We stopped by here after dinner, as we've been meaning to try this place since they opened. We were welcomed by friendly staff, and the place was spacious and clean with several tables you can sit at. We tried the S'mores, Funfetti, Cookie Monster, and Churro with caramel. They were still nice and warm, with a soft middle/inside and crunchy outside. It went well with a scoop of creamy vanilla bean ice cream at home. Definitely a must-try and great addition to local dessert places to visit. read more

See all

Delicious and worth every bite. Milk N Cookies is a sweet little gem! The cookies are perfectly baked -- soft, chewy, and full of flavor. The staff is friendly and welcoming, the shop is cozy, and there's a great variety. If you're visiting the town of Mamaroneck I highly recommend for any cookie lover! You will not be disappointed! read more

See all

We stopped in after dinner across the street for some sweet treats to go. It was close to closing so we were limited to what they had left. I decided to go with the Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie. Like a few other cookies shops the cookies are meant to share or eat in more than one sitting. My cookie was ok the flavor combo of oatmeal and chocolate chip was different. I would like to try them again when they have more menu options available and the cookies are freshly out the oven. I think that may enhance the experience. Just A Note: Parking can be hard to come by. read more

See all

Hmmmm Very very cool store The place is echoic like none other You literally could whisper on one corner and hear it in another. Sounds like you are in a cave. If you want to eat there--and others in store--forget it. Echo is bad and no tables. Lighting sis superb . The stuffed cookies--which I had before just not last night-- were, as far as stuffed cookies go, ok. Ice cream seemed like it could have been the real thing but the fact that I'm not sure should tell you something. Prices are a bit expensive but these days everything is. Acoustics of zero and no tables plus average (at best) ice cream makes this a 2. read more

Milk N Cookies - Entry - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Kudos on the creative aspect...great concept. We had the plain chocolate chip and trip chocolate...they were good...but not great. I prefer the consistency of Crumbl a bit better. The stuffed cookies may have a better consistency. I'll be sure to try one of those next time. We also had a vanilla cone which was about $7 regardless of the amount of topping you add...or none at all. We decided to get a plain cone...and didn't sit well to pay $7 for a plain cone. But the concept of having unlimited topping for a set price may be appeaking to some...especially those who like to load up on toppings. On a good note, the soft serve vanilla was very good. Large open and clean space with a few barstools and counter along the sides. Metered parking along Mamaroneck Avenue. read more

See all

These cookies reminded me of Levain bakery cookies. The only issue I had with these cookies was the lack of moisture. They were too dry. The chocolate chip walnut cookie were better than the chocolate chip cookie in moisture. Overall, the cookie sweetness ratio was right on...these weren't too overall sweet. I liked the cookie swell and shape! But, I just wish the cookies weren't super dry. I'll stick to Levain Bakery cookies. For others who want to come here, I read the stuffed cookies taste significantly better. I just prefer chocolate chip cookies for my usual cookie order so I didn't try the stuffed cookies. read more

Milk N Cookies - Chocolate Chip Walnut and chocolate chip cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

The service was great and friendly but what I can't understand is having all these cookies on trays with no signs as to what they are? You have to ask every time which is what and it takes forever. The server is usually one maybe two people and it would go so much faster if they had more info. The presentation is simple and basic. The cookies are decent. Honestly a bit overpriced in my opinion. I paid $25 for 4 cookies and I left the kid a tip so closer to $28. Not a bad place but not my number one spot. read more

Today's review (10/15/23) is mostly about the service here. Dude running the place by himself had quite a lot of plates to juggle; baking cookies, making milkshakes, ringing up customers etc. My advice if you're looking to explore Mamaroneck: park on one of the side streets by the library - don't bother with Mamaroneck Ave. Milk 'n Cookies also always smells so good! You can either smell the soap they just washed the floors with, or the cookies being baked - nice touch. Prices here are a little extreme. Around $5 per cookie, and $11 for a milkshake. Not bad! read more

Big stuffed cookies are a thing now, apparently. At almost $4.35 a pop, and not being a huge cookie person, these are extremely satisfying. The classic brookie (half brownie and cookie) is so far my favorite. No photo, sorry. I inhaled it. I was expecting the churro cookie (stuffed with Nutella) to be disappointing, but it was great. And for the curve ball, I hate classic Italian rainbow cookies, but they had a cookie that was their take on the classic and it was surprisingly good! It was not as rainbowy inside as the picture on the wall suggested, but tasty nevertheless. read more

Milk N Cookies - Rainbow cookie? - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

