Let's be honest who is dying for ice cream but tired of getting the same ole staples all the time??? Well if you are like me then you were searching and found this gem! I tried 4 flavors then had to come back and buy 2 pints for home. I had the Sorrel Rum and coffee biscuit. My companion had the Grapenut and Guinness Caramel. The Sorrel Rum is closer to a sorbet but definitely a great scoop. I loved that the spices used did not overpower the rum flavor or have a bitter after taste. Definitely a great try if you love Sorrel. Coffee biscuit was great for coffee lovers. Had a slight chocolate flavoring that i greatly appreciated. I love coffee chocolate. Grapenut was really tasty and smooth. Guinness Caramel was the true winner of the day. I could have had 4 scoops and not got tired of eating this. I left the shop and came back a hour later to bring a pint home. I can't wait to come back and try the rest of the flavors and the pops. Give yourself a treat and visit for a scoop or 5. read more

See all

- The iceys are really sweet, esp when they melt * It ended up being way too sweet, I had to discard it - The sorrel rum didn't taste very rummy - service was nice - no sample tasting during covid times - the ice cream looked delicious tho read more

So creamy and very good ice cream. Awesome customer service. A nice variety of Caribbean flavor, read more

Island Pops - Passion fruit cake cone. Very good - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Cute little spot with kind of Caribbean vibes, afrobeats, unique flavors, friendly and fast service, but small-ish portions. Delicious, though, definitely some favorite treats I wouldn't expect to find anywhere. read more

I purchased the $85 pack for delivery to Vegas. I Placed my order on a Friday and received it the following Tuesday. Despite it being 100°F the day of delivery, and sitting outside the recipient's house for about 3 hours, it arrived well packed and frozen! Recommend 100% This is some quality ****! The flavors were great and were not too sweet. Portions could be bigger but that's just wishful thinking ha! read more

Stopped in this Brooklyn gem tonight for some summer treats and my taste buds were extremely satisfied! I loved my rum raisin sorbet & vegan raspberry cookies (note: the cookies are out sourced from another company but still very delicious) . My sister and I sat outside and enjoyed our treats and even got to chat with the owner Caleb for a bit. I recommend to come early as flavors do sell out fast- but everything I've ever had off the menu has always been of great quality! Check them out if you're in the area ! read more

See all

Island Pops has four ice popsicles, my favorite is the Sorrel and Passion Fruit. Guess what? They are not extremely sweet, they are just right. The ice cream is fabulous and my favorite is GrapeNut. They have this other ice cream called Passion Fruit and it has cake pieces in the ice cream. It looks good but I haven't had the time to try it yet. Will keep you posted. You have to check this place out, favors from the islands. You can't find another place like it. Oh, I forgot. The customer service is excellent. read more

This was such a great find and the staff was so kind and patient! The Caribbean folks really know how to do ice cream! I was passing by and noticed their sign advertising a limited edition sea moss flavor and was instantly intrigued. As I was explained to, sea moss itself is bland but nutritious so Island Pops mixed it into a nutmeggy-vanilla base that tasted delightfully mellow and had a gorgeous velvety texture. I was so tempted to bring a pint home but unfortunately my freezer space is pretty limited so I opted for a cone instead. It's a bit of a drive from me, but I definitely want to return to try their tropical popsicles! read more

Island Pops - Menu as of 7/2020 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Walked into the store with my wife and friend and had a sour experience. We were only allowed two flavors (which was fine) but then we're rushed to make a decision because "customers" were coming through the door. (Are not customers" We were literally told to "WRAP IT UP." Never experienced such a rushed process. This was a new spot for us and we obviously didn't know what flavors were offered. Didn't leave with anything but customer service baddddd. read more

Excellent new ice cream shop featuring unique Caribbean flavors. My favorites are the guava cheesecake, tropical paradise, and passion fruit cake! They have very cute branding, the best staff, and nice outdoor seating. read more

Island Pops - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

That Sorrel Sorbet is the best thing I ever tasted in my life! And the Sour Sop one too everything was fire in there

I literally love any and everything coming out of this place. It definitely helps that they are West Indian (trini) to be exact . It's giving nostalgic when I have certain flavors. Takes me back to my childhood. read more

This is the spot to find in Brooklyn on a summer day. Where ever you are come here. They have divine traditional island flavors turned to Glorius creamy ice cream , popsicles & milkshakes. I got the island Sunday with vanilla. I would describe the island Sunday as like a strawberry flavor? But definitely mixed with other fruits. The double scoop is super generous. The staff is personable and patient while you try to decide on a flavor. read more

Island Pops - Double scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We went after dinner & got several treats such as the ovaltine milkshake with chocolate syrup drizzled down the side of the cup; Fantastic !. The mango popsicle that literally tasted as if they took a mango and stuffed it into it & the Guinness ice cream, amazing . Cute little shop that plays irie reggae jams to add to the island feel. read more

