First time got the Jimmy special. So thin and light delicious and full of flavor. I do plan on trying some more pies.

Very good pizza! One of the best around. Always hot. My mom has to have this pizza every weekend read more

It was tasty. We bought 2 slices to go. I would like to try it again hot. Unfortunately it was just lukewarm. read more

Jimmy's Apizza - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

We had been going to Jimmy's for a long time and last time we ordered a pizza my 9 yr old granddaughter found a screw in the pizza we brought it to the owner's attention and they asked us to bring it to them the next day which we did, they did nothing for us, no apologies nothing. We even told them that we had to throw out the pizza in case there were more screws, the owner seemed to not care at all never apologized or even credit us for the pizza that we had to throw out. Won't be going there again! read more

We tried Jimmy's pizza after a recent Dave Portnoy pizza review. After all is right down the street from us and we never had it before. The pizza was served very hot and was very flavorful. It was great to bring it home and feel like it came right out of the oven. We found their meatball pizza to be better than Sally's. Their cheese pizza was very good as well. We frequent New Haven pizza places, but found this restaurant to be a nice change of pace. It was also a very reasonable cost, and the staff was very friendly. read more

Alright, Jimmys Apizza in Milford. Walked in thinking, "Okay, another pizza joint, let's see what you've got." Walked out thinking, "Yep... these guys get it." The crust? Beautiful. Not that cardboard-flat garbage some places serve. It's got the right chew, right crisp, holds up when you fold it, but doesn't shatter like you're eating a cracker. Sauce is legit--actual flavor, not just red water splashed on dough. Cheese ratio? Dialed in. Not swimming, not stingy. Just right. Now, let's talk vibe. Place feels like pizza the way pizza should feel: no frills, no nonsense, no one trying to sell you on "artisan kale toppings" or whatever hipster disaster other spots are peddling. This is New Haven-style pizza done right in Milford. You want gimmicks? Go somewhere else. You want good pie? Come here. One bite, everyone knows the rules--and I'm not gonna lie, it's tough not to go back for a second, third, fourth bite before even finishing the review. Solid 8.4 all day. Jimmy's is the real deal read more

I cannot for the life of me understand the fuss. The pizza was thick and burnt. No toppings. Maybe it was na off day, but we got two horrid pizza paying way too much read more

Fantastic. And great that the really nice and cool dining room is now open even during lunch.

Gotten pizza here a few times mostly to go but this was the first time I've eaten inside. It was a Saturday night and surprisingly not too crazy inside which was nice. They have probably one of the best gluten free pizza crusts that I've ever had. The flavor is great and not too filling. I will definitely continue coming here! read more

See all

ordered a large clam pizza, which was very good. HOWEVAH - it was $37 + tax-25% more than Mama's or Sally's. never again....

If you're looking for great pizza and don't want to drive to New Haven, or you're just a Beatles lover, look to Jimmy's Apizza! The eggplant was awesome and crust was great. Jimmys has a hometown feel with clearly regular patrons. The walls are embellished with Beatles decor. We loved our pizza and would definitely go back to try their dinner entrees. read more

Jimmy's Apizza - Ashley Special with Meatball - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

There's an old saying I just made up that says "crummy pizza is better than no pizza at all." Well,sorry to say but the slices I just had here were in fact crummy. They were overcooked, thin, had little sauce, and they came to me out of a plexiglass box where it looks like they'd been sitting for quite a long time. I've driven by many times and always wondered how their pizza was... Now I know. The young lady who took my order was very nice! read more

Wow. can't believe i'm writing a negative review. I don't agree with bashing a business and that isn't the purpose of this rather than a wake up call or eye opener. we placed an order for a large bacon pepperoni pizza and a large salad with chicken. 1st off-there was prob 7 slices of pepp on the whole pizza. Like come on. I wiiiiish I took a photo, also we counted 3 slices of bacon on the whole pizza. not to mention it was F R E E Z I N G. Anyway, we got to the beach, open the bag and there's no napkins and no utensils for "takeout" also. dressing top was never closed and salad was a mess. it's sad because the place had serious potential. the flavor was there but the quality wasn't. this is a coaching moment to the staff, quality is everything. people willing to pay to eat out in the economy is a blessing you can afford to put more meat on your pizza and do the little things better read more

