I don't know why it's taken us years to stumble across this amazing local shoppe that's been hiding in plain sight apparently! You no longer have to wait until the fall season to get your fix of apple cider donuts since they're made fresh, year-round here, and are delicious! Everything from their cider to their donuts to their apple crumb pie was worth coming back for. We can't wait to sample their ice cream and jams along with their home made dressings next time. read more

The best place to pick up a fresh pie, a dozen varieties of apples and some fantastic cider. Probably the best apple cider I have ever tasted. You have most likely passed by this place 50x and never stopped in. Go for it. Besides the 300 bees that are always hanging around (I've been told they don't sting) there is literally nothing bad in this suped up farm stand. They have some prepackaged gourmet jelly's and preserves but otherwise everything is fresh. Lots of the apples are HUGE and could be considered Apple-meals. I do have to mention that the parking stinks bc you have to park alongside 106 but it is worth the hassle. Tip: The cider is perfect to heat up and mix with some cinnamon and brandy. read more

Quaint little house that sells delicious baked goods and ciders. Super friendly environment paired with amazing product....what more could you ask for. read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Apple cider - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

such a disappointment. the hot cider was cold and the apple pie was tasteless. we stood in line for 45 minutes

Went to high school near this gem and remember saving up my coins and lunch money to buy the apple cider donuts and apple cider and slushees. Everything they have in store is amazing literally nothing is just average. I live in queens now and drop by when I'm in the area to buy a pie or other treat and I'll freeze it when I have to save for a special occasion. Nothing short of amazing read more

I'm gonna have to disagree with the Jericho Cider Mill lovers here and throw up a "MEH". Jericho Cider Mill has a strong reputation on Long Island for good cider. I grew up 30 mins from here, and sadly I'd never been (I have had the (very good) cider, I've just never visited the mill). Let's begin at the beginning. Parking is confusing and needs signage or something. Previous reviewers have said that you need to park on the shoulder of Rte. 106 (I'm surprised the local cops are cool with this), and walk in. I got there at opening, and there was a delivery truck, and one other car besides my own. I parked next to the other car, nice and snug so as to not hog room. The other car got their stuff and left, so there was my car, pretty much in the middle of the lot (despite the snug parking job - it's a SMALL lot). When I'm leaving, some dirtbag smoking a pipe (really?), gets apoplectic b/c he's having trouble parking his huge pickup, and tries to tell me that I parked badly. Seriously? Now, before you roll your eyes and say my review is based on this jerk, go back to my original statement - JCM needs to have clearer parking. For people like me, who want to park with consideration, and for pipe-head over there, who needs plenty of room to maneuver his beast of a truck. OK fine. The apples. There were only a few apples available, but that's the season, not JCM. It's the pricing that I had a problem with. Sure, honeycrisp apples are popular, but I have paid less for them in the farmers markets of Manhattan. I paid nearly half JCM's price over at Meyer's in Woodbury. No need to price that highly, when comparable operations price much lower. Someone mentioned the jellies and jams. McCutcheon's, out of Maryland. Not homemade, not local. Fairway carries the brand. Picked up the supposedly legendary apple pie. The apple portion of the pie is admittedly delicious. Fresh apples, very nicely done. The crust? Phoned in. Needs a lot of work. I feel like I'm being mean here, but the pie doesn't hold the value of what I paid for it. Yes, it's good, but not for what JCM charges. And the counter boy (nice kid) said they were baked this morning. When, 2 am? Someone said to leave the lid open for a fresh pie, so as not to steam the pie - very wise advice. Except when the pie is cold. The temp this morning was in the 70's. Why is my supposedly just-baked pie colder than that? Are they baked, then thrown in a fridge? Confusing and disappointing. I would maybe go back to JCM once the season is in full swing. I at least must try their hot apple cider, to see if it's as good as the cider from Samascott at the E82nd St. Farmers Market. And I feel like I'm missing something, like the hype can't be -that- hollow. We'll see. read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

