This particular Jersey Mike's Subs location is in the Varsity Place shopping plaza and was a good overall visit. Let me start by saying that parking can be a bit of a challenge, but I was here early enough before the lunch rush so that parking wasn't an issue. I would say that that would probably not be the case if I came about a half hour later. The ambiance here is about what you would expect from a Jersey Mike's Subs. It is bright and inviting enough, but definitely a no-frills type ambiance. My go-to at Jersey Mike's Subs is an Italian for a cold sub and the Big Kahuna for their hot sub. Both are good and I would recommend either. Jersey Mike's Subs are my favorite of the national sub chains. Something that I think is a huge plus is that Jersey Mike's Subs are pretty consistent at any of their locations. That says a lot to the training Jersey Mike's Subs offers to its franchisees. I would definitely recommend this particular location. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Eat there several times per month. Always make a great sandwich and never seem frustrated when a make changes to my sandwich. Staff is usually very friendly. I'll keep coming back read more

Got the wrong sub delivered and the staff was very rude and combative when I asked for a refund or remake, they only said do it online and wouldn't give any information about where or how. They gave me stale wheat bread when I ordered whites, it's untoasted but so hard and dry I think it must be a few days past when it's supposed to have been served. Spent almost $20 on one bad sandwich and ended up throwing it out it was so dry and bland. Terrible service and experience. read more

Workers have rude attitudes. No hi, hello, how are you. Worker threw the bread back once we asked for a different kind. Talked so low and not at us to the point we couldn't hear them. The lady next to the guy didn't say a single word and just looked us up and down. Awful service and would pick subway over this place. read more

Big Kahuna is the only hot sandwich I like. If cold, the tuna. I enjoyed the Philly, with additions of banana, pepper, and tomato. Surprisingly the bread was soft. Like super soft, perf. Only change? Extra peppers, onions, and more banana peppers. I like to eat there so I can have it fresh and hot off the grill, and I will also have them put my bread on the grill with butter--to bring it all home. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Two years. It's been two years since I dare step foot back in this particular Jersey Mikes, my previous two visits gave me EVERY reason not to even try again, but, small town, convenience, blah blah blah. So I made the choice to try again. I'm glad I did. I NEVER had a problem with their food, it's a solid chain with solid specs to assure your food is consistent, now, the service, therein lies the rub. My last two visits (years apart) were, to say the least, sorely lacking in the service department and i will leave it there. Let's talk about this visit. I walked in, the place looked like it had been refurbished, renovated, it was neat and clean but even more so, I was greeted with smiles, "welcome to jersey mikes" AJ and Dre were friendly, chatty, efficient AF! Call me crazy but if I didn't know better I would think they actually LIKED their work, their job, it was refreshing and dramatically different from my last visits. They explained it was an all new crew and management and it was quite obvious these cats love what they do. The Big Kahuna was just as I remembered it, hot, cheesy and with those jalapeños just kicking!! Great job, good food, I came back the next day to make sure it wasn't. Fluke, got the number 7 and it was the same, good food, great service. Now I can hit add jersey Mikes back into my handful of places I trust with my business, again, thank you Dre and AJ, you won this old man back as a customer, great job. TD read more

Won't be back-went to tie my shoe lace on corner of a metal chair - General Patton made a bee-line for me and told me to get my shoe out of the chair! Firstly my foot wasn't in the seat of the chair and I was tripping over my lace-what a weirdo! You guys should have a talk with this employee-with his personality it won't be long till more serious issues arise. Just too many choices to put up with this kind of childish worker. Good luck with him PS I'm a husband, father and grandfather - I don't require correcting like that. I'm always considerate and thoughtful of others. read more

The food is almost always great. There have been one or two times when things haven't been as good, but a vast majority of time the food is great. The location is clean and looks professional. The service is always great. The workers are always really friendly. Overall, a great place for a sandwich! read more

This is the second delivery we have received from this location. The sandwiches were all slopped together and received as unappetizing messes. We won't be using this location again. It's too bad that apparently the workers here don't care. It's not Jersey Mike's fault. The Mahan location is really good. read more

Tamia was so kind and very helpful. The whole team was very hardworking, I will be returning :)

