Super cute place with all your cider basics - cider for later, hot cider for now, doughnuts, ice cream and pie. They have all you could ever need for fall festivities year round and at great prices. On top of all of that, their stuff is good! You won't be disappointed. Just to note, the place is tiny and you will need to park on the street. Well worth the trip. read more

I'm leaving this review because I'm beside myself with what they expect people to post for pies... I got go up to the counter and had 2 pies and a jar of apple butter, rings up to 63 dollars... what? Is there gold baked into the pies?? I put back a pie and it still came out to nearly 40 dollars... This thing would have to completely blow me away to be worth that price tag, like I get it the economy is rough right now but it's like that for everyone not only your pie business... When I walked in the place was a ghost town on a Saturday afternoon, now I know why. Please at the very least post prices to save people's jaws from hitting the counter at the register. Good luck! read more

Stopped by here one day and the homemade ice cream was delicious. My hubs seemed to like his candy apples. We'll have to come back and try more stuff. I can't believe this place has been here forever and we just never stopped in until recently. read more

Weirdest apple cider donuts ever. They're fluffy, but not the moistest and taste an awful lot like bananas. Probably one of the worst "fresher" Apple cider donuts I've had. Blueberry filled donuts were insanely dry. Can you imagine a donut worse than old Dunkin' Donuts donuts? If not, this their blueberry donuts can show you what stale means. Spicy pickles are extremely sweet. Not bad tasting, but far from what we expected. To end things - their donuts are ridiculously expensive compared to other fresh "mills and farms". read more

love this place! i just had to stop by the jericho cider mill to (un)officially kick off fall! this place is super cute. first of all their cider is some of the best ive ever had! you can get it iced, frozen, or hot and its all good! they also offer it in half-gallon & gallon size AND different flavors like mango, orange, & others! also if you're there you HAVE to grab some of their apple cider donuts or their bomb pies! these are the perfect desserts for fall! definitely stop by the jericho cider mill if you're in the area! read more

See all

Cute little stop if you're in the area, with an Instagram-able sign and local treats. Because the theme for this year is struggle I'll give them a pass but the Apple selection was a bit struggley. Left with only three good apples after digging for a few minutes. Def would recommend not leaving without trying the cider though. They have flavors that I don't usually see. I tried the mango apple cider and it was very delicious. read more

So excited I had an opportunity to come to this Cider Mill. Truth be told, the location is less than ideal and the parking situation is dangerous. For how well this place does, you would think a parking lot would be an investment they would consider making. Parking is street parking only and on the side of Jericho/Oyster Bay Road where the traffic is moving quickly at 60 plus miles an hour. Also, the side of the road is not paved, it's a dirty path and very rocky, it is extremely easy to trip and fall into the road making the entire situation very unsafe. After parking a ways up the road and maneuvering ourselves in-between cars we made it to the actual cider mill, which was much smaller than I anticipated. They had loads of apples in huge crates outside, with an endless supply but you really had to dig in there to find ones that weren't soft and bruised. Granted, that could be from people dropping apples back into he crates but regardless, you had to search for good ones. Probably not the best idea to have apples in crates so deep because when you want to toss one back in, you aren't gently putting them back, which makes a lot of them bruised. They had butternut squash, orange pumpkins, white pumpkins and some plants for purchase. Inside was where you could find your salsas, jellies, apple cider, apple cider donuts, pies etc. There was quite a long line but it moved fairly quickly and gave you a chance to look at all the products they were selling. I got a bag of apple cider donuts, a container of cinnamon covered sliced apples and raspberries that were a huge hit in my house, a thing of apple cider, peach hot sauce and a jar of salsa. Everything came to $40 and change, which was pricey in my opinion. The staff really wasn't friendly in my opinion, it was more about efficiency, no hellos now how are you's just, "NEXT" and that was really it. I didn't come here for the warm customer service, but still. I haven't tried the hot sauce or salsa yet but the donuts weren't loved by the family. The apple mix was delicious! If the ingredients were accurate being that the only ingredients were baked sliced apples, cinnamon and raspberries then that is a healthy delicious fall treat and although it was $10, I would recommend it. Moral of the story is, I wouldn't come here for whole apples, but I would come back for that apple dish and maybe a pumpkin. read more

See all

The people that work there are super nice and the stuff is tasty. Try the frozen cider! The cakes and pies are a bit pricey but the quality is good. read more

So far so good. I can't believe it took me this long to realize that this store exists! And I've grew up a couple towns over from here! I think the worst thing about this shop is that it's so small that it's incredibly easy to miss. Excellent choices from apples to ciders to donuts to pie to jam even ice cream! Can't wait to come back to refill once we finished. read more

I thought the apple cider donuts were decent but nothing compared to other farms/mills that I've been to in the NY/NJ area. This was a super small shop on the side of a busy road, which made parking challenging because you have to park along that road and walk to the mill. They didn't have many options and it just wasn't what it looked like online. Also, not sure if this is out of the ordinary but they didn't have the donuts fresh, only pre-bagged. Pretty underwhelming but could be nice as a family/pet friendly pit stop on your way somewhere else. read more