The apple crumb pie from here is hands down the best pie I've ever eaten. They bake a large selection of pies, including pecan, blueberry, and tons more. Their apple cider is excellent, and it's nearly impossible to get a pie and not pick up a nice cup of cider at the same time. Be prepared for LONG lines around the holidays; last year I waited in line for nearly 30 minutes, but it's worth it. You can also call ahead and make orders, but don't wait until the last minute, they normally won't take orders the week of a major holiday. Parking can often be a problem, there's only about 10 parking spots, and most people wind up parking on the (main) road, so just be careful when you're going to and from your car. read more

I come here every year on my way back home from the annual Oyster Festival. This year they made some renovations and upgrades! The inside is now like a mini market with a large space with cashiers. It use to be just a walk up counter to order from. The line this time was a lot longer but it was probably due to it being the weekend and because of the oyster festival. They are open ALL YEAR LONG. They make amazing pies! My favorite has been apple crumb pie, apple pie and pumpkin. unfortunately they were sold out of everything except variations of apple crumb (peachy apple crumb, apple blueberry crumb, etc). Im not sure if its because of the upgrade or just because it was busy but the pie was not as good as it usually was. I'll have to go back and try it again since this is my favorite place to pick up some pie. Also dont forget to pick up some apple cider! its deeeelish. read more

If you want a delicious apple experience, stop in at the Jericho Cider Mill. I can rave about their Apple cider (wonderful and fresh), the Apple pies (yum, so flaky and light), FRAPPLES (must try- a frozen Apple slushy) and apple turnovers. The fresh apples are just that - FRESH- never mealy...that's worth the little bit of extra money that they charge. Just be careful when you park on Route 106. It's a busy road with Jericho HS on the opposite side of the road. read more

I think I was expecting more of an apple farm with apples, pastries, and cider for sale. Instead, we were greeted by a roadside barn-looking building with apples out front and food/drinks inside. In all fairness, we had come for the cider, but I guess I was expecting a whole experience out of it. The cider was absolutely delicious, but there was really not much else to see or do. The cashier (owner?) was really nice and let us try samples of the cider before we bought some to go. I guess I'd come back for the cider, but I'm not sure if I'd have any other reason to return. read more

The Jericho Cider Mill is one of the few places on left unchanged as I remember it from my childhood. The Milleridge Inn, Meyer's Farm, and Zorn's are the others that immediately come to mind. My family has been coming here my entire life, especially before the holidays. The cider mill has withstood the test of time because their cider's fresh flavor isn't replicated by the grocery store brands. You can get the cider cold, hot, or slushy. Besides the apple cider, the apple crisp is my personal favorite. As other reviewers have said, it's safer to park on the shoulder of Rt 106 than squeeze into one of the few spot in the driveway. read more

Super cute place if you want to get cider and donuts. They also sell other treats like butters, spreads, coffee, ice cream, etc. will definitely be returning to try their peach and mango cider! read more

A little disappointed that this wasn't a typical cider mill, at least not like what I was exposed to during my childhood in Michigan, and that's why I deducted one star. That said, for breakfast I made an English muffin with apples and apple butter purchased from Jericho Cider Mill, and oh. my. goodness. It was delicious. So sweet, and mostly naturally so. I bought a couple pounds of apples, two apple butters (it was buy one, get one free), an apple cider (for the adorable 7 y/o that was with me), two baby pumpkins (perfect for season desk decor) and my purchase was just barely over $9. Not bad, and they accept credit card. read more

A staple of my childhood. I will forever stop and order a frapple on the way to my parents house. Love their cider.

In the days when I resided in New York, we paid homage to the autumn gods by standing on long lines for apple pie at the cider mill. Not just any apple pie, but the best apple pie any of us had ever tried. The kind of apple pie we gave to people who claimed they didn't like apple pie. Or dessert. Or things with mushy texture. A win, every single time. The apple crumb is their prized pie, but the other apple blends (blueberry, raspberry, peach) are delicious too. Now be a good little husband/wife/daughter/son/father/brother/sister/friend and buy this addicting locally-baked treat for your loved ones. Converting pie-haters since 1918! read more

