The suburban charm of Armonk is only enhanced by the most handsome desserts delivered to you by Sugar Hi. It tastes like.... It tastes like.... What??? Watermelon Sugar Hiiiiiii. A hidden gem within a hidden gem. In the beginning of where the burbs begin to look like the boondocks - A small downtown with an upscale feel throws its trunk into your funk. You, typically aloof and nonchalant, decide to let your hair down and groove. That cutie patootie broke your itty bitty heart and you know what else? When was the last time you done busted a move? Huh? BUST A MOVE. I took a chance, solo dance. I detected this dessertery online and saw limited evidence of the existence of Sugar Hi. But... I, a gentleman, wanted to surprise a sick somebody with some sick sweets. So I made the drive, unencumbered and uncucumbered. I, rather devishly, swag stepped (trademark) into the facility. Twas' frightened I'd be the one adult in a child's wonderland. I was. But I've since gotten over it. Over myself. I have no self respect anymore, and it sooooo looks good on me. My pet mule Paco agrees. Sometimes. Sometimes I wish I'd climb a top a mountain in the Catskills range. Lay down, look up into the stars and wake up 20 years later. Post-Revolution. A full 20 revolutions. Call me Rip Van Winkle. I need a spark, a twinkle. Come winter, when I reallllly let my love handles untwine, my hope - Neigh (Ha) - my belief - Negative - I KNOW that Sugar Hi can provide that spark for me. And why do I know that to be fact? BECAUSE SUGAR HI HAS THE BEST COOKIES IN WESTCHESTER. Da best? Best. I promise you that, and if my promise is no good then what's this all about? I'm elite, you should bow down to my feet. Don't doubt me. What? You heard that right. You unexploratory Westchesterites. Get off your wanna be baddy booties, steer yourself onto your nearest thruway and get ready to play. These pups are in the 9's. Ouchy mama. The Trash Can can getttt it. Chocolate chip. Da brownies. Da pudddd. Oh da puddd. Da Swedish fish. Get out of my way. Daddys coming home. Winter came early. Santa clause is coming to town. One foot in front of the other. Where's Fred Claus when ya need a brother. Douse me in some of the Elf's syrup, call that a North Pole smother. Come baring a box of these bad boys and see what happens under the mistletoe. Linguini B, bringing you Christmas in September. The weather is calling for it. I predict plenty of snow HOHOHOOOOOO! read more

Sugar Hi - Wowza - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

Everything was great about this place from the moment you walk in. Thank you so much for the most Beautiful cake ever. It was the highlight of the party. How did you get it to glitter lol Thank you again read more

See all

Only because I feel like I got ripped off. Paid the same price for small cones and one had barely any ice cream in it. I'm so sad. I got more ice cream in the sample honestly. Don't think I will give it another try. :( read more

Sugar Hi - a variety of candy in a store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

See all

This is a great place. I was brought treats from here and was pleasantly surprised. They were fresh and delicious. I'm a chocoholic and love great desserts. I'd definitely come back here to try more of their chocolate-y options. read more

Sugar Hi - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

See all

I pop in here every now and again to get some sweet treats for the lady and I. It's also a clutch Valentines Day stop as the day approaches. They have a crazy array of home made baked goods like the naughty brownie in the photo. So many cool desserts to try as well as candy and ice cream. The staff is super friendly and helpful. Recommend it for getting the sweet fix and for the other gentlemen out there looking for a good Valentines Day surprise and some brownie points at home. read more

Sugar Hi - Naughty Brownie - Fudge brownie / Oreo / chewy chocolate chip cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

This cafe was very warm and welcoming. My family and I were greeted at the door and given an explanation of how the buffet works. There is one side for breakfast and the other for dinner. We all only had breakfast, but it was good. We also had the mimosa. I believe we had the Sugar Hi Surprise, which wasn't on the menu I believe but it was a mix of different juices and it was tasty. During our meal, the owner came out to introduce herself and give us more information about the place. It was such a lovely story which only made the experience even more wonderful and personal. If you are ever in Nashville, definitely give this place a try! :) read more

