Ithaca Bakery

Caught this little shop out of the corner of my eye (I have an eye for sweets, lol) and stopped in…read moreafter lunch. Super sad they didn't have cupcakes but I did get a slice of chocolate cake and I'm SO glad I did. Great flavor and very moist. I was pleasantly surprised and impressed. I'll stop in again to check for cupcakes ;)

Cake products are GREAT here! My favorite thing on their menu is the cheesecake, stepped out of my…read morecomfort zone to get a cupcake and a slice of cake and was not disappointed! The food went from behind the glass to my belly quickly. Cute cafe with coffee right in the commons! 10/10 bakery, check it out! Bon appétit

Cheesecake with walnut crust and cherries

See all

A Big Slice of Our Awesome Carrot Cake w/Cream Cheese Frosting

Paris Baguette

4.1(58 reviews)

0.6 mi

Wonderful treats! Pastries and coffee are top notch. Wish we had this at home!! Can hardly wait…read moreto visit again!

Stopped in to check it out. Sweet smell of pastries filled the air. Very bright and clean…read moreatmosphere. Several glass cabinets hold sections of pastries, cakes, donuts that you help yourself to. They also had an area with snacks and sandwiches. Had just eaten a big lunch and had no room to try anything. For sure will be back and try an array of items.

See all

Hound and Mare

4.4(99 reviews)

0.7 mi

I'm going to dream about the Melrose breakfast sandwich months from now as well as their dirty chai…read morelatte. Don't judge me. This is a place that will spoil other establishments for you. We originally came here because we saw they have gluten-free bagels. And we need someplace to eat safely because of celiac. They made their OG breakfast bagel with a gluten-free one and it was a complete hit with my teen. So much so that we had to come back the next day as well. No complaints from me on doing that.

Stopped by Hound and Mare for breakfast on a busy Monday morning. A little bit of a wait but not…read moretoo bad. Had the Melrose sandwich and a Chocolate Donut - both were pretty good. The Lavender Latte (had it iced) was also very good.

Menu projected on the wall!

Avocado toast

See all

Front door 10/24:24

Sinfully Delicious Baking Co.

4.6(20 reviews)

0.4 mi

My first order from Racquel was back to 2019. Since then, I've ordered birthday cakes/cupcakes each…read moreyear for my two children who studied in Cornell. Racquel's cake is delicious and designed with a true artist's touch. She's very easy to talk to when I wanted to customize it. Her ordering process is also very straightforward, getting back to me quickly after the online form is submitted. We are from Texas. Racquel's business is truly a blessing to families like us and helps us to stay close to the important days with our children when they are thousands of miles away from home. Thank You Racquel for all the beautiful cakes and moments. I highly recommend this business!

We got our wedding cake and cupcakes from Sinfully Delicious and they were stunning and delectable!…read moreRaquel was great to work with as we nailed down our flavors and numbers, and multiple guests told us that this was the best dessert they'd ever had at a wedding. Our cake was cardamom sponge with lemon curd and lemon meringue buttercream, and my spouse, who has very high standards for baked goods, said that they could not have imagined having a better cake. Truly a fantastic experience.

See all

Mama Said Hand Pies

4.4(32 reviews)

Mama Said Hand Pies | Ithaca, NY…read more One of my favorite local food spots in Upstate New York near Cornell University! Mama Said Hand Pies is a cozy local spot in Ithaca serving handmade savory and sweet pies made with locally sourced ingredients and baked fresh daily. Sausage Gravy, Egg & Cheddar Pie (Recommend ) Filled with chicken sausage gravy, scrambled eggs, and white cheddar wrapped in an incredibly flaky, buttery pastry crust. The crust had a rich buttery flavor without feeling greasy, and the savory filling made every bite so comforting. Mushroom Pie (Recommend ) Packed with sautéed mushrooms and served with a green sauce on the side. Honestly, I didn't even need the sauce because the pie was already flavorful on its own. Pepper Jack Beef Pie Filled with ground beef, pepper jack cheese, and curry-like spices. This one wasn't my personal favorite, but my husband really enjoyed it!

