To say I'm disappointed is an understatement. I expected a 3 star meal based on other reviewers experiences but instead it was a 5 star meal. I expected over salted, lukewarm food but we instead received QUICK hot appetizers and entrees that were portioned correctly and flavorful. The side salad could have been a meal of its own. The wait staff? Excellent! Warm and inviting atmosphere and kids even loved their meals. Next time we'll go elsewhere for a less pleasant experience. read more

Party of four stopping by for post hiking dinner. Lots of places to try, and we settled on this one. Really disappointed. Pretzel sticks as an appetizer were not good. Main courses included chicken burrito, burgers and chicken sandwich. Burrito was okay, but not great. Imagine something you really made an effort on at home but were disappointed. That's the burrito. Burgers were ordered medium well and were over done. Chicken on the sandwich was too small for the bun. Sweet potato fries were the waffle type and cold. C'mon, man. Be better. Not sure what these folks that give five stars order, but we didn't order it. We love local spots over chains, but we wish we would have tried somewhere else this night. To be fair, five stars to Dominic for his service. Good dude. Food brought the experience down. Will not return. read more

The Hungry Buffalo is a great stop after a day in Hocking Hills for families and four legged friends. We sat on the patio and were happy to see that kids eat for .99 on Sunday's! The menu was diverse with options galore. I was torn between the Monte Cristo and Fried Green Tomato BLT. I went with the Fried Green Tomato BLT and fries loaded with cheese and bacon. The sandwich had house made garlic aioli and the ranch was perfect. The outdoor patio area had corn hole and axe throwing and it just was a great finish to the day. An ode to southern Ohio ambience and charm. read more

See all

Excellent place to go to visiting our son at OU. Packed as always but the bartender is so pleasant and she is always laughing which made it easy to be friendly to her... Food was fabulous, had their famous fried green tomatoes, then ordered their shrimp basket. Food and cold beers, good company and welcoming staff makes it fabulous to go to after a busy day at Hocking Hills are walking every where on campus. We will be back, just know they will be busy! read more

My wife and I stopped here for dinner while visiting Hocking Hills State Park. We were quite hungry and this place seemed better than going to a chain restaurant. Upon entering, we were greeted by two young teenagers that were serving as hosts. One of the teenagers immediately tried to seat us in the bar area. When we told him we would rather not sit there, he seemed surprised. My wife the Chicken Philly sandwich which came on 12 inches of bread but had only 6 inches of meat. I ordered the Appke Bourbon Chicken which came with " southwest rice". We shared some sweet potato fries. The Philly Chicken tasted okay (according to my wife). The Apple Bourbon chicken wasn't freshly grilled and you could tell by the taste and texture. The rice tasted like it was microwaved. The best part of the meal were the sweet potato fries. Ambience was classic sports bar, service was good (but huge tips were expected). Can't really recommend this place when a much better option is across the street. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Apple Bourbon Chicken and Sweet Potato fries - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

My wife and I were at the location of Logan Ohio we both ordered the beef tips with the mashed potatoes the mashed potatoes came out cold had to send them back the beef tips were very salty never finished them that's why I'm only giving him a two-star rating I would never go back read more

Visited the Hungry Buffalo over the weekend with a party of 10. We were sat right away, but had to flag down a server eventually. I ordered the filet tips which had onions and mushrooms with them and I got mashed potatoes and gravy and green beans with it. My food was average and not hot at all. My sister and niece split the sampler platter; their food also was not hot and the steak nachos just looked gross. From start to finish we were there for 2 hours, everything took forever. I do understand we were a party of 10, but if we're going to have to wait that long at least give us hot food. Hocking Hills is beautiful, though! read more

I try not to be a hater but this place just wasn't good :( the menu sounded amazing but a lot of our food seemed microwaved. Two of us got the apple bourbon chicken and the chicken was tough and the "apple bourbon glaze" was not a glaze but like an applesauce. Mash potatoes were okay but served cold. Rice and broccoli were dry and definitely microwaved. One of us got the ribs and those were good no lie. Appetizers we got were fried green tomatoes and potato skins and those were also good! Service was also good. Someone just help them fix their entrees :) read more

