This specific location = well oiled machine Today I visited this location at lunch time. We all know how that can sometimes go during peak hours. Not this place. 1. The team is totally in sync & super nice. 2. They are fast & efficient with getting your order done. 3. The person dressing your order keeps their entire area IMMACULATE. I've noticed other locations get sloppy in this area, not here!! 4. The tables and dine-in area are CLEAN. Tipping my hat to this entire crew! And thanks for my chopped stickball today! THE BEST!! read more

The staff was friendly and worked quickly, food tasted great, place was clean, and like all the franchises things were priced well and the menu variety was plentiful. Loads of places to park and a good amount of tables inside to sit at read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

I had a coupon for a free regular sub, thanks to T-Mobile Tuesday so we finally decided to redeem it for a philly cheesesteak. Hubby and both had the Big Kahuna Cheesesteak. He added a note to his to add chipotle mayo, and they did. I was a little surprised because usually, these notes in the notes section go ignored. The sandwich was good but it was much better with the chipotle mayo. I wasn't expecting much but I was pretty impressed by this philly and shocked at how much I enjoyed it. It was better than most pizza places that serve phillies, where the meat is dry and the bread is hard or chewy. This philly was legit, even for a chain. I still haven't found my go-to philly spot since moving to the area but I actually think Jersey Mike's might be a good contender. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

Complete incompetence. Completely wrong order and I only got one sandwich. Who the fuck puts lettuce and tomato on a cheesesteak?! This isn't California and it's not what I order. I'm at work and don't have access to other food. You fucked me. Great job.... You lost a weekly customer because no one at this location pays attention. Everyone was having personal conversations. Extremely unprofessional. read more

Food may be good but I wouldn't know. This is the Second time that this location failed to come through on the delivery! You Suck Mike's! We wait almost an hour and then SORRY! Your food order was cancelled. There won't be a 3rd time! DO NOT RELY ON GETTING FOOD DELIVERED FROM HERE! I ordered at 1:00 in the afternoon. They strung it out and cancelled around 2:10. read more

My folks and I always go here since it's the closest and let me tell you that everything here is great, the staff is super friendly and the food is wonderful. Very clean as well. read more

Unfortunately, I hate to echo all the other most recent reviews for this Jersey Mike's, because I love going here and I certainly love their subs, but the online ordering is just a hot mess. I have no problems when I go in, stand in line, and order at the counter. It moves pretty quickly. BUT, whenever I order via the online app it is never ready when the app says it will be. I'll even arrive late and my order still takes extra time to make. I've stood waiting for my order as people standing in line and ordering at the counter have come and long gone. I love Jersey Mike's and of course I will continue to patronize it, but when it comes to their online ordering system I'll continue to add extra time to the estimated pick up time. Also, maybe they can find a way to implement a better system? There were definitely a good amount of workers in there, is someone dedicated to only pick up orders? That may help! read more

How hard is it to get a sandwich right? I'm here atleast once a week and get our sandwiches MIKES WAY! How do I get home and no bacon on the sandwich??? I specifically said Mayo and Bacon. It's not ok to spend over $20 on a sandwich and it be wrong!! read more

My first time posting a review of a fast food location as one of the larger chains, but Jersey Mike's has become a beat-the-heat/summer go-to as a refreshing way for the family to have a quick meal. It's a bit pricey for a meal for three in comparison to a Subway (or a Blimpie if you can find one anymore), but the focus is definitely on giving more of the interior ingredient versus bread ratio... And, in that regard, Jersey Mike's leaves Subway (and it's turkey-based meat fillings) in the dust. If the price point was just a little less... Or if the peppers on a Philly Cheesesteak were cooked to soften a bit better (the second time I got one)... Or if it wasn't one of the larger fast food chains around... I just might give Jersey Mike's FIVE stars. Being as often as it IS a summertime go-to -- Perhaps downloading the app (and getting whatever reward they offer) would be a wise thing to do, and might push it closer to that level. read more

