A nice and quiet place, service was top tier, the food I have to say tasted as good as the photos. Classic wedge with great blue cheese crumbles and real thick bacon. Crab pot tasted clean. Lobster bisque was season properly and didn't call short. The skin on the Branzino was top tier! Seafood pasta was good. I will definitely be coming back here when I visit Jersey again. read more

See all

Food: fresh seafood - snow crab legs were decent sized and packed with meat; served piping hot, which is also a plus. Lobster roll was also delish; their housemade chips are crunchy like kettle style and are awesome. Their crispy branzino is also a winner. Their salad had breadcrumbs in it which was odd...their coleslaw was ok Service: friendly, no frills Ambiance: clean, open space read more

The food was good and very fresh. As you can see the portion was significant enough that I was able to finish it all. Staff was friendly and efficient. I found them to be swift with being for food out. A very relaxed atmosphere not too fancy. I'll definitely check plan to go back when in town. read more

See all

We stopped by Jack's to try their new lunch menu and it did not disappoint! The lobster grilled cheese and Po' Boy were incredible, and of course their famous lobster roll is still a must-get. Everything was super fresh and flavorful. The team there took the best care of us and the restaurant is absolutely beautiful, giving you that nautical feel! Even if you're not a seafood fan, there are plenty of delicious options to choose from -- they've really got something for everyone. Lunch is available Monday-Friday from 11 to 3:30, and you can dine in, grab takeout, or get delivery. Whether you're in Short Hills or Montclair, definitely check out Jack's for your next lunch -- you'll be glad you did! Check out our full visit here: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DQWqiESjWbE/?igsh=OHk3cmsyMjJrbHVp read more

See all

Still a great location. Service is good, nautical themed bright & clean environment with a casual feel. The food has not failed once. This time was the garlic bread and the Lobster bomb. Grades: Garlic Bread: A++ (they use real garlic chunks & butter) Lobster Bomb: A++ read more

See all

Everything was so fresh. I got the lobster roll and I can't believe they have six types of lobster rolls here. I love that they serve a little bit of lobster bisque with the lobster roll to dip the bread and it's delicious. Everything was super fresh and loaded with seafood. The New England clam chowder was definitely delicious and I recommend getting it in a bread bowl, I love the sangria at the service was amazing and the atmosphere is really nice. I like that. They have complementary parking and outside seating in the summer. read more

See all

The Lobster bisque and shrimp kale ceasar salad was DELICIOUS!!! There is indoor and outdoor seating available. Service was friendly and attentive!! Drinks were always refilled before the glass was empty. Food is fresh and cooked to order. 10 out of 10!!! read more

See all

i heard about this spot on tt and I'm glad I tried it. The food definitely is delicious, flavorful, and fresh. They have a bunch of innovative ways that they incorporate lobster on the menu which I really appreciated. The lobster burger was ahhhhhhhhhmazing. The beef was cooked perfectly. The lobster was cooked perfectly. Paired together it was like a surf and turf explosion on my tastebuds. I know that there's another location so I'd be interested to see how it matches up. I definitely recommend! read more

Went to celebrate my friend's birthday. I usually look up the menu before arriving but I didn't this time. I ordered a lobster roll with truffle fries. There was a decent amount of lobster in the sandwich. The bread was perfectly buttered and toasted. To drink I had a raspberry lavender fizz. It was very light and refreshing. The staff was very patient. It took me a while to decide on what I was going to order. Surprisingly for a Friday night, Jack's was not packed. We had a reservation. There was live music but it wasn't too loud where we were screaming to talk to each other. The outside seating area looks great for warm spring days and cool summer nights. I will definitely be back again to try more items on the menu. read more

See all

It was a sunny and warm day , so we sat outside. The waitress was attentive to us and was very friendly. The food was great. The Sangria was very good. Overall a great little place to have a nice Sunfay lunch. Definitely would go back and recommend this place. read more

