1. Jamestown Mattress

0

Fredonia, NY

Cancel

Open app

Search

Jamestown Mattress

1.8 (4 reviews)
Open • 10:00 am - 7:00 pm

Jamestown Mattress Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Jamestown Mattress

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tom D.
1457
1439
505

14 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Jamestown Mattress

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

City Mattress

City Mattress

4.1(51 reviews)
46.1 mi
•$$

Amazing place to purchase a mattress around Buffalo and Niagara Falls. Went there after a long day…read moreof driving around the city look at other mattress store. When we got in, we were surprise on how big the store was. They have bunch of more options compared to nearby stores. We were looking for a medium/firm memory foam mattress, so the assistant suggested to try the options they have. Their mattress pricing are really good for what you are getting. After a short time search for our mattress we were able to decide on which on to purchase. The assistant was not pushy on getting us to purchase the mattress compare to other store we went where they keep pushing us to buy a mattress we were not 100% satisfied and more expensive. Overall, it was a great store to purchase a mattress and will definitely recommend other to pay a visit.

UPDATE 11/30/25:…read more Store's Follow-Up Request Ignored by Management Despite the owner asking me to call the store manager about this unusable mattress, my message to the manager has gone unanswered for over a week. Meanwhile, this mattress continues to get worse. It simply cannot handle my 122 lb. body weight when in use. The materials instantly compress so much that I experience physical discomfort and soreness (an iPad on a stand next to the bed is now exactly level with my face while I'm lying down). This points to a massive failure in the product's support capacity. I'm forced to sleep on my couch now rather than my bed because of the hip and glute pain I'm experiencing. This company's system for resolving customer complaints is clearly broken if the manager ignores a significant issue a customer is having. I cannot recommend a company that sells low-quality products and provides zero follow-up customer service. I will file a formal complaint with the BBB and the NYS Consumer Protection Agency if I don't get a response soon. *****ORIGINAL REVIEW***** I purchased the Celestial Pegasus Plush Innerspring mattress and thought I'd finally get relief from the hip pain and foot numbness I had from my four year old Saatva latex mattress that I spent a fortune on. That wasn't the case. The Pegasus "Plush" wasn't plush at all and the hip pain and foot numbness continued. I should note the pain and numbness only happen when I'm lying down in bed so this isn't a medical issue. I used their exchange policy after sleeping on that mattress for 30 days and exchanged it for the Simmons Emerald Coast, which I was told was a plush mattress. Now I have a whole new pain - my glute is constantly throbbing from lying on this mattress and now I'm stuck with a very expensive mistake. Never purchase a pillow top from Simmons. They sag very quickly. After doing some Googling, I found out this mattress is best for back sleepers and I can see why. That's the only way to sleep on it without much pain, although I'm a side sleeper and can't get used to sleeping on my back. I told the salesperson that I am a side sleeper so I figured he was pointing me in the right direction for side sleepers. I don't have the money to purchase yet another mattress so I'm forced to live in pain. I never in my life had so many issues with mattresses and I know it's possible to be comfortable because I recently slept in a hotel and at a friend's and had no issues. Prior to purchasing the Saatva and then these two mistakes from City Mattress, I never had issues. Bedtime was a pleasure for me. Now it's torture. Service was just ok. Nothing special, but not bad either. I suggest going elsewhere where there are many more brands to choose from.