I had wanted to try this place for awhile. I pass by all of the time. Finally, I stopped in. They have so many cookies and it smelled heavenly! I tried the s'mores cookie and the triple chocolate cookie. They were both really enjoyable. The triple chocolate cookie was my favorite. I love chocolate! The s'mores cookie was sweeter but it was good. I would definitely stop back again soon to try other flavors. This is one of two of their locations. The other is in CT. I'm glad I stopped here and tried their cookies! read more

Milk N Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

Fun flavors, nice staff, delicious cookies, and in a bustling location. My friend and I really enjoyed our desserts from here. read more

Milk N Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Man do I love a good cookie. It is my dessert of choice. So I was excited to find this place. Now I'll start by saying they are kinda expensive. $4.35 per cookie. Yes the cookies are big but not almost $5 for one. The taste. The Cookie Monster was good. A little dry on the sugar cookie park but the cookie dough inside was good. And ummm your bowels will change color from the amount of blue dye in this cookie. The s'more was my favorite. Not dry, the marshmallow was still gooey. The Oreo cheesecake was also good. The chocolate chip cookie was my least favorite (and my daughters). It was very dry and the flavor just fell flat. We split each over 3 days and this was the one we had the same day and it was the driest and neither of us finished our piece. Service It was around 7pm on a Monday so dead. The worker (appeared about college aged guy) came right out and helped us. He was not rude but definitely also was not friendly. Just took our order, answered my question about which was what, and rang me up. I'll definitely return to try other flavors. read more

See all

Amazing cookies! and ice cream is even better. Nicky was very helpful and kind when I was placing my order. Definitely will be back

Super tasty ice cream cones and cookies. Have been here twice and enjoyed my experience both times. Found Milk N cookies on Yelp, and really enjoyed it so I decided to bring some friends. The cookies are yummy and definitely not your typical chocolate chip cookie. For ice cream I ordered the vanilla soft serve with lucky charms added and it was very good. The shop was beautiful decorated and it definitely a good chill spot to grab a small treat. read more

Milk N Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

the cookies are so warm and leave you wanting more and the service is excellent would definitely recomend the shakes as well!! read more

Milk N Cookies - froot loop shake - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

This place is a stoner's dream. The cookies and cereal milkshakes are everything! For cookies, I ordered the Cookie Monster (4/5), the Oreo Cheesecake (5/5), the churro (5/5), the funfetti (4/5), the triple chocolate (3/5), and the oatmeal apple pie (5/5 this cookie is amazing!) they were all delicious! My recommendation is have milk handy if you're going to have the chocolate cookies. For a milkshake.....I got the most amazing thing ever. Cinnamon Toast Crunch, with M&M's, drizzled in chocolate. Most delicious shake I've ever had in my life. They actually ground up Cinnamon Toast Crunch to make the base for my shake. This place is worth a stop by if you're in the neighborhood! read more

See all

Is there anything more comforting than the smell of freshly baked (chocolate-chip) cookies? When Milk opened in Mamaroneck, I was curious. Really like their trays filled with cookies against the modern and minimal subway tile design. And loved their intense black, Milk N Cookies logo- spread on their white flooring. Well-placed spot lighting, creates a relaxed vibe. What would make it really comfortable though- are some small cafe 2-seater tables- considering the large space they have. Other than that, Milk smelled heavenly. Didn't expect their cookie size to be that large. I mean.... those suckers were big- but still went for 2 Chocolate Chip Cookies, 1 Churro-filled and an Oatmeal, Apple Pie-filled to bring home. I'll be honest- I liked the moist, buttery and soft center in the cookies. Plus love how Milk N Cookies- doesn't skimp on chips either. And even when we got home, cookies that were already warmed, had cooled heading home. Popped a Chocolate Chip and the Oatmeal-Apple Filling in the microwave for 15 seconds and were amazing. The cookies sort of worked for me. There were plenty of Chocolate Chips and the Churro-filled, was very nice. But my only gripe again......is their bombastic size. Seriously though, Milk takes a good jab at some of their selections and taste was definitely there. I like they're trying to cover all the bases with their different flavors and setting themselves apart from offering the typical cookie. But I'm not sure if Milk nailed the best cookie size. read more

