This review is only for the portabella mushroom sandwich on wheat with extra cheese. This is hands down one of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten and I would never have expected such awesomeness from a sub chain. The sandwich is made up of grilled Portabella mushrooms, peppers and onions with melted Swiss cheese. I suggest getting extra cheese. According to the Jersey Mike's web site they are serving the freshest local mushrooms and I believe it. This is the official statement on their news page: "It's important to keep this fresh product locally grown, and it took time to organize mushroom growers across the country," "The mushrooms are picked, transported and delivered to our stores within days of coming from the growers." Additionally, their wheat bread is a perfect consistency with just the right amount of firmness on the outside with a melt in your mouth center that captures all the delicious flavors. I can't speak to any of the other things Jersey Mikes sells, and I doubt I will ever try them as any trip to one of their locations will be for the sole purpose of obtaining the portabella sub that I have fallen in love with. read more

See all

Ordered off Jersey Mike's website for delivery. Driver delivered wrong order. Store told me to contact customer service. BUT I ORDERED OFF JERSEY MIKES WEBSITE. Talk about passing the buck. Ruined Super Bowl Sunday. I did call DoorDash Customer Service. Talked to one representative that said she was going to transfer me. Now I have been on hold for over 10 minutes. This Jersey Dave is done with Jersey Mike's. If you are not going to take responsibility for DoorDash, find another delivery service, or create your own. read more

Rudest service. Will never return. This location shames jersey mikes all around. They are rude to each other, screaming at each other in front of customers as well as rude to customers. To top it off, the chicken cheesesteak was definitely NOT right. Very different from jersey mikes chicken cheesesteaks in all the worst ways. Maybe they had a bad day, maybe they are always this way, I'm not sure. Too bad of an experience to ever come back again. read more

I have been going to this location for many years. Theresa a Kevin are the best. They are always very professional and efficient. Keep up the great service read more

Great quality of food ,clean and efficient. Wonderful staff.being a family owed store they take pride in what they do and have fun along the way. read more

I actually cannot stand this place. I order frequently and every. single. time. I go I order ahead of time via phone and when I get there 25-30 mins later it's never even started. What is the point of even calling? Went there today and was literally ignored standing at the front waiting 10 minutes to pay. This place is a disaster that's all. Food is great though which unfortunately makes me come back. I would say for catering and such go to rt 33 they're much more on top of things. read more

All of the staff are friendly and efficient. I usually call ahead and order for large groups so I've been to this location many times and everyone is always complimenting the fresh bread, toppings and protein selections. I personally love the Original Italian sub and the Chicken Cheesesteak. I still continue to patronize this establishment as subs are made to order with high quality meats and customer service! My favorite subs are The Super Sub Original Italian Stickball Special Club Sub Super Sub Came today and got a turkey ham club in a wrap it was fabulous!!! Turkey Breast & Provolone American Classic Jersey Shores Favorite read more

Co-worker went out to get subs for the office.. he came back with my "Turkey and American Cheese" wrap. On the wrap itself was a bunch of lettuce, American cheese, onions, and a measley wimp slice of what once was a full feathered Turkey. I'm telling ya that this ONE slice of turkey couldn't feed a chipmunk. If I gave this one slice of turkey to a bird, the bird would have to fly around to other areas in the park because it would still be hungry. Can you tell how disappointed I was? I'll upload a pic to show you all that this IS the place if you want a salad wrapped in a wheat wrap. For all other people, skip this location. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sad - Fast Food Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

I expected something more than received from my Baja Chicken Wrap at this Jersey Mike's Subs in the Marketplace @ Hamilton. First, the menu on the wall was limited to a few sandwiches, wraps or cheesesteaks. No house made chicken salad, tuna, or the like. While there were adequate chunks of white meat chicken in the wrap, it was seriously overloaded with lettuce fill, and very little jalapeno. After opening the paper wrapping, it unfolded on the tray, and much of the filling slid out. That was caused in part by a too wet sandwich that was not able to hold together. While I appreciate that the veggies were washed before construction, they should have also been dried more before stuffing into the mix. Too, the sauce was plentiful, but thin, contributing to the flow. Messy. Hamilton has a lot of excellent submarine joints and delis that turn out quality memorable sandwiches. Frankly, Jersey Mike's is no where near their level of endeavor. And, it is more expensive than the old school shops like Little King and Classic, or even Firehouse, not to mention Circle Deli and it's siblings. Maybe I came on a bad day, or maybe this store is resting on its laurels. Not Jersey strong. Disappointing. read more

