Tough to review just a quick stop by the slice. I heard Sal's outdoes everyone else in this part of Westchester, so I accompanied my pizza fiend - oops, friend - down to Mamaroneck to check them out. And this is a place worth checking out. Old-school vibe inside, not at all like the new-wave joints around. You can tell Sal's has been here for generations, which means they do it right. You walk in, there's a pizza counter to the left, a few tables to the right, some more in the back... and a hidden whole other room! So there will be room for you to enjoy your meal. This review is divided for now. My friend got cheese slices. They're big, thin, covered just right in cheese - win. Crust just the right toasty to hold the slice up. Classic NY pizza we got here - everyone in Fairfield County should visit. I peeked over at the other table and they had Sicilian slices that also look legit, if that's your thing. Plenty of cheese, soft crust, all that. Then there's my side. I had looked at the BBQ place next door and decided "nah, too contrived", so when I discovered the neat-looking slices on their platter were BBQ chicken, I went for them. Well, they actually didn't come out that hot. The thickness of the meat probably got in the way. Then there's the fact they were white slices (since BBQ sauce gets in the way of tomato sauce), but not hepped up with ricotta or other white cheese inside. I'd make those suggestions for improvement. There are also some other bizarre slices on offer - they're not afraid of variety! I'd steer clear of the salad pizza though. So based on just the one visit and everything I saw and tasted - 4 stars. I would want to get a whole pie next time for a fresh-baked experience, see how quickly that goes and if it's done just right. I doubt my review will drop, but it could rise up to 5. To be continued... ... So, I came back a second time with my friend. This time, I wasn't even feeling the pizza vibe, so I went with a meatball... wedge. Which is a sub if you're not from the area. Don't be scared by the name. It was tasty, but as I expected, just meatball, cheese, and some sauce. Actually a better balance of sauce to cheese than the pizzas, I thought. I was a little perturbed that our visiting friend's white slice is just pure ricotta, no white sauce below, no mozz on top. From my second experience, I'm keeping it at 4 stars. read more

See all

The place is decent sized I the front with tables towards the back. The food is delicious! I had a margarita slice and a chicken parm sandwich! Let's start with the pizza. Nice crust, very flavorful sauce but not overpowering and a decent amount of cheese. Now this chicken parm was delicious! It comes open. I added some red pepper flakes to mine because I love the kick of heat! Fresh chicken cutlets with a layer of sauce and the right amount of cheese. Not sloppy and a very good portion to share. But if you want to devour it on your own go for it. You might struggle a bit with the rest of the sandwich but it's amazing! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

I love Sal's! I was having a craving for pasta fagioli so I headed there. we ordered the soup, as well as the mozzarella salad with chicken cutlet, eggplant Parmesan entrée, and a few slices of Sicilian. It was the perfect meal! Along with the hot baked bread that they serve with the soup, it was perfection! read more

See all

I grew up loving Sal's pizza. This is my first stop back in New York. Since 1964, they've been serving the best pizza in Westchester County. Their famous Sicilian is widely regarded as the best in NY & it doesn't need any toppings, it's just perfect!. We ordered at the pizza counter, grabbed a seat & got up when we're called. The pizzeria was filed with noisy teens on a Thursday at 7 pm. The slices are more expensive than I remember but larger. The crust is crisp, dough light & the pizza isn't salty but full of flavor. read more

Surprisingly very slow service, there was a huge line and they took our order after a while and we were served our pizzas but they guy who was supposed to grab our drinks kept getting distracted. He took our drink order and pulled our drinks out and set them on the back counter, then started helping another customer and we had to flag him down to remind him our drinks were sitting out and we still needed to pay, so our pizza was getting cold. The pizza was tasty, but I hope they do a better job managing their time next time. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Pleasant, busy pizza place on Mamaroneck Avenue. Can be difficult to park, but worth the walk. Very clean, lots of tables, and very good pizza. Al the employees are very helpful. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Clean - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