I came here during lunchtime to get a sandwich. I ordered online and placed a pick up for my order. I asked if my order was ready and they said no so I had to sit down for about 15 to 20 minutes. While I was sitting down I noticed there were roaches crawling on the floor in the restaurant. I was disgusted! Not only that, they didn't even tell me that my food was ready and it was just sitting on the counter. Once I got the sandwich I didn't even want to eat it because I was Disgusted by the roaches. read more

The workers were super nice and had a great experience. Best workers ever. Good food too I guess

My husband placed a order at Jersey Mike , online and the order was not ready , the two attendees that work there , one went to check the order and declared the order never came thur. When review online .. it's was a mistake on the company end... As I picked up the order . I had the online confirmation, with me.. As the person that sever on the front line taking orders, seem to think it was more funny to entertain the other customers that thought it was funny when she mistake the customer for door dash... and continue to entertain the friends in the store .. Rude , & #1 she should have took the time out to see where there mistake was... Instead of finding it amusing to sit there and laugh about it . So therefore I was not pleased no amused especially when I had a confirmation time and a pickup time but your staff seem to think that it was funny and entertain it with the other friends that she had in the store . Tallahassee Florida location West Tennessee Street store number 1801 "4 read more

Food here is very good but the service is terrible. I was the only one on the restaurant with 4 people working behind the counter but I waited almost 20 minutes to get my sandwich. They sliced the meat then proceeded to have a conversation with my half made sandwich just sitting there. Then some person came in screaming profane language, proceeded to cut me in line, and get their food before me. Definitely do not come here if you are in a rush. Not the first time this has happened either. read more

This place is a fucking joke. Just placed an online order, they confirmed it, said they were making it and then notified me they were out of bread and refused to give me a refund. If you're a sandwich shop and u run out of bread, just close. This is shop is pathetic, do better, figure it out. read more

Going the wrong direction. Walked in again today to see if they had worked on any of the challenges I faced on my last visit. As I walked in, again, there was no greeting, I mean how hard is that, a simple greeting? As I walked to the back to wash my hands, I noticed one customer in line, no one helping him, and a huddle of employees in the back. I also noticed that the same crew from my last visit was there, same manager, same dirty shirt, still untucked and just sloppy. I washed my hands and returned to the counter. Same customer in line, no one around to help, I asked if they had taken his order and he said no, he hadn't even been acknowledged. I decided there were far batter places for me to spend my money today and walked out. As I started to drive off I saw the other gentleman with whom I was in line was also walking out. Sad but true. So in the comments from my last visit, a manager from Jerseys Mike's had left a number to call, so I did. Alas, just More corporate rhetoric. They don't care, they simply do not care. They sit directly beside campus so they know they will have business. Were this place in a more competitive location, they would fail miserably. They lack even the most basic concept of customer service -in the service in the service industry? Employees are poorly trained and, quite frankly, dirty. That's the image they portray here. Best of luck in the future, though you really won't need it, you have settled for mediocrity over integrity. The corporate world wins again. read more

I used to get great service. I work for a car dealer and order EVERYDAY! Not always from here but I do order a lot. Todays sandwich a cheesesteak came with some of the meat out of the sandwich and stuck to the paper. The bread was hard and overall the sandwich SUCKED! For what I pay they should get it right! Don't bother ordering from here unless you want it to come messed up! I am telling everyone here to order Firehouse because they don't fuck it up read more

horrible service. The staff were very rude. I ordered two minis and the proportion was completely off we did not get a correct size . overall do better i do not wanna pay 15 dollars for wrong size of sandwich . read more

Great subs! I'm a vegetarian so I order the veggie and I always get it "Mike's Way" which is with onion, tomato, lettuce, oil, vinegar, & their blend of salt, pepper, and other spices. I also add in pickles and mayo. I ask them to grill the green bell peppers all the time for me because it adds a bit of a warm element to an otherwise cold sub. It's great if you go on Monday for double points or Tuesday which I believe they give $2 off. read more