The Jericho cider mill, a cute little stand on the side of the road, embodies all the things I love about fall; crisp air, leaves, cider, pumpkins and apples. I have woken up before sunrise on holidays to wait for their pies -apple crumb, blueberry and pecan are all fantastic. The apple pies are nicely tart and not sugary. The pecan pie (my favorite) is sweet and has a bit of a butterscotch essence to it. I bought an apple pie yesterday and it was still warm, fresh from the oven -and everyone from my job loved it. Frozen or steamed, their apple cider is the absolute best and is a nice treat for me when I can get there. McCutcheons peach salsa is also delicious, as are their fudge and maple candy. The only item that I didn't love was the all fruit pastry(?) item -it was good, but my money is on the pie and the cider. read more

Easily the best cider you have ever had! As you get closer to the holidays, the line of cars along 106 is impressive.... Very good jams as well.... If u haven't had an apple from the tree lately ( unlike those from the market that have been in cold storage), you'll enjoy one of several varieties for sale there. read more

asked my dad to make a u-turn just so i can get my hands on some cider and donuts. This place is small! so you might want to park along the side of the road. They have so many options for apples! i'm not sure what the going rate is for apples at the market these days but they seemed like a good deal. The cider! so good! I was really looking forward to donuts but they ran out by the time we got there. The pies all smelled delicious. I did have a scone and it was super flakey with the perfect amount of safety. read more

$25 for a blueberry pie that was just ok. I don't know maybe I am spoiled by Briemeires Farm our east, but you can find very comparable pies for a lot less. read more

Been coming here my whole life. No family holiday dessert would be the same without their pies. Some of my favorites are the apple crumb, blueberry crumb and of course you can not come here without leaving with some apple cider. This is a must try and must have for every individual on earth read more

Just a Fall institution...Stop in to feel the season. Girls working were super nice and we're very nice to our dog. I go for a gallon of cider and a cup of hot cider for the ride home. So much apple in a single sip. Fun preserves, doughnuts, pies, and oh yea apples. Had about 7 different offering when we went. Stop here and then do a fun walk at Muttontown Preserve for the foliage. read more

This is, hands down, the best apple pie I have ever tasted. A friend of mine works on Long Island and from time to time will bring their magnificent apple crumb pie back with him. One bite is pure decadent joy. Everything is just so, from the homemade crust, to the mix of apples and sugar. Perfect for holidays, I.e. Thanksgiving, you'll be a big hit. Just a couple words of advice, I've heard the mill is easy to miss because its a nondescript house. So keep your eyes peeled if you go for a visit, and be sure to have your favorite map app handy. Also, since I've never gotten one straight out of the oven, be careful how you reheat. You'll want the crust nice and crisp, so keep it out of the microwave. read more

Best cider, hands down. When the leaves start to turn color and the temperature starts to turn chilly, I head here. Their hot apple cider is deliciously tart, I get excited just thinking about it! It truly warms my heart and soul. They also make wonderful pies! Thanksgiving wouldn't be complete without one! Have a Happy! read more

So, I have not been to this place...however I bought a bag of their apple cider doughnuts at the Rise of the Jackolanters and OMG. They are the best Apple Cider doughnuts ever!!!! You can't deny the apple cider smell and I can only imagine how good they would be fresh out the fryer! Can't wait to visit. read more

Don't go there. Get there products for the local markets that sell their cider and pies like North Shore Farms. The new management lack integrity and class. read more

O M G ! A P P L E . P I E !!! APPLE PIE ! CRUMB APPLE PIE ! The best you will ever EAT !!! Order early for Thanksgiving or you will be stuck in a large line. And get there early!! They need to do something about parking. They should build a small parking lot next door. You park in the side of a busy highway and the way New Yorkers drive its a accident awaiting to happen. People leave this place and head for a U-turn nearby and don't pay attention to the traffic that is coming. read more

Fresh and delicious! I had the donuts and hot apple cider. The place is small and easy to miss on a busy road but stop and go inside. read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Yummy Yummy! Fresh and delicious donuts and cider. - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

Their apple cider is delicious! The apples are super fresh and the place just feels like a farm stand. Be careful parking because it can be tricky but well worth it! read more