Another great meal at Sal's. The pizza is the best. Thick or thin crust with all the toppings. Seating is limited if you eat in, but the pizza is best hot out of the oven. Spaghetti was good too. If you're looking for great pizza, this place is top of the list in Mamaroneck. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - My pizza at Sal's. - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

I came on a Sunday on the first day June and there was a bit of a line and the place was busy! That's how you know it's good! Can't wait to go back and try more dishes! read more

See all

Food is good but staff are not very welcoming unless they know you. Staff give you an uncomfortable feeling when sitting there. I always get my food to go because of that uncomfortable feeling. read more

I live in Laguna Beach, CA and Mom lives in White Plains. Whenever I'm back East, Sal's is always a must and well worth a visit. The amazing white pie is nothing like we have back West, the friendly vibe, fast service and a classic pizza shop everyone should try. RIP SAL and thanks for your tasty legacy! read more

The food is very good and is quite a value. We had a large Sicilian a slice, a salad and some drinks all for around $60- The ordering I think is the biggest weakness, there are a herd of fellows behind the counter and there doesn't seem to be any organized mechanism of taking or entering orders. A little better process would yield huge benefits in this area. Try it, you will like it. read more

This view is Sicilan-based. So I ate here years ago and wasn't impressed. I think we had a plain pie but not sure. I came back to give it another shot but had seen someone's photos of their Sicilian. It looked cheesy and good so that's what I had my sights on. I am going to give it four stars instead of three right now. Reason being, I didn't get to judge the plain so it feels unfair--nor any other menu items. Anyway, there was a great amount of cheese, the crust was good and texture pretty good. However, I felt the flavor was really lacking. At first when I grabbed a little piece of cheese to try I was pleasantly surprised, it tasted good. But as I went on to take bites I felt that it was a bit too mild for me on the flavor. Pretty "mid" I think is the word used nowadays. I would give the Sicilian slice a 4 or 5 out of 10. Service was good, no complaints. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Sicilian Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Have not been here in a long time but the pizza has not changed at all! Such delicious pies.....we had mushrooms, a meat lovers, plain and Sicilian! Amazing! The Sicilian is the best one I've ever had! It was lots of us and didn't get to take any pictures but so worth the 1 hour drive for us!! read more

I got the worst food poisoning last month from here. I suspect it was from the Caesar salad.

Always the standard in Westchester, best Sicilian ever and I will always go there, over 50 years of Sal's pizza and still loving BUT Asking for an opinion here, is it just me or every once in awhile does it seem the Sicilian is not as thick as it used to be??? Went 6 mos ago, almost looked like a grandma pizza but thin Went back and it was perfect, light and quite thick. Went last night, thin again. Please don't tell me that Sal's is shrinking the Sicilian a bit, that would be a bummer. Someone please weigh in and tell me I'm wrong or right? read more

Sal's has had the best NY pizza for at least 40 years. Tonight we ordered on Uber and picked it up. There was a line out the door and a doorman handling the crowds at this modest pizza-by-the-slice joint located in Mamaroneck. The Sicilian pizza has so much cheese and a crisp and chewy crust. We always get the Gorgonzola salad, a very not- fashionable-but-so-delicious salad of iceberg lettuce, tomato slices, Gorgonzola, and a red wine vinaigrette. Eggplant parm is to die for. And the pizzas. Our all-time favorites. read more

Having grown up in Miami I'm no stranger to NY/NJ style pizza, and this is my preferred style (Chicago deep dish/thin and Detroit be damned!) so needless to say I was beyond excited to try some authentic NY pizza. Sal's was EVERYTHING I had hopped it would be; ooey-gooey cheese, crisp spicy pepperoni cups, and the most tangy red sauce, soooo good! The crust was also very nice. Perfect undercarriage, flawless chew, really delightful. The Sicilian wasn't bad either, but definitely not my style. Tho it was a very good slice as well. Overall for the price and for the wait, definitely can't ask for more. Highly recommend stopping by if you're near by. read more

