, not great. Didn't feel like there was enough cheese, but the steak on it was actually really nice. The rice bowl was really not exciting. There was nothing elevated or nuanced about it. The shrimp was the best part and was beautifully cooked and seasoned, but that was an add on and I would have been disappointed with it if not for the addition of the shrimp (which then made the bowl over $25). We ordered the burger medium rare, and it came very well done. To be fair, when we mentioned it to the server, she took it off of the bill, which we appreciated. Overall, I would say the food is hit or miss. Most of our proteins were cooked very nicely and with good flavor, but the other parts of the meal were just fine, not great. The price point is such that I expect a little more for what I am paying. That being said, the staff is nice and the ambience is good, so for a quick and easy meal, it's worth it if you are in the area.

Bar interior

Bao Buns

See all

Pork belly

Augustine's Salumeria

4.4(96 reviews)

0.3 mi

My sister and I were the first ones in the restaurant. There were 4 servers and the manager and…read moreowner were sitting at the bar, so I thought it'd be a good experience. My sister and I ordered food, before anyone else came into the restaurant. My latte came in a soup bowl. I could barely pick it up. We ordered the pancakes and eggs. My entire plate was meat and I had two very small eggs. The bread was very stale and hard. It also took over 45 minutes to come out. Save your money. There are much better restaurants around here.

This restaurant is conveniently located right across the street from the Mamaroneck Metro North…read moretrain station. The decor is tasteful and elegant. They have several tables in the front and additional seating in the back. Our waiter was very kind and accommodating. To drink, I had a mocktail. I was worried it would be too sweet because it included sprite and cranberry juice, but it was actually very pleasant and bursting with flavor. For my main, I had the frittata. It was tasty. Some of the broccoli rabe was a little tough to chew, but not too bad. It was topped with a generous portion of cheese. I loved the tender mushrooms. My husband got the cozze. The portion of mussels was large and he enjoyed the sauce. We also shared the cinnamon french toast, which was delicious. It didn't even need syrup as it was perfectly sweet with the cream and berries on top. Even so, they had several syrups to choose from including amber and maple. Looking forward to coming back to try the dinner menu.

Cacio e Pepe Zeppole

See all

Alessia's Trattoria

4.5(61 reviews)

0.4 mi

Anthony and Antonella are among the kindest, most caring, and supportive people I have ever met…read more They truly embody what being a business owner is all about. I had my bridal shower at Alessia's on June 6th, and I honestly don't think I have ever experienced such incredible service and positive energy. Not only was the food amazing, but the atmosphere was absolutely perfect. What truly sets Alessia's apart is how personable Anthony and Antonella are. They take the time to get to know their guests and make everyone feel welcomed, valued, and cared for. Their genuine warmth and hands-on involvement create an experience that goes far beyond great food and service, it makes you feel like family. Anthony, Antonella, and their staff went above and beyond to help me create the best possible experience for both myself and my guests. Their attention to detail, kindness, and genuine care made the day even more special. Alessia's was already one of my fiancé's and my favorite restaurants, but after this experience, we've also chosen to host our rehearsal dinner there in October. The way they treat their guests is truly exceptional, and it's clear that they put their hearts into everything they do. I cannot recommend them highly enough!

Food was very good. Service was much better compared to last time we came to Alessia's. Lots of…read morespecials to choose from.

Hot Antipasto

See all

Aperol spritz

Village Pizza & Pasta

3.6(23 reviews)

1.2 mi

Excellent pizza and other dishes. Very friendly staff, treat their customers well. My favorite…read morepizza in Mamaroneck. Seating is a little uncomfortable but otherwise, outstanding.

Best cauliflower pizza!! If you can't eat wheat like myself and are gluten free, try their…read morecauliflower pizza. I love White pizza and they make an amazing cauliflower white. Slaps every time.

Second time this happened: Email confirmation says half spinach, half artichoke. Delivery was half sausage, half artichoke.

An hour wait, the cheese isn't even fully melted. I am very disappointed! I've been ordering from this place for over ten years!

See all

Huge chef salad with Italian dressing

Modern on the Rails

3.8(328 reviews)

0.3 mi

Went here for dinner after church on Sunday and it was very nice. The ambiance and decor were…read moreamazing. The outdoor seating was nice as well but the sun was too unforgiving to sit outside. I ordered chipotle calamari for appetizer and hubby ordered clams. Both were good. For entree we ordered the pappardelle with lobster in saffron sauce and the zuppa Di Mare. Both were delicious. I really enjoyed everything from the seating to the service.

