Delicious hot mess of a pizza! We walked in 15 minutes before they closed after our show at Red Rocks was rain delayed. This was the only place in town still open. The bartender greeted us and never made us feel awkward about coming in so late. The beer was cold, the service was friendly and the pizza was crazy good! Thin crispy crust with loads of fresh toppings. The entire experience exceeded our expectations and we're grateful they were still open. We'll definitely be back! read more

James Peak Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

See all

OMG. This place is amazing. The pizza is New York style. So good. We will be doing take out next week for a party if 24. read more

James Peak Pizza Joint - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Awesome pizza and great service...Service was attentive without being hovering, the wait was totally reasonable, and the prices are fair for the quality you're getting. This isn't just good "neighborhood pizza" -- it's genuinely great pizza, full stop read more

EXTREMELY rude and unprofessional. Walked in and the bartender was rude and made weird comments. Made an order to go because couldn't make one over the phone. Order to go took over 30+ mins for 15 wings. read more

I was hungry and decided to pick up a couple of slices on my way into town. I see that many reviews cite excellent service, but I got to-go pizza so I can't speak to that. However, I paid $18 (plus tip) for two slices and a soda when I could have gotten a way better frozen pizza and bottle of wine at Safeway for less than that. If you don't have a place to cook, there are several better pizza options in Winter Park and Fraser. Deno's, Elevations. Heck, I'd go to Domino's over this place. read more

I've had take-out here twice and the pizza is very good. I've had the Margherita and the plain cheese. Both were very good. I've never sat down and can't speak to the service, but the interior looks to be a good blend of sit down restaurant with a bar area with lots of drinks to choose from. The menu seems to have plenty of variety too. read more

This to be honest was the only place open when we arrive in town. I gotta say, it was amazing! Such friendly service, full bar, great prices, and great food. You can literally smell the pizza from the street! read more

James Peak Pizza Joint - The two slice special for $12.99 - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

Really good food! Get there before 9pm if you want pasta. Chicken Alfredo and vegetarian Primavera were a big hit. Really delicious pizza crust! Ashley makes amazing cocktails but they have an impressive beer selection too. read more

We had dine in and the service was excellent! We had the fried ravioli and chicken parmigiana sandwich and everything was fresh, hot and delicious! Will definitely be returning. read more

We came in just after 6pm on a Saturday night and got seated right away. Food quality was high and we liked our food and drinks. This is a sit-down pizza place. They have a full bar plus wine and beer, have more than just pizza and seem to be raising the bar a bit in terms of their other quality items like real bolognese sauce, good chicken parmesan, etc. The service was friendly but spotty as they seemed to struggle to keep up with dinner rush. We received our food in a reasonable time, so that was good. But fixing items, getting a drink refill and then waiting for the bill all took uncomfortably long. I would probably have given 4 stars, but the blaring TV football game ruined an otherwise decent meal. When we came in they were playing music, and then about midway through our dinner they switched over to the football game and increased the volume. We were struggling to have a conversation over the game and commercials for psoriasis drugs. And when we left, I looked around the room and maybe one single person at the bar was actually paying any attention at all to the football game. They've got like 6+ large TVs on this small place... which seems like a bit of overkill, but would be ok if they were muted with subtitles. I think they need to decide what they want to be... While pizza is the central theme, I wish they would embrace the italian restaurant concept and ditch the competing loud sports bar concept. We liked some things and really wanted to like it more. But we fell that Hernando's Pizza has a better vibe if you are looking for a sit down pizza restaurant. But we will give this place a mother try on a few months, and I will update my review if warranted. read more

Went to pepes next door the day before and the food was cooked inside a sink. The servers are pepes were rude and racist. James pizza is A MUST HAVE. When we entered James pizza we were welcomed with open arms and were seated immediately. The menu is easy to read and the food was delicious. We had the large cheese pizza and the Alfredo pasta with breaded chicken. All pastas come with a side of garlic toast! Highly recommend great food and service and they close at midnight! read more

This place is definitely a hidden gem. MOOSE was awesome, NANCY was ahhh-mazing. So grateful for the service and even more grateful for that NYC STYLE PIZZA. The pasta and the sandwiches down to the wings were 10/10. Highly recommend this place. Thank you for your kindness and for treating us like your own. Side note: we actually went next door to Pepe's first and were shown the door (racist vibes) and ended up at James...thank you! read more

James Peak Pizza Joint - NYC STYLE CHEESE PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Colorado

They're new, and definitely don't have the kinks worked out. The pizza was not good. Actually not cooked completely- the cheese was still diced on top. It was also not correct with the toppings- $28 for a 12 inch. And really expensive. read more

Rolled into town around 10:30 last night super hungry and tor, no groceries yet, and we weren't finding any open restaurants. Yikes! We finally saw the OPEN sign at a pizza joint! Score! Moose was so friendly and welcoming! The late night menu's pizzas and toasted ravioli absolutely hit the spot, too! 10 out of 10, highly recommend! read more

Pizza perfection - who knew I could find New York style pizza in the middle of Winter Park?! This was perfect after a full day bike race. They're open late and the staff is super friendly. Good vibes within, you can tell it's a popular spot in town. Will definitely come back next time we're in town! read more

MUST COME!!! This is my favorite restaurant in Colorado: the food? Amazing! Prices? Amazing! The owner??? The BEST! Perfect for every occasion read more

Very friendly service and I thoroughly enjoyed the bolognese. It was fresh and perfect texture. Will be back!