Tried these at the farmer's market! Very yummy!…read more We tried the blueberry one with lemon icing and the spanakopita. The blueberry one was piping hot. Honestly these were both really good. the crust wasn't soggy and I liked trying both a sweet and a savory hand pie. I have also tried the mushroom oaxaca one which is my favorite! Overall, I would recommend!

Vegan knish

Sign out front

See all

Blueberry w lemon icing

Alley Cat Cafe

4.4(56 reviews)

Went here with my parent and had an amazing experience here! We booked our spots online (highly…read morerecommend you do that before coming in) to see the cats for one hour, at the cost of 10 dollars. (They charge 5 dollars for every 30 minutes.) We paid at the front, and the worker guided us to the car rooms and made sure we signed in and sanitized our hands first before entering. The cats seem to be decently well-cared for. Some were lively, others seemed lazy, but overall they appeared to be in good health and spirits. They were also very interactive. The moment the two of us stepped into the rooms, the cats immediately came over to us and played. I unfortunately forgot to try out the food/drinks at this place, so I cannot say anything about those... but overall, a great experience!

They have several gluten free OR dairy free options for pastries, and one that is both! So hard to…read morefind!! The lunch menu is very accommodating to food allergies too. Great coffee, cute and interesting local merch, cute and cozy aesthetic, and the cats!! Such a great way to get a feel for cats as a future pet, especially for those unfamiliar with the quirks of cats. It's also just good animal therapy. Go hang out, support a local business, and get some nuzzles from a new furry friend! Oh and the owner is so kind!! Great service every time.

See all

Moosewood Restaurant

3.4(647 reviews)

Moosewood was like the main place everyone said to try, both in person, and from online searches…read morefor Ithaca. We both actually love vegan-inspired restaurants so we happily made a reservation and came to celebrate a new job while on a girl's trip. Parking was a bit of a hassle for us having arrived in town after dark and not knowing the area. We eventually found some parking on the street about 2-3 blocks away but it looked highly sketchy and walking back around 9:30 pm seemed sus. The restaurant is smaller than expected but cozy and our server was great. My friend has a soy allergy so, it limited what she could have from the menu a bit but this is what we had: -Elote Corn Hummus - 10/10 - soooo good -Veggie Lasagna for my friend - loaded with eggplant which she loves -Green Curry for me - spicy! But good. Loads of cauliflower. I had a coffee with cream and sugar for dessert and they feature the local Gimme Coffee brand which was strong and delicious with some creamer in it. My friend had the Peach Cheesecake and loved it. I did try it and it was tart, fresh, and the crust was A+. Loved this meal - it's highly expensive for vegetarian but we knew that going in. It was fun to have a fine dining feeling with a vegetarian twist. Worth it!

We booked a table for Thursday night and were seated right away -- even had our pick of sitting…read moreinside or out on the patio. A glass of Pét-Nat from Osmote made for a great start; I'm a huge fan of this winery. Service was decent, and the food came out impressively fast. The patio was lovely, if a touch noisy thanks to the busy street nearby. We shared the broccoli to start, and it didn't disappoint. Naturally, the Thai Green Curry was a must-try -- and a good call it was. Only downside: the portions ran on the small side.

Entry from street

Vegan Apple Pear Crumble

See all

Entry gift shop area

Press Cafe

4.0(52 reviews)

A cute spot in downtown Ithaca for coffee! My fav coffee spot in Ithaca!…read more We tried the rose matcha w oat milk & chocolate orange latte w almond milk. I preferred the chocolate orange latte- neither the chocolate nor the orange flavors overpowered the other. Delicious! I also liked the rose matcha- more of a subtle rose flavor. One complaint is that I wish they had skim milk. They also have charging ports and wifi which is nice if you want to work here. Lots of natural light but not much seating.

They have a pretty creative menu! I had their rose cappuccino with raspberry foam, it was really…read moregood!! Their espresso shots were pulled well and the flavoring is really good.