Great restaurant in westchester. Spent a day with family hiking and visiting parks and wanted a…read morenice meal to end the day. modern on the rails hit the spot. Beautiful restaurant right next to train station. Parking is free which is great. Building was beautiful inside - upscale and elegant but not stuffy or pretentious. We had on jeans and tshirts (and even shorts) and did not feel out of place. Service was prompt and attentive. The highlight though was the food - it was excellent. Everyone enjoyed their dishes. Highlights were polenta over artichokes, mussels in marinara sauce, cacio Pepe pasta special, lamb chops. Dinner finished on a high note as we ordered Italian donuts- zepoli - that desert was enough to feed table of 6 and had half left over. Beautiful hot sweet donut dough with Nutella and raspberry dipping sauce - sweet paired well with cappuccino and was a great way to finish the meal.

Wedding at Rails

Lobster Ravioli

See all

Event

Sofia’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.7(56 reviews)

1.5 mi

Sofia's is a little pizzeria that's tucked into this quiet street corner among a few other eateries…read moreon Harrison Ave. We've ordered for takeout several times and even dined in on occasion. They remodeled a few years ago and the white tiled dining room is pretty spacious and comfortable now. When we recently ordered several large pies for the office, they delivered a 1/2 hr earlier than expected and the pies were still pretty hot. There were 3 large cheese pies, 1 pepperoni and 1 veggie, but the clear favorite was the chicken bacon ranch pie drizzled with ranch dressing because that disappeared quickly. C'mon, who can refuse bacon? Plus they do a slightly thicker crust than other pizzerias in the neighborhood, they generously pile on the cheese almost as thick as the crust and the number of pepperoni per slice was a lot. The wedge/hero sandwiches are alright, but nothing spectacular. I do want to try the pasta meals though, when we order-in during late night shifts at the office.

This was always one of the best pizzerias around but no more. I assume there is new ownership and…read morecooks in the kitchen. We ordered lasagna and a meatball wedge and both were AWFUL. The lasagna was cooked in the delivery tray and the bottom layer was completely burnt. Sauce was awful and the dish tasted very oniony. Overall not good. The meatballs in the wedge were cold in the middle so obviously they had been frozen. The sandwich was incredibly dry, very little sauce which may have been a good thing since what sauce was on it wasn't very good. Massive disappointment

Chicken Scarpariello Dinner

Large Veggie Pie

See all

Large Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

John J.

9 years ago

The pizza is incredible, by far the best tasting pizza around. Sal's doesn't come close. The only reason it isn't more well known is because the location isn't in the middle of the village, so it often goes unnoticed. Buy a fresh pie and enjoy the best pizza you're ever gonna eat. Jimmy is a great guy too, always very friendly, and great customer service. Great prices as well. read more

Riff M.

2 years ago

My entire family LOVES Jimmy's Pizza, we will be so sad whenever he decides to retire. I hope he shares his recipe with someone else when that happens and they decide to keep the business going! read more

Eryka C.

7 years ago

Personal pizzas were delicious. Plain and pepperoni. Definetly the way to go. 2 personal pizzas filled me and my husband. Will def be back

Steven P.

7 years ago

Terrible pizza, definitely was not fresh. May have been frozen pizza that is pre made and then sits out

George V.

2 months ago

Excellent ! Love this pizza ! Sooooooooo goood. So so good read more

Louise T.

12 years ago

Jimmy's Pizza is best in Mamaroneck. The greatest pizza I had since I been in NY.

Max A.

11 years ago

Great Greek pizza! Jimmy is so nice and cares about clients. Yummy!

Jimmy's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Restaurants near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Things to Do near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Parking near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Desserts near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Coffee near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Shopping near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Breakfast near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Dinner near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Burgers near Jimmy's Pizza

BEST of Mamaroneck, New York Movie Theatre near Jimmy's Pizza

Best of Mamaroneck

Things to do in Mamaroneck

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Jimmy's Pizza also viewed

Broadway Pizzeria of White Plains

(103 reviews)

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Square Pizza - Order it! Just Order it!! Its perfect! So delicious, every…read morebite has a delicious flavor, the crust is so crunchy and even the oil on it is full of garlic and flavor!! And the lumps of sauce on it, what? Why do I feel like its a different sauce then the regular pizza? Its so unbelievably tasty! Thank you for making this pizza!

Love coming here, always the first stop on my trip home. Cesar salad pizza is my favorite, but they…read morehave so many options that look amazing. The napkins have been changed since my last visit to paper thin, so thin the air conditioning was blowing it off my table if I didn't put the salt shaker on it. But the quality of the food and the quickness of service make this my favorite pizzeria.

John & Tony's Pizza

(34 reviews)

Place is a little hole in the wall. I ordered a cheese slice (yes just plain cheese is my all time…read morefave)& a Pepsi. I can tell the sauce was homemade! I'm more of a sauce person.I feel like the sauce makes the pizza instead of anything else. It was very tasty! The crust was kind of thin crust but not quite. It was just the right crisp.The portion was above regular size but not giant. The person who helped me was friendly & his paisanos!

