When I worked downtown we ordered there alot always delivered hot great pizza good wings I luv…read morethere food miss it alot I highly recommend you order it

I ordered the chicken strips that were really good, but it did take a while to make them. I think…read moreabout 15 minutes. They ran out of orange pop, so I asked them to refill it. I'm sure they got around to it by now. They have plenty of seating, and they have a key to the bathroom

I love this place!!! Always good vibes, great menu - more than JUST pizza, good drinks, & great…read moredeals!! We went to watch some of the World Cup games and wanted good food! We ordered the Cesar salad, Pepperoni/sausage/banana pepper pizza, and for dessert the cookie skillet!! We ordered a medium pizza and it was definitely enough for two people if you both aren't starving! Cesar was also a good size and had real anchovies in it!!! The cookie skillet was obviously delicious! More whipped cream than ice cream but still yummy!! Can't wait to come back and try more things off the menu!!

My review stands but didn't add photos. Declined food quality needs to be addressed over profit.read more

If I could give zero or negative stars, I would. From start to finish, this experience of ordering…read moreand eating from Sambinos was downright appalling. First off, the workers could be more customer-friendly and nicer. I had to repeat myself at least three times when ordering. I placed my order for delivery, not pickup. I had to call back to check on my order, which the person answering didn't even seem like they knew which order mine was. It was written down as pickup, not delivery, which explained why it took forever to get to me. When my food FINALLY arrived, the gentleman that dropped it off was very nice, which was the ONLY positive from this entire experience. I ordered chicken parmasean. Normal chicken parmasean is a crispy chicken breast with cheese and sauce. The one I recieved was cheaply made noodles with watery sauce and two chicken tenders. The fact that they market this as chicken parmasean is very sad. I also ordered chicken alfredo. It was made with the same cheap noodles and watery alfredo sauce with minimal amounts of chicken and mushrooms. If you're going to put mushrooms in your alfredo sauce, it would be nice for you to make that known to your customers. This place was downright disgusting in every way! I had high hopes for this place but for the amount of money that I paid for two incredibly sub-par dinners is sad.

Ribs don't even have any meat on them and the price for them is not even worth it i will never have…read morethem again

THE MEATBALL SUB…read more Best in town by far Ohhh that meatball sub!! Wow. It's is so great. Handcrafted, big ass meatballs, cheese melted just right. So savory. Great flavor. You can get the half or the full size for a discount. Me & my brother split it. Best sub in town. Best I've ever had anywhere in fact. I do like that spicy meatball sub at firehouse but this one is better. Similar spice level. Pizza is great. They have the spicy kinda hit honey house sauce or just the basic tomato pizza sauce which might be the one I prefer. Big M if that's his name is a good dude, nice people there. They pull a good crowd. Have a karaoke night. Always turn right out the parking lot and go home on Lake. I pulled out left and cut off a policeman. Thought my life was changed for good but he lit up a drunk ahead of me. I am down to 8 lives lol. Go home on lake rd. My buddy likes the calzone we meet there occasionally. They do a local discount on aarp if you're a geezer like me. I can't drive 55 is all I gotta say. 5 stars!

This place needs to be cleaner. Plus false advertisement with graphic sign in front of business. It…read morestates half price appetizer but owner/ manager stated only Mondays or Tuesdays. The sign did not state a specific day of week. I honestly felt taken and chose a different item. When I left I read the sign and it did not state is was only certain days. What a disappointment neat by home.

Best old Skool pizza on the west side! Bold claim…read moreacknowledged. Alas, there is much to love in (1) pricing (2) baking (3) ingredients. Remember this is pizza, not lobster; it's supposed to feed a crowd in minimal time & money. (1) A 16" cheese pie is $13 & a half sheet cheese is $15. That's a lotta pizza! Pro tip: $2 off XL rounds on Thursdays! (2) Athens bakes the pizza till the cheese is evenly brown & gooey - the best! (3) They don't skimp on toppings when you order a variety and their sausage is THE BEST sausage in the city! It's flavorful, a lil spicy, a lil bit oily & finely ground* for incredible distribution over your glorious pie. (*expect a couple big chunks too - pop those right into your mouth hole before you bring the pizza inside to your loving family). This is an old Skool pizza joint in a somewhat forgotten part of Cleveland on Dennison. Don't expect anything from the outside but you know what *they* say about books and cover bands. If you end up arriving early for your order, take solace in the gentle truth that Athens has your urges covered with a classic pinball machine to keep you on your toes so you can stay alert for the free authentic smells.

Been going there for 50 years or more food is always great. Service is always good. Best taste in…read morepizza ever had.

We wanted to give a local spot a long overdue try after not ordering for years. As with many small…read morebusinesses, they're facing their struggles and have been receiving a lot of support from our area. We just got a basic pepperoni and it was very good! It had a nice crunch to it :) I will for sure order from them again...give it a try!

Simply horrible now. No way could I eat this garbage. Significant change and not for the better…read more Had to toss it in the trash as I didn't want wildlife to get sick eating it. So long. A legend it was. Not anymore.

Great tasty food prepared safely. Reasonable prices. The food is served in to go containers so your…read moretake home meal is ready to go and the staff has fewer dishes to wash. The restaurant is quiet. People can hear each other talk. It's kid friendly. Everyone is made to feel welcome there.

The Double Decker & Pepperoni Explosion pizzas were very tasty!!! Not skimpy on toppings!!! Italian…read moreSub also loaded with toppings!!! This place was small & cozy!! Food surprisingly excellent!!!! Waitress was very friendly,patient & on top of everything!!! Appreciate a GREAT DAY out!!! Very clean place, with very clean restrooms!!! Parking available in front of business!! Could be tight on weekends!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND to give this business a shot!!!

Wanted to try a new pizza spot and Toni's just happened to catch my eye…read more Uber was having a buy one get one promotion, but of course at check out I didn't get a discount and had to pay for both. But I digress. The pizza arrived and when the delivery person handed me them, the boxes were so light that they felt empty. I stomped up the stairs and into my place, certain this was a waste of $35. I opened the box and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza looked amazing. The pizza has a thin crust and a fair amount of pepperoni and cheese (though one slice didn't have any cheese. Phooey!) This is perfect fold over pizza. A slice you fold in half and enjoy the pie like a sandwich. My stars! This was totes amazeballs for the tastebuds!! Totally took my back to old style NYC slices. This is not easy to find outside of NYC! It was a perfect melding of ingredients and very satisfying. I'd definitely order from Toni's again!

I'm keeping this review short compared to my other reviews…read more I visited in July 2023 and ordered a medium size pizza to-go (takeout) with sausage, pineapple, and mushrooms. The pizza was good and the sausage was well-cooked. I would rate the pizza a 3.3/5. The crust wasn't as firm or cooked as I would have liked. I had their pizza another time when a friend ordered some for us for our church meeting last summer or Fall (2025). I believe we got pepperoni or a cheese pizza then it was fine, edible. Service was average (not too long) and efficient. The people working there are friendly and nice. **** GOAL of 250 reviews in 2026 - 125/250 total reviews in 2026 - 966 total Yelp reviews - Reviewed on 11 June 2026