They put a full cup of oil on my sandwich and now its soggy and gross. Why so much fucking oil

This used to be our "go to" sub shop. You can't beat the friendliness and helpful guys behind the counter, 5 stars for them! But the last couple visits, both our subs tasted off. Not the delicious flavor they used to have...don't know what happened? Did they change meat/cheese suppliers? Sad as they used to make one helluva sub but now looks like we need to find a different sub shop. read more

Jersey Mike's Geneva served our sophomore football team for their away games. All of our orders were perfectly packed, labelled and ready to go for pick up on time. Urbano and his team were easy to work with and super helpful and friendly. I would highly recommend using Jersey Mike's for any large team functions, they did right by us! read more

Comsistant good sandwhich, nice employees, nice store. When you cut meat and cheese from the end of the disk, you get less. In the case today, 36% less. 5 inch circumference to 4 inch losses that much. I don't mode paying $10 for a med Turkey and cheese. I mind when it's that much smaller. Easily fixed. Add two more slices of meant and one cheese when slicing the last 2 inches. read more

Their website does not allow a person to order online. It will not allow you to select a location to make an order. You have to go there and stand in line to order. read more

LOVE! Always fresh, so many sandwiches to choose from, made as ordered, fresh meats and other ingredients! Excellent! Thank you! read more

Clean, friendly, efficient, high quality. This is an elite Jersey mikes. Even when busy the line moves along. Will be making regular appearances here. read more

Needed some sandwiches to feed a group, ordered a box of sandwiches, labeled and packaged very nicely! Thanks

Jersey Mikes never fails me, ordered 3 sandwiches to go Monday afternoon and the young man making the sandwiches was the nicest and polite well mannered person. It really made my day and will go back to this store hoping he will still be there serving customers. read more

By far the most efficient Jersey Mikes I've ever been to. In and out in less than 5 minutes every time and great food.

i never write reviews but the staff as of 7-25-25 is the best. they always remember order and names and are always quick to make quality sandwiches. love this spot. read more

Jersey Mike's is doing it right during the pandemic. Their app is a dream to order from, and when you get there to pick up your sammy, you only have to step in the door and snatch it off a nearby table -- no rubbing shoulders with the teeming masses here! The sandwich is just as good as ever, too. Fresh-baked bread (not some concoction that the EU recently ruled couldn't be called bread - I'm looking at you Subway!), fresh ingredients, where you see the care they cut and stack and finish your sandwich to perfection. No squeezed up tight balls of bread and meat here, your sandwich actually looks like a sandwich when you unwrap it (I'm looking at you now, Jimmy John's!). TIP: Get the app, you'll never forget to get your reward points, you can easily order for the whole office and make sure every sandwich is clearly marked with that person's name. read more

I have been a loyal customer at this location for years. Recently I have had some frustration with "Ordering Ahead" on the app. I will place my order and come in 10 later than my "pickup time" according to my order confirmation. I will stand waiting for as much as 30mins more while they make sandwiches for everyone walking in after me. According to my receipt it should have been done 40 mins ago? I understand it can get busy but what is the point of ordering ahead? read more

Great people nice it's a nice clean place food is fresh parking is always there carry out service l give this business a five star and more food is not over priced thank you Jersey Mike for your Service read more

The service in here is excellent and fast. They can make anything you want and it's all fresh. My first time was recent and I've been back multiple times since. read more

This JM does a really nice job at their restaurant or delivered via DoorDash. I am about 20 min from this spot but when I order a hot sandwich ( in this case the big kahuna) it is delivered hot and fresh Great job on being consistent! read more

I enjoy Jersey Mike's as a Sub joint for several reasons- 1. I love that they slice my food to order. 2. I love that they have the best gluten free option with their Sub in a Tub. 3. The local Jersey Mike's locations, operated by the same family, are extremely supportive of the local school communities. 4. My husband actually likes this sub place and doesn't like any others :) Great service, very clean facility, and delicious food- I'll be coming back for sure! read more

I've visited Jersey Mike's a few times since my last review, and I've enjoyed the sandwiches every time (I still advise against a salad). The staff is friendly and make an effort to make small talk with their customers. That implies a good hiring process for Jersey Mike's which you always want with fast casual restaurants. I generally order the turkey sub (number 7); I find it's the cheapest sub that still includes provolone along with the standard toppings. It's a standard sub with lettuce, tomatoes, etc and boar's head meats, so you'll want to get it "mike's way". Mike's way is simply red wine vinegar, a mix of canola/olive oil, salt, and oregano. Good to add to your meals at home and these sandwiches in general are easy to make. This location also offers a student special for $7.99 that includes a regular sub, chips, and a drink. read more

See all

Great and CLEAN store! Highly recommend going! Ryan was so helpful with helping me decide on what sandwich i would like best. His customer service and speed in running the shift is AMAZING! 100% will be coming back! read more

