Our team absolutely lucked out staying at a hotel next door to JC's! We were in town for a…read moretournament and ordered to our hotel pizzas and salads for 20 hungry 12yo boys and their families. This was hands-down some of the best pizza we have had! Saying the owner, Jesse, went above and beyond to make sure all went smoothly is an understatement. He and his staff (special shout-out to Rachel) were friendly and courteous. I am very much looking forward to being in the area again and dining in next time. Sounds like I will need to try the buffalo dip...along with one of the desserts!

This place is a train wreck. We ordered food to go and waited at the bar, where the…read morebartender--while friendly--was clearly overwhelmed. Despite placing a to-go order, food kept coming out with no containers ready, and food runners seemed indifferent to whether the order was correct or not. It was genuinely sad. I had high hopes when it transitioned from Tony Sacco's, but unfortunately it feels like it's heading down the same path--and quickly.

Best pizza in SB area by far. And it's not even close. Make the drive, get the pizza, and enjoy -…read moreyou won't regret it

Iggy's is the best pie in town and the surrounding area. Small business but high quality products…read moreonly walk out the doors. Ingredients I trust (not a bunch of processed junk) and the flavor profile of each pizza is out of this world... sad when they are sold out

We are trying yo make this our "go to" for take-out pizza, but struggling…read more The GOOD: Love the crust. Chewy where it needs to be chewy, crispy edges, just the way we like it. The staff is very friendly. The BAD: inconsistencies with the toppings! Tonight's pizza was so bad, I felt the need to write a review. Typically we'll have a bad 18" inch (or two) and not order again for a while. Then, we'll try again and have a tasty pizza. On/Off relationship! Tonight we opted for a veggie pizza instead of a Lenten Fish Take-out. Our pizza was overbaked, couldn't see or taste green peppers, onions were stringy, black olives tasted spoiled, etc. Not good. Not fans of the Tavern cut either. Help!

1st time caller We ordered over the phone for pick up. 18" pizza - "Everything" (comes with…read moresausage, mushrooms, green bell peppers, onion, and extra cheese). We asked for regular hand stretched crust and no onions. It was ready in about 20 minutes and huge! We loved it!! The crust was really good (like artisan style) , sauce and cheese are fantastic... and the sausage was delicious. Tips: 1. They defaulted to party style cut for the 18". Next time, we will probably order two 14" pizzas (so we can try more toppings) and ask for traditional wedge cuts. 2. They offer the option of fresh or canned mushrooms. Just in case they forget, make sure you specify what you want. We got the fresh mushrooms, and they were great. I dislike canned mushrooms, so I'm grateful that they offer fresh. The only two issues we had were: 1. We think that the "Everything" pizza should have more than 5 toppings or maybe change the name to deluxe sausage or sausage supreme. It confused my family when I told them what I was bringing home the Everything pizza and it didn't even have Pepperoni. A name change could eliminate confusion. 2. My husband thought the amount of toppings on the 18" was a little light compared to what he expected. Delicious though. However, if I'm reading the menu correctly, adding extra toppings doesn't cost much.. so order what you want and enjoy!! Nice folks.. I hope they do well.

Tried this for the first time and really enjoyed it! I had ham and cheese calzone and a Nutella…read morecroffle. Delicious! It was very clean. Owner was very kind and worked quickly. She was literally running around to serve everyone.

Quite the "yummy" NYC pizza experience in the middle of Granger, Indiana. We called to order for…read morepick -up and the pizza took about 30 mins or so to be ready for pick up. The pizza slices were HUGE in comparison to the pizza slices I'm used to. So I pretty much had 2 slices and was full. The crust itself was nice and thin as expected for the NYC style pizza they are known for. We ordered 2 pizzas. The first pizza was a sausage, onion, and pepper. The second pizza was the chicken, bacon, and ranch pizza. I did not have the chicken, bacon, and ranch pizza since I like the traditional pizzas better, but everyone else seemed to enjoy it much better than the classic sausage, onion, and pepper pizza.

One of my top 5 pizza places. Not only are the vegetables cut fresh everyday but the sauce and…read morericotta are made in house. Its a great thinnish crust with a great crispiness to it. Employees are super friendly and treat you as a friend and not just another customer. Toppings do not cost extra which is amazing. But dont overdue it. Unlimited toppings sounds great but too many all at once ruins a good 2-3 topping pizza.

I can't tell you which is better- the friendly hard working staff, or the lovingly made pizza. This…read moreis one of the better pizzas in town for the money spent. Their ingredients are fresh, and they make is to your specifications. I used to go to Pie Five, but they started getting real stingy with ingredients. Not with Crushed Tomato inside of Martin's Supermarket. I get what i want within 8 minutes and it's delicious. They have no problem standing behind their product and have remade pizzas for us if there was an issue. The people working behind the counter CARE that they make a good pizza. Very refreshing! Kudos to Martin's for combining a great staff with a great product.

This place is amazing! It's seriously the best pizza I've ever had. My grandma, who is 73, agrees…read morethat it's the best pizza she's ever tasted, and I couldn't agree more! The waitress is incredibly attentive and friendly, creating a cozy and warm atmosphere while dining here. My family and I love it! We really wish this restaurant was more widespread. The food is absolutely to die for! On a different note, I usually don't eat the crust on pizzas, but I got so full from the pizza that I ended up eating the crust because it was so good! It had a very crunchy, cracker-like texture.

Still awesome. Tonight's was their best pizza ever. Good job Starlite! Pepperoni, sausage & ham…read more Yummy

Pizza was delicious! I was in the mood for an authentic pizza. I did not want a pizza from a chain…read morepizza place. I placed my order. They told me 20min. When I arrived, my pizza was ready. Everyone there was pleasant too. I will be back and will spread the word.

Got a slice of pizza at lunch. Pizza was OK, very spicy. The sign outside the restaurant said "Best…read morePizza in Indiana!" Not even close! Okay place to grab a quick slice for lunch but wouldn't go out of my way.​

Amazing pizza! The service was exceptional and it has an old school atmosphere. There's a reason…read morewhy it's so busy all the time.

Good food, good service, great atmosphere... a nostalgic pizza joint with good people! I love…read moreRocco's!!

Pizza too expensive not enough red sauce. Pizzas were very dry any chewy. They even charged extra…read morefor the box I have had barabys pizza over the years this was the worse ever. Not like they used to be I understand that the downtown south bend store is still good though. Just look at the side vie of 3 different pizza 1 meat lover 2 cheese 3 cheese and pepperoni and they all have no red sauce under the cheese

Barnaby's is our place for pizza! It's a great place to get together with friends and family…read more Just put in your order and enjoy probably the best pizza around. Staff members are very nice, too.

super fun place !! good variety of drinks and some pretty tasty pizza. very up-beat vibe. ski-ball…read moreand darts are a great activity.

I'd give them a zero star, but that's not an option…read more Poor service, and to top it off they had my car towed. Parked in their lot, ran in to Oliva's to give my wife her wallet, then went over to Hop's. I guess they never watched the camera footage of me walking back out and coming to their place. $270 later for the tow and shitty service. I won't be going back.