The Jericho Cider Mill is a fall tradition on Long Island. Located on the 106 it might not be the biggest location but they do offer one of the best variates for fall goods. It's an easy place to miss so make sure to keep a watchful eye. There is a very small parking lot in front of the stand but chances are the only spot you will find is on the shoulder of the 106. If there is only one thing you get make sure it's the cider! I don't know what they do to it and the only ingredient listed on the bottle is "apples," but they have the best apple cider ever. Every time I stop I manage to leave with at least a gallon and a large hot apple cider to go. In addition to amazing apple cider the Jericho Cider Mill has incredible pies and other baked goods, a huge assortment of fresh apples, fruit preserves, mulling spice and so much more! The Jericho Cider Mill is open from September to May, so make it a point to stop by soon! read more

Quaint little place that offers delicious apple cider and different types of apples and veggies. The apples we picked were all fantastic and great quality. The warm apple cider is awesome, however, I would skip the frozen apple cider. It's sort of like a slushy, and it would probably be very good if they added more cider to it. Also available are pies, apple butter, and a variety of jams. We wanted to purchase a pie, but we had somewhere else to go and did not want to leave it in the car. Plenty of free parking on the side of the road, but there is also a VERY small lot that holds maybe 3 or 4 cars. Also, make sure you watch out for the bees. They are attracted to the apples and they definitely make their presence known. read more

A taste of home sweet home and the crisp breeze of fall all in one.....,the pies and cider are to die for.......the pies are fresh out of the oven and totally taste homemade....the apple crumb is the best I have ever tasted!!! I am going to stop there again tomorrow on the way home from the Bayville Waterside festival.....order your pies early especially during the holiday.......enjoy the taste of homemade with out all the work! read more

I loved the pecan pie and the apple cider! They were both delish!!!! I cant wait to go back and try their other pies! read more

Jericho Cider Mill - Pecan pie - Fruits & Veggies Near Me - Jericho, New York

See all

Legend. Just go get some doughnuts, hot cider, pies and apples. There's a reason it's been here so long and the lines match it's age.

I've never been here before so I thought I'd give it a shot. They have apples, tomatoes, and corn you can buy. Everything is reasonably priced which is nice because I've been to other places that were over priced. They have a pretty good variety of pies and jams. I highly recommend their donuts because they are soft and sugary. I recommend this place to anyone. read more

I love the fact that it's open all the time now but becoming too commercialized. Everyone there used to be passionate about Apple now just work there. read more

Best apple cider donuts I've ever had. The apple crumb pie left a little to be desired but the hot apple cider made up for it. I go back often now just to introduce friends to these donuts. One day I'll venture outside of the donut line to try some jams. read more

Everything from service to the delicious pies i give a 12/10. There is nothing bad i have to say about the mill. They have being doing it right for decades and even adjust to covid for online orders ready when you arrive. If you love hot or cold cider this is the place for you. The apple blueberry crumble was a hit for this years thanksgiving. read more

This place has long lines and it's not cheap but you get what you pay for. The 10 inch apple raspberry crump pie was beyond delicious. I will be going back. read more

Bought a Jericho Cider Mill apple pie at a Holiday Farms market. It cost $26, and, naturally I figured, boy, must I have just gotten the granddaddy of all apple pies!! Got it home, had dinner--even bought a good quality vanilla ice cream for some guests who like pie a'la mode. The pie? Puhleeze. It is loaded with sliced apples--okay, it's not stingy. Shouldn't be stingy when you take $26 for the privilege of eating your overstuffed pie. It was so sweet, I might as well have simply eaten from the Domino's sugar bag. The crust is gummy. I'm tellin' ya, when you take $26 for a freakin pie, large though it may be, I think you have the right to expect the pie to be kick ass. It wasn't even massage ass. read more

I was very disappointed i my peach pie. The peaches were not fresh and they were obviously canned. Even the crust was so-so (soggy). It was clear that this pie was not fresh baked or created by the Cider Mill. It was just "fair". I could have gotten a comparable at the grocery store for one third the price. read more