Really solid four stars for me here. It prob would be a little higher if I could give 1/4 or 1/2 more. I have been twice, once for lunch and once for dinner. Lunch: chicken sandwich with a side salad. Dinner: Scallops were good - not great, but very good. My colleagues had steak and they said it was excellent, and one had a crab cake too and liked it a lot. Classy decor/ ambiance and good service. read more

I have eaten here twice- once for a dine in experience and the other was take out. Our service was excellent each time. I am a vegetarian, but my boyfriend said that Wagyu Burger was the best burger he had ever had. The steak he got the second time was "the best steak I've ever tasted in my life." He was literally able to pull the meat apart with this fingers because it was so tender. On our to go order the burger we ordered was extremely rare which we didn't know until we got home, but I called back up there and Trip was very respectful, extending an invite for us to come back in and get another. Overall I highly recommend eating here for a night out! read more

If I want a casual meal with an upscale feeling, I always consider this place. The quality of the food and drinks is always on point. There were a few times the service wasn't a 10/10, but the food made up for it. They have an impressive wine list and a pretty decent happy hour as well. Be sure to try the creamed corn with burgers bacon. OMG... Out of this world. I could eat that forever. It's ok for kids, but I would say it's more appropriate for adults or couples. You forget you're by a mall in the nice atmosphere. This is a must try if you're in the area or want some quality food after shopping. read more

J Gilbert's - Happy Hour Menu - Seafood Near Me - Des Pers, Missouri

Very unexpected sunrise. Fabulous food wonderful service and really great value too! They got me here with a coupon for my birthday and I will definitely be back read more

Subpar service, dried out medium well steak and just overall mediocre. I decided on a weekday date night with my wife, I ordered the 10 oz steak with lobster Mac and cheese and creamed corn. The waiter brings out after a long wait, a dried out inedible steak, potatoes au gratin and creamed corn. I could only manage to eat 1/3 of the steak and none of the sides, the waiter takes my food, boxes it up and brings it back to sit it on the floor. Complete waste of a date night and $100.00. read more

I had the pleasure to meet a amazing waitress named Sarah. She made my experience here so delightful. She was very knowledgeable about menu. Any question I had she took her time to explain them and her suggestion was dead on when I've tried the items. I hate I didn't get any pictures of my plate. However, other staff was very attentive as well. I like how manger Chris took his time out check and greet us. P.s please order the pineapple martini read more

I would officially give J Gilberts a 4 1/2 star, not a 4. After a somewhat disappointing food weekend in NYC, I was brought full circle with the dinner at this new steakhouse in STL. The decor is perfect for a steakhouse with the dark brown wood, fire place, plush booths and exposed floor to ceiling wine cellar. All of the staff was extremely attentive and it was nice to see Winged Nut by Urban Chestnut on tap. They had a very nice beer menu to accompany the wine list. I went with a party of 4 on my actual birthday and literally heard every single person rave about the appetizer and their entrees. We started with what I am guessing is their specialty app, hand cut chips smothered in a blue cheese/mayfair dressing. Absolutely delicious and the right amount to snack on before the meal. Between the four of us we ordered a KC Strip (me), bone-in pork chop, prince georges scallop dish and crab cakes. The steak was cooked a perfect medium rare and had just the right amount of fat. The pork chop may have been better, hard to say, because they were both so good. For a steakhouse, I really liked the bite of scallop with berblanc sauce. The crab cakes were seared with very little breading, almost all crab. After some very fancy dinners over the weekend that didn't quite live up, it was awesome to see everyone so excited about their meal. The only reason they do not get a 5 is because the Creme Brulee was underdone. It still tasted good and you could tell it would have been awesome if left to bake for a few more minutes. Overall, I am excited to go back and think it is worth the price (which is very reasonable). We finally have another great steakhouse in town that includes sides and is not way over the top. Cheers. read more