See all

Definitely will become one of my staple fall to do items! The donuts were soft and fluffy and not dry like some other farms or stores. Their frapple was an interesting twist and tasted like fresh apples. The apples themselves however seemed a little old and we're getting rotten. Maybe I went too late and all the good ones were chosen already. I also got their peachy apple crumb pie which was also delicious but could do with some more peach. The apple crumb ice cream was a miss in my opinion but my boyfriend enjoyed it. Beware the parking situation is a little sketchy, cars were parked on the shoulder along side the freeway read more

Quite overpriced given the quality. After a long wait, we ordered hot apple ciders and they were lukewarm at best. Also, the apple pie tasted flavorless. Disappointed after seeing the other reviews. read more

Food is great. Everything is good. What needs work here is the "I don't need your business attitude" I walked in and asked if they had any pecan pie "nope" said the girl without looking up from her phone. I asked if they planned on having any soon "nope" she said again, without looking up from her phone. I had been in the store for two minutes - not even - and I guess It is not necessary to be polite or offer assistance. I placed the items I wanted on the counter - she made a big sighing sound - hasn't looked at me yet - then she put her phone down..... " is that it?" She asked Happy holidays cider mill. Since your food is great, I have no plans to stop buying stuff from you. If there was a better option for apple pies locally I would go there. Since your customer service stinks, my only recourse is to give poor reviews for customer service. I was in there last on Thursday 12/15/16 read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Apple crumb, 1/2 of a donut and trying a raisin cake! - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

Very cute place. My nieces and I made an impromptu stop and we're pleasantly surprised. The store is small and they didn't have a lot of items but everything they did have was yummy! We especially loved the cider donuts and jams. We will definitely go there again. read more

I heard of this place and finally went with my daughters. We were excited to try another place for yummy treats. We bought apple cider donuts which were very good however I bought a mini apple crumb pie and I have never said this about any pie before but it was awful. The crumb had zero flavor and was like eating sand. It literally fell off the pie like it wasn't cooked. I was also so disappointed that the pie had no pie bottom. This pie was $10.00 (a bit pricey ) which made it worst since it went straight in the garbage after my first bite. read more

Apples have no favor , bought different varieties- all no favor - waste of time and money -BEWARE !

Such an underrated place! I've never had a bad item from this place (hot cider, cold cider, apple pie, you name it). I love that it's open year round as well obviously the selection isn't as great in the winter months but not their fault. Parking was very limited, by the location is very cute, has seating, kid-friendly. I tend to buy my cider in bulk ! :) read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Deliciousness - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

So glad we randomly drove by here and decided to pop in! Their frozen apple cider.....omg. So good. Also loved their apple butter. Parking isn't great but we figured it out! Would totally go back. read more

Parking alongside zooming cars on 106 is worth it coming to this little, shack? Let's call it a shack. This place is very nostalgic for me because I used to come with my mom when I was little. The main thing I come here for is the cider, it is delicious! One of my favorites. I Always can't wait for the fall when they open. I like to have it ice cold or I stick it in the crockpot with spices to have it hot. They also have homemade pies that are constantly coming out of the ovens. Great jams and apple butter as well. Half of a gallon of cider was around $4.50 and $8 for the gallon. Be careful cider once consumed is addictive, very addictive. read more

See all

Ahhh nothing said fall on Oyster Bay, Long Island, NY like a trip to the Jericho Cider Mill. For those of us lucky enough to be Native NorthEasters, many of us had our own apple trees. Even if we did, the Cider Mill made some of the tastiest Cider, pies and apple goodies around. My Dad used to leave a few gallons in the garage to make Apple Jack. Couple of times they exploded; guess the fermentation process was not quite "scientific." It is one of those places that brings my heart and mind "home" and on the short list of MUST stops during season. Another place I truly love seeing photos of my friends and their kids keeping the tradition alive. Memories, scents and tastes forever etched in my Wonder Years. Yelp 100 Challenge read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Jericho Cider mill photo courtesy of my friend Brix - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

We picked up some apple cider doughnuts along with some apple cider. The doughnuts were cake like yet not overly dense. They had just the right amount of sugar. The apple cider was delicious. They had hot cider, cold cider, and frozen cider. Parking is available along the shoulder of Jericho Oyster Bay Road (Route 106). The shoulder is wide enough to park and open your door all the way without interfering with oncoming traffic; however, I tried to be careful because traffic was moving over 50 mph. read more

Fresh Fruit and pies! I totally forgot about this place - and I drive past it everyday. They have the best stuff there especially in the fall when the apples are in and they are making their famous pies. I usually pop in to grab a few pies on my way to visit people for Thanksgiving- but you have to go early due to the crowds that park all up and down route 106. They also have these big crates of apples and tons of jelly and assorted "country" items to keep you happily fortified for the winter. As Steve M. mentioned, the Frapples are really good and unlike anything you've had before. Their cider is top notch (and mixes well with vodka FYI). read more