Great food, attentive staff, so very full. Had the surf and turf burger served medium and it was perfect. Good char, hint of pink, on a burger big enough that I nearly had to unhinge my jaw. Absolutely no complaints other than needing to be rolled out in a wheelbarrow from being so full! Definitely on our short list. read more

Food was delicious! The mini lobster rolls, the mussels, seafood linguine in garlic sauce, the lobster Mac n cheese and the cognac amaretto rice pudding were excellent! Rest rest of the menu looks amazing as well! We'll be back! read more

See all

I had a real craving for lobster roll. Jack's did not disappoint. Wonderful lunch specials - I had a terrific Manhattan Clam chowder that was very flavorful, along with a lobster roll sandwich, home made chips and a Cole slaw which was a very good- a touch sweet. Very nice waitstaff in an informal but pleasant space. Well worth going here if you are in a nautical mood! read more

I got the hot lobster roll Connecticut style to trial. A little expensive for a sandwich but is tasty. It looked overflowing with lobster until you realized, the bread was not totally sliced to the edge- only a little over halfway. The chips are fresh cooked and well seasoned. I personally could use a lot more butter on my bread and lobster (that's just me). I like a little bread on my butter- lol. It is side street parking. The place is cute and inviting and at least I didn't come out smelling like a seafood place. Service was fast and friendly. read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - Take out Connecticut style lobster roll with chips. - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Every thing I tried was amazing. The lobster bisk hands down my favorite. The oysters were really fresh and delicious. The lobster po boy was delicious too They say it's BYOB, but they do serve wine. The cheesecake was delicious too The restaurant is nicely laid out, did wish the seats had cushions but that just me with my bad back. The waitress was polite and gave great recommendations, wish I could remember her name (Spanish lady with glasses) also her music playlist had my friend and I dancing in our seats..I almost got up and started dancing. I'm definitely coming back here. read more

1st time here and I had the lobster roll with platter with lite mayo and I did substitute the chips for french fries. The lobster roll was delicious and fresh. I will definitely be returning FYI they are byob so feel free to bring a bottle of wine read more

See all

Pretty good seafood place in an area lacking seafood offerings. Our dinner was ok yet some dishes arrived cold. Service is friendly yet very slow which could explain dishes arriving cold to your table. It's ok for a simple night out. read more

Wow!! One of the best experiences I've ever had catering for my film crew!! I spoke with Koko directly who was unbelievably kind and knowledgable, and went above and beyond to ensure my crew and I were happy and well-fed. Even when going to pickup the food, he helped me carry everything out to my vehicle as it was a large order. As aforementioned, I placed a large catering order on a Monday morning and Koko and the team made it happen! I discovered Jack's Surf and Turf at a recent event and saw online that they also had non-seafood options, as we had a few seafood allergies/aversions on set. When I called to place the order, Koko was super accommodating and assured me I could feed all of the crew with vegetarian and meat options--and I did! Everything was cooked and prepared to perfection. The tacos were FULL and loaded with flavor (we got chicken and beef), the salads and dressings were delicious, the coleslaw was (and I quote) "some of the best I've had" from some members in the crew, the sliders were gone in seconds, the mac & cheese was flavorful and creamy, and the chicken tenders and fries were a yummy combo. I found the personal touch of my name on all the "thank you" notes on the boxes such a lovely thing to do. Again: above and beyond! My only note for next time is maybe including a hearty vegan option, as I wasn't aware of any on the menu. However, everything else was fantastic and I was able to accommodate the vegan crew member with a salad and fry platter. I believe they're undergoing a rebrand to "Jack's Surf and Turf" and let me tell you right now, their "Turf" is just as incredible as their "Surf", so I'm in full support of this haha! Overall, I was blown away by the service, kindness, flavor, and value, and I don't write this kind of thing about just any place. If you're in the area or ever need to cater for an event, this is your place!! I'll be back! read more