Glad we gave them a second chance: Our first visit was disappointing, however after several months we returned and they redeemed themselves. Our food and service was outstanding. Our table ordered and shared tastes of ribeye, pork chop, and halibut. Each were cooked perfectly and had mouth watering flavor. The shrimp cocktail for both visits had jumbo shrimp that tasted like I was eating them beachside. But truly, the crab cakes outdid themselves with tasty large bites of real crab. I will definitely return and order those again. I happily upgraded this review from a 3 to 4+. They previously only earned a 3 because last time the shrimp cocktail appetizer was the only food that was really good. That day the steak was dry, the potato wasn't warm enough to melt the butter and the tiny Alaskan King crab was...barely there. We should have spoke up that day. Their management was quick to reply to my post and I'm sure would have served us new plates that day if we had said something. I did not plan to return even though I liked the atmosphere (chic with a nice framed fireplace). However, friends that had a good dining experience here previously convinced us to try again. Our second experience was redemption. Specifically, the crab cakes and pork chop was a rare treat! I'm slightly allergic to pork, so I couldn't order a whole entree, but the bite I had was worth it. read more

I did respond to the business but it's been over a week and they chose not to reply to my email. . I was impressed that they cared enough to respond but I'm terribly disappointed that they decided not to reach out. read more

J. Gilbert's Restaurant is our go-to destination for special occasions, and anytime we want The best crab cakes, scallops, steaks, and side dishes in St. Louis. Their crab cakes must be 95% crab, I'm not kidding. The large chunks of crab that they use use are very fresh, tender, and sweet. My favorite side dishes are their amazing au gratin potatoes served sizzling with a wonderful crust in a cast-iron skillet, and their amazing wild mushrooms in truffle butter. I cannot mention one bad experience from many visits to this beautifully conceived, and immaculately managed restaurant. Every single waiter we have had has been polite, friendly, well-mannered, fast, professional and warm. The decor is modern yet opulent. Picture Manhattan penthouse meets country club. You will taste flavors here that you will not at any other restaurant in St. Louis. read more

J Gilbert is a great Steakhouse! I look forward to going to this restaurant every time! The service is great and the food is equally wonderful. Our waiter was very knowledgeable about the menu. In fact, everything sounded so good that we let him surprise us with one of the sides, and we are glad we did, the zucchini bake ( not something I would have choose) was amazing! Next time you go to J Gilberts ask for Derek and enjoy your evening! read more

J Gilbert's - I think its safe to say J Gilbert is now my birthday dinner spot! The food is so amazing and the service is great ask for Derek! - Seafood Near Me - Des Pers, Missouri

We go to this restaurant at least 6 times a year. They never disappoint. Steak is done topnotch, seafood fresh and tasty. Even the sides are divine. Service is awesome, as always. We had a server named Jeff tonight, what a personable and fun person. Order the Filet Oscar one of our faves. Would recommend this place anytime! read more

This restaurant used to be good. We had a table of six last night. Service was lousy. Had to ask multiple times for our drinks. Had to ask for bread. Waited a long time for dinner. I had the special seasonal salmon and it was so small and thin and was terrible. Other tables around us were complaining too. Our bill was $437 without tip. Not going back. read more

I wanted NOT to like this place. It's "in" a mall. It's a chain (owned by Houlihan's). The prices rival many fine-dining restaurants. But, it's just that good. I got the cheap flat-iron steak with fries for an early dinner. Swapped sweet potato fries with real ones -- no problem. My typical lower quality flat iron steak would put up a good fight to any backyard grilled ribeye you could throw at it. Top it with acho chile / garlic butter; and, you lose. Add your name and email to their list to get a $25 gift cert on your birthday and anniversary. I'll be back. read more

What a great experience. Our service was the best we've had in ages. Sara is fantastic, kind, and such a pleasure to meet and work with. The food was great and we had a great night. read more