See all

Sal's has been a favorite of mine since I was in elementary school in the late 1960's to the present time. A few years ago, I was extremely sick, and a friend gave me a choice of any place I wanted to eat and I chose Sal's! I have brought friends and family from around the country and world to Sal's all raved about their pizza's! Staff is always friendly and helpful! It's a classic. Not fancy, and no one cares! The lines out the door prove the ambiance is perfect! Lots of happy clients from all over the NYC metro area prove the 5 stars I left! Westchester Magazine has been saying for decades it's the best of Westchester! Don't miss Sal's!! read more

What the heck happened to the Sicilian slice here? Went last year and it was very good. So was the regular. Went the other day and really lousy. read more

The service was extremely poor! I ordered a chicken Parm wedge And the person who supposedly, placed the order never checked on it ! My husband ordered a Sicilian slice and it came within 15 minutes. I was waiting and waiting for my chicken Parm hero and it never showed up ! They checked on the order and apparently it was never placed or the person who was to prepare it never did. They did return my money and said sorry that was it. As I was getting into my car, I turned, around and looked into the store window and I saw the person who took my order eating a slice of pizza in front of the oven and did not give it a second thought. I have been coming to Sal's Pizza since I was a young girl (over 30 years)and I will never return! read more

delicious slice of salad, pizza... Would definitely stop it if it's in the area again... parking is annoying but it's ny read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Always great dating back to the 70's. I'm gonna try and meatball sub for a change. I almost always get pizza. Very busy as usual. Service is very good. You can't beat the prices. And I found parking in front of the post office. read more

See all

I have been going to Sal's for as long as I can remember. Growing up we'd go out for dinner at least once a week to Sal's. Now we do take out on Fridays and it's just as good. Sal's is the place you go to for a homey feeling with some of the best pizza/hot dishes. When I talk to people and they tell me they only eat the pizza, I always tell them they need to get the penne vodka or the gnocchi. By far my favorite two pastas! The people that work there are always the same and some of the nicest people. Service is always great, but plan on waiting to sit at time because sitting is limited. It's worth the wait though! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Sister date! - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Favorite place to go when I visit westchester! The salad pizza is divine. Also really love the Sicilian- you can request the corner if you'd like! Small quaint seating area that does the job for a pizzeria. Also love the garlic knots! This place never misses. Think, crisp bottom, very little droop! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Salad Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Great pizza, Sicilian is crunchy and soft at the same time. Pepperoni is my favorite. No atmosphere but great food

Great pizza by the pie or slice. Fast service. Excellent selection. Close to the train station. No real seating meant for takeout mostly.

You seem to have changed your time honored recipes over the last few months. You went from being something special to just ordinary. This is quite sad. Whomever is making changes to the formula needs to go back to the way you were previously making your Sicilians and salad slices, both are no longer anywhere near as good as they used to be. read more

Pasta delicious Pizza delicious lots of cheeses Very nice packaging for delivery Came on a tray read more

What's not to love? Regular slice? Good! Sicilan? Good! Salads? Fresh and large and generous portions of chicken or cheese. Subs? Surprisingly good when the real focus here is the pizza. Always busy and family friendly. An institution for good reason. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - House salad - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

I guess it took me moving away from the neighborhood to appreciate the BRILLIANCE that is Sals Sicilian Pizza. Truly the best Sicilian you will find anywhere. We flew 3000 miles and One of the first stops we made was to Sals. If you live within driving distance: get yourself here and get a slice of the Sicilian! read more

My father grew up in the area, and this is the best pizzeria in town. The quality of pizza is always great . I recommend it to anyone.. In fact, every time I traveled from Philadelphia to Boston for work, I always stopped at Sal's pizzeria . It's worth a detour ! read more

All I can say is that at $27, the Sicilian pie is a great value to feed your family. 10 generous slices. We had left overs. What is that in my fridge? It looks like delicious lunch to take to work tomorrow. Winning! read more