We love stopping here whenever we're in the area. It's always 10/10! Service is great, atmosphere is a chill, fun bar vibe, it's never too busy, and food is awesome. Also, the prices are VERY reasonable. $67 for an appetizer, 2 big meals, and multiple drinks. Highly recommend the cheese curds. If you're in the area, check it out! read more

The Hungry Buffalo was a delicious, nicer Sports Bar with a fun vibe, extremely clean, indoor & outdoor space. We stopped here for a late lunch after hiking Hocking Hills State Park! We ordered the Bison Queso Dip with Chips as an appetizer- it was so good, we wanted more. I ordered the Louisiana Shrimp Basket and had the garlic Parmesan dipping sauce. The amount of shrimp was way more than you expected so it was nice to know the portion sizes weren't shorted. I had enough for leftovers. The service was really good, efficient, our server / bartender (I'm sorry I forgot your name!) was really nice. I'd def go back and recommend to anyone! read more

Terrible out took over 30 minutes for our appetizer to arrive and when it did it was cold. Didn't say anything until patrons at the bar who arrived 20-30 minutes after we did had gotten appetizers and entrees while we still waited for our meals. To make matters worse when I asked about our entrees, the bartender who had an attitude since the beginning argued with me that because we ordered an appetizer it was taking our food longer. No apologies for the wait of almost an hour. I have been to plenty of fine dining and casual restaurants never have I waited an entire hour for my meal. Also I waited tables and bartender for many years, and was appalled at the attitude of the bartender, not only that the manager who was called to comp our bill didn't come over to even offer an apology. AWFUL read more

The best thing here is the pretzel sticks (comes in 3, which is an awkward number). The chicken tenders are horrendously small and come with no sides. Boneless wings were also ordered and the same size as the tenders, so essentially nugget sized. The nachos were literally just melted shredded cheese, dry chicken, and diced tomatoes. The nachos were supposed to be an appetizer but came with the rest of the food. Our waitress came twice between us ordering and the check. There's a gift shop attached and it took at least 10 minutes for someone to check us out because they were out smoking. Wouldn't be back. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Chicken Tenderstenders - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

Well we did enjoy our Axe throwing, our coach was helpful and knowledgeable. Dinning was a bit different although the staff were friendly our waitress needed to visit our table more often, to correct discrepancy with our meal. We did talk with manager and compensation was made. read more

Had a decent experience here. Went in a Wednesday evening . Had decent food and good service. I heard a lot of mixed reviews that this place was hit or miss. This time it was a hit. Again food is decent and our service was good. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Chicken burrito - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

Two hours and got some of our appetizers. Just cancelled remaining order and left. No communication, had to walk up to the bar to order more drinks. read more

We stopped here while on vacation. The food and service were great. If we ever go back to Hocking Hills we will eat here again.

I had a great dinner at The Hungry Buffalo in Logan, Ohio! The atmosphere was fun and welcoming, with a rustic charm that made it feel like the perfect spot to relax after a long ride. My server, Lacy, was absolutely fantastic--friendly, attentive, and on top of everything from start to finish. She made sure my drink stayed full and had great menu suggestions. I went with the chop steak, and it was delicious--cooked perfectly, well-seasoned, and super satisfying. You can tell they put care into their food here. Overall, great service, great food, and a great experience. I'll definitely be back next time I'm in the area. Ask for Lacy if you go--she's awesome! I had a great dinner at The Hungry Buffalo in Logan, Ohio! The atmosphere was fun and welcoming, with a rustic charm that made it feel like the perfect spot to relax after a long ride on my Harley. My server, Lacey, was absolutely fantastic--friendly, attentive, and on top of everything from start to finish. She made sure my drink stayed full and had great menu suggestions. I went with the chop steak, and it was delicious--cooked perfectly, well-seasoned, and super satisfying. You can tell they put care into their food here. Overall, great service, great food, and a great experience. I'll definitely be back next time I'm in the area. Ask for Lacey if you go--she's awesome! read more

The food was definitely edible, but would not come back. I got the steak tips, came with mashed potatoes, and another side, I got Mac and cheese. By the time the waitress brought all of our food out it was cold, barely warm. And the three others I was with also said their food was cold. The atmosphere was very quiet, no music, no game playing over the speakers. They had a football game playing on the tvs but absolutely no sound. All around a very odd experience. read more