Island Pops - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Amazing deserts! Loved the tropical sundae , it was a calm rainy day, ambiance was nice, love the different variety of flavas they have

Heard about this place for quite a while now and I finally decided to swing by to experience it myself to see what was so special about this spot and I must honestly say I'm sorry it took me this long to visit because this place is absolutely amazing. Incredible flavours, great atmosphere, the staff are friendly and welcoming makes you wanna come back for more and more. Overall I truly had a remarkable experience and I highly recommend it to you all. Swing by and give it a go. I had the rum and raisin and the Guiness Caramel which was marvelous. read more

Island Pops - Rum and raisin and Guiness Caramel - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Island pops is a unique ice cream shop with delicious Caribbean/WI flavored ice creams and ice pops. My favorite flavors are sorrel sorbet, Ovaltine, and passion fruit cake. I've been going since they opened but really appreciated this spot during covid as a place to grab some ice cream, sit outside, enjoy some fresh air and people watch. Also after just coming back from T&C where the ice cream shops served regular flavors (ie; strawberry, etc.), my appreciation is renewed. read more

YUMMY ICE CREAM. I ate the honey roasted peanut flavor and really loved it. My friend had nutmeg and we were both really happy. read more

VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE! I'm writing my review now because this is the second bad experience I am having. I love support my people; Caribbean people. But this time took me over the edge. I I place a large order over the phone and was given a time to pick up when the order would be ready. Drove 45 mins to the location and when I got there I was told they sold part of my order to someone else and ask if they can replace it. UNACCEPTABLE! I want what I ordered... I had to wait over 30 minutes for them to get my order together again. If they are not rushing u to order in store they are messing up when you order ahead of time. I love their products and would hope things can be better in the future please. Ps. If management sees this: PLEASE FIX YOUR SERVICE AND MAKE YOUR CUSTOMERS' SHOPPING EXPERIENCES BETTER. This is unacceptable. Especially for large orders and people who order ahead of time! read more

The customer service here was extremely disappointing. We were excited to try the ice cream, as it came well reviewed. Upon entering the store we were immediately rushed to choose a flavor and pay. This was our first visit, so we wanted to check it out and see what they had to offer. We were allowed to sample two flavors only before again being rushed to order. There was one other couple in the store who was leaving; no long line or reason to rush us. Also note, they have a full coffee menu, but when we wanted to order a coffee they said no they wouldn't make any. The ice cream itself was quite good, I would give it 4/5 stars. There's a lot of potential, but a little kindness would go a long way. read more

I saw this place on Instagram, and was immediately excited to try the ice cream. As the child of caribbean parents, ice cream flavors such as Grapenut, Rum Raisin, and Coconut are nostalgic and so tasty, When I walked in with my partner, we were greeted by one of the employees. She immediately started pressing us for our order. I shared that it's our first time, so we wanted to sample some flavors. Within two minutes she started pressing us again to order. There was no one behind us, so I was confused as to what the rush was about. When her friend entered after us, her attitude completely changed, it was all smiles. The ice cream was wonderful. However, the service was really disappointing, especially since we'd been looking forward to trying this place out. Unfortunately, I'm not enthralled about coming back because rate of this service, but the ice cream was truly wonderful so maybe it will be worth it if I'm in the neighborhood. read more

I finally made it out to Island Pops! Nothing I love more than supporting a black owned business but on top of that a Caribbean business. Their flavors are reminiscent of childhood memories growing up on the island of Grenada. Coconut, rum and raisin , nutmeg just to name a few. Tonight I picked up their ponche de creme , rum and raisin and banana baileys coconut. Their ponche de creme is a Christmas time flavor and lasts until the end of December- it is decadent and reminds me of Christmas back home - of sorrel and ham , black cake and Christmas parang. Island pops is a much needed piece of light in the darkness that is 2020. If you're a Caribbean national like me and looking for a piece of home this Christmas and throughout the year I strongly recommend Island Pops. I will definitely be back to try their other flavors. read more

Island Pops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

After a nice stroll through Crown Heights, a necessary stop was made to taste the exotic ice cream that's flooding my social media timeline. Upon entering, I couldn't help but notice the palm sitting in the corner that quickly brought me into a Caribbean vibe. The galvanize against the countertop gave that trendy storefront look an element of 'Shanty Shop' - a quaint family owned establishment usually built by family or neighbors in the community to sell goods. The menu selection was simple yet confusing due to their check mark and x system showing the flavor that was available. As customers came in the impression was that the flavors with an "x" were not available which made it seem as if the shop had limited stock. That was quickly corrected when the owner gave a bit of humor with reverse psychology regarding the checks and balance system. As more customers poured into the ice pop shop, the owner told tales of "back home" when Caribbean parents dropped off the children to grandma's house. He engaged the customers in stories about drinking Ovaltine- A chocolate malt drink served hot or cold. The Ovaltine tin presumably had chocolate powder in it, but the kids would either eat it all or pour mound in the milk as a bedtime treat or morning tea without telling grandma it was close to the finish. That sweet story clearly conveyed the owners' rationale for serving up that particular flavor. The Ovaltine ice cream had a hint of chocolate malt flavor like pouring milk into the Ovaltine tin to absorb what was left. I'd expect the flavor to be more chocolatey but it was delicious. The Guinness ice cream also had a hint of stout as grandma's recipe for mixing stout and milk for the children to "build up their system". lol The rum raisin is the boozy best! Each piece of raising nice and thick with rich rum flavors. They've got this one right! The nutmeg was pronounced!! BIG UP to the GRENADIAN SPICE! That's a winner! And the mango chow ice pop...Halleluja AMEN! All authentic mango chow flavors- sweet, salty, tangy, tantalizing. The ice cream shop is a jewel in the community. Customers sat and savored the flavors while reminiscing and chatting about life. I shall return! read more