We ordered a large pie with meatballs and peppers. The pie itself was very good. Done New Haven-style. I like it that way. What I didn't like, however, was the scarcity of the toppings. A tiny handful of peppers dashed in the center of the pie. A handful of mini meatballs scattered here and there. And I paid $21 and some change for this pie? I know other New Haven-style pizzerias that are far more generous with their toppings and make it worth the extra $6-$8 I would pay there. read more

Ordered takeout and was impressed. Certainly the best place among many options within a mile radius. Would recommend to a friend! read more

We support restaurants during this difficult time of social distancing. We've been steady Jimmy's Apizza customers for 10 years. But, seriously! The last three out of four take-out orders have been so burnt on the crust underside that the pizza needed to be thrown out. It just wasn't edible. "Buyer beware!" doesn't mean that while picking up a molten pizza, a customer needs to hazard burnt fingers to check the inside of the pie to check if it's solid black carbon. We expect more from Connecticut pizza parlors. Clean your ovens, Jimmy's Apizza! This is just lazy, wasteful business practice. read more

Jimmy's Apizza - Jimmy's Apizza order from last night in Milford CT. 7-11-20 Too burnt to eat. - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Just moved in around the corner from Jimmy's. Our usual place didn't open for another two hours. Read the reviews and gave Jimmy's a shot. Holy Crap!! This place is awesome!! True Apizza!! If you haven't tried Jimmy's, you should!! Excellent!! read more

Have had takeout from Jimmys twice now. First time had a cheese pizza and bacon cheese fries. Second time enjoyed a Hogan pie (chicken parm pizza) and bacon cheese fries. Pizza is solid and generously topped, but let me tell you the bacon cheese fries are life! Lots of bacon, great fries and loads of cheese. Looking forward to more takeout soon! read more

Jimmy's Apizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

We went to Jimmy's last night after waiting a very long time at another establishment down the road. We were seated immediately and the service was outstanding . There was a mixup with our order. Our waitress came over and apologized profusely and took full responsibility for the mistake. She brought us another round of drinks on the house. I appreciate an establishment that cares for their customers and provides excellent service each and every time we visit. read more

There pizza is delicious but the only thing its salty a bit but overall it is good and yummy

Typical New Haven burned, charred, whatever you call it pie. Typical for the area. Id go back if I was hungry but would rather find a good Italian deli Service was great! read more

Updating this to 4 stars. I ended up there for a group event, and the service was actually GREAT! The waitress was super accommodating to our group, and went out of her way to provide the kids with crayons and even a little dough to play with. Food was good as well. read more

Awesome CT style pizza, friendly service, and an easygoing atmosphere and cool vibe. Great for lunch. There is indoor and outdoor seating available, and they do serve beer and wine. I would like to check this place out for dinner sometime too. read more

Jimmy's Apizza - The Brittany - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

In my humble opinion, this is one of the best pizza's in CT. The crust edges are a little thicker than other CT pizza's but still have that proper dark bottom crust that CT pizza is known for and their dough is gorgeous where flavor is concerned. Personal fav is the Milford Seafood pie. You have a choice of shrimp or clams red or white. I always choose the shrimp with red sauce and cheese. The shrimp are large and succulent with that hot oven grill flavor. Another fav is the Buffalo chicken pizza medium hot. They also have really good garlic knots with a ton of garlic on them. Haven't been disappointed yet with anything we have tried. read more

I thought about my prior review, and now actively trying other Pizza restaurants. I do generally like the food although the pizza always has burnt bits on the underside that I have to clean off and sometimes it strays from well done to just way too burned to consume, and I prefer a well done crust. read more

The pizza was ok but cold. A disappointment. It's too bad because it's the first pizza we've had in months and it was burnt and cold. read more

If you want tasty pizza in Milford, check out Jimmy's. The crust is delicious. The pies taste fresh and offer a great variety. If you want to be a little daring; try the mashed potato pizza. Definitely different but surprisingly tasty. Unfortunately, I did not pickup and cannot advise on the safety procedures in place for COVID. They are offering take out only and have not opened up the dining room. Enjoy! read more

Just tried this place and it's the best pizza I've had yet in Milford! Covid friendly pick up too, and you don't even have to get out of your car. read more

Jimmy's Apizza - Ashley special - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Ashley pizza is our favorite. Can be very busy on Friday evenings with wait times over an hour.