VERY OVERPRICED, got to pizzas to go cost 72$ frozen pizza would've been better. Not sure what the deal is with the outside seating but dogs weren't welcome so we thought we sit outside "it was to cold outside for them" not us them. read more

Food was real good, good NY style pizza. Service was great. Great Anti pasta salad. Only issue is we had half a pizza left and owner wouldn't give us a pizza box for leftover. Only gave us these little slice boxes so we had to stack slices on top of each other and pizza ended up sticking together. Pretty cheap if you ask me. Waiter said owner wouldn't let him give us a box. read more

Overpriced and took over 2 hours to get our pizza which was cold and the bar tender only served the regulars and brought food and pizza consistently would not recommend read more

Love this place! Good food, atmosphere and service. Pizza is excellent and the Italian beef is amazing!

This is the best! We had chicken tenders with sauce, spaghetti with meatballs and pizza. All to perfection. Gregory , our server , very attentive and nice. Awesome atmosphere. Highly recommend! read more

What a fun experience. There were five of us eating out on a Sunday night. It has a sports bar atmosphere. The food was wonderful and reasonably price for Winter Park. We did not try their pizza, but enjoyed appetizers, awesome cocktails, dinners, and dessert, all were far better than expected. It was a very pleasant surprise. Will be returning the next time we visit Winter Park. read more

Went to Pepe first and got terrible service, then Decided to go to the pizza place next door, they took care of us. I had to make a yelp to give them a review never felt so compelled to make one. Good job pizza place !!!! read more

Great happy hour deals - we had the 2 slices and beer for $12, slices were pretty good sized and hot. Lots of great local beer on tap. Plenty of but TVs for watching sports games, lots of bar seating. The guys here are working hard and way understaffed, so cut them some slack, they are super nice and passionate! read more

What a great place!! An Italian bistro vibe, clean and welcoming. The garlic bread was delicious, the Alfredo sauce was so creamy, plenty of meatballs with the spaghetti dish and the pizza toppings were plentiful and the perfect size. Gregory, our server was great. It was a busy evening and he took care of all the guests with super friendly service. Will definitely come back again. read more

Great service and great pizza and Antipasti last night! Order was on time and with a smile!

I would Like to state very good food but today when I ordered I got half my meal that I paid for which was brunt when my boyfriend went to go in to pick it up he stated the guy up at the bar wasn't paying attention instead trying to get a girls attention that was sitting at the bar in a inappropriate way. He appeared to be drunk and/or high. I love the place and the food but today was very upsetting. Chris was the name of the employee read more

We were excited to try a new pizza option in Winter Park and the Tuesday night Margherita pizza and Margaritas special drew us in. We've been to this space through its many iterations. The new owners have updated it nicely with many television screens to watch your favorite sporting games. In addition to the Margherita and Margaritas we ordered an Italian salad and a Supreme pizza. The New York style pizzas and salad were excellent, but the margaritas could be improved. The owner, Bill, stopped by to say hello. It was interesting to hear how he perfected the delicious pizza crust at altitude. He also brought us samples of some of the pasta sauces; marinara, bolognese, and meat sauce. Being a vegetarian, I liked the marinara, my husband liked the bolognese and my son liked the meat sauce, so you really can't go wrong here. They also have appetizers and pasta and a full bar. We are thrilled that there's a good Italian restaurant in Winter Park and we will definitely be back. read more

We were on our way to tacos when we walked by this restaurant. We peered in the windows and it looked clean and fresh and very Italian! So we threw tacos out and embraced pasta! I had the marinara sauce on penne. It was so savory and flavorful! And my husband had the primavera on angel hair pasta! The portions were generous and steaming hot fresh out of the kitchen. We were blown away! I could have eaten that marinara sauce on cardboard! It's that good. And the pasta primavera was loaded with vegetables. You could taste the white wine and garlic and butter. Bill, the owner came out and personally asked us about the meal. Nice guy! Cares about our opinion. And our server, Gregory, Greg? - not sure I'm getting that correct... He was great. Knew the menu backwards and forwards and was very attentive and fun. We learned a new game also, "shut the box".... Thanks to the bartender, "Moose(y)!! This place is family friendly, affordable, great beer selection, fantastic food and open late! Winter Park needed this restaurant! We'll be back! read more