Authentic Italian food and people highly recommend!!! The negative reviews are for the old owners…read more The new owners Tommy and Ro are the most genuine and welcoming people.

Fresh food, plenty of choices great sandwiches. never an unhappy customer in this store. Everything…read moremade fresh quality ingredients fabulous service. Everday feels as exciting as Christmas morning in this store.

I'll start by saying I am not a "yelper" I don't do reviews. Was a little tough to spot and don't…read morelet the exterior aesthetics sway your decision. This is a solid spot with quality ingredients. I drive all over north Jersey being in service work and hitting the best delis around, so my standards are a bit high. Stop in and give this place a shot, don't expect some extravagant imported Italian deli, just a solid spot, so 5 stars for that.

Called on a Saturday morning to place a large order for work, and they were able to accommodate…read moreeverything we needed! Subs were huge and delicious. Everyone loved everything! Love supporting local businesses!

Great place. Traditional home town deli. 6 table. 16 chairs. Awesome roast beef sandwiches among…read moreothers. Breakfast too friendly employees good prices

Love this place! Found it today after hiking Garett Mountain. Had the veggie panini, Called Daddy's…read morelittle girl. So good !!! So fresh. As this is during the virus outbreak we sat outside to eat the deli owner came out to tell me she just cleared a table for me and wanted me to be comfortable too. Strongly support this business !!! And YUM!

Sister's Deli is such a great spot to enjoy your lunch. The deli is small but cozy. You can grab a…read morebite to eat and then head to Garret Mountain. I had the number #9 the tattletailer panini sandwich and it was so good! I love the pesto sauce and the toasted focaccia bread - yum!! Sandwich also came with a bag of chips. Customer service is always amazing here. The owners are always super nice. They also have specials of the day. I had the chicken Marsala with rice. Great prices for the amount you receive. Food was great! They open early and close by 3:30. If you're near the area- give it a try, you will not be disappointed!

The chicken cutlet hero with mozzarella, broccoli rabe, sun-dried tomatoes, and balsamic vinegar…read morewas out of this world, very fresh and juicy. Service was excellent I also ordered the rare roast beef which was good.

Hadn't been here in years, but was in the area and popped in to buy some Italian specialties. I'm…read moreso glad I did. Their food is exactly as I remember, some of the best meats around. The homemade sausage, both pork and chicken are outstanding. Looking forward to stopping in to grab everything for my Memorial Day weekend! Do yourself a favor and head to this old school gem!

Very good sandwiches. Employees were very busy with a huge order and still managed to serve us…read more Highly recommend going here and supporting small local business.

Went in recently this is a follow-up to my first review…read more... My first review was a scathing review--- on how the presentation or portions are not good at all however the sandwiches are decent enough but nothing like the previous owner... in my previous review I put some pictures of what I used to get from the previous owner all for around $10, that might've contributed to why he went out of business in addition to COVID-19 but what was funny was the owner actually damn well New pretty much that I'm the guy that just left that scathing review... You can tell she was looking at me and talking to one of her workers and then they looked at me and you would think that she would've put a little more effort into the turkey club that I got... For some reason, I don't think they have tripledecker on the menu like what is shown in the picture below

Plaza bagels, formally Punk Rock bagels is fantastic. Even…read morewhen there's a line, it moves quickly. You can see them making bagels all day right in house. They have mini bagels, flat bagels, and all the fun flavors. Tons of different cream cheese to choose from. They give a good amount without it feeling like a huge glob block. All the staff is nice. Old metal heads. Cool to see old music memorabilia on the walls.. someone must be from New Orleans too because there's a lot of saints and New Orleans stuff. (Hard to find those Zapp chips up here) Cash or card. Parking lot. Full grill. More than you asked for.

Enjoyed an everything egg bagel which was freshly made and thick! I really appreciate how the eggs…read moreare freshly made and folded onto your bagel, paired this with some bacon and couldnt go wrong. Tons of bagels to pick from and the service was fast. This shop has tons of drinks and options to pick from, but no seating!

Very good family-owned deli! I ordered a turkey sandwich with lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo. The…read morelady at the front asked if I wanted oil and vinegar too, which I appreciated. The sandwich was piled high with turkey and everything tasted very fresh. The sandwich, soda, and chips came out to a bit over $7. Will definitely be coming back!

I don't know what the other reviewer is talking about because the sandwiches I've gotten here are…read morepretty damn good and I live in Manhattan. I believe it was a turkey and swiss on whole wheat with lettuce and tomato. All fresh all crisp generous portions and very tasty. Keep up the good work.

It was really nice experience. I gave some custom order and they made it right. When I asked, what…read moredo I have tell you to order same next time? They got my name and hold that special order for me!!!!!

The prices are good but the employees and the customer service are horrendous and I feel extremely…read moreoffended because the cashier was talking bad about somebody in a language they don't understand.

Going with 5 stars on this one, because it's going to be hard to beat. They have parking along…read morewith street parking. Very busy, so you know it's solid. Especially with competition right across the street. They have everything organized inside with the ordering and paying/ pick up area. I was craving an Italian sub. So I rolled the dice and ordered one. Quality was excellent and priced "normally". I'm not sure we know what normal is when it comes to eating out, but this was below what I was expecting to pay considering what I received. My son got the Buffalo Chicken wrap and the results were exactly the same. Being a bagel joint, I'm sure their specialties are breakfast sandwiches, so I'll have to visit earlier next time. Lunch was totally on point and I'm looking forward to trying their breakfast sandwich.

Excellent and friendly counter service. I love the Everything bagel with egg and sausage. Never…read morecrowded. Plenty of space for me to journal and people watch.