Tucked away within more or less a single square mile of the Highland Park area are three bakeries that are known either in part or by definition for their cookies. As per usual, I wanted to find out which were the best, and decided to do so via a head's up competition:
Creme de la Cookie: http://www.yelp.com/biz/cr%C3%A8me-de-la-cookie-dallas-3
JD's Chippery: http://www.yelp.com/biz/jds-chippery-dallas
Great One Cookie Company: http://www.yelp.com/biz/great-one-cookie-company-dallas
Star 1: How were the service and atmosphere?
While closely located to one another, each of these three cookie shops has a totally different vibe.
Known for their award winning Chocolate Chip cookies, Toni Rivard's Creme de la Cookie is a more comprehensive bakery, and I imagine they even do far more business on cake balls, cupcakes and other delicacies than they do on cookies. CC definitely aims for the more gourmet atmosphere that I have no doubt brings in the Highland Park moms and Louie V yielding SMU students by the droves, but I won't say for a second that it's a bad thing.
JD's Chippery and Great One Cookie Co on the other hand are strictly cookie spots, although even between the two there's a different vibe. JD's has been here for more than 30 years, and in every way they've become part of the community as a mom and pop cookie shop.
Great One Cookie Co on the other hand is more of a newcomer, and Pam Denesuk's small but modern storefront will have you feeling like you've truly found a hidden gem in the city with the names of cookies simply displayed with the actual wares hidden in the back.
Single Star / Single Star / Single Star
Star 2: How were the portions relative to the cost?
Another point of diversity amongst these three cookie shops related to both price and portion size. Here's a breakdown -
Creme de la Cookie: Average price of $1.20 per cookie
JD's Chippery: Average price of $0.75 per cookie
Great One Cookie Company: Average price of $2.00 per cookie
You can browse my pictures if you like to get a sense for the size of each shop's cookie, and depending on which review you're reading you'll see one grouping of the three depicted below, but for reference Creme de la Cookie and Great One Cookie Company both had what I would call standard sized cookies whereas JD's had slightly smaller cookies. The portion size between JD's and the others is reflected in the price, but Great One Cookie Company was a real outlier with prices that were nearly twice that of portion similar Creme de la Cookie. Worth it? I suppose that depends, but it's certainly worth pointing out.
Single Star / Single Star / Single Star
Stars 3 and 4: How was the food (or in this case, the cookies)?
Let's not kid ourselves here: The Chocolate Chip Cookie is the rightful benchmark for how all cookies should be measured, so for this dual star category I decided to dish out one star for the Chocolate Chip cookie alone and a second based on the others.
With respect to the first star, this was essentially a runaway victory for JD's Chippery for two reasons. First and foremost, call me crazy, but I like my cookies to have a slightly crunchy outside and a soft inside, and that's exactly what JD's Chocolate Chip cookies had. My Creme de la Chocolate Chip Cookie was soft with the upside of having the chocolate chips essentially melted into the rest of the cookie, but the lack of a crunch left me a tad bit unsatisfied. Great One's chocolate chip cookie was soft to the point of having me wondering whether or not it was cooked all the way through, but this was made up for by having a seriously absurd quantity of chocolate chips. The second reason behind my thinking that JD's Chocolate Chip cookies claimed the category came down to the cookie ex-Chocolate Chips, where JD's had an absolutely delicious unique flavor that I can't quite place whereas CC and GO were more plain if you go a bite without any chocolate chips.
With the second star in mind, JD's once again claimed a crown of sorts thanks to their cinnamon packed Snickerdoodle that also packed a crunch when compared to the softer and more mildly flavored doodles from Creme and Great One. One thing I will point out is that the Ginger Snap at Creme de la Cookie was fantastic, and the Peanut Butter Pretzel Chocolate Chip offering at Great One should be sampled by all cookie enthusiasts.
Single Star / Dual Stars / Single Star
Star 5: Would you eat here every day if you could?
So there you have it folks. Again, everyone has their preferences when it comes to cookies, and my preferences line up best with JD's for the reasons I've stated above. 5 Stars to JD's Chippery, 3 stars to the rest.
No Star (3) / Star Granted (5) / No Star (3) read more