See all

I came here a year and a half ago while I was in town for work. Came back to stay in Jersey while I visit the city on vacation and wanted to stop back in for a lobster roll. It's usually so quiet whenever I stop in and I don't know why. The food is fresh and tasty. Loved my lobster roll again tonight. Would come back again! read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - Lobster Roll Platter Shrimp Tacos - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Excellent food. Maybe the best lobster bisque I've had. Lobster rolls were also amazing; we had the lemon garlic and the Maine. Maine was slightly better. They were packed with meat. Mac n cheese bites were also great. Presentation, service, and vibe were all prime. Looking forward to coming back. read more

I'd give Jack's a 3.5 the food is good but picking up from here is always a mess. Every single time I'm standing and waiting. Very disorganized for take out. If it's not ready tell me the truth but don't say 5 more minutes and it becomes 20. The lobster rolls were good but lacking in the mayo on my recent trip and the fries were soggy. I'll give it another try but another experience like that and I'm done. read more

Nice place. We used to go one location in Weehawken, NJ once a year now we have one within 10 minutes away. They have almost same food. The food was great and server was nice. This place is larger than other place, too. Fresh lobster meat, roll was great. We had fried calms which were plentiful, tasty. I would go back again, now I have this place not too far away from home. I recommend this place for good seafood. read more

See all

Came for a lobster roll and some apps like the fried clam strips. Really friendly hostess and service right at the front who took our order to go. Tried the Joe's strawberry lemonade with my meal which was delicious. Everything was cooked perfectly, the lobster roll was full and not lacking any meat. Overall really great food read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

If you're wondering about coming here, the food is absolutely amazing. Crispy shrimp to start it off was amazing. Their strawberry lemonade was great. The customer service was 5 star. If you are thinking about coming I would recommend you come on a Friday night. Live music is the cherry on top. Beautiful music with 10 Strings and 4 Hands. 1000% recommend. read more

I stopped by for lunch on New Year's Eve 2021. Obviously omicron has made everyone less out-and-about. There was one table of dine-in customers and plenty of other available seating. Im sure this is at least part of the reason my dish came out in less than 10 minutes. I went with the cod sandwich on ciabatta. It's delicious fresh fish, just as advertised. But its breading was totally unnoticeable in both flavor and texture. Cole slaw in the sandwich added a needed crunch and carried a very sweet mayonnaise that is done well, although sweet mayo isn't to my liking. Thick ciabatta was the perfect vessel for holding a messy sandwich. The potato chips weren't good. No potato flavor, and short on crunch. I'd go with the fries next time, even with the $3 surcharge. Summit and Short Hills aren't exactly overflowing with fast casual seafood choices and this place is just down the street from Wine Library, so I'd be happy to go again when I'm in the area. read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - Beer Battered Cod Sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Been sick all week and decided to try some fresh seafood here, which turned out to be a disaster. The lobster bisque soup tasted like thick melted cheese. Order the Connecticut style lobster roll which had no butter but some sort of salmon color oil. The waiter was pouted face when taking the order and serving water, however appeared super excited to speak when they give the bill. read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - Lobster Bisque - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Had a delicious dinner here. The Connecticut rolls were DELICIOUS and had so much lobster meat. I also really enjoyed the crab cake, cooked to perfection and very tasty! Definitely will be back! read more

See all

I've been a patron at the Montclair and Edgewater locations, and I'm thrilled to have Jack's in my town. My Maine style lobster roll was terrific, fries good, coleslaw a tad dry-but nicely seasoned with caraway seeds. Pleasant staff, and there is usually no issue finding parking. read more

Food was so good I truly forgot to take a picture. That's how great it was. I have family that moved into this area so I'll be here a lot more often. Can't wait to try different things on the menu. We got food to go but the service during our take out experience was well welcomed, and the ambience is very welcoming read more

We are frequent customers of Jacks. Food and service is always great! They have Wednesday special for a whole lobster. They also sell wine (bottle or half bottle). read more