See all

Always love Jersey Mike's.. no exception here except the fact that it takes an hour for them to make your sandwich. I mean any slower and they'd be turning bread into dough. All I'm saying is order ahead. Lovely people. read more

By far the best Jersey mikes location in the area. Family owned and operated. The staff is friendly, the establishment is clean, and the food is great. I would recommend this place to anyone over any other sub shop in the area! read more

This place is staffed by the worst, most rude, least courteous people on earth. I have never ever gotten into an argument with retail staff in my life until I went here. The entire ordering process was a disaster. First we tried to add salami to a kids sandwich and were willing to pay for it. But were told "no we don't do that" not "I'm sorry sorry we can't make modifications. Or It will be an extra charge." But "no we don't do that". Then we ordered a cheese steak from the grill. The response from the associate was "well that's going to be at least 20 min because we are working with half a grill today. The other half is broken and there are already 3 orders ahead of you " with an attitude that she was upset I even bothered to order a grill item. So we changed to two different subs. While I was ordering those new subs which we decided on the fly the cashier person was asking questions about the kids meals and if we were going to order drinks and chips. Of course it was my fault I can't listen and answer two people at the same time. So I told her we want chips and a drink. This was not an option for a kids meal. So I said fine we'll get extra chips then. She apparently never heard this and walked away to do something else. This led to issues at the end of our meal. We moved to the register when everything else was complete. A different person came to finish ringing us up. We placed everything in the tray. Paid the total with a credit card and walked to our table. After setting up our food I could not find one of the kid straws. So I went up to the counter and asked if could please have another kid straw. The reply I got was "I already gave you two" and I said. "Yeah I can't find one of them" it doesn't matter why I'm asking for one. There is no posted limit on how many straws I can have and I clearly needed another. There was no reason for the attitude. But that's not even the worst. At the end of the meal. After we had already paid and eaten all of our food I went up to ask for the cookies that came with our kids meals. Which are self serve. But we were never told that. When I showed them the receipt it showed they had run us up wrong (they never included the chips we ordered and placed on our food tray and showed the cashier during payment.) I said how about you keep the cookies and we'll call it even. I walked away attempting to leave. Another associate decided this was not acceptable and called me back and told me we had to pay for the chips and was accusing me that it was my fault they were not included originally and that I owed them more money. Of course if I never showed them the receipt they wouldn't have even known. I explained everything was on our tray. We already paid. If you make an error and the transaction closes it's on you and your staff. The associate decided to argue with me and then told me and my wife who were obviously aggravated not to act in this manner in front of our children. That was the end. I left a ten dollar bill on the counter and walked out. This is the worst retail experience I have ever had. I'm sure this is an anomaly and you won't have the same experience but if there are people that work here that are capable of such a disaster in customer service you should rethink where you are spending your money. I'll be reaching out to corporate customer care and disputing the charges with my credit card company. read more

I'm obsessed with their Italian sub! They are great for catered events too! I've been here any times and it's always consistent and good.

Tables were dirty. Looks like same sandwich at jersey mikes flemington has more meat at cheese than here. Will not rerun will keep going to flemington read more

Staff is very friendly and attentive. Subs are delicious. I got the classic American and it was really good. I would go back. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Classic American sub - Fast Food Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

I love this Jersey Mikes! It is definitely always yummy. My favorite us the chicken bacon ranch wrap. The owner is wonderful and the staff is always friendly and helpful. The food is always fresh and made to order. Whether we call it in or just go in and order it's always quick. It's always our go to! read more

I have been frequenting this store for a while now, however during the pandemic this location has gone above and beyond for my family and I. Thankful they have been open and serving the community! The staff is the best and have made us feel safe in these crazy times. Thanks Jersey Mike's. read more

Stopped in during my lunch break for a sub to go, it was super clean and the staff was so friendly and funny! Definitely one of the best locations I've been to. I will be back for sure! read more

I come here all the time with my friends and coworkers. The staff is always friendly and the service is always quick! The sandwiches are always fresh and delicious! read more

When i have my hand out for the receipt dont place it on the counter like you dont see my hand. Racist. We here to stay so deal with it!!

