What can I say? All of the Barnaby's are great , but my favorite is the Grape road location

Pizza too expensive not enough red sauce. Pizzas were very dry any chewy. They even charged extra for the box I have had barabys pizza over the years this was the worse ever. Not like they used to be I understand that the downtown south bend store is still good though. Just look at the side vie of 3 different pizza 1 meat lover 2 cheese 3 cheese and pepperoni and they all have no red sauce under the cheese read more

See all

Barnaby's is our place for pizza! It's a great place to get together with friends and family. Just put in your order and enjoy probably the best pizza around. Staff members are very nice, too. read more

Barnabys - Granger - Thin crust, sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

We had a private party there. It was great! Their pizza is always delicious. I will keep them in mind for next get together.

Placed three delivery orders, they screwed up every single one. The wrong order delivered almost ice cold? I hate seeing a small, locally owned business start to unravel like this. Such a waste. read more

We went there on afternoon around 2pm nobody there customers and my friend ordered 2 1/2 pound burgers and the the burgers tassted horrible and the fries where not done (don't go here read more

Horrible service, food is ok but waited forever and they had no knives or spoons clean, only forks. served the ketchup in packets. Girlfriend's food came way earlier than mine and even came before appetizers. Very unorganized and poor management. read more

this is our time second time here as a big group of family . Was told by the busser maybe , idk he does the bar also, to not put our dirty plates on the other tables bc they were clean, and that the front girl would come and get them. We were making room for our table , not like you can't clean the already sticky tables . MEANWHILE , the cooks in the back making pizza while eating pizza. BAREHANDS , NO HAIR COVERS OR BEARD COVERS!!!! Makes sense right ! ?!?!?? oh and my pizza box cost me .54 cents to take a large pizza home . read more

Amazing pizza! Below verage service. Average ambia. Like Mishawaka location better. Thank you, we will order take out in Granger.

Ordered green olives on my pizza. There were about 8 slices on the entire large pizza. Most slices had no olives. Called to complain and was told the manager would contact me. Never heard from anyone. There are many better pizza places around ~ do not waste your money here. read more

Barnabys - Granger - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

Best deep dish pizza in the area! JR bakes and awesome pizza! Butter crust, lots of cheese, delicious sausage, veggies are always fresh.

There is a reason this place has 2 stars. Awful service. Too many pizza places in granger to spend your money here. Go elsewhere. Manager is rude. read more

Had a deep dish stuffed pizza - it had a crunchy, buttery crust, the sauce was that right mix between a little acidic, a little sweet, a little herby, and the stuffed toppings (sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers) were excellent. This is my new go to pizza in town, beating out Luigi's read more

Barnabys - Granger - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

what a bizarre experience. A friend of mine who didn't know better picked this location which oddly happens to be connected to a gas station. the restaurant was virtually empty and took over an hour for our pizzas to be cooked. we contemplated getting up and leaving, but had to prepay for the pizzas. The employees were hard to track down for drinks or to change the TV channels away from dodge ball to the college football playoff game. Barnabys is my favorite pizza in the area but will never return to this locatjon. I will say after the lengthy wait, the pizza was still good but not waiting over an hour in an almost empty restaurant again. read more

We mistakenly ordered from this location thinking we were ordering from the one on Grape Road, but honestly, it was everything I needed: it was ready quickly and the hostess was attentive. We ordered a cheese pizza and a pepperoni and sausage pizza and both were devoured by my family. I didn't know this location existed, but I will be back for carry out the next time I'm in town. read more

We have gone to Barnaby's on Grape Road for almost 46 yrs. We decided to try the Cleveland Rd location as it's just a little closer to home. Major disappointment. We were there 7-6-25 at 2:30 & had the worse pizza we've ever had from Barnabys! The crust resembled commercial store bought crust & was so burnt, it was crunchy. Edges were black! There was no tomato sauce so that added to it being hard & dry. We've tried this location 3 times & it just keeps getting worse. We love the Grape Rd location so will go back there for sure. Hopefully the owner will get on top of this before his business gets hurt by it. It may be catching up already because once again we were the only customers there! Maybe the crew at the Cleveland Rd location should take some lessons from Grape Road! It's just a shame... read more

Awesome pizza $5.50 and a burger with fries $6.00. Excellent food and service. The ambiance was wonderful!

My family has always loved Barnaby's pizza. But the last few times -the prices keep going up, which I know is happening everywhere. But the 3 pizza we ordered last night has hardly any toppings. maybe 5 pieces of sausage on an entire pizza. 3 pizzas and 10 breadsticks set us back $95. No pepperoni on the pepperoni pizza. read more

Showed up at 5 on a Thursday, only 1 other table with 2 folks in the whole place. We ordered 3 regular pizzas and had to wait an hour and 45 minutes for them to be made. There's a reason this place charges up front. Service is atrocious. Will never be back read more

I just ordered pizza for the third time from barnabys granger the first time I ordered was soon after they opened and the pizza was alright not quite the usual barnabys standard but I wrote it off to being new The second pizza I got from there was alright still not the usual barnabys standard The third one that I got today was really to put it in a nice way bad the crust was way under cooked it was terribly soggy and not even close to what I would call a decent pizza I hate to have to write a review like this but Mike you need to get some better quality control over what is going out the door I won't be back read more

The pizza is always good but I got a salad for dinner and it was yellow, brown and inedible!!! It was the inside of the head of iceberg lettuce. I don't eat meat and ordered the pizzas with meat for everyone else. The salad and an order of fries for me. The fries weren't even done, in fact they are in my oven right now to finish them off. So disappointed that I now have to make my own dinner because the salad went into the trash. read more

Barnabys - Granger - Salad sort of - Pizza Near Me - Granger, Indiana

Great pizza, cold beer, nice people. Laid back atmosphere and we always get right in! We'll be back!