See all

I first discovered Milk N Cookies after a number of my friends sent me a Journal News article highlighting the business and its impending opening. After a quick skim I instantly got hyped - I'm a fan of dessert spots like these so I immediately smashed the bookmark button. I couldn't wait very long though, so I grabbed my brothers and made up an excuse to go to Mamaroneck so that we could try some cookies. Located on the main strip in the town of Mamaroneck, Milk N Cookies pops out from its surroundings due to the openness of the space. The aesthetics are super modern with white walls, clean lines, and minimal decor. You basically walk into a large space with the counter set on the back wall. There's no seating, and a number of reviews here complain about that - but I get it and am not bothered. It seems they're really aiming to capture the essence of similar dessert spots in NYC - the aesthetics and menu remind me of a cross between Milk Bar and Levain. Dare I say this place looks almost *too* trendy for Mamaroneck - especially because of the concept and the fact that they stay open until 2am. Judging by face value, MnK looks like it would be more at home in White Plains or New Rochelle than in one of the villages. The obvious star of the menu is cookies; MnK is actually an official vendor of Duchess Cookies, a company based on Long Island. Additionally, they have some ice cream selections (including vegan options) plus cereal and associated beverages. Walking in, the place was pretty crowded - especially for 8:30 on a Thursday night in the 'burbs. There was a line but it moved at a pretty good pace, so before we knew it we were at the front of the line. We came for cookies, so that's what we directed our attention to. They had a number of them on display, and said that the other flavors on the menu were being made if we wanted to wait. We decided to work off what they had ready, and chose the Oreo cheesecake, Funfetti, chocolate peanut butter chip, and chocolate-pretzel-sea salt caramel (or something like that). The cookies were big and warm, but overall I was left underwhelmed (which brings me to why I'm giving them a 3). The Oreo cheesecake was pretty good - the cheesecake filling was kind of runny but out of all the ones we tried had the biggest flavor. The caramel-choco-pretzel one was okay as well - nice balance of textures. Chocolate peanut butter chip was disappointing, mainly because I was expecting big flavors that fell short. Finally, Funfetti was probably my least favorite - it just had a generic cakey taste and the texture inside the cookie was a little off. *sigh* Service was fine - the woman taking care of us was friendly and upbeat, though the man ringing us out barely acknowledged us - telling me my total and a 'thank you' would have been nice. Overall while I like the whole concept, I was underwhelmed by the product. The cookies weren't bad, but they just didn't stand out as being destination worthy - and if they want to emulate the NYC dessert spot vibe, they need to cater to more than just the locals. That being said, I understand they've been open for less than a week - so the kinks are probably still being worked out. I'll be back though, I want to try more of their cookies and possibly some of their cereal creations. I really hope this business succeeds - if anything they're introducing a concept that's rare to non-existent in Westchester, but we'll see. read more

Milk N Cookies - clockwise from the top: chocolate peanut butter chip, salted caramel pretzel chocolate (something like that), Funfetti, Oreo cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

What an amazing concept and location! Stumbled upon this place while traveling through New York and couldn't be happier with this find! If you're a cereal lover, an ice cream lover, and/or a cookie lover, then this is definitely the place for you! The possibilities are endless here! They have a big choice of cereals to pick from, that will eventually get added to your ice cream and blended together. I chose to mix vanilla ice cream with Cinnamon Toast Crunch, topped with a caramel drizzle. It was amazing! Their stuffed cookies were calling my name, so I couldn't leave without at least trying one. So I chose the Oatmeal Apple Pie cookie! It's basically an oatmeal cookie, stuffed with apple pie filling! If I could have taken the entire tray with me, I would have. Those cookies were that good! They're soft and gooey, especially right out of the oven! read more

Milk N Cookies - Ice Cream Cup - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

I think the general consensus around this place is approximately correct. The interior is nice and it presents well, but I don't love the price or the quality of the product. I would say the cookies are better than the ice cream. Store was fairly empty so we were served quickly and well. I suggest they focus more on improving the quality of the cookies. read more

The cookies are not the best and especially for the price , it's quite horrendous . I ordered both the s'mores and chocolate chip cookies for the first time . Both had a taste of an oatmeal raisin base. Not a go to for me . Price is overpriced for little and low quality based cookies. read more

See all

Was excited to go and grab some cookies! I know they had vegan ice cream which was great, but when we asked the staff about vegan cookies they said they didn't know if the cookies were but that they think they were made without eggs. I feel like if you work there, you need to know about the items. Cookies are super thick so have a drink nearby. They didn't seem to have the cookies on the menu, but did have other options. Slight disappointment in the visit. read more

The most disgusting cookies I've ever had, undone and overpriced. If you want to risk having a heart attack from the insane amount of calories then sure, maybe give it a try, but i without a doubt prefer store-bought cookies. read more