This restaurant was recommended by a friend. I checked out their website and signed up for their email club. After receiving a $25 discount we decided to try it. We made a reservation for 8pm on Friday night and it really wasn't necessary. The restaurant was maybe half full when we arrived. Nice ambiance and music. Typical dark wood steak house. There is a nice patio area but it is located next to the mall entrance. Our server was very friendly and we ordered a drink while we scanned the menu. Drinks were tasty and the top shelf alcohol drove the prices a little high. My husband and I both decided on the filet combos. He chose a crab cake and I chose the scallops. The food arrived in a timely manner and it was hot. The crab cake was large with nice solid chunks of lump crab. I was surprised to see the scallops were the size of quarters and maybe an inch thick. Although small, they were sweet and cooked well. The sides were pablano au gratin potatoes, Sriracha carrots, Yukon mashed and asparagus. They all tasted fine but nothing stood out as amazing. Run of the mill flavor and the veggies were not bright or fresh looking. The steaks were cooked perfectly (just a little under medium) but there was a hard char on one side. What should have been the star of the plate ended up ruining the taste of everything. There was so much seasoning on the steak that it had burned and gave the steak an extremely salty, bitter taste that overpowered everything on the plate. I know that salt is an essential part of cooking a steak but this was just too much for my taste. I guess if it weren't for the price I probably would give this restaurant a higher rating. I expect much more from the food when I have a tab of $125 (+ tax and tip) for 2 cocktails and 2 entrees. I could think of a dozen other restaurants in the St Louis area that serve that same meal for less with much better quality. There are better options out there than this mall restaurant. Seek them out! read more

We stopped in for a quick lunch after a morning of shopping and was very surprised...known for steaks and seafood but their burgers, chips or sweet potato fries were delicious. Staff was very friendly and attentive. read more

It was a pretty good steak. Nothing to write home about. The problem is, it's in a weird place from a price point. Not as good as the Fleming's of the world, but for an additional $20 per person you could just go to somewhere like Fleming's. read more

I love this place and we come here often. Great atmosphere, excellent service and the food always exceeds my expectations. I almost always end up getting the filet mignon, asparagus and green beans. But last night I went with their specialty mixed seafood grill - which was an amazing deal. Two jumbo shrimp and a mussel skewer, a 4 oz lump crab cake with creole remoulade sauce, and a 4 oz grilled Atlantic salmon filet with mango tartar over mashed potatoes and asparagus w/balsamic reduction and tomato relish. YUM. I have never been so full. read more

From the minute we arrived the staff at J. Gilbert's made both me and my friend who was also celebrating her birthday feel extra special. The service was wonderful, we had the best waiter who made sure we were enjoying ourselves. The food, as usual, was wonderful... right down to the complimentary dessert!! The coconut cake with pineapple ice cream was seriously amazing! Warning - watch out for their bread. Once you start eating it it's hard to stop! If you're celebrating a special day, this is the place to go! read more

Its a chain but it's a big, dark cave of a restaurant / bar which works for me. Cool & dark in the scorching summer, warm & cozy when it's cold out. On the perimeter of West County Mall (next to McCormick & Schmidt's) you might not know it's there unless you're looking for it, which is a shame. The bar area is buzzy & has ample seating with booths, large booths, bar top & a few seats in the waiting/lounge area. The restaurant is large-ish with generous & smaller perimeter booths & center tables. However, the low light, dark wood & large back wall gas fire keep it feeling cozy & warm. J Gilbert's isn't cheap, but the filet steaks are heavenly as are the lump crab cakes. Dont be fooled by some modest appearing portion sizes because everything I've had has been rich and more than satisfying. The wine list is decent with a few nice ones that won't break the bank. Add friendly servers to the mix and JGilberts has become a regular for me. In the 8-10 happy hour and/or meals I've had there this year, I've never had anything but a great time. Although it's buzzy early, the restaurant & bar clear out surprisingly early in my opinion. Although we've never felt rushed by the staff to wind it up, I've gotten up from weekend dinner at 10pm only to notice that the restaurant has emptied around us. It's almost as if they have one seating (7:30-9:30) instead of 2-3 per night. It just seems strange that it clears out so early as it's comfy enough to hangout for a few after dinner drinks in. Definitely worth checking out if you need to hunker down somewhere dark & cozy with a glass of cab & a steak. A little overlooked IMHO. read more