Ordered a large Italian with oil and vinegar and oil on the side. I got an Italian version with mayonnaise I never asked for. When I put the oil and vinegar on, not noticing the mayonnaise it turned the vinegar and I got so sick I missed work the next day. read more

Jersey Mike's is definitely better than the likes of Subway, Blimpie and Firehouse Subs. (But we both know the bar wasn't all that high when it comes to sandwich-chains.) And maybe it's not right to compare them to the countless delis and sandwich shops in North Jersey because it wouldn't be a fair fight. But just judging them independently in regards to price, how the finished sub (I mean hoagie, I mean grinder, I mean hero, I mean...) tastes, the cleanliness of the shop, etc. - Jersey Mike's is mighty fine. Their #13 ('The Original Italian', my standard go-to) is solid. (And to their credit - they're open more/longer than most delis - in case you do get a craving for a sub at an odd time.) Workers are always friendly. (Some old-timers at your favorite deli don't mind letting you know they have a chip on their shoulder and you'll deal with it.) And I can't give Jersey Mike's enough credit for all they've done since the world got hit with COVID-19... helping with meals for the kids in need when schools started to close and donating a percentage of sales to Feeding America - that's awesome and they deserve a star just for that. read more

This was my first time ordering from this location. I ordered via Uber Eats and had zero issues. I ordered the chipotle cheesesteak in a bowl. Is it pretty? No. Was it delicious? Absolutely. Their portion sizes are perfect. I'll definitely be ordering again. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #43 Chipotle Cheese Steak in a bowl - Sandwiches Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

Love this location, always very friendly and extremely accommodating. Always going above and beyond & who doesn't love a sub!

Just a ok sandwich shop. Probably biased because so many good Delis in New Jersey. Do give good value for money but cold cuts are not the best. Ham and cHeese were second tier deli meats. Service is good and fast. Best of the chain sandwich shops. read more

See all

Am kind of really hating to give Jersey Mike's a 2 but for the last 3 times I did on line orders and given a time......I've had to wait almost 30 minutes more that time given. If I placed an order at 6pm you tell me my order is going to be ready at 6:20, I'm rushing to get what I need to get so I can pick food up either on time or shortly thereafter.......NOT 30-40 MINUTES. I think they either need to hire more people to assist with the overflow of patrons or give it up. My opinion, hire more staff. You got a good thing going on here. read more

Jersey Mikes has good sandwiches but definitely not for the price they charge. For $25 I can go to a restaurant and order a whole dinner! It's crazy for a sub sandwich! I can go to a real Italian restaurant and get so much more for my money than a sub shop. Not worth it anymore for the price. You don't have to make a 500% profit on each sandwich. Disappointed because you serve a glorified subway sandwich. read more

Excellent service, super friendly staff, great team effort, which is especially needed for when you're buying for your family of four lol. They were super patient when I asked questions because I am not tech savvy. Highly recommend this location. read more

So disgusting!! There was hair in two of the sandwiches I bought, it has to be in the vegetables because it's was wrapped in a pepper. They need to wear hairnets because this is definitely a health code violation. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - East Rutherford, New Jersey

See all

All of the subs are a great choice, my favorites are the 13# Italian, 42# Chicken cheesesteak with chipotle mayo, and 55# Basically has all ingredients possible for hot sandwiches and steak. The most underrated move people make is not getting their hot sandwich Mikes Way. It changes the sandwich into the most delicious sandwich possible. I used to work there for a year and always recommended customers tried it out. ALSO! for those people who have little patience and expect the sandwich to be made in 5 seconds. Don't go during rush hour which is in the afternoon. It takes time to make a good sandwich Overall great subs and don't be shy to experiment with the toppings and ask the employees for what they recommend! read more

