We had a party of 47 people after our kids' baseball tournament today, and everything was amazing! The food was incredible, and the service from Chelsea and Haley was absolutely impeccable. I called last minute this morning, and they accommodated our large group with no issues at all. We truly appreciated how smoothly everything went. I would highly recommend this place to anyone in the area! read more

We came here for lunch and had a good experience. It was not busy, service was fast and friendly and the ambiance is welcoming. For lunch we had chicken fingers, broiled fish sandwich with tater tots and buffalo chicken wrap. Everyone enjoyed their meals, my only comment would be the broiled fish sandwich did not have a lot of flavor. It was a piece of mahi mahi so without much seasoning it is not a fish with a lot of flavor. For dessert we had the key lime pie and it was divine. I would highly recommend saving room for dessert. Overall good experience and would recommend giving it a try. read more

See all

Came in for drinks after a wedding reception. We had a fun time, they had an awesome band inside and a solo artist outside. The drinks were cold and the bartender was great! read more

Service TERRIBLE came in for happy hour three servers seen behind the bar all ignored my party seated at a high top Seriously at a time when businesses are struggling for business to ignore customers is unconscionable read more

I love this place! Irish Pub but so much better. Anything made with crab is made with crab, no onion, no peppers, just crab. Highly recommend! read more

I am going to start with... I don't write many reviews. I think this is my 5th. I just had dinner at this location and value for quality and quantity is grossly off. $15 for "Loaded" Pretzel bites netted me 10 Pretzels about the size of Combo's snack food, with the most meager drizzle of Queso and what can only be described as 1/4 of a bacon bit (not strip just a bit). They swung and missed on Quality that could have easily been made up for in Quantity or Price. For an Entree I had Blacked Fish Tacos. 2 tacos arrived and were given far more attention than the pitiful attempt at an appetizer. Even at that they were just "ok". Coupled with their Stale Tortilla Chips and about a tablespoon/tablespoon and half of Salsa all with another $21. Beers were priced where they should be, so that was nice. The waitress did what she could to help the fact the kitchen was extremely slow for the app and meal. (For reference the tables around me came in after, ordered after, got food before, paid and left BEFORE I got the Pretzels.) I have eaten at this location before, but it was around Xmas time. It was really nice and the food was better. Maybe it is just this time of year? I like the Lewes location and the only issue I have ever had there was waiting for a table. Next time, I'll just stick to that location. read more

Had a fun meal tonight at Irish Eyes in Milton before attending a show at the Milton Theatre. Service and food were great. We go here often because it's always a fun place to eat with good food for everyone. I want to point out that I was very happy to see that the Milton location still offers a Beyond Burger. My go-to dish at both the Milton & Lewes restaurants was always the Burger Bowl with the Beyond Burger ( and I get it without cheese). It seems that recently, the Lewes location has decided to eliminate the Beyond Burger from their menu. As a vegan, that leaves me little to eat at that location. I like both restaurants, so I really wish the Lewes location would reconsider and put the Beyond Burger option back on the menu. I'm a really good customer, and I am sure that I am far from the only vegan in the area. And when I go out with friends, we chose a place where we can all get something to eat. We would all like to go to the Lewes location sometimes. read more

Try to eat here every time I'm down in Milton. Almost always order the same thing because I absolutely love it: the fresh catch sandwich with blackened Mahi Mahi (usually the Fresh Catch fish special) with a side of terrific potato salad. I've also enjoyed their burgers and, of course, their yummy soups. Came here a few times in the mood for finger foods. Had their nachos and their tuna w/wonton chips (not at the same time, lol). Both were winners. Service is good. All said, I recommend! read more

We went in July and had the fish and chips. Amazing!!! So crispy- beer battered and the cod was so tender. Highly recommend!

The food was hot but very dry. Rueben and shepherds pie were disappointing but the crab dip was delicious

Waited 40 minutes. No one waited on us. Several customers who arrived after we did were waited on. Management needs improvement

While visiting Milton I had dinner here. I had the crab cake dinner. Two delicious perfectly cooked crab cakes with mashed potatoes and a vegetable medley. Service was very good. Place was jammed. I didn't have to wait long for my meal or drink refills. I'm glad I chose this place for my dinner in Milton. read more

Nice family friendly pub. It's been here for years and I go often. Their potato salad is delicious! It's mostly standard bar/casual restaurant food, but they do it well and the portions and prices are good. Servers and bartenders are friendly. read more