Of all the chain sub shops, Jersey Mike's is my favorite. Their version of an Italian sub (#13) complete with spicy red pepper spread ("hots"), puts Subway's, Jimmy John's, and Lenny's to shame. Their cheese steaks and chicken cheese steaks, especially the Big Kahuna (#56 stuffed with mushrooms, peppers and jalapeños) are delicious. On this particular visit to the campus adjacent facility I opted for the Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak (#44). Frank's Red Hot sauce, lettuce and blue cheese dressing topped the chicken. It was a buffalo wing on a roll, and hit the spot. Pepsi products are on draft, so if you're a Coca-Cola person you may want to get your sandwich to go. Prices are reasonable for a combo (about $10) and service was attentive and friendly. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Tim D you suck. This place is so gas and the staff was so dope. Maybe you went in when the college kids were hungover idk. But my sub is always so good from there. Maybe don't go there next time. You prob being an a** anyway. Some people are trying to make a living here‼ you look like a douche anyway read more

Probably my favorite sub shop out of all the choices out there. The mini is big enough for lunch especially since I get chips too. I usually get the original done Mikes way which has Italian cold cuts, lettuce tomato and onion with vinegar and oil and seasonings. Yummmm! read more

I would leave jersey mikes with a 5 star but the customer service is absolutely disgraceful. Laziest fucking people I've ever seen in my life. They get paid to serve us not stand around at the register and stare at customers. Do ur fucking job. read more

I am completely understanding of an afternoon lunch rush, but I have never in my life had to wait over an hour for a hot sandwich. Typically when a chain company such as this one fails to meet their service standards, they will try to make up for their shortcomings or apologize for the wait. None of that was done and again considering this is a multimillion dollar company, I was really disappointed. read more

This is one for the record books. Just left the Jersey Mike's store on Market St., in Tallahassee. I waited in line, alone, for almost 10-minutes before my order was taken. Ordered only to be informed they were out of white bread. That happens, so I ordered an alternate. I paid, had a seat and waited and waited. After another 10+ minutes, inquired about my sandwich. Found out it wasn't ordered to the cook. Without an apology, the cashier, the one that I ordered the sandwich from, asked for my receipt of which he hadn't provided to me to begin with. He did though, remember what I'd ordered. He asked to cook about the order, she had no clue and he was baffled. Said something about if I wanted a wrap! I asked for my money back; he asked for the receipt!! Another 4-5 minutes of him on the phone asking about how to access the cash register and finally, gave me back my $11. Departed and will not return. Again, no apology, nothing. Total disrespect, shameful. You can do better! read more

Far and away the best Italian sub in the world, and the employees are always pleasant. I'd eat there seven days a week if I wasn't trying to live to 100! read more

Red headed employee was short and super rude today. Watched him blatantly disrespect customers and roll his eyes when a customer made a simple request. read more

Chicken Philly Steak Hot Sub where have you been all my life?!?!? Lunch hour Rush is killer here and found me waiting over 20 minutes for a hot sub. Believe it or not, it was my first time so I didn't know what I was getting myself into. A little pricey for a combo, almost $10, with standard fare chips and soft drinks you find in most chain sandwich places. Clean but crowded. A fridge offers a path less traveled for drinks but nothing exciting, some bottled alternatives to the soda machine. The hot sub was delicious though (and the reason for my 4 stars). Packed with crisp bacon, overflowing cheese, and smoky peppers and onions with a moist grilled chicken. Yum! Plus- I really liked that there was an alternative to the traditional steak option and found that it hits the spot when craving more a more savory lunch. read more

I placed a order through call. Once I arrived, I noticed ALL the employees were ignoring me and my friend, talked to a worker who said he was "looking for my food" but instead he continued to throw out trash and I did not see him look for it once. When I asked an employee, she said to wait. It wasn't until 30 minutes of no service that I realize it was because I was wearing a FAMU hat at a FSU jersey mike location. Asked one more time because two people who came in after me left with their sandwich after 10 minutes and I was still told to wait again. Very disappointed with my service, this was a item on my bucket list that I've never had before and it hurt for that to be my first experience. This place is located in West Tennessee in Tallahassee FL. read more