Sal's is a Westchester institution in its 60th year of serving great pizza. It specializes in "New York" style ultra-thin crust with a blend of cheeses and spices. It's the same slice you'll get from some of New York City's best slice joints. The slices are extremely thin (delicious - but thin) so double whatever your normal slice order is. Servers are friendly and ambience is. . . well, it's a pizza joint. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

ok first of all its the best pizzeria in weschester county and putnam hands down. if you dont agree its cuz you havent had the pizza. my main gripe is a sicilian pie is almost $40 and on top of that its half as thick. i stopped going. too expensive for me. sorry. the only other place you are gonna find pizza this good though is philly or manhattan or queens. read more

After all of the recommendations from neighbors and Westchester Magazine, I finally tried Sal's Pizzeria famous Sicilian Pizza. Reviews were spot on. With Sal's Sicilian, and their regular slices as well, it's all about their ingredients. My wife and I went there last Saturday for lunch and we sat down and devoured our slices. Sal's is a cozy neighborhood spot with adequate seating, lovely family vibe with beer sales as well. I'll definitely be coming back there soon read more

I wanted a quality slice of pizza and decided to try out this place due to the positive reviews. I ordered 3 slices, a chicken roll, and an order of fries via Uber eats. The cheese pizza and chicken bacon ranch slice was okay. All slices arrived cold and needed to be reheated. The buffalo chicken slice and pizza roll were inedible. I've never had a slice of buffalo chicken pizza that I couldn't eat so this was a first. The pizza roll may have been good had it arrived fresh but it was hard and just got harder when reheated. The dipping sauce was watery and also inedible. Needless to say, I will not be ordering here again. read more

See all

I've heard many good things about Sal's from friends and colleagues but had never gotten around to trying it before the other night. I'm generally weary of pizza in Westchester but people have said this is some of the best in the county. With most eateries being closed or takeout only due to the COVID-19 pandemic, I thought this would be a good opportunity to try Sal's out and to support a local business during these challenging times as well. Sal's is old school - it's been in Mamaroneck for over 50 years and is famous for their Sicilian slices. The interior totally emulates an old school pizzeria - I loved the aesthetics and feel of the space. Their menu is mostly pizza with a number of toppings to choose from as well as some staple Italian dishes. I wasn't feeling the Sicilian, so instead I got a regular pie with sausage and hot vinegar peppers. I was also curious about their mozzarella sticks so I picked up some of those as well (I was sharing with others - I can eat but I didn't totally lose control ;-). I called ahead to order and was told 25-30 minutes which was perfect since it was going to take me that amount of time to get there. The pizza was good - in my opinion, the closest I've seen to an authentic NYC slice here in Westchester. The crust wasn't too thick, the sauce was solid, and the toppings were just enough to add good flavor without overwhelming the pie. I thought the mozz sticks were great - they were fried in batter instead of breadcrumbs so they kept their consistency when you bit into it and didn't ooze out cheese or fall apart. Overall, I had a great first experience at Sal's. Is it the best pizza I've ever had? No - but when comparing it to other pizzerias in Westchester it's one of the best, and it can hold its own against NYC. When in Westchester, I would definitely go out of my way to come here - after all, I still need to try that Sicilian. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - pie with sausage and hot vinegar peppers - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Five Star tasting Sicilian pizza slice from this small spot famed for just this thing. Recommended to me by my savvy New Rochelle cousin this place fulfilled the promise. normally not a Sicilian slice guy but this pie was delicious - hyper flavorful sauce and cheese and tasty crust with just the right amount of crunch !!! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Sicilian pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Good hole in the wall pizza place with fresh ingredients and fast service. No bells and whistles, just great NY pizza. I got to try the thin crust and silician crust pizza. I love thick fluffy pan crust style pizza like Detroit and Chicago style so the silician style was perfect for me. It was airy with bubbles and the corner slice had a delicious crispy crust. I got it with fresh garlic, anchovies and mushrooms. Lots of toppings and fresh. I also got to try the thin crust cheese pizza. It lacked on sauce but the cheese was nicely layered. The sausage roll comes with a small container of marinara sauce. A great place to stop for lunch. read more

Plain and simply the best salad slice AND Sicilian slice in Westchester!