See all

Food was not good. I hate they advertise as Jacks Lobster Shack. It's very misleading. They don't inform you that they're not Jacks that use to be in Edgewater NJ. Don't be mislead. read more

Exactly what we were looking for on a nice summer night. Decently priced, great serving sizes. I have no complaints and can't wait to go back again! Service was great, too; they even checked on another table several times as a small bee was bothering them. Easy parking, too. read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - French Fries, Onion Rings, Connecticut style Lobster Roll. DELICIOUS. Bun was perfectly buttery and toasty. - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

See all

Unfotunately not a good experience at all. Placed an online order that was reported as ready, however when arrived six (6) individuals were waiting for their orders already past due. It was 45 minutes later my order was delivered. Though it was Fathers Day, for which the hotstess apologized as the excuse, there was less then a third of the tables occupied, and plenty of staff to serve. They stopped all on-line & delivery as soon as I entered, as the kitchen was overwhelmed, there was little if any management going on, mostly chaos as a number of people tried to come in to sit, but were turned away. The food here is good, but expensive for what you get, and there were misses like the grouper sandwich was over-cooked, extra charge for not enough Marinara with Calamari. Lobster Roll was more filler and mayo than Lobster. However, the Lobster Mac N Cheese was very good. read more

The shrimp was raw & lobster mac & cheese tasted funny. Me and my bf spend the night with food poisoning thanks to this place.

Decided to stop in and try Jacks since it isn't far from my office. I've already been to Montclair and Edgewater so wanted to see if Millburn lived up to the others. Gladly it did. Victor greeted us very warmly and sat us immediately. Our server, Lucy, was friendly and polite. We got lobster bisque, lobster rolls, and fried oysters. Everything was fresh and the food came out pretty quickly. Glad to report that the quality remains constant at all three locations. The spot here is nice and spacious. I think they also have an upstairs. This will not be the last time we stop in for lunch. It's been added to the list of local spots to go during lunch hours at work. Go check them out. ENJOY!!! read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

Surprisingly large restaurant with balcony. We sat outside, easy street parking. Our server was super friendly. We both ordered oysters and a chowder to start, all excellent. We both ended up getting lobster rolls. Nice portions with a $2. upcharge option for fries or onion rings. Nice addition to the hood. We'll be back! read more

See all

Jonesing for an authentic lobster roll since Bar Harbour, we checked out this place. We smiled when we noticed that the place was decorated with colourful bouys and paintings of lighthouses. This felt promising. I ordered the warm lobster roll in a toasted bun. Although it was Connecticut style, it brought back the taste of Maine. That's how you do Lobster Roll. I paired it with Maine Rootbeer on the rocks. Excellent! I could just leave at that point. But no, we must dessert. I opted for the Three Berries Pie, cos I knew there would be blueberries in it. It had some notes of mild tartness and just the right sweetness. And then we left. Happy and Satiated. The wait staff was very polite and attentive. Lucky to have found Jack. read more

See all

The place is always exceptional. Guilty pleasure eating of seafood, lobster rolls and don't sleep on the chicken fingers and fries! It should always be crowded. Service is always welcoming as well read more

LOBSTER ROLL, CONNECTICUT STYLE: Lobster had too much seasoning. If I ordered double meat, which was an option on the menu, It would cost exactly twice as much; ie, I would have gotten screwed out of the bun. Better to order two "rolls". Meat, even with the butter, was very dry. FISH N CHIPS was more like "fish fingers" which was also dry. The CHIPS, it came with were from (my pet peeve) frozen potatoes; not fresh. I did appreciate the CLAM STRIPS appetizer at $11 as they were crispy and tasty but a little oily. I would definitly consider going back for a double portion of these and bring a beer. read more

Jack’s Surf & Turf - Seafood Near Me - Millburn, New Jersey

So we ordered take out and the lobster was dry/overcooked and tasteless. Just a warning. I was so disappointed.