Don't let the wafting smell of freshly baked cookies fool you. I was really excited for this place as the area is lacking bakeries that specializes in chunky cookies. I ordered the strawberry cheesecake cookie and the oatmeal apple crumble. The strawberry cheesecake has a very artificial aftertaste to it. I guess it should be expected considering the cookie is pink and there is edible glitter in it. Oatmeal apple crumble was better, but not by much. It isn't very flavorful. read more

Milk N Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Overpriced...I don't know so much about cookies but I do know that as large as the cookie was it still wasn't that impressive to warrant $5.25. The next order of business that I'd like to attend to is the cost of the chocolate milk I'm sorry the chocolate almond milk that was sold was $4. you can buy silk dark chocolate almond milk 8 fluid ounces 6 per pack 3 packs per case. For about $30. That means that the cost of each silk single serve almond milk would break down into...1.67. and these people have the audacity to sell it for $4? Gtfoh...not worth the money. read more

Milk N Cookies - Fancy shmancy box with not much substance for the money I spent. - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

This was an amazing experience and treat. The fact that I can combine my two favorite things to eat into one is mind blowing. The organization was very clean, they had too many combinations and options to counts which will keep me coming back. The I decided to go with s'mores cookies & oatmeal cookies and and Cookie Crisp milkshake. I highly recommend this place and anytime I'm in the area I will definitely visit for a treat. read more

See all

Came here last night after hearing about it from friends and had a great time! There are a bunch of cookie flavors and they also sell ice cream with cereal toppings! The cookies all looked really good! I tried the cookie monster and a friend had the s'mores. Both delicious! I got a vanilla milkshake with fruity pebbles and loved that. They have a lot of cereal choices to put either on top of your ice cream or mixed into a milkshake. They also have some other toppings and drizzles. Everyone I was with loved what they got! We came around 10 and it was not crowded at all. They are open until 1 am which I think is awesome! The staff was friendly and it is an a convenient area that had a lot of parking. I would definitely come back here and recommend it!! read more

Milk N Cookies - fruity pebbles shake - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

Awesome cookies. They are so soft on the inside, like cookie dough (obviously). The cookies aren't cloyingly sweet and there's something for everyone. Both classics and more eclectic choices. They are pretty expensive at almost $5 a cookie but truthfully I'd buy it again. read more

Milk N Cookies - Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

See all

I've been to Milk N Cookies about five times probably since they've opened, and I must say I'm a bit disappointed often. The availability of the traditional chocolate chip is typically a given, but otherwise it is hit or miss. I understand that they could run out, but they could also make more as they're open until midnight most days and 2 am on weekends. It's disappointing to come / bring a friend for dessert and then you don't have the Oreo cheesecake cookie. The ordering process is horrible. The cookies often don't have labels or describe what they are and everyone sort of just congregates in front of the counter. They should maybe have an order here, pay here, and some labels for which cookie is which to help the flow better. The cookies themselves are great, for one bite. They are so sweet and filling and a true cookiegasm in your mouth. Big fan of the s'mores cookie. So soft, gooey and tasty, but I totally struggle to eat a whole cookie especially if it's stuff'd. I also think it'd be cool to have a stuff your own option, but I am pretty sure these cookies are purchased from a wholesaler (Westchester cookie co), so that wouldn't be totally possible. read more

See all

Absolutely not worth the hype at all. Came in on tonight (Saturday) and was extremely let down. Waited 30 minutes in line to get to the front to find out they don't even have any chocolate chip cookies, and didn't plan to make anymore? Chocolate chip is the foundation of the cookie world and y'all aren't going to make any more on a Saturday hours before you close? The cookies I did get (Cookie Monster and funfetti) were hard on the outside and not in the good crispy way but rather old stale cookies. The Cookie Monster cookie was also dry with no flavor and the center was straight fudge. The funfetti cookie was basically raw in the middle even though the outside was hard. Hoping this place can figure out their supply vs. demand as well as a better overall process for their customers. read more