Island Pops - Double Scoop of Guinness Caramel topped off with chunky rich Rum Raisin in a waffle cone is good for the soul. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Island Pops is a family vibes ice cream shop! Not only was the ice cream great but the staff were so welcoming. I had the soursop ice cream flavor and truly enjoyed it! Will be back! read more

Maybe it was just my husband, sister,mom and I but we went with high expectations and was disappointed. The soursop did not taste like soursop, most of the ice creams did not have the explosive flavor caribbean ice creams come with. I do like that everything was clean. The ice pops, sorrel and guava were watered down and portions tasted like frozen ice more than frozen flavored ice. Not worthy of pictures. We didn't take anything to go. I grew up eating fraco VI, raspow Panama and Lindy from the Caribbean. We were all disappointed. We vowed never to go back. read more

I asked for a small ice cream. I didn't know that small meant literally one scoop. I was charged $4. Never going back. Ridiculous. read more

Island Pops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I haven't been to this establishment in a while.... I miss you guys..... I have to add that the service is so good and I love the different selections (flavors). I will be there soon - coming back for all the flavors and I can't wait to see if you have new flavors to choose from. read more

Extremely watered down ice cream. Every thing taste the same. Lacks true Caribbean flavor. Couldn't tell the difference between grape nut or, guiness. I blame tik tok. Ugh read more

Very nice spot! Great selection of ice cream! Customer service was incredible! Highly recommend

You can't go wrong with these pops. Sorrel. Pineapple. Mango. Lemon lime basil. All my faves!

five star place!!! im so happy i found grapenut ice creammmm!!!! the service was amazing!!! and the place was very clean. i'm so happy i found this place. read more

Love, love, LOVE Island Pops! It never disappoints. Their soursop ice-cream is absolutely divine especially when paired with their coffee Ice cream...lord havest mercy! Whether it be summer or winter, Pops is my number one spot in Brooklyn for ice cream. read more

Island Pops - Soursop, Coffee, Peanut - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Staff was really nice and allowed my friends and I to try multiple flavors. I ended up getting the Guinness caramel and it was amazing. I live an hour away and I will definitely come back here. 100000% recommend read more

My 8 year old son wanted to leave the below review: Hello, everybody. I went to Island Pops with my mom this afternoon and I loved the ice pop flavored lemon lime. So if you ever want to get an ice pop, you should go to Island Pops. read more

Ice cream is tasty and delicious! Service is a little slow but worth the wait! Love the unusual flavors that is offered.

I've had the pleasure of supporting this business several times. The flavors are definitely reminiscent of "home". Everything is really fresh and none of the artificial mess. The atmosphere is friendly and attentive. My favorite flavors are the nutmeg and rum punch. I highly recommend! read more

This is a perfect black owned spot to eat Ice cream. The owners are very friendly and allow you to taste before purchase. The flavors are unique and can't be found anywhere else. They have vegan and non vegan options. I had the sorrel rum and my friend had the Guinness caramel and soursop we loved it. read more

See all

Interestingly, I heard about this spot from a woman in town from Toronto, so I had to check it out. After trying out several different flavors (and loving all of them), I ordered one scoop of Guiness caramel, one scoop of sorrel, and one scoop of nutmeg. The Guiness caramel (as well as a couple others (contain alcohol, but I don't think there's much. I've also tried the soursop, and I wanna try the banana Bailey coconut, but my memories of Ovaltine weren't that fond, so I'mma pass on that one. Maybe. I also like the reusable orange spoons that come with each order; I've already collected a few of those. The last time I was there, they were testing out some new desserts, but I'm not sure if they've decided to sell them. Either way, I'll be back frequently. read more

I really enjoyed the sorbet (i'm lacto) and the relaxed vibe of this shop. It certainly helped that this has been a particularly hot and humid week in the city. Folks are super nice too! read more

Love love their ice cream !!!! Friendly customer service!! Love the soursop ice cream ! read more

Island Pops - Love love their ice cream Will be coming back !!!!!! Yummm soursop ice cream !! My fav ! And you can't beeat the friendly customer service! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brooklyn, New York