We wandered by this beautiful restaurant yesterday, and decided to come by for lunch. We started with a dozen oysters, and I ordered the corned beef and cannage, while my partner got a Mahi sandwich with a side salad. Oddly, the side salad was the first thing to come out, long before the oysters. The oysters were not that good, and very poorly shucked (still attached, one on the wrong half of the side, and drained of any liquid). They also didn't seem very fresh -- considering the area, that's shocking. They were served only with cocktail sauce and saltines. The crackers were actually stale. Lol. The corned beef was fairly good. Great flavour, good portion with a huge chunk of cabbage and a good portion of potatoes. It was a little drier than I prefer, but not bad. The Mahi sandwich was okay, but not good. A bit bland and dry, but passable. It really needed some kind of sauce. Although I would utterly avoid oysters, overall, not bad, but not great, particularly considering the price point. Probably wouldn't give it another try. read more

Irish Eyes Pub & Restaurant - The corned beef was a winner. - Pubs Near Me - Milton, Delaware

See all

Kind of expected more from this place. My meal was good, but nothing extraordinary. The chicken and the pineapple salsa were good, but the coconut rice was kind of dry and could have used a sauce. The meal also came with another side, and I chose the Caesar salad. It came out much later than my entree (I had to ask for it multiple times) and it was not a good Caesar. The dressing was only on top of the salad, which I wasn't expecting. The restaurant itself was nice and had good atmosphere, but I'm not sure if I would return. read more

Irish Eyes Pub & Restaurant - Hawaiian chicken - Pubs Near Me - Milton, Delaware

It was amazing! The view was fantastic, the service exceptional and the food was delish! We shared the tuna tacos and crab Mac n cheese. We also tried the Bloody Mary!! Go there if you get the chance!! read more

Irish Eyes Pub & Restaurant - Epic Bloody Mary! - Pubs Near Me - Milton, Delaware

See all

Very good drinks and food! Would recommend. Nice location on the water! The mac and cheeses are delicious! I had one of the crab meat sandwiches and it was very good! Staffing was great! read more

Food was delicious and plentiful. Server was excellent. Restaurant was crowded because of the holidays. They offered to sit us in enclosed patio area. Definitely do not recommend. It was not warm enough to relax and enjoy your dinner. Next time we will wait for a table inside. read more

Stopped in for lunch! Great food with great service! We arrived right at opening time to get a table near the window and enjoyed a quiet meal among few others. Definitely will return! Husband loved the fish and chips! Said it was one of the best in the area. read more

Have to say went to Irish Eyes in Milton and they get it right. Hostess greeted us as we walked in and sat right away even though they were pretty busy. The serve stopped by, said she be right with us and she was, very pleasant. We ordered our cocktails and beer and they came right away. They have several TV's in the dining area so you can keep tabs on your sporting games; only complaint is that the fans are on and it can get cool. We ordered a few apps, all good dumpsters as a special; tuna wontons ( I could have used some wasabi), soup was tasty from what I heard at the table. The burgers, they got the temperatures right, a well, a medium and a medium rare; I did like that. The fish and chips had a nice crust and the other guest really enjoyed it. The server was there to please us, extra napkins, tartare sauce, lemons etc. It's a nice neighborhood spot; you know what you're going to get for the price. read more

Food isn't the issue there for me, always been good, same with drinks It's some of the people that work there. I went to the jazz fest this past weekend, then stopped in for a few drinks and some food. I sat outside and ordered a drink , which I got kind of. The biggest issue was I then waited for about 35 minutes to get something to eat. A no show @ 35 min got me to leave. I was going to wait though and see how far the time would up , but that timed me out. I then went up to the person working the back outside and let them know. I'll say they did seem a bit shocked about it, but I was out of there. I paid for my $12 drink and off I went. To be honest now a days it's hard for a business to get good workers; this proves it. read more

Walked over after Nunsense today; we had a wonderful experience. Shephard's Pie and Fish and Chips w/cheesecake for dessert; the meal was scrumptious. We are discerning Irish too. ;-) Chelsea, our server, is delightful; we will certainly ask for her when we return. She was attentive, helpful, kind, and funny too! She made our experience extra-memorable. Thenk you, Chelsea and Irish Eyes. See you next time. read more

Love the bartenders! Marissa and Corinne! Great service! Reuben egg rolls and the fried pickels are amazing! Crabby grilled cheese and pork tacos are amazing too! read more

Irish Eyes Pub & Restaurant - Peanut butter pie was made with so much love by the best bartender there! MARISSA! CORINNE IS AWESOME TOO! - Pubs Near Me - Milton, Delaware

Irish eyes in Lewes has one rude and unpleasant staff member. most other staff members are pleasant. but it takes only one to ruin your experience. food is average. I used to go there for music and ambiance of being near water . But not worth dealing with their rude staff . they need a training course for how to be hospitable to their paying clients. and not have people who work there with a chip on their shoulder . may be that rude staff member is an owner of the place . but still has no right to be downright rude for no reason whatsoever. basic courtesy and manners were absent read more