Alright, we're here at Jimmy's Apizza in Milford, CT. They have restaurant on one side, and a small pick up/take out on the other side for quick service. We will start off with a small regular cheese pizza, perfect size for 1 person maybe 2, nice color, melted cheese, toasty crust, let's dive right in, one bite everyone knows the rules. hmm, good good good, great pie, new haven style thin crust, very good, we'll give it 7.9 and that's a review! Bonus pie, buffalo chicken pizza. different levels of heat to choose from, we went with medium, very good spice, breaded chicken, not overcooked. definitely could use a dipping sauce each or blue cheese but very good overall, 7.5! read more

Had a sausage and pepper pie that was very good as a to-go order. Pie could have been a little more generous with the toppings, but it tasted great. read more

Needed to find a place close to Milford Point Brewing. Good pizza, friendly. It is cute that most of the pizzas have people names, for whichever one was the vegetable one. Lots of toppings, good sauce. Would definitely go back. read more

Great pie with tastiest dough ! One daughter loves the white broccoli the other moss and pepperoni. Staff hustles in and out so the consumer never leaves the car. read more

On our pizza quest Friday, we are trying a place in Milford. My husband and I got such a good vibe as soon as we entered. Owner loves music and played some really good music in the back ground and the dining area is decorated with music memorabilia...which was very cool. Restaurant is very clean and the waitress we had was very friendly and attentive. A We will definitely have to come back read more

See all

To start, the young lady answering the phone knows nothing about Italian food, ordered a chick an parm hero sauce on the side, came in a platter and dried like baccala! I ordered brocolli rabe and sausage, no idea what cavatelli was so I got ziti on the side cause I'm carb free and I repeatedly said light garlic and it came LOADED with BS pre-minced garlic, I mean you cant even use whole garlic so I can take it out! One of the worst meals I ever threw out! And furthermore, I ordered way ahead of time and still had to wait 20 minutes for crap food. NEVER AGAIN!!!! STICK TO PIZZA And to add, they put white onions on the salad,,,,,,,seriously read more

I get my sauce and dough for my Pizza oven from Jimmy's. The guys are always a pleasure and helpful read more

It pains me to write this review as Jimmy's was once our "go to" place for pizza. I hadn't been there for awhile due to moving and decided to do a carry out pizza. Arriving home and opening the box I found one burnt and dried out sorry excuse of a pizza. I guess they've gone so far downhill that they simply stopped caring and take no pride about what they're serving. Shame on them! read more

Jimmy's Apizza - Lovely way overdone charcoal crust - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Have gotten pies from here many times they seem to be fine but I went and ordered an egg plant Parm dinner yesterday and God it was disgusting they use pizza sauce or seems to be on the egg plant that was so bitter And not made for eggplant very disappointed and nice place like this should make their own sauce and let it simmer for hours your customers will be a lot happier read more

Can't believe I haven't reviewed Jimmy's yet. It's my favorite pizza in Milford. Michael Anthony's is probably second. They have wonderful New Haven style pizza and have been around for years. I enjoy the garlic bread, fried mozzarella, and fried calamari in addition to their pizzas. They have so many great specialty pies. The Devyn (mashed potato) and Ashely (ricotta and eggplant) are some of my favorites. If you eat in, they usually have a couple good craft beer options too. read more

I've been to Jimmy's a number of times and it never disappoints, Chicken Parm subs, meatball parm subs are outstanding. The pizza is absolutely delicious. Service for pickup is top notch. Highly recommend this place!! read more