Cortado

See all

Menu and espresso machine

Collegetown Bagels

3.4(166 reviews)

0.7 mi

I had 3 meals here in 72 hours. Granted 2 were breakfast but I'd go again…read more Everything bagel breakfast sandwiches and coffee drinks were great. They were made to order so be prepared to wait just a little bit. Staff is professional yet friendly. Also picked up a gingerbread cookie for the plane ride home. So glad I did.

Stopped by the downtown location of this popular restaurant for a late breakfast…read more Had a Cinnamon Raisin Bagel and a Pizza Bagel and they were fine. Friendly service, a bit of a wait.

See more unrecommended reviews

Long Island wheat bagel with jalapeño cream cheese

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

32 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Nicholas M.

6 months ago

I recently visited Ithaca Bakery and had an excellent experience. The atmosphere inside is very clean, welcoming, and comfortable, which made it a great place to grab a quick meal. One thing that really stood out to me was the menu. It's displayed in a simple, chalkboard-style format that's incredibly easy to read and well organized. Honestly, it's one of the best-designed menus I've seen. It keeps things clear without being overwhelming. As someone who has to eat gluten-free, I was really impressed with their options. The gluten-free bread was easily the best I've had anywhere. I ordered a gluten-free sandwich along with a juice, and everything tasted fresh and high quality, especially for the price. The staff were also very friendly and helpful, which made the whole experience even better. Overall, I had a great visit and will absolutely be coming back. Highly recommend, especially if you're looking for good gluten-free options! read more

JohnnDiane C.

10 years ago

Too much hype over not much. My coworker loves the place so I'll go but I think the food is overpriced. The baked goods are not good at all. Maybe the bagels but everything else is terrible, dry and bland. I've had muffins that I fed to the birds because they were so bad. It's a trendy place that everyone in Ithaca thinks they have to love but they really don't. Just afraid to say so.. lol If you want healthy, great lunch food go to Wegmans. IB is not worth the crowds. read more

ReMax I.

12 years ago

So many options and never enough time! Our office is super close so we order here often. The soups are always incredible. The Danby Revisited sandwich is simple in a parsley garlic sort of way, but so fresh and filling that 2 of us usually split it! And then there are the GIANT cookies! Hello! Mmmm! read more

Sam L.

201

132

348

12 years ago

Lots of variety here so you are bound to pick something incredible. I had the New Yorker which is a Pastrami sandwich with coleslaw. We went on one of the busiest weekends and they pumped out the food fairly quick. The outdoor seating is nice on warms days. I'd come back if ever in the area again. read more

Richard M.

10 years ago

Bring the old Ithaca bakery back I loved the old one the new bakery I hate it won't ever go back rember when I was a kid going to the green and white building they us to be in and gram would get us half moon cookies now this place I hate it not like it was I loved it 30 years ago read more

Ellen R.

12 years ago

It's a must if you're visiting Ithaca. It's a landmark really. Not fast food, not big box junk. Delicious homemade food. Great soups and the sandwich selection is unreal. They bake their own bread that available to take home. We always get a few loafs and freeze them! read more

David B.

8 years ago

Iced coffee means I can do my job! Friendly and courteous staff that has learned my name and always knows what I want before I even say it. If you are what you eat, then I am coffee. read more

Maria K.

8 years ago

Not impressed with the food. A little on the expensive side. Also we tried to get a cake from them but the selections were very limited...

Theresa B.

9 years ago

Amazing So much to choose from, everything is delicious. Staff very friendly. They have so much to choose from and prices are reasonable read more

Marie B.

9 years ago

Delicious and fresh! I would go to this place every day if I could!! Cannot go wrong with any of your meal choices

Ashley M.

4 years ago

Really great selection for lunch, I ordered out for a group and everyone was very happy with what they ordered.

gable e.

10 years ago

Really tasty, but small portions for the price. Other than that, would be 5 star experience.

A M.

8 years ago

Great for a quick breakfast sandwich and coffee. Sometimes they have music in the evenings.

Heather H.

6 years ago

Very nice and clean . Frosted cookies were very good would stop again when in that area

Mandy P.

