I'm obsessed with this place and have proclaimed it my favorite sandwich shop! It's a little out of the way and I only know of the one location but it's a hidden gem! Their meat slicer is NOT a prop like at other places: all meats and cheeses are sliced in front of you when you order at the counter. Excellent selection of cold subs and their bread is wonderful! On top of all of this, they are wicked fast! I do kind of wish they had more hot subs but I haven't even sampled any of the hot subs they have - I'm still working my way through the cold subs. Worth the trip to Fuquay! read more

Jersey Boy Subs - #1 - Whole ham with cheese with tomatoes, onions, jalapenos, lettuce, spicy brown mustard, mayo, and oregano. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina

See all

Real good tasting sub! I can't believe I haven't found this place before now! I got there in the middle of the afternoon so there wasn't a wait-just being a grubhub order. The place is clean they've got 9 tables with chairs and a great location down in Fuquay Varina! I ordered the Jersey devil with crushed hot pepper relish and oil . The Rolls are better than many, as soon as I fit into it I realized these are fresh vine ripened tomatoes! Good amount of meat and great quality! This is my new go-to I hope you shop in Fuquay-Varina! read more

Jersey Boy Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina

Great little sub shop. First time in quite some time I couldn't finish a sandwich. Absolutely loaded with meat. Had the boss and the jersey boy, both variations of an Italian. Fantastic subs. Bread was really good. Better than most but not a true fresh Italian roll. Which is reason for 4 rating instead of 5. Huge portion great quality and great price. Will surely be back when I'm in Nc. read more

Jersey Boy Subs - 6. The Boss Sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina

See all

This place hands down makes the best and biggest subs in the area if not the entire Triangle. It's locally owned and operated, the kid who owns it looks to be about 12 but he can make killer subs. The restaurant itself is always super clean and tidy and service is almost top notch. They are very friendly and work hard to get your order exactly right. My favorite sub is I think #14 the Jersey Devil. It has soooo much meat. The first one I took home I weight it and it was 3lbs. If you go to Subway you are lucky if your sub is half a pound and pretty much costs the same. There is a photo of one on the scale topping out at 2lbs10oz. The subs are so big I always have them quarter them for me and they pretty much make four meals. The most epic thing I did once was order one for a motorcycle trip then I rode straight to the top of Mt. Mitchell where I enjoyed one of these subs. My only beef I have with them...they have a loyalty program. I always get the Jersey Devil which is one of the most expensive subs at $17 (was $13 when they first opened). This is not a problem because it's so much food. So I was in there and went to redeem my free sub and I had my kids and they usually get a small ham sub or a turkey sub which is about $8. I checked out and went on my way but didn't notice until I got home that they redeemed my free sub for $8 instead of the big one!!! Of all the places Ive ever been with loyalty programs they always give you the most expensive one for free....I guess here you have to make a separate order to do that. Felt like my loyalty got taken advantage of. Lesson learned. read more

See all

Good portions and a fair price. Soooo much better than any chain sandwich shop. I loved the bread!

Tasty subs, made fresh. Heads up, the whole size is massive! So you'll likely want to share it.

Let me tell you unbelievable stuff here! Harrison recommended me the #6 and safe to say it's here to stay! I'll back

Food is always great awesome service I have been going there since they opened. Favorite sandwich spot in town

Google Maps dropped me off in the street, so I looked around a bit. It's right next to the Weight Watchers in the strip mall. Guys, if you've been looking for the ULTIMATE New Jersey subs transplant, search no more. This is pure Jersey Shore sandwhiching. Not even Jersey Mike's has brought me this close to home. It starts with the bread. When I looked them up online and saw their work, I knew JBS was worth checking out. They had me with the bread. Then came the meat slicing. It was such a familiar scene that I had to take a picture of it to show my family, who all moved here before me. I ordered the "Boss" because it looked closest to the stuff I ate up north. Shot the breeze with the owner's son who told me a bit about their beginnings. It looked like a clean, simple place. I was gradually becoming more and more excited. It seemed as if I'd found my new spot for subs. Perfect. The prep, the build, the presentation, the taste. When I brought my sister's order to her, she opened the bag and immediately squeeled "It smells like them!" (meaning subs from home.) Yes guys, you've made at least two new fans. Okay bye. read more

See all

Quality sandwich very similar to Jersey Mikes. Nice big menu with a lot to choose from and all the classic sub toppings. Only reason it's not a 4 is the staff aren't the friendliest and I really just enjoy friendly service. But overall a good, casual place for a sub! read more

Jersey Boy Subs - Large 9. Jersey Boy Sub - Sandwiches Near Me - Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina

See all

This sub shop was really good. They have a lot of options, my husband and I both chose a half Jersey Boy! Club and my mom chose a half meatball sub. All subs come straight up, that includes lettuce, onion, tomato, salt, Jersey Juice and spices. I also added mayo and honey mustard. The meat was thinly sliced and all of the subs were tasty. I liked that they had Miss Vickie's chips too, I chose sea salt. If you are in the area, check this spot out. read more

See all

Love this place. They've done plenty catering events for me in the past and it's ALWAYS a hit. Everything is so so fresh and delicious. Never takes long to get in and out and staff are very nice. read more

Jersey Boy Subs - This is a HALF! #16 Turkey and roast beef. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina

See all

Quality meats, the bread is very good. I ordered the Boss sandwich with all of the condiments, the peppers were fantastic. I will be returning for another sandwich. read more

Pretty good subs. They've won best of Fuquay. Good for a quick lunch when you have a hankering for a good sandwich. 8.5/10

Never had a bad sandwich from Jersey Boys Subs. A full sub is usually a 2 day meal. The employees have always been great. Some know us by name. If you haven't tried a Jersey Boys sub you're missing out read more

10/10 would highly recommend. These subs always hit the spot and are super consistent. I try the veggie sub always but my husband has tried the other and have loved them all. Support this business! read more

I only just finished my meal a few minutes ago, but it was so outstanding that I felt I HAD to leave a review ASAP. Forget about any chain sandwich places in the area, Jersey Boy blows them out of the water in every category. The bread is fresh and better than you'll find anywhere else. The meat has a great flavor to it and they are generous with the portion. If you get a club, you get crispy bacon that's actually chopped for you, not laid down as a full piece inside the sandwich. So you're not struggling with it the entire time. I LOVE an extra little touch like that. Me and a friend got a small sandwich each and traded a half so we could get some variety out of it. I almost had trouble finishing mine. Talk about bang for you buck. I stopped ordering sandwiches for awhile because the chain places got so disappointing not only in portion, but in complete lack of flavor. I'm thrilled to have discovered a place like Jersey Boy where quality, taste, and value are ALL top notch. Will most definitely be returning! One thing of note: while their site has an option for delivery, I was told they don't deliver to my address and I'm less than 2 miles away. So I had to utilize a third party app. That isn't an issue. As long as I can somehow get my hand on these sandwiches, I'll be happy! read more

Close by , decided to try JB for the first time , here are my thoughts : * Ordered the French dip , I knew full well going in , it would be a sandwich shop French dip not a Winston's on Falls of Neuse French dip ..that being said , the quality of the roast beef was good , I did expect the roast beef to be warmer than it was but that wasn't a deal breaker . Bread is good .. * I want to try their other subs with more fixings as the dip just had meat and cheese ... * The place was clean , so that's always a good thing .. I would say if your in the neighborhood, stop by and try them out . read more

I was super excited to try this place because of the awesome Yelp reviews, so I decided to pick up subs for my boyfriend and I for lunch today. I walk into the sub shop and I'm greeted with silence. There were 3 guys working, no masks during the pandemic when cases are at an all-time high. I decided to overlook it because the subs looked delicious. I am standing at the counter, waiting to be acknowledged to place my order. And I continued waiting for 5 minutes, still nothing. I'm literally 2 feet from the employees and they refused to speak to me!! I felt like I was trapped in a parallel universe, it was crazy. So, I walked out. I will never be back. read more

I'll start this off by saying this review was a cake walk to do - I just copied the previous review since it was so spot on (Thks Spri J !) and changed a couple of details, but the description of the sub is spot on. They hit this one out of the park. These were by far the best subs we've had since we moved here 9 years ago fr FL if you've been looking for the ULTIMATE New Jersey subs transplant, search no more. This is pure Jersey Shore sandwhiching. Not even Jersey Mike's has brought me this close to home. It starts with the bread. When I looked them up online and saw their work, I knew JBS was worth checking out. They had me with the bread. Then came the meat slicing. It was such a familiar scene that I had to take a picture of it to show my family, who all moved here before me. I ordered the "Boss" because it looked closest to the stuff I ate up north. Shot the breeze with the owner's son Harrison who told me a bit about their beginnings. It looked like a clean, simple place. I was gradually becoming more and more excited. It seemed as if I'd found my new spot for subs. Perfect. The prep, the build, the presentation, the taste. The formula for THE perfect sub! You guys have nailed it! read more

I'm a Jersey boy and I love Jersey Mike's subs but they're too expensive so I thought Jersey Boy might be less expensive. But unfortunately they are almost as expensive and inferior. read more

I ate here on a Monday evening with one other person for dinner. These are my thoughts and observations. - The location Yelp has listed is somewhat inaccurate. The GPS will take you to a vape store across the street, but Jersey Boys is really next to Staples. - The decor reminds me of budget Jersey Mike's. - The establishment was clean and the employees were friendly. - They have your standard sub options with standard sub prices. - Their subs were strictly average. They need something to take them to the next level. I found mine to be dry and too bready. Overall, Jersey Boys is a serviceable sub shop, just don't expect anything mind blowing. read more