French dip beef tough texture of corn beef, dip extremely Salty small potion not worth price payed. Both pastrami and corn beef rubian fried flat top not steamed l tasting dried out crushed dry beef ,again small portions same as Irish Eyes In Lewes you won't get you money's worth Sad to say The TURONS Love the place read more

Very good food and service. Easy to park and to get into restaurant *************************************** read more

Cute atmosphere! Our waitress was sweet. Not her fault. I won't ever go here again. The nachos were soggy and cold. The white cheese sauce was gross. We paid $6 extra for bland chicken. The wings were dry and cold and we asked to crisp them up and they were better. The pickles were cold but the sauce was good. Find somewhere else for the price and quality. The busboy was very attentive and nice too. The staff was great. Food not so much. read more

The Seaford shepherds pie I had was amazing!!! The wait staff seems a bit "burnt out" but Sarah the hostess was a doll (get that girl a stool to sit on! hubbies burger bowl looked amazing... a nice lunch after another difficult day. read more

See all

We came to Irish Eyes in Milton for dinner prior to the Milton Theatre show tonight. It was very busy. Our server, Marina, was a delight. As busy as all the servers were, Marina made sure we were taken care of in a timely, professional and friendly manner. Bravo. read more

Food was good, service was excellent. We were in town to see a play and had a limited amount of time. Our server made sure that we had time to eat and to get to the play on time. We'll be back. read more

Love the food, views and service. This is my weekly go-to in the densely crowded restaurant scene here in Lewes.

We came here later on a Sunday afternoon. They'd just wound down from a busy Sunday brunch/lunch crowd. We opted to sit outside. Our server greeted us quickly and happily. She was knowledgeable about the menu and made great suggestions. Everything was fresh, hot and delicious. Crab pretzel was so good. The only thing that was a hiccup was that our app (ordered well before the food) came out literally 2 minutes before our food. Beyond that, all was really good! read more

The service is terrible and the food is sub par. Think sad cafeteria. Salad drowned in too much dressing. Chicken breasts over cooked. Only 3 of 4 entrees made it to the table. Yes, 4 entrees on the final bill which took a life time to get and then another decade to correct. The waitress double parked in our car because she was late and lazy. The outdoor seating looks on to a parking lot. read more

Irish Eyes Pub & Restaurant - Out door patio - Pubs Near Me - Milton, Delaware

Irish Eyes is apparently the place to hang out while in Milton. I mean my friend owns a home there and we were visiting so we decided we would take their word for it and go here for dinner. Bar in the back, restaurant in the front. Plenty of parking. The bar area is okay and they have a decent number of beers to choose from (except they were out of a few...on a busy Saturday night). The restaurant area feels like someone's living room but there's plenty of space. They had a DJ by the small dance floor but instead of playing recent hits (which most bars/restaurants like this would) he played hits from the 70s and 80s (more like a karaoke theme minus the actual karaoke). He did say he was just messing around but we were there nearly two hours and nothing changed. Food menu has a lot to offer which makes me nervous since I prefer places with a smaller menu that makes everything well. I had the crab cakes which comes with the daily veggie (brussels sprouts) and the daily starch (baked potato). The crab cakes were delicious and had almost no filler. The baked potato was standard. The brussels had been steamed to hell and back and were as mushy as baby food. The bill was cheap which is nothing to complain about. Tons of people knew each other since Milton is a small town. Kind of a Cheers feel to it where everyone knows your name. Maybe I would come again just for a drink and skip the food. read more

Fast friendly service. Tasteless shrimp ceviche with mango. Tasteless grilled shrimp over a fresh bed of fresh greens. This establishment may be a fine place for a happy hour with friends; But do not count on exceptional food. Bland and tasteless would be a more than kind understatement describing our two selections. read more

The food was very poor. The noise in the restaurant was ridiculously loud. The price was very high for the quality.

We bikes from Lewis to Milton to actually go get a beer at Dogfish Head brewery. Place was closed so we ended up here at Irish Eyes and it was exactly what we needed. Perfect smiokehouse chicken sandwich and great burger, perfectly cooked. Their French fire are crispy and even served with my favorite, a side a vinegar. Service is crudely and patio overlooks a nice park. The one missing star is because there are WAY TOO MANY flies. read more

Full bar and was a fun place to hang out. I'm only giving it 3 stars based on the quality of food.

Not sure why this place only 2 1/2 stars. I loved. Great outdoor patio area. Over looking the water. Had The Cheesy Nachos. The cheesiest nachos I have ever had. My main meal was the tuna on fried wanton. That meal was heaven. A must to eat at if you are In Milton. read more

See all

My Irish eyes were crying during my visit. Food was bland, hot dishes were not even warm. Appetizers and entrees came at same time. Just a bad experience and the prices were high. The pickle and root beer were good. read more