13 years ago

Great food - a little pricey and the place is always packed on weekends.

Patrick H.

7 years ago

Decently a college town Bakery but very good coffee and awesome staff

Kate T.

14 years ago

Yum!! For a guaranteed delicious lunch get the Milanese sandwich!

Peter L.

14 years ago

Good breakfast environment. Recommend their oatmeal and bagels.

A K.

4 years ago

Great muffins, their fresh pumpkin muffins are to die for

Wendy K.

13 years ago

The back goods are amazing!!! I had an awesome breakfast.

Ithaca Bakery - delis - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Ithaca Bakery also viewed

Cafe Dewitt

3.7

(153 reviews)

Nice overall diner with an old school vibe good food, and decent service!…read more The French toast special was outstanding

Located in the middle of the DeWitt Mall, the cafe features uneven flooring, a bathroom key on a…read moresoup laddle, fish tanks with goldfish and guppies, yes, quite good food. They have a handful of staff and what looks like a tiny kitchen. Even so, they are very warm and welcoming. Since the Carriage House on Stewart Avenue has been long closed, I decided to get the cafe's French Toast. It came out nice and hot, sprinkled with powdered sugar, and a side of maple syrup and butter. The crisp exterior gave way to a moist fluffy eggy interior. Much yum. Bonus points: they can also offer French toast in a gluten free variation. My wife opted for the Potato Pile, which was a plate with a pile of potatoes, dressed, along with their homemade kimchi, and eggs. The potatoes were great. The cafe partners with local farms to serve up great produce.

Dolce Delight

4.5

(153 reviews)

Delicious food. Great service. Nice staff. Will go back again. Pastries looked amazing.read more

This place was hard to find but cute. Its right on the corner, but no sign. We went to their…read moreneighbor first. Tried a couple of breakfast sandwiches. I got the Joey special on a croissant. It had fried egg, bacon, sausage and cheese. It was a lot with bacon and sausage, but good. Husband got the Entourage with eggs, bacon, cheese, avocado and some spread. He loved it. He tried a muffin and i had a peanut butter cookie. All was delicious. Service was friendly but a little slow.

Hound and Mare

4.4

(99 reviews)

Paris Baguette

4.1

(58 reviews)

Wonderful treats! Pastries and coffee are top notch. Wish we had this at home!! Can hardly wait…read moreto visit again!

Creekside Cafe Trumansburg

4.8

(65 reviews)

It is an old school mom and pop restaurant. The place is filled with warmth and it is reflected in…read morethe food and the service! The owner is a lady and her two daughters and close friend manage the kitchen and cash register. They mentioned they buy fresh vegetables and do not frozen stuff. We got the avacado toast, french toast, breakfast burrito and egg white omelette. Made fresh, good portion sizes and serves healthy and delicious breakfast.

Great breakfast sandwiches with some variety! The baked goods also looked delicious although I was…read moretoo full to try one. Cute little corner shop along rhe creek with limited indoor seating.

Coal Yard Cafe

4.2

(149 reviews)

To start the breakfast croissant sandwich I got was was AMAZING ! The bacon was the best part but…read morelike all of it was so so so good. The place is really cute but pretty small, it was crowded when I went but our food and drinks came out incredibly quickly so I was satisfied.

A solid spot for brunch in Ithaca!…read more I wish it was located a tad closer to c-town, but when the weather is warm it is actually quite a nice walk (still definitely walkable even in the winter)! We tried the breakfast croissant, the breakfast burrito, and crepes. We also ordered a hot Razz Mocha and an iced matcha (both with oat milk). I wish they had more milk varieties (only had whole and oat). Everything except the matcha was super tasty! I really loved the razz mocha- I will definitely be ordering this again. The crepes were my favorite entree- slightly thicker than your typical crepe, more of a chew. Nonetheless, very yummy. I like the berry compote and whipped cream. I enjoyed the croissant sandwich- ours had lox and egg. Too much egg, but perhaps the right amount of egg if you just want an egg sandwich without meat... Burrito was fine, though a tad watery. There was a bit of a line when we came- Saturday around noon and not much seating. We took our food to-go. Better to come when the weather is warmer- there is more seating under the tend in the back. Have heard mixed things about their other dishes, but I will definitely be returning!