See all

I was kinda excited that another ice cream place was coming to the Ave. I knew it's gimmicky (maybe Insta worthy?) and I knew it was overpriced but it was an extremely underwhelming experience. The line was rather long and it would appear most cookies they didn't have or one was offered a 5-15 min wait. No samples, no detailed description of the cookies flavors or ingredients. A lot of people attempted to wait which accounted for most of the people on the store. The cookie I ordered was the salted caramel one and it was raw within the first bite. Or maybe, so gooey that it is still soft in the middle hours after buying it. Tasted fine, nothing amazing. It also didn't travel very well in the bag I was given after a 10 minute wait for ice cream. For $22.82 I received two uneven cups of ice cream. Which is basically vanilla ice cream with a small serving of cereal smashed into it. Close to a flurry. It comes with one topping and one drizzle. But no drizzle was offered. Everything else is 50 cents more. There is one ice cream mixer towards the corner. I noticed that one can't really watch their ice cream being made to ensure it's right or make the price tag with it. I also notice there seems to be no real way to keep the area allergen free. It would be risky if one had an allergy to peanuts or chocolate to order something without those allergens due to the one ice cream machine. Half the order wasn't even right but with no number system and clear communication between staff I figured it was time to cut my loses. My small child had enough and was bored. They had no to go cups and no seats for small children to eat (thought seats were mentioned in the initial reviews) it was a struggle to get the ice cream home in the middle of winter. I was surprised because I have never been not given the option for take away when there is no seating. I am interested to see how long it will last with two other ice cream locations on the Ave and Rita's re-opening soon. read more

Milk N Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

I've been anticipating the opening of Milk N Cookies for a while and finally got a chance to stop by. I got there around 4 PM and the store wasn't too busy. After perusing the menu I made up my mind of what cookies I wanted, however they didn't have available at the time so I ended up just getting the unicorn cookie and the funfetti cookie. Two cookies came out to just about $10 which is kind of crazy, but they are decent sized. The unicorn cookie was very indulgent as it was stuffed with cheesecake filling. I ended up only eating half and saving the rest for later. The decor inside is sleek and clean. Very modern, but they have no tables or chairs. The whole process seemed to want to get you in and out as fast as possible. Due to prices I would consider this a "once in a while" treat. Hopefully next time I can try the cookies I had originally had my eye on! read more

Stopped in for a snack this Saturday afternoon, what a great place! Very clean, and good variety on the menu perfect for your sugar fix. I chose to get the Cookie Monster and had it immediately, it was still warm and crispy on the outside. The chocolate chip inside was exactly as you'd expect it, gooey and delicious...would definitely get again when in the area and highly recommend. read more

First, to all the vegans: cookies are made with flour, milk, eggs, butter and sugar! Sorry to burst your hipster bubbles, but this is why they are yummy. Yes I know your crazy hippie aunt Petunia made vegan no-bake blobs of tapioca flour and almond milk, but that's not a f&@!ing cookie! That is a military ration/dog biscuit. Also: the lines have died down, so it's pretty normal in there now, got my cookies in less than 2 minutes. Finally: expand your mind beyond chocolate chip folks, this place's speciality is their stuffed cookies. And no, they are not undercooked in the middle, that is luscious, gooey filling. It's like a chicken pot pie, but it's a cookie! Now enjoy, and stop with the ignorant reviews. This place is too good for Westchester to handle. read more

Overly priced wannabe hipster establishment. Cookies are good but overpriced service is decent.

Good dessert. Always a good late night cookie spot and always quick service. never had any issues.

I was just taking a casual afternoon stroll when I happened to stumble upon this delicate, adorable bakery. Curious about what exactly they were selling, I couldn't help but go inside. My! An assortment of round, colorful cookies blessed my eyes. When I asked the cashier if there was filling in the cookies, they kindly took the time to answer my question, along with quite a few others. I ordered the unicorn cookie, which transported me to a magical, heavenly realm. The warm, gooey strawberry cheesecake filling, the sparkling glitter and rainbow colors, and the softness of the cookie was enough for me to imagine what true unicorn magic tastes like. I will definitely be stopping by again soon--to try many other flavors and to be transported to new realms of deliciousness! read more

Definitely a plus for Westchester County! That is the cookies I get in Manhattan! In fact there is a place in the gansevort market that has these exact cookies. The cookies were very good. We ordered the s'mores and the triple chocolate cookie. Both were very good. read more

Milk N Cookies - S'mores and triple chocolate - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York

I have been here a couple times and love it always. Not too sweet, unlike typical cookies Always so fresh and warm Best cookies! read more

I loved the decor, and the smell when you walk in is divine!! I got a cookie with cereal ice cream on top. The warm cookie was delicious, I just wish it was a little chewier but that's just my personal preference. The cereal ice cream was so-so. I don't know if it was just an off day but I've just had much better cereal infused soft serve else where. Overall yummy, and def worth the experience. I'm not totally sure if I'd return because it was a little pricey but more of a niche dessert spot. read more

Milk N Cookies - Chocolate chip cookie with reese puff cereal soft serve on top! - Bakeries Near Me - Mamaroneck, New York