Courteous workers but quality wasn't up to the price. Bread tasted somewhat dated but meat was fresh. For the prices being charged, quality should be first. Today it wasn't. read more

Excellent sub shop! Menu is very similar to Jersey Mike's. Staff is friendly, and does a good job. The food is always excellent, it's very clean, and feels very fresh. I usually visit a few times a week, and always have a pleasant experience. read more

Very good stuff better than Jersey mikes I got the boss and my wife had the French dip every thing was fresh and delicious will be my new go to spot for a sub read more

My husband and I tried it because we never heard of the place. We loved that the meat was fresh and cut at the time of order. We were missing some toppings options and wanted my sub toasted. Solid option but not a top choice. read more

I'm from Jersey. Closest tasting to Jersey subs that I've tried so far in the Raleigh-Durham area.

I really wanted to like this place. I love East coast jersey subs. However I must say I was highly disappointed. For the good: bread is fresh and good. They are a local establishment, which is why it pains me to write a bad review. But look, the selection is average...nothing special to be blown away by. But the worse part is how thin and skimpy the amount of meat and cheese is that they put on the rolls. And this is no fluke...been here twice now. Paper thin slices of meat. You can barely taste the bread. This place also needs to get a wow factor sandwich going and a great homemade sandwich spread. Think Caprioti's people.....now they got signature sandwiches. Also having hot sandwiches like a cheesesteak would be great, but I know its expensive to add a grill. read more

I have never stepped foot in this place as I've been lucky enough to have members of my family pick up our phone orders. From my family members? The people that work there are friendly on the phone, super helpful when you arrive and the orders are always right. The sandwiches????? ON POINT! Let me be clear, I am but a sandwich person but I choose this place because it's fantastic. The bread is amazing and the ingredients are fresh and flavorful. I can tell you that I am now in love with sandwiches i never even knew I liked. They excel at sandwiches, especially "The Boss". Don't think it's your thing? I didn't either and I'm in love. This place is great. So glad to have a legit sub place in Fuquay. read more

Best sub ever!! Hidden gem in Fuquay Varina. Subs are delicious and bread is fresh. I had salami and pepperoni sub. Very clean inside which is always a plus! Definitely will be back! read more

We got a Jersey Boy sub and a meatball sub, and both were super fresh and tasty. The place is very clean, and the staff was careful to prepare the subs the way we wanted. It was a great experience, and we'll be back for sure the next time we're in Fuquay. read more

We wanted to like this place so bad because we try to always support local, but who doesn't have American cheese?!? To us it seemed like a jersey mikes but with a lot less options. Hopefully as they work out the kinks they add more traditional sandwich toppings. We will try it again in a few months and update here. read more

Just moved from NY and really wanted subs for supper! Amazing! Absolutely get your money's worth and then some. Workers are very courteous and friendly. Will definitely be going back!! read more

You're not paying for frills here, you're paying for a good, simple deli sub. Have had the jersey boy a couple times now with sweet peppers added and it's a great sandwich. Not the fanciest place in the world, but filling and simple yet if you're looking for a quick meal. Better than the chain sub joints in Fuquay for sure. read more

Went in tonight as a first time customer! Born and raised in New York so I know a good deli sub. This place is out of this world! I got The Boss sub, loaded with all the veggies and "Jersey Juice" and hands down best sub I've ever tasted! The thing was as long as my arm and had to weigh at least 3 to 4 pounds haha! The staff member I interacted with was very friendly and the restaurant was very clean. I will definitely be back and I will also spread the word. 5 out of 5 stars easily! read more

Jersey Boy Subs - a large sub sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Fuquay-Varina, North Carolina

See all

Excellent sandwich and excellent value! Really enjoyed by Roast Beef and Provolone straight up! Please visit and support this local sandwich shop! I will definitely add Jersey Boy Subs to the rotation! read more

Great customer service every time! Ingredients always taste fresh and my family has made it part of their lunch routine too.

I was down in Fuquay and saw a sign for Jersey Boys subs, and since I was right there at Staples, I picked up a ham and cheese sub. Well, it was wonderful! My husband ate the second half and he even commented on how good it was. The place was clean, friendly staff, and the sub was fabulous! I am going back today! The bread was very fresh, and it was just an awesome tasting sub and they gave me chips for free! read more

My new favorite sub shop. Great subs for cheaper prices than local competitors. Nice workers and the manager Harrison is great.

This family ran shop is great, the only problem I had was they close early. Food and restaurant was excellent. Let's keep these guys in business during this troubled time. read more