Allechant

4.4

(56 reviews)

recently hosted a dinner party at Allechant in Ithaca, NY, for my daughter's bridal shower weekend…read more At the website it asks that parties over 8 please call, that it may be necessary to rent out the entire restaurant. Allechant is a small owner/chef run French Restaurant. They are only open for dinner Thursday-Sunday evenings and for brunch on Saturday and Sunday. I did call and email. Patience is key, because owner/chef, Matt, is busy Thursday-Sunday at the restaurant and I'm sure the other days, he is planning, shopping, returning emails and calls. We did connect and he was just wonderful to work with. I did book the entire restaurant as our party was planned for 10-15 people. He offered several selections for entrees, appetizers and desserts for me to choose for our menu. Since I wanted to have a steak offering, he asked that make entrée selections in advance for shopping purposes. We worked out a wonderful menu. He even accommodated a wine tasting of two different flights of wines that would be offered all evening. The evening started with glasses of champagne and socializing in the first room of the restaurant with has the bar area with a few seats and several small dinner tables. Matt had the second room set up with a large rectangular arrangement of the tables, so that our entire party could be at one table. This room adjoined the kitchen, so you could see Matt at work. After initially greeting all of us, Matt went to work and his delightful assistant served as hostess, sommelier and waitress all evening. She was positively amazing! We were pleasantly surprised to find out Matt had prepared our personal menus and placed them in the Allechant menu books. They not only made wonderful souvenirs, but it was nice to have a record of the wines we tasted. After we were seated, we were offered the first of the wines in the white flight. What was very nice about the wine tasting, is that each taste/glass was brought out sequentially and each guest was asked if they wanted to try that wine. The appetizers started coming, and one by one the other white wines were offered for tasting. Both the gyoza and lamb meatballs were cooked perfectly, sauces were delicious. Entrees were coming when the offerings of the red wine flight started. I had the red curry salmon which was cooked to perfection, the sauce was generous and amazing and portion so large, there were leftovers. My mother had the coq au vin blanc, and said it was absolutely the best she had ever had. And those having the steak and the gnocchi raved as well. (entire menu in pictures with review). The food was incredible, portions generous and service was excellent. Then came dessert; once again, very generous servings, perfectly prepared. It was an amazing evening. I can see why Matt asks patrons to book the entire restaurant when the party is larger. Since he is the chef, he wants to be able to prepare, serve and time every course and every entrée so that no one is waiting, everything is service at the right temperature and is cooked to perfection. If you are looking to host a special, elegant evening in Ithaca, then Allechant is the intimate, friendly, 5-star restaurant for you.

Great spot for dinner in Ithaca! I love the house-made desserts!…read more I tried the mussels for appetizer which were very good. Not too heavy or salty. For mains I tried the vodka gnocchi and the cod stew. Both were excellent! I think if I were to return I would get the cod stew though- it is much more unique. Only complaint about the gnocchi is I wish there was more cheese on top. Desserts were divine! I love how they display them all on the table by the fireplace! We tried the pumpkin cake and the poppyseed coconut almond cake. I truly don't think I could pick a favorite. I wish the whipped cream was also homemade though. I came for dinner on a weekend night (with reservations). Service was solid. Overall, I would return! I will definitely be coming back to try their brunch!

Blackberry Inn Kitchen

4.3

(38 reviews)

Excellent bagels!!! My husband and I each ordered a build your own bagel. It was filled with meats…read moreand cheeses. Super yummy! Lots of bagel choices! No public restroom, but fun fact - 2 doors down is the police station and their bathroom is open to the public.

I love going here. The service is always friendly and Lynn makes sure to know her customers and…read moretheir names. It is a great small cafe in downtown Watkins Glen. You can eat inside or outside. I always customize my food order, and they are more than happy to do it for me.

Shortstop Deli

3.8

(177 reviews)