Gave it three stars because the service was amazing, but the food was subpar. Our waitress was really attentive and made sure we had everything we wanted, but the food was not very good at all. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Decent food. Really great service though. Would come back. - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

The service was awful. We had 2 different people. It took 30-45 min just for some appetizers, yet seeing table with party of 10 who arrived 30 min after us getting the same apps before us. The waitress was very robot/monotone and rude. Our food took another 30-hour. They forgot about one of the entrees. The food for the price not worth it at all. Don't recommend. A million tvs all same channel read more

Found this online after hiking at Hocking Hills. It was a holiday Friday and they were a little understaffed because of the big holiday crowd, but the staff was very nice and apologetic, working super hard to keep up. The restaurant is very cool with a quirky national park vibe. It was fun to look at the pin map where all the different patrons had come from. I got the boneless wings and waffles and my wife got a fish sandwich. The portions were very generous (the fish was HUGE) and everything was very tasty. Great fries as well. Overall I would highly recommend the Hungry Buffalo if you're in the area. I was surprised to see as many lower ratings on here as I did - my wife and I thought this place was great! read more

We had to wait a long time for our food. My baked potato was very small. Chicken tasted burned. Other than that it was a cute place. But froze to death read more

OMG Hungry Buffalo was horrible!!! Don't waste your money!! Go somewhere else, anywhere else!!! Tony ordered Nachos with Buffalo Chili and 2 PBR in a can, the beer was cold abs so was the food. The cheese was barely melted,the sour cream and salsa barely existed and the small cup of chili to pour on ( while it tasted good) was cold...don't worry about burning your tongue on this food!! I ordered a side salad with 1000 island dressing and a cup of creamy chicken tortilla soup...it came out cold and Gloppy like jello pudding..it was weird. I tasted it and sent it back to kitchen, just take off my check PLEASE!!! I ordered Iced Tea but it was like barely flavored water...so re ordered soda, flat Pepsi!!! I can't catch a break!!! $39 tax and tip!!OMG Save your money!!! Don't stop read more

See all

We were greeted quickly and sat right away. Our server was friendly and efficient. We ordered Filet bites and the Monte Cristo sandwich and both were 10/10. That sandwich is AMAZING. Great atmosphere. Will return. read more

Hungry Buffalo - The Monte Cristo Sandwich - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Waited 40 minutes for a booth that when our turn came up we were directed to a high top table with a 3 year old toddler. She then said it would be another 30 minutes for a booth OR we could sit outside. We opted to sit outside-- the table was wobbly and the bugs were horrible. We ordered the chicken fingers with garlic sauce and one with dead buffalo which turned out to taste like straight Tabasco! It was sent back and while the toddler ate his kids meal we shared the first order of fingers and ordered another. It was 30 minutes before our waitress came back to ask if anyone had brought our order out! She would have known this, had she not been over in the garbage area with some guy making out.... Yes we had a full view of this... while this was recommended in a book we got, I would skip it and move on! Price for 4 chicken fingers with nothing else with them was expensive.SERVICE was beyond poor. read more

Hungry Buffalo - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Service could have been a little better. The food was delicious. I recommend the fried green tomatoes.

The food was very salty. We had pickle chips and they were incredibly salty. I ordered a chicken sandwich and it was very salty. Mostly not returning or recommending because the place was dirty and sticky. Sticky tables, sticky chairs, glass around the booths was dirty like it had been there forever. Not going back another night. Out waitress was nice. read more

For the area, this place is great! Out of the 4 restaurants they have all over hocking hills, this was pretty much our best option for lunch without the 3 hour wait ...so we waited 1 hour. Our server was absolutely amazing, she was super helpful, attentive and friendly, gave us suggestions and was on top of everything! Tried the firecracker appetizer and that was good, mild to no spice, but still good flavor. I got the 9 oz ribeye, with Cesar salad and sweet potato fries, the ribeye it's self was not good at all, super thin, overcooked and no marbalization through it, so dry! Wouldn't recommend at all. The sweet potato fries however were great!! She even brought out a sweet caramel sauce and that with the fries turned out into pretty much dessert for me! We also tried the chicken Philly and that had great flavor, chicken was seasoned perfectly and cooked perfectly too! Would go here again, menu is huge with lots of options. read more

