Not sure how this could have been better. I got the Giant Italian sub ! The toppings were very generous and service was very quick and polite. The only thing, if you get the oil and vinegar as I did, you will want to eat soon after or lay napkins on the paper they wrap it in to prevent the bread from becoming soggy. That's what I did because the Giant can last you throughout the entire day. The bread would have been mush if I did not use many napkins to soak up all the moisture the lined the paper wrapping read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Giant Italian sub Super fresh toppings - Fast Food Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

Fast, patient, efficient service. Guys were friendly. Clean interior. Food is always on point if you're in the mood for subs. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Part of the dining room. - Fast Food Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

See all

I have to start this DO NOT PURCHASE DELIVERY FROM THIS STORE!!!! Awful experience and no management worth a crap. Wife ordered food for herself and the kids and they handed it to doordash. The driver delivered to the wrong house and we never got the food so we call the restaurant. They say they cant do anything to call doordash (even though we ordered from the jersey mikes app). So we call doordash and they say to call the restaurant. WTF is going on here. So manager tells my wife there is nothing he can do. OVER A SMALL $20 ORDER. So I call my bank and file a dispute. The restaurant challenged the dispute and it was denied. Seriously? This is a shady restaurant. I will NEVER use them again and neither will ANYONE I know. You should be ashamed of ripping people off and not taking care of customers. My wife ordered from you every week for 3 years now and you LOST all the business by ripping us off. This is 100% accurate information. If the owners of this location see this GOOD. They need to know how they rip people off. Reporting to BBB and all over social media pages. You messed with the wrong person. Enjoy that $20 for nothing. read more

Service here is always wonderful. The staff is cheerful and the store is clean. They build a beautiful sandwich read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - A beautiful sandwich - Fast Food Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

The food was A-mazing! My mother owns a small business like this too and it really makes me happy to see it doing so well! The blonde lady holding down the fort was also great and very cheery, amazing service overall. The location is not the best, but once you go inside the establishment it really changes your whole mood! As soon as I inhaled the smells of subs, I was practically foaming at the mouth! Thanks Jersey mikes, for an amazing, wonderful, and delightful Sunday afternoon. I will be back soon read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

The new chicken cheese Mikes Sauce was disgusting!!! I watched him take a frozen thin piece of chicken on the griddle , overcook the crap out of it and throw some onions on it. The meat was so gross I threw it in the trash. They also forgot the Mikes sauce. 10.65 for trash. The bag of Doritos were my dinner. Do better !! read more

Very kind staff and very friendly, this blonde curly haired lady was very kind and helped me with my order. Would return again!

So, the employee would not let me have 2 subs, a chicken Philly and a big kahuna on one 6 inch sub bun. So, they would be open faced. My husband and I are trying to cut down on our carbs so we only eat our sandwiches with one side of bread or bun. The employee said it would get messed up in the paper. I said, just put it in a container like you use for your salads. She said no, corporate won't allow it. I mean, come on! You think you would want your customers to be happy. And we go to Jersey Mikes a lot. But, they wouldn't do it so I left. Very, very in happy. Jersey Mikes lost my business. And no, I don't want to hear some lame ass excuse of why they don't allow it. I've gone to other sandwich places, they just say sure! No problem! read more

the best Jersey mikes around!!! seriously so much better than other locations! always so tasty. they just know how to do it, what can I say? excellent GF bread and safety! read more

Freshness and service are their strong points. An efficient menu that is easy to select from unlike that other "underground" named place. Our current go to for take out subs. read more

this is one of the worst stores i have ever been to . i ordered a sub and it was delivered, only to find the sub had too much pickle juice on it, it was soaked. I drove the sub back to the store and they argued with me about what was on it. i asked if they could please redo it, they went ahead and help all the people behind me first, then just stood there. so i walked out. i called and asked for a refund since they kept my sub, but wouldnt do it. the employees are never friendly, one girl that works there is always rude. i would never go back there. since then i order from johnstown, and never have a problem. horrible store, horrible employees, worse management. read more

loved the sub but did not love being forced to tip. Never went back.............................................................................................................................................................................. read more

Server asked what I wanted while she was making a sandwich and asked me to repeat it because she was busy. Why ask what I want if you're not going to listen. Due to me raising voice for order. The manager Marcus had a bad attitude talking back to me raising his voice. Maybe should have said sorry about that but took the low road. Very poor manager and customer service. The store needs customer service training! read more

Really good subs. A little pricey however you get what you pay for which are big delicious subs. Never fails !

