I totally get the hype about this place! If I lived nearby, you can bet I'd work my way through…read moretheir whole menu. There's just something different about this style of sandwich. I've had sandwiches in NYC and Boston, but Tony's were definitely better! The menu is overwhelming because so much sounds good, so we went with two 7 inch sandwiches to split--one hot and one cold. Although a helpful tip from the cashier is that you can order any cold sandwich hot. We had the Lucky Luciano (hot) and the Sophia (cold). Both were really good--it was hard to choose between the two. But if I'm being honest, that cold sandwich was reminiscent of subs I loved in the early 2000s from places that no longer exist...with that super thinly sliced turkey, thick slice of Swiss cheese, and basil mayo--it really hit the spot. We also had a cannolo--not as good as others I've had. The bottled root beer was delightful. The Lucky Luciano was the kind of sandwich I came here for, and don't get me wrong, it is deliciously cheesy and will make your hands messy. But the Sophia is the kind of sandwich I'll be craving. My only regret was not taking a sandwich to-go for later. Open a location closer to Houston, please. :)

Many visits later it pains me to remove a star FOR BEVERAGE ISSUES ONLY (the food is still…read morefantastic). They are a pepsi place (booooooo!), and there's no diet pepsi (pepsi zero is their only zero calorie soda option). If you drink Diet Coke (most popular diet drink in USA), then you don't want diet pepsi, but you'll probably drink it if you have to; however, you're very likely to hate pepsi zero (and Coke Zero, too), so no soda for you here anymore! A full Coke setup that also includes Dr Pepper AND Diet Dr Pepper is ideal. I realize a pepsi fountain is more profitable because of distributor incentives, but pepsi is favored by almost nobody and hated by many...so is it really worth it? Tony's is so great that pepsi just does not fit in. Hopefully they don't deteriorate further and change to Wonderbread for all of their sandwiches. Bottom line: at the very least, please add diet pepsi to your soda machine if that brand remains in place.

Wow. Glad we checked this out while in the r Galleria area. We saw this restaurant on TV as a top…read morerated NY deli. Lots of seating, great wait staff, and the sandwiches are gigantic--as they should be for the price. $30 for a sandwich on average. We split an open face pastrami (which they brought an extra plate) and we are glad we did. The potato salad is tiny. Too much sandwich for one but not enough potato salad for two! The pickles they provide before your sandwich arrives are yummy- not like a traditional out of the bar pickle. These are what I remember from NYC. Garlic and not sweet. We also had the apple pie alamode. Also pricey and gigantic. It was warm and delicious. Glad we tried this icon. We went at lunch and they get quite the crowd. You are not rushed at all. You can even take some bakery items to go--if you are too full to eat there. Amazing selection of cookies, rugala, black and white cookies and more.

Highly recommend: Carrot cake…read moreCheese cake Rugelah Eclair (enormous) Pastrami Salads Round baked potato knish Matzoh ball soup Salmon Egg salad Ruben Lindino tacos Blintzes (made like a dessert) Etc. so much good food to choose. It's expensive but so much you could make 3 meals or share with others at your table. It's well worth it! The atmosphere is nice too.

Loved this place! The vibe is very unique, feels very Italian inside. Food was excellent and good…read moreprices! I got the red beans and rice, my husband got the biscuits and gravy, and we shared a cannoli! Everything was delicious and we really enjoyed it! Great spot

One of the OG restaurants on the island. If you want Galveston classic with an Italian market vibe,…read morethis is your place. Everything is great but if you want a classic go for the muffuletta and round it off with one of the best Bloody Marys you will ever have. Don't forget to bring extra spending money for any spices or Italian goodies you may need. Our favorite is the tomato gravy. The guys running the counter are helpful and friendly.

First visit today. I ordered the Gandolfini with the intent on taking it home for a late lunch. I…read moreate it in the gas station parking lot next door while I was filling my tank. I was huge and smelled so good. It tasted even better. I had to find a sandwich place after visiting Rome in February. I found it and I will be back. Thank y'all! That sandwich made me happy.

My friends raved about this place and they had every reason to. I was at a pickleball tournament at…read moreERA Pickleball in the Woodlands which brought is much closer to Tony's than where my friend lived in Houston and decided to go pick up a bunch of sandwiches. I'd have to say, the sandwich was pretty life changing and it's something I want to try to replicate, but likely can't 100%. Although they have many sandwiches to choose from, the Stallone was the one recommended to me. The bread is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and has a concoction of pesto, cheese, tomato and garlic? Inside it's LOADED with capicola, ham, salami, soppresata, and provolone. The sandwich was definitely a flavor bomb and I still think about it til this day. I would love to go back and try some other sandwiches of theirs too!

This is a pretty eclectic place that fits in well here in Galveston. During Spring Break, they…read morewere a little busier during the weekday than normal. Lots of good options on the menu, and I was craving their famous cinnamon roll pancakes, but then a server brought out migas to a table and I immediately knew I wanted that instead. Here, it's a little opposite from most places, you gotta pick your seat first then order as the seats, especially the tables, are hard to come by at times. There are plenty stools along the window but the tables are better and most tables are family style so you'll likely be meeting someone new. I also added a chocolate bread pudding for myself which looked really good. The rest of my group ordered the granny's breakfast with sausage, 2 scrambled eggs and Benny's tostadas. The food comes out surprisingly quick for as busy as they are. Everything was so delicious! I ate a little of the bread pudding at the restaurant, then eventually ate the rest over the course of the next few hours. Yum! This restaurant is highly recommended!