Photos
City Mattress
City Mattress
City Mattress

See all

Jamestown Mattress

Jamestown Mattress

3.0(2 reviews)
23.6 mi
•$$$

My experience with them has been nothing short of a nightmare. After purchasing what I thought was…read morea quality mattress, it quickly became apparent that it was faulty. Naturally, I reached out, expecting them to honor their warranty. Less than a year old and it started killing my back. It had a large hole in the middle. Not only did they refuse to replace the defective mattress, but their communication was abysmal. Repeated calls and requests for updates were met with excuses. To make matters worse, without any prior notice, they randomly showed up at my house to haul away the mattress. They didn't bring a replacement, leaving me without a bed currently because they insisted the factory needed to "inspect" it first. This is beyond unacceptable. Save yourself the frustration and avoid this company at all costs. So I currently have no mattress and there has been zero communication from them about it. I called again the following week. Talked to the same person at the factory. they had absolutely zero idea who I was or what I was talking about. And promised they'd call me back later in the day. Still have no mattress and no hope of getting it back. My experience with them has been nothing short of a nightmare. After purchasing what I thought was a quality mattress, it quickly became apparent that it was faulty. Naturally, I reached out, expecting them to honor their warranty. Less than a year old and it started killing my back. It had a large hole in the middle. Not only did they refuse to replace the defective mattress, but their communication was abysmal. Repeated calls and requests for updates were met with excuses. To make matters worse, without any prior notice, they randomly showed up at my house to haul away the mattress. They didn't bring a replacement, leaving me without a bed currently because they insisted the factory needed to "inspect" it first. This is beyond unacceptable. Save yourself the frustration and avoid this company at all costs. So I currently have no mattress and there has been zero communication from them about it. I called again the following week. Talked to the same person at the factory. they had absolutely zero idea who I was or what I was talking about. And promised they'd call me back later in the day. Still have no mattress and no hope of getting it back. They finally called back and said they would redeliver my mattress tomorrow. We will see if they show up.

Seriously, best bed shopping experience of my life! Picking out a great king size bed was super…read moreeasy and fast. I absolutely love it and it's exactly how it was described and ordered. This is the highest quality bed I've ever had in terms of precision. Every thread is in place every everything is perfect the attention to detail and comfort are amazing. After falling in love with my king I got a twin for my office /guest room daybed.

Photos
Jamestown Mattress
Jamestown Mattress
Jamestown Mattress

See all

Big Lots

Big Lots

3.0(1 review)
1.3 mi

Here is another store with a distinct smell to it - not sure what it is, but know that I really…read moredon't care for it. The cleanliness and organization of this store - well - right now I think it isn't good. The reason - they recently moved everything around and now I don't know where every item is - maybe a good marketing idea, but for me - I hate it! Try to use a bathroom elsewhere because these are not the best or close to it! The people are hit and miss here as far as friendliness - sometimes they are great - other times they aren't. Returns are easy - no questions asked and I mean that. Just make sure you have your receipt. Another good point is the rewards program - and it's getting better they say. I like discounts. Speaking of discounts - this place normally has things that are old - out dated - repaired/refurbished - so if it sounds cheap - keep that in mind and ALWAYS check expiration dates on your perishables - and that includes things you don't eat too! Plenty of parking - it's located in a plaza! Stop in once in awhile because stock continues to change and with that - the item you bought and decided you really liked probably won't be there the next time!

From the owner: Big Lots offers the residents of Dunkirk great discounts and deals on furniture and mattresses. We…read moreare located on Central Ave near SUNY Fredonia. In addition to low prices on great merchandise, we offer furniture delivery and leasing programs.

Photos
Big Lots
Big Lots
Big Lots

See all

Xtreme Discount Mattress

Xtreme Discount Mattress

3.1(40 reviews)
44.0 mi
•$$

My mother went in to buy a new mattress for my niece, and I looked around at the mattresses and was…read morefeeling them all and checking everything out. They had a nice large selection there and I loved some of the beds and instead of having frames they had a really cool thing that you just put your mattress on top of where you don't need a boxspring, and then there's plenty of room to put stuff underneath your bed. I would not mind getting one of those for the future. The prices were very reasonable. The employee, taking care of us, was very nice and willing to explain every little thing, and repeat himself over again, when my mother did not hear him, or could not hear him. Next time I need a mattress I would definitely go here and I would recommend anybody else checking out the store first before going anyplace else.

I don't know if it's just Me but I seem to have good Karma with this business so far. I bought My…read morefirst reasonably fair budget mattress and foundation set up under three years ago but the starter was a soft plush and started sagging a little. I was able to take the required pictures and E-mailed them and they awarded Me My swap out ticket with no hassle. I went back into the store to test out Plush vs Medium Firm and the Medium Firm was the way to go for My 50 y/o back. I purchased the Harmony Firm with the old mattress as the discount towards the new one. Hence the name of the business. I hope to keep having good Karma with this business because commercial mattress prices are quite horrific but You won't be able to swap those out for a discount either unless you paid the warranty. I believe George Costello surveyed many of frustrated mattress consumer.

Photos
Xtreme Discount Mattress - Mattress box

Mattress box

Xtreme Discount Mattress
Xtreme Discount Mattress - Mattress label

See all

Mattress label

Jamestown Mattress - mattresses - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...