I am blown away by all the negative reviews. I've been going there for a few years and I've been there more times than I can count. I've never really looked at the meat cutter, so I'll give some of the previous reviewers benefit of the doubt. However, I've never recieved wilted lettuce/ tomatoes or hard bread and every sub that I ever ordered was loaded with meat. I think their meat quality is great and for the most part, their sandwiches look just like they do in the posters and other advertisements. My only complaint is that their prices are a little higher than most places and they could use a bigger variety of drinks and chips. read more

For starters, it was too expensive for what I received. It was $7+ for a plain wrap and I felt sliiiightly deceived since it said grilled veggies and what I got was onions and some green peppers cooked with oil on the grill and added to lettuce and tomatoes. I thought grilled veggies were more than just onions and a spoon-full of green peppers. HOWEVER, I must say, it tasted good-- I didn't feel that my money went to a horrible meal. I was full and pleased with taste and the people behind the counter. I don't think I'll be back but thats because I wanted some more vegetarian-friendly variety-- but the turkey subs looked fresh and tasty for meat-eaters. read more

Usually love this location but I left my job early tonight and arrived at this jersey mikes 25 minutes before closing, says it on the door, says it on the website.... but the girl behind the counter just gave me the cut sign from across the room I GUESS telling me they're closed early. I can't even explain how upset I am with this business. Would have made it 1% better if she could have came to the door and explained the situation but she just turned around and acted like she didn't see me. We do big orders for work sometimes and I honestly never want to return here. Disappointed is an understatement but at least I got a delicious meal next door at jersey girl cafe. read more

Fail. I'm 56 and never heard of Jersey Mike's until they had franchise start ups in South Carolina where I lived before. High priced. Better off going to a Mom and Pop sub shop. Very disappointed. More roll, less meat like Subway. I guess this would be a good place for a quick lunch break rather than burgers, but if you want to relax and savor the taste of a good hoagie, this is not the place. "Ich Don't Think So" read more

I love the jersey Mike's location at the Hamilton marketplace. Customer service is bar none as soon as you walk through the doorway. The employee's are very proficient, and friendly. Sandwiches are very good and alway fresh. You can tell that they take pride in their work. read more

I was here back about a year ago the sandwich was great. wHAT HAPPENED The lunch meat was horrible. The man slicing my ham had it so thick I was hating that. Then it wasn't making it in the sandwich half was on the counter no gloves on. Let me just say all the ham went in the garbage I ate the cheese. They need to get some better stuff. In need of a clean up read more

This store is such a messed up store. I walked in to get a #43 in a tub with extra meat, bacon and mike's way with no chips or drink and I paid a 10% on tip. I did not pay attention while I made the payment. The lady at the cashier gave me the receipt to sign and threw away the other receipt that got printed out in front of me and I wasn't bothered. So now I don't have a receipt. I checked my credit card being charged $18.37 the next day and I only bought 1 tub. I get the same tub at every Jersey Mikes (Kenilworth and Cherry Hill both locations the NJ) and always get charged $12.53 (8.25 for sub+$2 for extra meat+ $1.50 for bacon+tax) for it as a sub in a tub versus a giant tub. I called up two days after to find out why I was being charged so much more. The owner of the this store was very rude while I was trying to talk to him explaining my situation and try to understand what went wrong. He never let me speak and he was so loud. As an owner of any business you don't do that to any of your customers no matter what the problem is. I was in no way trying to cheat him and he said so that I was cheating him by asking for money back. I had to hung up on him as I knew that I was talking to the walls! I will never ever go back to this jersey Mikes ever again!!!! Very much disgusted with the attitude of the owner and how he spoke, it's unacceptable and plain rude! read more

Ordered a club supreme online. After I opened up what I thought would be a fantastic sandwich I realized there was no bacon, Mayo or oregano. It's a club sandwich, got to have bacon. Clearly I was robbed from this location. This isn't the first time I've had a bad experience with ordering a club from Mike's. I've ordered many times in person and have been asked "would you like bacon". "YES" its a club. Why would you even ask that. read more