The place is always good. I usually get whatever the fish special of the day is. I have never had a bad meal here. It might be in a mall but you would never know. Great service food and atmosphere. Perfect for a date night. read more

My husband and I have had many successful experiences with j Gilbert's . Very fond of the ribeyes and they send out nice invitations to several upcoming events. Pleasant environment. Love the comfortable booths near the fireplace. read more

Once again we had a great experience here! The food is so good. And Megan did an outstanding job. Couldn't ask for a better evening. The steaks came out perfect the carrots where amazing and where the sautéed mushroom. Definitely one of my favorite places to visit. read more

This is a great place to eat with family or friends. The restaurant is very attractive and they have a menu that should satisfy everyone. The only drawback is that were obvious: The restaurant is poorly lit which makes the menus difficult to read. And the wine list, while extensive, is overpriced for offering very common wines which could be purchased at Walgreens. read more

This place has a very classy, modern feel to it. Service and ambience is great for date night as well as for a family night out. They have a great selection of menu for seafood and steaks as well as yummy appetizers. We ordered the lump crab cakes for appetizers. They were bomb. So moist and crisp. We also ordered a filet and salmon with a side of cremated corn and asparagus. I ordered the wash burger with a side of fries. I loved everything in the entrees. The filet and salmon were fresh off the grill and tasted amazing. The cremed corn was probably the highlight of the menu and I will have it over and over again every time I go there. The burger was juicy and tender, and the fries were fresh and crisp. Overall, we had a great experience at the restaurant and would definitely recommend going here. I don't think you can really go wrong with anything on the menu. read more

J Gilbert's - Seafood Near Me - Des Pers, Missouri

See all

What a great dinner experience. We all had steaks and all were prepared just as ordered. I had a Porterhouse. It was outstanding, cooked perfectly and it was as tender and flavorful as could be. Our service was spot on, friendly and always around when we needed him. Kenneth was simply great! Trip stopped by to check in on us as well. Great to see him. read more

Decided to stop in at J. Gilbert's today and utilize the birthday offer that I receive once a year. My friend and I went in as lunch was ending. Unbeknownst to us, we were unaware that they close to change to the dinner shift. We were seated promptly and greeted by our waitress who was nice, personable and attentive. We both ordered the 6 ounce filet medium. The steak was well seasoned and cooked perfectly. The Yukon mashed potatoes were plentiful. The verdict is still out on the lobster Mac and Cheese (up-charge). Seems like it was missing something as the consistency was watery which was odd since Mac and Cheese is normally a hearty dish. Being that I was celebrating my birthday it would've been nice to have been offered dessert options. I probably didn't need it anyway. Nevertheless, I always enjoy J. Gilbert's. I simply wish that we could have ordered from the dinner menu and a sweet treat would have been nice ending to a decent meal. read more

Super good! I got the Petite Filet combo with the scallops and it was good! Our server, Sam, was nice and knew a lot. I'd recommend! read more

J Gilbert's - Seafood Near Me - Des Pers, Missouri

Always a treat, drinks, service and food tops. Trip is the best leader since they opened. He's hands on and very professional make it feel like a private high end club. read more

Disappointing -- My husband & I chose this restaurant on a Friday night because it was near our home and we both really wanted a steak along with a nice dinner out after he had a tough work week. The atmosphere was certainly lovely and the bread served while we waited for our food was good, but that's where my compliments end. We each ordered sirloin, medium well. My husband's steak was cooked correctly, but mine was medium, not medium well; both were very dry. The vegetables were kind of mediocre in terms of taste and my husband ordered "carrots," plural. He received one strip of a carrot and some other vegetables he didn't really want. We're not the type of people to be fussy or send food back unless we feel it's unsafe to eat. (There are simply too many people starving to have any other attitude.) We ate what was served to us, but honestly, the chicken tenders & fries served to our two small children were better than our adult entrees. The service was "ok." For the price, we expected the food to taste really good & the service to be top notch. We definitely didn't get what we paid for and are unlikely to return. Updated to say: I only noticed recently (in 2020) that J. Gilbert's staff reached out to me to try to resolve the situation. I responded just to tell them "thanks" and the team invited us back to try to provide us with a more positive experience. Unfortunately, we live too far away now for that to be a possibility, but I appreciate that they did show they care about our experience. read more