Apple crumb pie was amazing and fresh out of the oven! We all liked the apple cider as well, which didn't have that tart taste that some store bought ones have. There didn't seem to be any formal parking spots though. read more

Fresh cider Fresh pies (I got an apple crumble pie and it was amazing) About 10 jams for you to buy Fresh cut sunflowers Park along side of the road (there is no real designated parking area) Will I be back? Yes. Probably next year though, when I am on my way back from the annual Oyster Festival read more

I was just recently went to the Cidermill after many years of not going even though I live down the street. I was so impressed. They have so much more variety than I expected. The apples are delicious and I love the baked goods read more

Delicious apple cider and donuts but omg the crumb cake is beyond magnificent. we went on a fall Saturday so it was packed but the line moved quickly. read more

The cold cider is delicious! Make sure you buy the gallon one. The sugar topped donuts are eh. Not my favorite. I'm not quite sure what the hype is. However I do love the Blueberry filled crumb donuts. Those are delicious! Apples are great! It's nice to get fresh picked apples without having to go to the orchards. Be careful of parking. You can only park on the side of the road. read more

The pecan pie is one of the best I've ever had and I choose to buy it from here instead of making it. I make everything else from scratch so they can do the work for me lol. Last year though, my order was incorrect and although I emailed them, no one even cared to get back to me, not for a refund but just an apology would've been good enough. So I guess this year, I will be double checking my order no matter how long the line is ‍ read more

This roadside cider mill is the best for a fall treat! It is very small but has so many delicious options of pies, jams, cookies, donuts and more... a cup of cider and a warm cider donut are my favorite: ) definitely worth a stop off! read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

Was a little disappointed when I got here last weekend.. I thought there was gonna be more to the shop but they didn't have donuts or pies left. The lady behind the counter didn't know where the apples came from when I asked and was taken back when I asked.. I was imagining more of a farm-like atmosphere but it's simply a shop with some apple flavored goods. The cider is definitely delicious though (reason for the 4 stars) read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

This place is great! It's a cute little Apple store by the side of the road. I'm pretty sure it's part of a house? Anyway, the lady behind the counter was lovely, and the apple cider rum cake is TO DIE FOR. Next time you're on the way up to the Oyster Bay Town Hall, do yourself a favor and stop by this Apple store. PS. My iPhone keeps capitalizing Apple in Apple store. Probably subliminal messaging on Apple's part. read more

Delicious homemade apple pie, blueberry pie and ice cream. I am normally not a pie person but their pies are fresh and have just the right sweetness. They also have very good customer service. One time I have a problem with my order and they offer an exchange. read more

Jericho Cider Mill is one of my favorite places of all time. Delicious cider and pumpkin pie are the most popular things to buy here. They also have their own brand of maple syrups and jams, as well as every kind of apple preparation you can imagine. The only downside is during the holidays, it is very difficult to get a parking spot. There's only space for a handful of cars in their lot, the rest is street parking. It's also difficult to get popular items such as pumpkin pie. Finally, the representatives of Jericho Cider Mill are very, very nice. It's a very enjoyable place to go. read more

The frapples are out of this world. Be prepared for long lines around the holidays. The staff is top notch they will help and assist you with anything you need. The pies are also unbelievably amazing!!!! read more

Nice little place, very helpful staff - I was able to snag a delicious pumpkin pie as it came out of the kitchen. The frosty apple cider is VERY tasty, and I am NOT a fan of apple cider! Note: for driving directions, neither address "NY 106" nor "Jericho Oyster Bay Road" came up on my older GPS - try entering "Route 106" instead. read more

I have to say I have been a long time fan of their crumb applepie. However the apples are chopped into very small pieces and I was very disappointed. It effected the taste and you also could not eat a forkful without it falling offof the fork. pleae go back to the apple slices read more

Although I did think this place had apple picking, it actually does not. It's more of a market place for fresh apples and I also saw some pumpkins. However, the sunflowers here made up for it. They are so beautiful and healthy. In addition the prices for the pies were a bit expensive for me, about $24 for a big one. I did purchase the apple crisp for $10 and am excited to try it. read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

Donuts were average (tasty but nothing to write home about). I bought an Apple pie and it was very sour for an Apple pie. I get not having a lot of sugar in the product but this was the worst Apple pie I've ever had. Come for the donuts; skip the Apple pie. Cider donuts also had way too strong of a cider taste to it. read more

Every thanksgiving I come here for a specialty pie , but this year they only made pies for people who pre-ordered and none for the public they had about 2 or 3 plain apple pies left for sale which looked like they'd been sitting. I bought one anyway so I wouldn't show up to dinner empty handed. Very disappointing. Not sure when they started pre-orders or stopped baking for walk ins, but I could have just purchased a plain apple pie from the supermarket near my house as I traveled an hour just to get there. read more

The place serves fresh juice and slushes. It was delicious and the place is so clean, I have gone there 10 times and every time I was so appreciated. I would definitely go back! read more