My experiences with Sugar Hi have been nothing short of incredible. In addition to a few trips to the store, I had the pleasure of enjoying their treats at parties and gatherings for years. While they seem to rotate the menu often, my favorite, BY FAR, is their cake jars. I'm looking forward to many for years of decadent treats and crazy designs (picture of a cake from a bat mitzvah a few years ago). Keep up the good work! Pro-Tip: The cookies and cake jars ship really well. Keep that in mind for gifts. read more

Sugar Hi - Sugar Hi custom cake from a Bar Mitzvah I attended! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

Wow, this place is spectacular. Spoke to the husband of the chef today, who has been a longtime caterer who's opened her own business. I tried her Chocolate and Marshmallow fudge cookie and, guys, this is outrageously good. I'm already scheming how to go back tomorrow. Get this cookie, no matter what. Also get the Homemade Strawberry Pop tart. And heat them both up for extra amazingness. Next up for me: the cookies and cream slice of cake, banana cream pudding and the bowl of "cake scraps." 5 stars!!!!!! read more

Sugar Hi - OUTRAGEOUS deliciousness - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

I'm hoping it was just a fluke but I was not impressed with the selection. Maybe because I went on Saturday at around 5 but I didn't find much to choose from. I did get the classic brownie though and it was delicious! read more

Sugar Hi - Classic brownie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

See all

If you're looking for sugar overload this is the place to be! Too many goodies to list here. I got the regular Ring-Ding and my wife got the peanut butter one. Both the excellent. Ice cream, unique candies, cookies, cupcakes, you name it it's here. Excellent! read more

See all

Came here to fulfill my craving for some chocolate, I am lucky we came across this place. I would be back here again in a few weeks. read more

See all

Good place but the women that work there are very angry. You would think a bakery would have people working with a positive personality. Felt like I was dealing with tow truck drivers. read more

The place to go for a sugar fix. Creative desserts and cakes. They also have freshly baked goods, custom cakes, premium ice cream, trendy freak shakes, hand crafted chocolates, liege hot waffles and a huge selection of bulk and novelty candy. If you are the Armonk, you must visit. read more

Sugar Hi - Sugar Hi - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

See all

Went there because I was craving banana pudding. The flavor was okay. The cup I had had more of the Nilla wafers than pudding. The cashier was friendly though. read more

OMG these cookies are insane!! I went to sugar hi and had such a good experience, the staff was friendly and inviting. the girl offered to grab me warm cookies from the back that had just came out of the oven she was very sweet. Highly recommend. read more

Sugar Hi - a box of cookies and pastries - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

Baked goods are overpriced. Go to beascakes down the road for fairer prices and much better quality

My daughter and I took a ride over to try out this new sweet shop after seeing it in the online Westchester Magazine. We decided to try some ice cream, a Pop Tart, the homemade Ring Ding and a Cake in the Jar. Upon first appearance, the shop is nicely decorated with plenty of seating. Yes as advertised they have a pay by weight wall of candy. We did not go for the candy wall as we were there for some of the homemade treats. The ice cream was good. I had Cappuccino Explosion and she had Fudge Brownie. Next cost we will go all out for one of their famous milkshakes!! We took the rest of our treats to go. At home we had a taste test. First was the "Cake in a Jar". Very tasty looking, very cute packaging. The cake itself was yummy as was the frosting, my daughter loved it. Her only complaint was the layer of sprinkles being to much. The "Ring Ding" was awesome!! However, very sweet and it was large with a lot of creme filling. We only ate half because of how sweet it was, definitely great with milk!!! Here is where the 5th star went. I'm sorry to say that we both did not like the chocolate "Pop Tart". It was a very dry pastry, and even though it has a chocolate fudge like center it doesn't work to moisten the pastry. Our other issue was that it seemed to leave a unpleasant after taste. So we really enjoyed Sugar Hi. My daughter has already chosen some of their other desserts to try next!! I see the S"mores bar in our future for sure!!! read more