The location should close is they can not find a better manager. Aggressive. Terrible customer service. Created an account just to rate this guy. One time, maybe a bad day. Everything than he has to go. If this is what Jimmy Johns has become short the stock. read more

I came in for lunch today with my group of nine. Bryan and his crew gave us exceptional service! They were very attentive to our requests and every sandwich turned out perfect. We will definitely be back! Thank you from Opportunity House! read more

I have ordered lunch from Jersey Mike's a few times during this pandemic. Sandwiches were great and the way it is set up for pickup was great. A table right inside the door with your bag of food labeled with your name on it. read more

The subs here are delicious and freshly made. The service is super friendly and fast. This is a go to for subs in the area. It beats our local Subway and Jimmy Johns. read more

It was OK. I was hoping for a great sandwich, but it didn't happen. I'm not sure why. In theory, it should've been a great sandwich. My go-to sandwich for comparing sub shops and delis is whatever they call their Italian sub. They're generally pretty similar and available at most restaurants, making a comparison easy. I got the #13 Original Italian in regular size. The bread was fine, the meat to vegetable ratio was good, and they didn't skimp on the meat (I'm looking at you, Subway). The meat seemed to be of good quality. The veggies were crisp and fresh. "Mike's Way" was not at all the horrible mess some people make it out to be. The size of the sandwich was satisfying for a meal. This all sounds like the recipe for a good sandwich, right? Unfortunately, it all came out merely average. The sandwich was satisfying, but it wasn't amazing. I don't crave it. It was fine, but not good enough for me to want to go back anytime soon. If someone offered to pick up something from Jersey Mike's, I'd go in on it. If a friend wanted to eat there, I wouldn't protest. I might give their hot sandwiches a try, but I'm in no hurry to go back. I'd say Jersey Mike's is better than Subway. A Jersey Mike's sandwich seems to be made of better quality ingredients and is better put together than a Jimmy John's sandwich, but the Jimmy John's sandwich wins when it comes to flavor. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #13 Original Italian. They put a satisfying amount of meat on. - Sandwiches Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

See all

Since moving back to the suburbs I have been on the lookout for a good veggie sub place...I have found that there aren't really a lot of choices that aren't chains. Subway...is well Subway... No thanks. And the Subway by my house the weird owner asked me how much I paid for my car out of nowhere? Really I came here to get a sandwich...not to tell you how much I paid for my SUV...uncomfortable and WEIRDO. Jimmy Johns was just gross (but the people are nice) So here I went into Jersey Mike's...not a lot of topping choices but more than Jimmy Johns but way less than Subway. Employee one (man): super duper nice was nice enough to show me the sizes of their sandwiches...took the time to start my sandwich and answer all of my questions Employee two (woman): this is the girl who put my sub together...unfriendly look annoyed Employee three (man): really nice and pleasant...he is the one who wrapped my sub. Funny and charismatic Employee four (woman): this woman was also unpleasant-no smile nothing she just wanted me to pay and get he heck out (that is how she made me feel) The sub was good I would come back---except for the 2 unpleasant ladies who were working that day... Ladies- I have a hint for you...be nice and don't be such jerks! You work with the public throw a smile on your face and be nice to your customers! No one is forcing you to work there! Maybe it's because they haven't taught you manners in high school yet, maybe you missed that day at school. Maybe I'll try another location. Because this location and the unpleasant teenage female employees SUCK! read more

Having moved to the Chicago area from South Jersey over 30 years ago, I'd learned to do "widdout" the occasional cheese steak because there was never any place in Chicagoland that could make a decent one, let alone a delicious one. I learned to make them myself and, while time consuming and pretty messy, satisfied the urge. And subs (or Hoagies, as we called them)? Nothing out here ever came close to the taste of the proper seasonings and fresh cold cuts. Until now. I heard about Jersey Mike's and read the Yelps and was expecting to be underwhelmed but I believe I can officially hang up my chopping spatula! I called JM's on Randall in Geneva asking about catering for our Christmas Eve get-together. Although they were closing at 6:00pm that evening, they would gladly deliver by 5:00pm. A big thing about East Coast cheese steaks and subs is the bread, and the bread used at JM's was just right, ever so slightly crusty on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside with just the right amount of bread so the ingredients are the stars of the sandwich. Suffice it to say that our Christmas Eve meal, Philly-style, was great...right down to the yummy Kosher pickles. Mostly cheese steaks, but we also had the Jersey Favorite sub, the Chicken Parm, the Tuna and a Big Kahuna and all got high marks for flavor. I understand this is a franchise and I'm not sure if quality will vary from location to location, but to all you Fox Valley transplants from the Philly area looking for a taste to rival the better South Philly/South Jersey sub shops, this is the place! read more

Best sandwiches ever! Try the 5, the 12, the 43, try 'em all! I prefer to get my sandwich Mike's Way, but have it how you like! They slice the meat right in front of you. Never heard of the meat? They'll gladly let you try a slice. The service is super-friendly at this location, and I know this place will be here for a very long time! Enjoy...over and over again!!! *just south of the Border's on the west side of Randall read more