I saw this place from a Galveston influencer. He really hyped this place up. I see nothing but…read moregood reviews so It pains me to say this but this was the worst meal my wife and I ever had. People rave about the service. The service is fine. You order at the counter and get your own silverware and drinks. The food is another story. I had the chicken fried steak with mashed potatoes and corn. Mash was fine. Corn was whatever. From can to plate. Nothing added. The CFS was atrocious. It was like breaded & over salted shoe leather. See the pictures. I couldn't eat all of it. The best thing on the plate was the toast. Oh, and they charge $19 for it. Whether frozen or homemade, which I doubt, to deliberately serve this to a customer, shame on you. My wife got the BLT. $13.50 for bread and lettuce with a little bacon. No mayo or mustard. Plain and bland. We realized later that you have to procure your own condiments, I think. Still, it was not good. The fries were undercooked and tasted baked. Sorry, but I feal betrayed by social media and what must be friendly reviews. This review is honest. The place is cool and I had high hopes but was sorely disappointed. Oh, I had a piece of cherry cheesecake. It was good.

I stumbled across this place on Yelp, and given the glowing reviews decided to try it…read more A delicious meal -- NOT! It's a little farther away than I usually go for lunch but not bad. Since it's a small place I waited 'til past my hungry time to avoid as much waiting as possible. I arrived at about 1:15p on an regular weekday. The place was closed. They indicate they're open every day. It's 2:30 now and Yelp says they're still open -- wrong! I have no idea how I could have one check-in as I've never eaten here but it was on the webpage when I first brought it up to look at the reviews. ___ I've Eaten Out Every Meal for more than 25 years

Love this place! Or should I say LOVED this place? Not sure they are still there (since the…read moreHurricane of 2017). But man oh man, do I wish I had one of those amazing Chicken Salad Sandwiches on a croissant right about now though. Called the number listed to check and see if I would get the opportunity to have one and sadly I received someone's home voice mail. :( If this one is gone, man will it ever be missed!

Can I say awesome! Belen was wonderful and so very personable. Her service was outstanding! As…read morefor the corned beef, just like NYC. The interior is full of NYC memories and only adds to the ambiance!

My friend and I were craving sandwiches and couldn't think of a place we wanted to try more. Katz's…read morealways impresses me with how elegant and cool the look and vibe are. We were seated immediately and our server was attentive and friendly. We had the amazing meatballs as an appetizer, and the sauce was phenomenal-tangy and sweet. I ordered the Carnegie Burger and it was amazing! The gochujang sauce complemented the perfectly cooked meat. A truly fantastic burger. The chocolate milkshake was also rich and tasty. I also ordered the chocolate cake and have to say it's famous for a reason, the layers were rich and decadent and a great way to end a meal!

My family and I were looking for somewhere to eat near Great Wolf Lodge and my son said the food…read morewas good. We were not disappointed. There was 7 of us from 6 to 66 and everyone found something different to order and everything was good. They are very attentive for a fast food place. I'll be back.

I've always had good food and good service from here. The staff are always nice and friendly. The…read moreteas are Texas sized. They will not let u leave here thirsty. lol. I've had the brookie- delicious, the sandwiches are always good. The smoky pepper jack turkey is my fav sandwich here and the SW salad is yummy. The staff are so great here they make sure u love your food and I also love the pickle on the side. Can't get a better deal for your money than MC Alisters.

These are the best sandwiches in the area. The ingredients are fresh, the bread is super soft, and…read morethe prices are very reasonable. The friendly staff is the icing on the cake. This place has been a local favorite for years, and I highly recommend it. PS. if you want a cheap sandwich with cheap ingredients, then by all means there is a subway around the corner.

Order: Turkey Sandwich on White…read more Very cute location, clean and very old school vibe. I located this place when looking for a sandwich shop near my work. I love the options for sides such as pickles and they have a great selection of chips and soda. They have a super old school TV in the back if you opt to eat here. The sandwich was good and straight to the point!

Old Moon Deli was fantastic to work with for a catered event at my workplace. They made the whole…read moreprocess easy from start to finish -- communication over email was simple, pickup was a breeze, and paying through an emailed invoice was quick and convenient. The sandwiches were absolutely delicious. I was also very impressed that they prepared the gluten-free sandwiches in separate containers from the rest of the order. That extra level of care really stood out. I highly recommend Old Moon Deli for anything from a single sandwich to catering for 30 people. They're great.

Stopped in for a bite between parades (Mardi Gras weekend). We had a party of 8 with us. The staff…read morewas great. Fast and friendly. The food was made fresh. I did a create your own sandwich, so I can't speak for menu items. My sister got the Monte Cristo and said it was great. Side note: They have gluten free bread and sweets!