Sugar Hi - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Armonk, New York

We had Sugar Hi make a customized birthday cake for a party of 70 people. The cake was an amazing hit with EVERYONE! The design was incredible to reflect the sailing and sunset love of the birthday person and the taste was better than any cake we have had before. Scott and Hillary were a pleasure to work with and a creating a unique cake and having it ready for the big party. Can Rave have enough about them and Sugar Hi. read more

I think you can make almost anything tast good, when laced with excessive amounts of sugar. So no real skill or unique product being offered at this facility. read more

Like most reviews, this place has got sweets down to a science. Even if you don't enjoy sweets, the color scheme of SugarHi is so appealing just from driving by that you just want to go inside and pretend you're a kid in a candy store again. Having tried a majority of items here, and not being a sweets person, I can honestly say they truly perfect each and every item. For example, I dislike ice cream, but I can't stop eating their mint chocolate chip. Some of my other favorites are the cookies N' cream cake, chocolate covered Oreos, and the rainbow cookies. 5 stars for the food, and 5 stars for the atmosphere as well. The interior is black and pink, with a seating room for small parties or those who want to demolish some sweets right at the store. The weighted candy selection is right to your right when you walk in which makes it hard not to buy a 10 lb. bag! Anyways, the chef makes amazing cakes and really knows how to keep her customers yearning for more. See you soon, Sugarhi! read more

Everything is great, from the cakes, cookies, candy to ice cream. Service also is top notch!

The cake was cute and did taste very good. It was a well spent $48 for a special occasion. I'm giving three stars because I'm not a fan of poor customer service. Truthfully I should give it only two. The girl behind the counter acted as if I was annoying her just by being there. My visit to the bakery took no more than 5 minutes but her attitude was vile the entire time. If I didn't need the cake that same day I would have taken my business elsewhere. While the cake was good I won't be using this bakery again. read more

Sugar hi never disappoints. My friends and I came after school on a hot day, and are eating the best ice cream of our lives. It is not too expensive, and the ice c cream flavor itself. I recommend coming here anytime, because Everything is good. read more

Tl;Dr: Was condescended to for delivering to wrong door, and not tipped on an order for them ($100+ dollars of ingredients delivered to the store) Not a customer but someone who's done delivery for them. I work for a 3rd party delivery app which supplies the majority of my income (not gonna use company names). Last week I was sent to shop an order for them which basically entailed cleaning out the entire baking section of a local target. Admittedly while in a rush I missed the note to deliver to the back door, and had this information condescended at me while holding about 30lbs of their groceries. Delivered the last bag to the back through an overgrown alley, which I would not have been able to get through with the larger and heavier bags I had brought through the front. They never even ended up giving a tip, and I waited a week to write this to make sure it wasn't an app delay. If you support delivery drivers, don't support shops that do this. read more

This place is absolutely INCREDIBLE, DELICIOUS and SWEEEEET in every way. Every baked good and dessert is amazing! We have ordered cakes, cupcakes, bread pudding and a host of other items-all always beyond delicious.  We also love the waffles with ice cream and outrageously creative shakes when we have time to stay and eat!  The candy and other treats (including the non-edible type) around the store make it a dream for parents and kids. The store has great energy and is always a vibrant place to be.  The family owned and incredibly run store makes the place even more special than the delicious items it serves.  Just thinking of the flavors, colors and incredible tasting goodies makes staying at home a little bit brighter! read more

Honestly this is one of my favorite bakery and candy shops of all time. I've had the pleasure of living all around the country. And I have various friends who own shops. And this place is just the best of the best. The cakes are unbelievable their candy selection is top notch. And they're working their tails off. Especially during this very difficult time they've been actively supporting the community. I love this place so much. Also a bunch of my friends kids had their birthday parties there and they were the best. read more

Simply the BEST! The Banana Pudding is out of this world and the ring ding can't be beat! Great place for gifts, chocolate baskets, platters and UNBELIEVABLE artistic cakes! The staff is always friendly and willing to help! Not to mention the crazy candy wall..... read more