Love the vibe of this place! Everything from my drink to my service was amazing. The lobster Mac is my absolute favorite! They did an amazing job on my lemon drop with Hennessy always an option for a good steak. read more

Fantastic all around the Lamb Rack is top notch! Cold shellfish platter is awesome! My new favorite restaurant. Been there 4 times and perfect every time! read more

Another great dinner at J Gilbert's! The wedge salad is a classic that they do very well, and the warm bread is always a hit with everyone. I started with a Cosmo and my husband had a Manhattan -- both great! My husband had the ribeye with baked potato and spinach; I had the NY Strip with the amazing scalloped potatoes, and asparagus, and my teen always enjoys the streak frites. The food was great, as always, our waiter, Kyle, was wonderful, and the atmosphere was pretty alive for an 8:30pm dinner in St Louis. Love the fire feature along the wall and the cozy atmosphere. Convenient if you are shopping at the mall, but a destination steakhouse in its own right, as well. read more

Took a friend for his birthday and we cannot wait to go back! Our wine was delicious and a great price for a 2011 bottle, appetizers were incredible. He got the Cajun rubbed filet and it was perfect! I got the scallops with lobster risotto and it was also just to die for! Joseph was our server and he was probably the best part of our experience!! When we go back we will definitely be asking for him! Thank you for an amazing time, Joseph! See you again soon!! read more

All time fav steak and crab cake place. The only place I give 6 stars to. Service and consistency is rated high by me!! Will be going for my bday every year!! read more

TERRIBLE, AWFUL service. We were ignored, never had water, had to ask for table to be cleared, waiters changed mid service and no one ever told us. I can't say enough how bad this place is. WILL NEVER GO BACK OR RECOMMEND TO SOMEONE. read more

I took my beautiful wife to J Gilbert's for our 25th engagement anniversary on Valentine's Day. I wanted to make it extra special for her since I planned on re-proposing and presenting her with a new diamond ring...the whole works. The staff at J. Gilbert's made everything happen for me. Brandon Prange, the manager, went out of his way to help me coordinate everything I wanted to do to make the event special...even when I wanted to sneak my guitar in and sing the song I wrote for my wife right there in front of everyone in the restaurant! He worked with Tripp Anway, the general manager to make this happen. He helped create the plan down to the details of where we would be sitting and what direction my wife should sit so that I could sneak out the side door at the right time to get the guitar. Everything went like clockwork with the help of all the staff and especially our wonderful waitress Nikki, who took care of us like we were royalty. She helped me coordinate the whole surprise that night...and it was unbelievable. The crowd was super supportive and cheered loudly when I got down on my knee, proposed and presented her with the ring (she said yes, of course!). They cheered more when they brought me the guitar and I sang her song. It was one of the most memorable evenings we have ever spent, and J. Gilbert's made it happen. But...it is not only the people that make this place special...the atmosphere and the food are top notch. Our filets were cooked to perfection, the drinks are wonderful, the timing of everything is excellent, the wait staff is amazing...and the patrons are equally gracious. All in all this is one of the best restaurants in the St. Louis area. Great food, great people, great everything. A+!!!!! read more

One of the best filets I have ever had. I ordered mine meduim and came out medium rare but still good. My wife's steak was ordered medium and it was medium well. No one ever ask if our steaks we're right. Waiter was nice but not as refined as I would expect in a high dollar restaurant. I thought prices were too higher than an equal quality restaurant. read more

This was our first trip and is awesome! You can see from the pics we had the ribeye and pork chop with risotto and potatoes and spinach and asparagus! Everything was perfect except the flies that wanted some too! Install some fans on the patio please! We'll definitely be back! Big 4 for us!!! read more

J Gilbert's - Seafood Near Me - Des Pers, Missouri

See all