I'm not expecting a whole lot from a sandwich shop. Decent food at a reasonable price is all I ask. This is apparently too much to ask from Jersey Mikes. There are a few things that I am looking for in a good sandwich. Good bread, flavorful meat, and fresh toppings. The bread wasn't terrible, but it wasn't good either. The meat and cheese had no flavor at all. I had a turkey and provolone "Mike's Way" which means it comes with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, vinegar, oil and spices. I also had them add some cherry pepper relish. The cherry pepper relish is the single reason I'm not giving this place one star. The ordering system isn't very efficient. You queue up and order your sandwich, at which point they slice your meat and bread. Rather than keep you in the line while they assemble your order they have you pay. At which point telling the person behind the counter how you want your sandwich becomes a little difficult because you are either past the register or behind the line. Parking is almost nonexistent. We got there at 11:30 AM and there was one spot available. By the time we were leaving at 12:10, there were four cars circling the parking lot and some douche had parked his jacked up Chevy Diesel on the grassy space between the parking lot and the street. All in all, there are plenty of other places I'd rather spend 10 bucks on a sandwich in Tallahassee, but none have cherry pepper relish. I am sure I wasted a perfectly good snooki reference in here somewhere, but it's not even worth the attempt at mediocre humor. read more

Between this place and the Chipotle next door, the parking lot is usually packed so full you'll see cars parked on the medians. I thought this was unusual behavior until I ordered my sub, and the guy commented on it by saying that yea, they usually encourage people to just park up on the grass because they usually get people in and out quick. I guess they don't tow? Either way the sub was really good, the bread which they bake on site is really fluffy and warm. The ingredients seemed to reflect the relatively high cost of the sandwich (I got a 6~ inch Philly cheese steak for 7 dollars), but it was pretty damn good. I guess that's always subjective, though, so you'll have to decide if the ingredients are good enough to merit your dollar. Also, they do this thing where you enter your phone number into a box every time you order, and it'll send you a text letting you know how many sandwiches you've bought. Once you hit a certain amount of purchases, you can get free sandwich, but I could see how this system might be annoying for people without unlimited texting plans. Because of the price, you wouldn't want to go to Jersey Mike's if you just want to grab a quick sandwich on the way to work - but definitely a nicer place to eat at than say Jimmy Johns or Subway if you instead wanted to get a really casual & quick dinner with some friends. read more

I love love love Jersey Mike's! Specifically, the Tennessee Street location. I eat here all the time, and I never have a complaint. I am gluten free, and no matter the amount of people in line, the employees take the time to wipe down the counter and slicer for me. The manager, John, encourages his employees and they all seem to be having a good time working! Considering the amount of people that eat there, it's awesome that the employees can remember my order! read more

I have always ordered the chipotle chicken philly this time they were out of chicken so I decided to try out the chipotle steak philly. I added lettuce and tomato to it which I know is kind of weird for a philly but it was really good! Maybe even better than the chicken and I love the chicken. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Chipotle philly - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Subs here are fresh and delicious. a little over priced but you definitely get a nice portion for what you pay for. I'm from Jersey, so they aren't as authentic with the variety of toppings but they have the basics down and the ingredients are fresh, which is most important. read more

Be careful with delivery orders through the official mobile app. They forgot to include my chips, and when I called they could not digitally refund me the difference nor offer to deliver the missing chips. The manager asked me to come to the store to get a cash refund for a delivery paid via Apple Pay. While I was on hold waiting for a manager, I overhead them talking about how they often forget chips on delivery orders. Submitted a complaint. Waiting on follow-up. read more

I really l like this place. And guess what? I can proudly say I have never EVER received a problem from Jersey Mike's. Except one.. ITS TOO GOOD! read more

I have been coming to this Jersey Mike's for years and it's always been wonderful but today they made me the best sandwich I've ever seen in my life. If you are lucky enough to have Kendrick working during your visit, prepare yourself for a perfect and beautiful sub. read more

Delicious!!! It's so much meat and so juicy. I'm always drooling for more!! The first time I had the Steak Big Kahuna Regular I had it without mushrooms. The second time i went, i said let me try this lol And it was delicious like really flavorful and juicy read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Steak Big Kahuna Regular I should get a gift for how much I come there - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Jersey Mikes is fantastic! They have a happy and friendly staff that makes your sandwich very quickly. And it's delicious!! If you have any questions about how things taste they will let you sample. It's a pleasure buying a sun from them because they are so great. Really happy they are here in Tallahassee. read more

Great subs and friendly faces! Always a good experience and their sweet tea is great.