This is my favorite sweet shop! The cheesecake bars are the best!! Ice cream and frozen yogurt are delicious. The chocolates and candy are the highest quality. All the camp baskets for my grandchildren were perfect - they were right-on for what they wanted and appreciated. The owners and staff couldn't be nicer, friendlier or eager to please. It's always clean. read more

WOW! What a fabulous store, second only to the warm, welcoming and helpful staff . We brought four of our grandchildren to Sugar Hi and it was the favorite part of their weekend. The candy selection is beyond belief, the ice cream was fabulous and the baked goods were mouthwatering,, Everything was delicious. We will definitely be back! read more

The owners are so rude that it is shocking they continue to do business. After I ordered, I went online to read reviews and read were someone had the same experience and claimed that the cakes are not home made and the icing came from a can. I did not what to believe it but we cut the cake, I tasted and sure enough it was from a can and that was boxed cake. This place is not a bakery and the baking is not fresh nor baked from scratch. The cake we had was Dunkin Hines with Pilsbury CANNED ICING! It was DISGUSTING to have an establishment charge the HIGH prices they charge for BOXED and CANNED flavors. I threw the whole cake in the trash along with my money. Will never go back and I told all my friends. They should change their name to #FAUXBAKERY. The High is appropriate for the prices. Go to Deccicos - the cakes there are delicious and real! read more

I have to say there's no place better than Sugar Hi. Everything they sell is incredibly delicious. And there are no good words to truly describe the creativity of their cakes! Wow - every time I go in there I see something I am blown away but what they can do with fondant and frosting. Plus their talented and friendly staff! We are so lucky to have them in Armonk!! read more

This place is the best! So delicious! Fun-fetti cookie is the best cookie on Earth. Fantastic customer service!

The cakes and treats at SugarHi are SO good that my sister who is on a strict diet has broken it once in the past 3 months only for a SugarHi cake the other night. So nice to have a friendly, family run bakery with amazing baked goods willing to make anything and do everything for their customers. Not only are the cakes beautifully decorated, but they are also the best tasting. SugarHi is amazing... people drive hours to come pick up goods for special events -- when I go visit friends they beg me to bring cake scraps!!! read more

Great place to satisfy your "sweet" tooth! They have mouthwatering deserts, including ice cream, cakes and chocolates.

Sooo good! The shop is really cute; tons of bins of all different kinds of candy! We tried a slice of cake and a cookie, both of which were honestly out of this world. The cookie was soft, chewy and delicious and the cake itself was perfect - I can't remember having any like it before! Can't wait to go back when we're in the mood for sweets! read more

I've been in many stores through the years- but no one can bake and create like Sugar Hi! I love their cookies and special order cakes which are just out of this world! If you have not been here, you are missing something special!!! This business gets 5 stars from me!! read more

NEVER COME HERE!! We took our three year old in and she acted like a three year old in a candy store. Looking, touching packaged candy, excited. STACY the employee stared her down with such disgust and anger like she was a criminal and a total nuisance. The level of unprovoked rudeness and the way she made us feel was terrible. I said something to her on our way out and she apologized for "the fact that I felt that way." The ice cream was fine but not worth feeling like a parasite in their establishment. Negative stars for this! read more

My 7 year old son and I stopped in yesterday and here's his review. "I really like their trash can ice cream; It was good in a shake. They had a lot of different flavors and fun stuff including little toys". It's a great place to get a sugar high! We will be back soon! read more

This is the best place on the planet! I love every single thing they sell here. The people and the food are unbeatable! The vibe is amazing and this is the most fun dessert place ever! The cakes are amazing and the waffles and ice cream are sensational. The chocolate m and m Oreos are delicious. A great thing about this place is that they make GORGEOUS AND DELICIOUS platters for parties and gatherings w friends. The owners and staff are so cool and fun and always happy to talk (which rlly adds to the vibe!) 100% A+ 10/10 RECOMMENDATION!!!! read more

This is the best bakery of all time. We have them send us their amazing desserts down to Miami. Thank you Sugar Hi.