I didnt know what to expect from Jersey Mikes. Kind of thought it would be like all the other sub sandwich places, but I was really impressed that they slice the meat and cheese right before they put it on your sandwich. All the ingredients are very fresh, the employees are very welcoming and the decor is pretty decent for a quick serve. I also really like that their sandwiches are more of an authentic deli taste than say a subway sandwich. As a result, it takes a bit longer than the other chains to get your sammie but its totally worth the wait. You also get a lot of bang for your buck as the size of these subs would even impress Bill Cosby. The mini is about 5 inches, regular is about 8 maybe and the giant is massive. read more

Love this place! You get to watch them slice the meat right in front of you old-fashioned deli style. Plus, they like to engage in conversation while making your sandwiches so get used to that. And when they ask if you want it 'Mike's Way' they mean everything on it. #13 (The Original Italian) is my personal favorite. And #17 (Jersey Mike's Famous Philly) is delicious. Even better try #54 (The Big Kahuna Cheese Steak) but I warn you this one can be a bit greasy. read more

This Jersey Mike's ROCKS! I visit frequently since my workplace is close by. They always get my order right and the staff is extremely friendly. I accidentally placed my mobile order to the north aurora location and the staff helped me figure out what happened and called their other location to let them know they would make my sandwiches. I am beyond pleased with the service this location provides time and time again! Thanks guys! Keep up the great work!!! read more

If you need a different chain sub shop to go to, Jersey Mikes is the place for you. I have been to far superior local/family owned sub shops, but this is one of the best chain shops. Very good service, tasty subs and good serving sizes. I usually get the BLT, Mikes way of course :) However , a warning. Not something you eat everyday. Its just not that healthy for you. A good once in a while treat tho. read more

Handled the lunch rush like a well oiled machine. Very fast and organized. Nicely done!

Jersey Mike's was pretty good. I got the vegetarian sub and I thought it was very good and flavorful thanks to the dressing. I'm not sure if it would have been good if I got it to go since it was starting to get a little soggy as I finished it, but if you're eating there it's good anyway. My mom recommended this place to me and I'm glad she did or else I probably wouldn't have suggested eating there when my boyfriend and I were doing some shopping on Randall Rd. He got one of the cheese steak sandwiches I think and he said it was really good. I don't know if I'd go out of my way to go here again, but if I'm nearby I wouldn't be opposed to it. Although I kind of agree with the other reviewers who mentioned how over-the-top friendly the staff was... it was a little awkward. I don't want to be interrogated about my day while I'm waiting to pay for dinner. In fact I think they might be the reason I went with 3 stars instead of 4. I guess I'd say the food is 4-star-worthy but the experience was 2.5 or 3. read more

Best sub shop compared to subway or jimmy johns better bread and they slice the meat while you wait. They are priced higher but the sandwiches use better ingredients.they have really yummy hot ingredients sandwiches that are my favorite This will be my goto sandwich place for now on read more

Great food....#7 is amazing! Staff is always so friendly and nice. Best sub place around...fresh bread, meat and cheese. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Geneva, Illinois

I like this place. I've had the ham sub, the turkey sub, and the chicken philly. Turkey sub the best out of the three. I'm trying to avoid high-fat meats otherwise I'd like to try their salamis and prosciutto selections. "Mike's Way" subs are good but I prefer putting the spicy sauce on it rather than the oil & vinegar. Nice people, good service here. I go at least once a week. read more

Alright, IMO these are the best subs in the area. Obviously better than Jimmy John's or Subway. Better prices and larger sandwiches than Potbelly's. I'd give it 5 stars, but... You guys need to seriously stop interrogating customers. Seriously. Manager, whoever you are, listen to me: I have chosen to NOT eat at your restaurant because I cannot take the questions anymore. YOU ARE LOSING MONEY. Do you understand? Customers: If you go in to this restaurant, be prepared to be asked 2+ questions from the staff to make it seem like they give a crap about you. The most recent pointless question I received was: "So...Did you watch any golf today--OR--are you a a golfer"? Geez just give me my food. For fun, try giving them answers that can't possibly be correct just to see if they're paying attention. For example, when they ask what your job is, try saying Lion Tamer or something like that. See how it goes. Should be mildly entertaining until you can escape with your sub. read more

Awesome! I'm a native New Yorker, and this place tastes like home. They make the perfect subs, or wedges, as I call them. Now that I'm writing about them, my mouth is watering for a provolone cheese steak. read more

We just tried jersey Mike's a few weeks ago it's a pretty good sandwiches are made right in front of you and they give you a good amount of everything on it deafly give it a try it's a good place to eat thanks Donna G read more

Ok, now that I've been here now as well as the St. Charles one (for their VIP Grand Opening Night) I can see why it so popular. It's the atmosphere. The whole Italian style Deli feel. Still have the same review for how their subs are but a little bit pricy for just a sub sandwich and now I can see why. Your paying for atmosphere. read more