Called to order take out at 8 pm Saturday. Was told they no longer were taking orders. They were supposedly open until 11 pm. Ordered from Grape Road and no problem! If you don't want my business, guess what? You don't get my business. read more

We constantly get the wrong order every time - This is the fourth time! I love Barnaby's pizza but we are done. When I called to tell them we received the wrong order I had to go through 3 different people to explain the mix up - the third person I finally hung up. Very disappointed. read more

My wife and I were visiting Mishawaka and hungry for pizza. People recommended Barnabys. We put a to go order in and arrived. My wife went in to pick up the order and was really ticked off when she got to the van. Ordered 3, 14" pizzas and garlic cheese bread. Total came to $99.94. She got charged $.50/take out box which came to $2 plus tax, because we got it to go. Ridiculous. Then, the person taking order failed to tell my wife that we could've got double the garlic cheese bread for $1 more. Not worth the money for such a half order of garlic cheese bread. The pizzas were small and thin and the crusts were burnt on a couple of them. Little Cesars pizza is a considerably better value than this joint. The pizza wasn't bad but reminded me of something from Pizza Hut. Garlic cheese bread wasn't hot. Just a crappy experience overall. I would never, ever recommend these jokers, to anyone. Service was terrible, pricing double what it should be for what you get. Located in a gas station complex. So weird and undesirable overall. Do better. People, go somewhere else, this lousy rating that they have overall is definitely indicative of what you can expect. Wish we had looked at the ratings first. Never again!! read more

Good pizza but ordering by phone is very frustrating. Can't tell you how much I've grown to hate hearing, "Please hold" when they answer the phone. Then I wait and finally give up. It usually takes several calls before I finally get someone that answers and takes my order. Also don't believe the quoted times. I was told 45 minutes. I arrived at 20 minutes and it was ready. Glad to get it sooner anyway. read more

I just ordered pizza for the third time from barnabys granger the first time I ordered was soon after they opened and the pizza was alright not quite the usual barnabys standard but I wrote it off to being new The second pizza I got from there was alright still not the usual barnabys standard The third one that I got today was really to put it in a nice way bad the crust was way under cooked it was terribly soggy and not even close to what I would call a decent pizza I hate to have to write a review like this but Mike you need to get some better quality control over what is going out the door I won't be back read more

Ate here for dinner last night with a party of 10. Ordered 3 pizzas, breadsticks and salads. All was great!

Meatball sub was great, as well as the CBR PIZZA! Was fire and I heard they've got a brand new oven!

Positives: Plenty of parking and seating. Pizza arrived hot and fresh. Negatives: We arrived a few minutes after they opened and it took 1 1/2 hours for the pizza to arrive. There was one lady who was the hostess/waitress/ phone order taker/ and barmaid all in one. The salad bar was in a dark corner and I had to use my phones flashlight to see the items. Neutral: The cheesebread was pretty good, and the pizza was pretty "average". We'd been to the other Barnabys before so we knew what to expect from the food. Overall, maybe we arrived on a bad day but they need more help in the front of the restaurant. read more

First time visiting the granger location great service and the food was outstanding as the Mishawaka location .... thanks for opening in Granger!!!! We will be back!! read more

Our pizza was excellent as usual. My husband thinks that Barnaby's has the best sausage in the area. Greg checked on us several times to see if we needed anything. In fact, he was working the whole room to make sure everyone was taken care of. Great pizza + great service = 5 stars! read more

Extremely unhelpful/ incompetent staff. And of all the Barnaby's I've been to, this one is by far the worst. It makes no sense. You can't order drinks when you order the pizza. Have to do it separately (but there is no signage anywhere to indicate how any ordering is done at all, and it's different from any other Barnaby's anywhere, so first-timers, good luck!). And you go to the bar-a completely separate room from the restaurant AND nowhere near where you order the food... and of 5 drinks ordered, the lady got 2 of them wrong. Oh- it says nowhere anything about where to pick up the pizza when it's ready, and the silverware is in a completely different space (across the room) from where the napkins and condiments are. Completely disorganized. Absolutely no reason to go back. read more

I've been to the Granger Barnaby's location several times for both carry out & dine in & I will definitely return. The food was great (same as their Grape Rd location) & the staff pleasant! I also love the family friendly atmosphere, the beautiful dining area & the restrooms are very clean! I would definitely recommend Granger Barnaby's to everyone! read more

pizza and great service got to try the deep dish it's amazing

Pizza was just okay, definitely way overpriced for what you receive. Two larges definitely not worth $52. Could have traveled to Ft. Wayne and back for pizza and still saved money. read more

Well, let's talk about the pizza and garlic bread w/cheese. Pizza was classic Barnaby's and very good. Garlic bread was definitely garlic bread which was amazing and the amount of cheese was awesome. However, the hang around staff had me tripping. It seemed like a family unit that does not know when they should leave and moved into a table. Where it looked like they brought groceries for the long haul. Then, what made it worse was one of them was trying to run the front desk and must not be able to read because she kept bring up the wrong order or did not know what was going on. The only two shinning stars were the cook from the back that actually asked how everything was and the girl in the yellow beast hoody that was basically doing it rest (praises to her!). I think the owner should be worried about this. Especially, if I hear you are closing the Mishawaka location. I recommend just using this place for takeout. read more