I've been a fan of JMS since I was a child vacationing down in Point Pleasant or Seaside. I was even more thrilled when I found one in Ramsey and months later this one opened up closer to home! Man I wish I had thought of opening up this joint here myself! I love love love coming here! Sandwiches are always true to my memories of the past - fresh soft bread piled high with meat and toppings done Mike's way all day every day! Staff genuinely engages with their customers here and never look disgruntled. My faves here are the Big Kahuna Cheesesteak #56, Original Italian #13, and Ham, Salami, & Provolone #11. My hubby loves their giant sized Chicken Cheesesteak #31 or their Turkey & Swiss! Add on a drink and some chips and we are set. Their roast beef and tuna are also good, but I found the RB isn't piled high so it left me kind of disappointed as I ate more bread than meat. Maybe I just grabbed it at an off day of theirs, but I would try ordering it again. Overall love the sandwiches and the staff here as you can read! Plenty of parking in the lot and place is often packed from early lunch through evening! Sign up for their emails and rewards club and you will get coupons and double points days to redeem for food! read more

Three stars for the freshness of the ingredients. I have been here numerous times. My husband and I came here last Wednesday August 10th and this is the second time I asked for a little bit of oil and vinegar. So what does the woman who is making my sandwich do? She drenches it. The manager of this location needs to explain to the employees what the word LITTLE means. Unless you like soggy sandwiches please go to this location. I will never patronize this place again. read more

Great sub shop, and way more consistent that "S" and "B". Adding special instructions when ordering ahead is super easy and reliable!

Jersey Mike's has always been my go to sub shop...until now. I ordered a whole Club Supreme which has turkey, roast beef, and Swiss. I was amazed at how ridiculously skimpy my sandwich was when it came to the cold cuts. There was barely a thin layer of each. If you are going to charge almost $20 for a whole sub, it had better be stuffed. Sorry to say that you've lost a customer. (Store in East Rutherford, NJ) read more

IMO, Jersey Mike's is the best fast food sub chain, period. Everything is sliced fresh while you watch. Staff is friendly and accommodating. They really go out of their way to make you feel welcome and satisfied. Jersey Mike's has taken the Subway concept and improved on it in both process and food quality. Taste and quantity of meats and garnishings are a full cut above. Of course all of that freshness and cut to order goodness does come at a price as they're about 20-25% higher priced than their downscale competitor. But for me, who eats at one or the other once or twice a month, I'd rather pay the extra money and go to Jersey Mike's. They also have a much larger staff than your average Subway or Quizno's so the wait is a lot shorter during those times when you need to order and get the hell on your way. Really great place. Delicious, too. read more

Jersey mikes in east Rutherford we ordered 2 sandwiches steam sandwich the bread was so soggy you had to eat it with a fork you could not pick it up the other was a tuna the bread was so stale that it when you picked it up it just crumbled read more

This place has so many health violations how Is it even open. I went in there to get my sandwich's, the veggie option was cooked right on the grill top next to bacon. Not to mention the kid cooking personal appearance was a disaster, his hair looked like a pubic hair no net not pulled back wild and revolting. They tried to give me a sandwich that had also been sitting out as not to make a new one. Told the corp office not heard back will not go here again read more

This Jersey Mike's popped up in this strip mall very stealthily. It seems like a small space between Five Guys and Chipotle, but it's bigger than you'd think and there are a lot of tables in there. OK, it's a chain, so if you've gone you know the food. But props always go out to places with nice employees and clean, well-kept restaurants. There is also plenty of parking and a Starbucks steps away for coffee and dessert. If you haven't been, it's a sub shop with a Chipotle-like assembly line. The bread is fresh, and on the softer side. The menu has just enough to select from and I like that. A 'regular' size is plenty for lunch. I just had lunch there and it was really good. So 3 1/2-4 stars for this Jersey Mike's if you're craving a sub. read more

Went to Jersey Mike's and ordered a sandwich as usual , people multitasking and a guy in front of me orders a cheese stake so the employee grabs the raw chicken with her gloves on and throws the steak on the grill for then tells another employee to finish it and starts cutting my meat for the sub. I immediately thought cross contamination but I really regret not saying anything and little do you know ,no longer than 30 minutes later I had the runs and still do today. Someone has to really sit these people down and explain to them the consequences and to finish one task especially when it comes to cross contamination. Didn't want to be a grinch but did not want to spend the day in the bathroom. read more