I walked into this establishment thinking I was going to get an old school style pizza slice. What…read moreI got was a bland, half warm/cold pizza slice from people that should not be working wherever the public is being served, they act like they are doing you a favor serving you a below average pizza slice, if the owners are the ones working there on a day to day basis, I suggest you sell and retire before you go bankrupt because of losing all your customers

Pleasantville Pizzeria

4.0

(43 reviews)

Best pizza. Hands down, for me at least…read more There are all kinds of pizza out there, most of them I won't touch. I grew up in the Bronx and if you like pizza from the Bronx this place should be on your list. Did I say best pizza? Yes it's the best. They have good food too, but I stick with the pizza.

My favorite pizza by-the-slice pizzeria in Mount Pleasant. The taste of the condiments,…read moreparticularly the cheese reminds me of Joe's pizzeria in Manhattan. It's a straightforward, thin crust, New York style pizza slice. A little thin and floppy in the front, but with a solid stronger foundation as you eat towards the crust, which allows you to fold the pizza in half (as one should ;)) . The ambience feels like a city pizzeria as well. The owners are very friendly to myself and my little one whom they regularly show hospitality towards. Definitely a neighborhood staple for me. A couple slices of pepperoni and a Coca-Cola and you're good to go.

Crestwood Pizzeria

4.1

(65 reviews)

My family and I have been patronizing this pizzeria for around 30 years now. It is the absolute…read moreBEST pizza I have ever had. The sauce is perfect. The crust, perfect. Unfortunately, I now live in California, but every time we come back to Westchester to visit family, we come HERE. Not only is the pizza great, but they always greet you with a smile and get your order out quickly and efficiently! Do yourself a favor and get your pizza here. You will not be disappointed!

Damn good pizza! Thin crust with the perfect amount of toppings. Plus it's easy to fold. I'm from…read moreNY so I know good pizza and this place hits the mark. The slices are huge so I recommend only getting one unless you haven't eaten for days.

Tutto Italia

4.8

(25 reviews)

Get the heck out of town and go to Tutto Italia - it is the best pizza in Westchester! I had two…read moreslices- the first a plain slice and and an upside down slice with three cheeses on the bottom crust tomato and basil on top. Ice cold can of Diet Coke. The crust on this pizza had a perfect high temperature char on it. On Mondays they have wedges one of which is homemade porecetta with broccoli rabe. Can't wait to try it.

THE BEST!! In the world and I actually wish I was being dramatic. I have never had such good food…read more Frankie is the BEST. Such a hard worker, personable and truly cares about making the best pizza every single time. Consistency you wouldn't be able to find anywhere else in the tri-state area. 11/10 recommend 110% worth traveling hours for Again, not exaggerating. It really is just that good!

Sunrise Pizzeria

3.8

(118 reviews)

The best place for an inscribe variety of Pizza. They will do anything special for you. The owner…read moreand his son give both personal and friendly recommendations.

After running a half marathon here in Rye I was a bit hangry for some carbs. While heading back to…read morethe train station I found Sunrise Pizzeria. Nice little locals pizza joint where you can grab a slice and soda before walking over to the train station. Two slices definitely hit the spot to refuel. Pretty tasty.

4 Bros Pizza

(67 reviews)

Really good pizza and food - very garlicky but I can ask for less fresh garlic…read more However, not always opened on a consistent basis. Closed a lot for local events or randomly. Unfortunate when I am in the mood for a great slice! Not a lot of great pizzerias around here so my only hope is that they can figure out a consistent schedule to be opened.

Really enjoyed their pizza they hosted for a Club West event!…read more I love that their slices are smaller, so it feels more guilt free. LOL. The crust is thin. The sauce has a little sweetness to it, which I prefer in a pizza sauce. The pepperoni was bite size and not large slice that are sliding off the pizza. Can't wait to go back and try more food! Special shoutout to Carlos for the delivery!!!

914 Pizza

(12 reviews)

This little gem is home to one of the best Margherita slices I've ever had. Do yourself a favor and…read morevisit this place.

LOVE the creativity of the menu! Love vodka sauce on pizza even more!! This grandma vodka pie was…read morepretty good, I think the vodka sauce could've had a bit more flavor but the dough was great. Will definitely be returning to check out more of those interesting menu items.

Pelham Pizza

4.3

(231 reviews)

Love this place! Pizza is always great nice and crispy! The guys here will treat you like family as…read moreyou walk in. Real warm place with a lot of history!

The food was amazing! The beers were cold and the shrimp tasted very fresh! Make sure you book your…read moremassage appt with coo coo Michelle @ The time leisure beauty spa & grab a bit to eat AFTER at this delicious pizza place/diner joint! This pizza place was so cozy and family oriented!

Village Pizza & Pasta

3.6

(23 reviews)