This place is very discusting plain and simple . I went there 5-31-2013 I ordered a tuna sub with swiss cheese. 1st the slicer they used to cut the cheese was dirty and gross it was covered with pices of old meat and scraps of old cheese it looked like they had not cleaed it all day. Next the bread they used to make my sandwhich was out and sitting on the counter it looked old dry and stale. I complained to the person making my sandwhich a young girl who worked there she just looked at me funny and did not correct the problem. I walked out with out a sub and I did not buy the one they made for me. I have contacted the Board of Health because there hygiene practices are far below the normal standards and it unsafe to serve food in this way . I would not go there again for any reason. read more

My local Jersey Mike's is so much better than this location. The staff clearly don't care and are super rude. The sandwich was eh, super oily and bread disintegrated from all the oil and vinegar. Was hardly edible. Had the nerve to ask for a tip when they don't even serve with any semblance of kindness?? read more

Sandwiches are always very fresh and wonderful. Best subs around! Owner is always nice and professional.

Recently started eating here, food is always so fresh and worth the price. The staff was efficient and worked so fast to keep the line moving which was great for me on my lunch break. I will definitely keep coming back and telling my friends about it as well. read more

Fresh sandwiches, great service, all around nice people. I would recommend this place to anyone.

Best jersey mikes I've ever been to! An employee Kevin was super funny and personable. The rest of the team was great as well

Jersey Mike's is a New Jersey institution that does not disappoint. I've eaten many Jersey Mike's subs over the years including at their original location and the Hamilton Marketplace store presses everything the way I remember it from when I was a kid. My favorites are the turkey, roast beef, Italian, and cheesesteak. DW also gets tuna on occasion. read more

I don't eat meat so it was extremely refreshing to find a veggie sub that actually tastes good! Their vegetables are crisp and fresh, their cheese is delicious, their bread is nice and soft and the oil and vinegar is the icing on the cake. I couldn't even finish my veggie sub from Subway. I will be coming here regularly :) read more

Great sandwich place, always get a great tasting hoagie here. I love the bread, way better than Subway. Wish Jersey Mike's put more lunchmeat on my sandwich, they really should for the price. Bottom line, this place is better than Subway but not as good as Italian People's. read more

Awesome tasty subs! The sandwiches here are great always fresh, the staff is always friendly and courteous. When I order I always get the tuna or steak sandwich with onions peppers no cheese. Great sub shop with genuine people. read more

Came in with my family. Enjoyed a great mix of subs: #5 ( extra oil &vin) and hot cheese steaks. Nice team behind counter and good menu. Well worth a visit, glad to see Jersey Mikes is in town. read more

I am a Jersey Mike's points member and often go by the one I work near which has a very friendly staff. On occasion, I visit the Hamilton location. The last time I was there a few months ago, several of the staff members were being rather mean to a coworker, complaining she moved too slow and ordering her around in front of customers. It was a bit uncomfortable, and the staff all seemed miserable. I returned because it was Double Points Day and I had a $2 off a regular sub coupon. I was ordering a sub and a cheese steak. When I was being rung up, the cashier informed me that I couldn't use my point card and the $2 off coupon. I thought it odd because I never have been told that at other locations. I told her it was no problem but asked if it was possible to ring up one sub with the $2 off coupon and the other separate for the points. She told me no, I can't earn points on already discounted items. This confused me as I wouldn't be getting points on discounted items, but I didn't push it. The man who was grilling the cheese steak turned then and very rudely told me I couldn't do both as it was the same thing and stated something along the lines of I would be "cheating them". I truthfully don't think I have ever been spoken to so rudely at a business. I simply had asked a polite question, did not demand it, and the man thought it was ok to turn around and insult me in front of other customers when I was not asking to "cheat" anyone. I wasn't asking for points on the saved $2 or even the balance of the sub they would use the coupon on. I ordered another sandwich that to me, would qualify for points. I politely said thank you, paid and left. I will never return to this location again. There are way too many mom and pop sub shops like Classic Sub, etc in the area that have better customer service and sandwiches. read more