This was my first visit to this sub chain. I stopped in this strip mall with its abundance of dining options because I really had no idea what I wanted. Jersey Mike's is between a starbucks, an salad works, an asian place, a Five guys, and a Chillis. I have to admit I've been curious about Jersey Mike's. I ordered a hot chicken philly with peppers added on their italian focaccia bread. The staff was uber pleasant and friendly. The shop was super clean. My sandwich was $8.50 and I enjoyed it. It was filling but not too heavy. I got the regular size. Tasted very fresh and was not greasy or oily. Next time I'd probably ask them to toast the bread but it was fine as is. read more

The thing about Jersey Mike's is that their ingredients are FRESH and very good quality. It isn't an Italian Deli in Bensonhurst (nothing else is) but if you're on the road and Wendy's and Burger King make your stomach clench...Jersey Mike's is an oasis for decent fresh food. read more

Great sandwiches but need to work on organization and manners in front of the house. Came in today to pick up an order I placed online ahead of time and paid for..."skip the line" you know? I got there, no one greeted me. I watched as the cashier rang up three transactions before even asking me rudely, "do you have a pick up order?" She handed me my bag like it was hot garbage, didn't say thank you, smile or generally appreciate that part of my check or any other customers goes to paying her wage the slightest . Not cool. Your company made a smart decision to have pick up orders deal with it in a professional and courteous manner. People Remember read more

This is by far the best Mikes I have ever been to. The reason is Sam! She is incredible !! Always greats you with a big smile . Sam is very efficient and makes the best sandwiches! The quality and care that they all take to make you a great sandwich is what separates this location from any other that I have ever been to. Great job Sam! Thanks for making my day better! Rob read more

I'm giving this one particular jersey mikes a 3 star rating due to the hard bread they use on they sandwiches I really suggest they get a new vendor for they're bread it's crusty ,and hard,and very flaky,my other reason they give such lil meat I really think they need to step it up and fix these issues,I've been to other jersey mikes stores and the bread is way better,and they give a better portion of meat. When here in east Rutherford definitely request soft bread,and you might have to pay for extra meat because they are very cheap and stingy with the meat read more

I don't really go to sub/sandwich places anymore but the girlfriend informed me they have gluten free bread. I was getting a bit nostalgic while watching the staff prepare my wrap and the gluten free sandwich. I used to go to Blimpies and Subway but stopped as I got older. This place was fun and very active. I observed it was clean and had a very friendly atmosphere. The chicken wrap was delicious and very filling. But the MVP of the lunch was the gluten free sandwich I tried and my girlfriend ate. It's so good knowing that Jersey Mike's has gluten free bread for its patrons. I will definitely come back again. read more

Over-hyped and over priced! Nothing special about their subs other than there is a limited menu.

I keep trying to give this location a chance, but yet again disappointed. Ordered for pickup, ordered a plain Turkey and Amercan cheese sandwich, when I got home and opened the sandwich it had EVERYTHING on it AKA Mikes way ‍. Wasted sandwich as my son will not eat it. I also ordered a sandwich in a bowl which came with hardly any lettuce and no oil & vinegar. NEVER AGAIN! read more

Last night I called and gave them the impossible task of making 20 subs in 20 minutes for a hungry HS hockey team. Not only did they get it done, they were all bagged and ready to go as soon as I got there. Great job!! The boys appreciated it! read more

Sandwiches are really good. A bit on the pricey end but ingredients are fresh. A lot of meat in their sandwiches. Customer service is pretty good as well. The Italian (#13) is my go to sandwich and one that I'd highly recommend ordering. read more

Ordered Online for pick up arrived well after my scheduled confirmation pick up time and still waited over 10 minutes, along with other patrons whom were complaining to each other. People walking in were served faster than those who ordered online pick up. read more

This is a great place to get something quick to eat. The staff is extremely friendly and nice. They go out of their way to make sure you get the best service. I had ordered a 26 Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch dressing. Will differently go there to eat again. read more