Ordered delivery on the app. It arrived delicious and fast! No extra ordering fees. Our sandwiches had a few special requests for toppings and everything arrived perfect! read more

Service is always OUTSTANDING and food is always 100% FANTASTIC quality!!!!‍ The dude always working there is extremely personable and an outstanding multitasker. I feel bad i forget his name... BUT GREAT SERVICE read more

this has happened to me twice. one person ahead of me I ordered one regular sub the people behind me had a four big subs order they did the people behind me first. I waited at least 15 minutes or more, I almost walked out. Why? good food poor service read more

For just opening they really got it together!! We ordered 3 yummy subs and were not disappointed!! Totally delicious. Barley a wait, despite the amount of customers. Our subs were so yummy!!! We will definitely be eating subs from here again and again. Fresh and delicious! read more

I don't understand the low rating. Reading the TWO other reviews, a guy is mad he had to wait for his sandwich (that he ordered hot) to get hot? This upsets him, so he gives a low rating. That's so uncoool. Smh. Anyway, this place is SO good. It's clean, it's fresh (they slice the meat right in front of you!) and the staff is always above friendly! I order the mini Italian on rosemary / cheese bread, Mike's way*, add mayo (don't forget this part ;)Omgosh - I crave this sub at least twice a week. Get some salt and vinegar chips on the side, or one of their fresh baked, gooey chocolate chip cookies and a root beer (or cream soda) and Yummm. An affordable meal you'll get addicted to - just like me! *Mike's way means to add onions, lettuce, tomatoes, olive oil blend, red wine vinegar and spices read more

Had to wait 20 minutes for a warm sandwich..... bullshit. The place is not logistically sound If you order a hot sandwich you stand in line while everyone is passing you. Have been to many Jersey Mike's..... this one sucks! read more

Food was good as always. The lady who made my sub was professional, nice and quick. However, the man working the cash register on 9/16/21 was loudly complaining about how people don't tip or tip low and showing his displeasure with it. read more

Nice staff, quick service, and food's good every time. I get the stickball (provolone, ham, and salami) on white bread. The bread is baked fresh. Mondays are double points days. read more

We've ordered subs from the new Pataskala Jersey Mike's and they were really good. Service was fast and staff was friendly. We will definitely visit often read more

Jersey Mikes has a new location in Pataskala, Ohio. We love it but this one in particular has issues. We order online to pick up and every time we have they never seem to have the order ready. As a matter of fact, they do not even start it until we get there to pick it up. You are supposed to beat the line when you place an order online. The staff was so concerned about the line that they were not filling carry out online orders. I actually overheard one of the staff say people in line come first. Well, no, I don't think that is true. There were 4 staff members but never actually saw a manager. So maybe someone needs to manage them. They were borderline rude. I waited another 15 mins before they got it done. They took care of the line inside first. Probably won't go back. Too bad as I really like their food. read more

I have been there 4 times now and have been impressed every time. For a new place in town with new young workers they are doing a great job. The place is very clean, employees greet you and are very pleasant every time. We have ordered both the hot and cold subs and have not been disappointed at all. I think my favorite is now the super sub with bacon added. Welcome to Pataskala read more

Pataskala has been dry of food forever until jersey mikes was introduced. They bring the spice of great subs for a decent price, great service with very nice workers. Andrew and Taylor are some of the most polite people i've ever been helped by! read more

Finally Pataskala gets a Jersey Mike's! The food was good even though they got my order wrong. To be fair it was the day after grand opening so I understand that. The staff was friendly and fixed my order. The only thing I had a problem with is if you pay with a card it wants you to leave a tip. This is before you have even ate your food and you have to get your own drink, straw, napkin, and wait at the counter for your sub. Why should you be asked to leave a tip? read more