See all

Hungry Buffalo was a quick dinner option that was close to our hotel. Our food was fine, the service was great, and it was super busy inside, so it must be liked by many. I ordered the taco salad, thinking I was going to get a salad with taco accoutrements on it. And I did, kind of. But it was surrounded by a tortilla shell almost as big as my head. So, not really the semi-healthy meal that I thought I was going to get, but that's probably my bad for ordering a salad at a place named after a gigantic, ravenous mammal. I also ordered mini corndogs and a cheeseburger for my children. There isn't a cheeseburger on the kids menu (strange!), so if your child wants a cheeseburger like mine did, you'll have to order one from the regular menu. The cheeseburger comes with tomato, lettuce and onion, all of which I had to pick off because: child. It also comes with fries. The kids mini corndogs come with your choice of side, and apple sauce is an option, so I chose that. There is no outside seating here. Your only options are to eat indoors in their dining room, or order takeout. If you're ordering takeout, they prefer you to order from their website. When I tried to order my food to go at the bar, a kind woman told me that they would soon be phasing out ordering takeout in person, so be aware. One interesting tidbit about Hungry Buffalo is that on one side is a restaurant, and on the other is an axe-throwing bar. So if you're 18+, you can have a meal and then mosey on over to the other side of the building and throw some axes at targets. read more

Service... okay, good enough for middle of day Food...meh. Don't get the chicken tenders. They are dry and even though you order sauce you can't taste it. Side salad was good. Kids' Mac n cheese was pretty good. Cheese curds came with no sauce like most places but they were okay. Beer was yummy. I recommend the yam beer. Overall...tourist trap that cost too much for the quality. Only came to watch football and eat chicken. Instead ate dry, bland chicken chunks and watched Ricky Bobby. read more

My friends and I went axe throwing next door, which is super fun! Highly recommend! Afterwards, we ate at this place. This place serves BBQ, but the quality of it was superbly disappointing. I ordered steak, which came out in such a small piece, and it was overcooked, dry, and not seasoned super well. The mac n' cheese tasted like it had fake cheese and was not very good. The drinks were okay, but definitely overpriced. Our waitress was super cool! She was fun and advised us some things and gave us the honest truth about the place or foods to get, which was nice. But overall, don't really recommend this place. The waitress was such a cool person though. read more

Hungry Buffalo - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

Service was good. Staff was friendly and very welcoming of my furry friend. They even had dog biscuits for him and his own bowl of water! The food though, oh the food. What a let down. We were a party of 6. Waited over 45 minutes for our food. My pork chop was overcooked and only warm, not freshly cooked. Some of our shrimp was cold. The baked potatoes were dry(both the plain and loaded potatoes) and were very chewy, like they had been made ages ago and sat under a heating lamp for a long time, I had to cover my loaded potatoes in sour cream to make it swallowable. Everything seemed bland and needed a lot of salt. If you want drinks and a pet friendly atmosphere then this is the place for you, but if you want good food, go elsewhere. read more

We were traveling today and needed someplace to eat lunch, and this place got my attention. It only had 3 stars on Yelp, but it really looked fun. It was so worth trying! Actually, we really enjoyed our lunch here. My husband hand the Bison burger and fries and loved it. I had the Ham Club and Fries and it was also delicious. The bread was toasted with butter on both sides....... YUM! They have a gift shop and also and Ax throwing area. It's best I stay away from Ax throwing. I'd hate to have an accident. They had a wait list, but we went to the bar and were served immediately. I'd go back! read more

First time in the area and came here for dinner and was extremely disappointed. The drinks were good and the service was good, but that's about it. My boyfriend and I both ordered the ribeye steak medium rare and I added on the 1/4 rack of ribs. While the flavor was decent, The steaks were extremely well done, thin and tough and looked cheap even though they claimed on the menu to be hand cut daily. The ribs were also super dry and tough and the mashed potatoes tasted microwaved. My boyfriend really enjoyed his sweet potato fries. Disappointed with the amount of money spent on this meal. Maybe their other food is good but don't get a steak. read more

Attentive staff, nice outdoor areas with corn hole & horseshoes, a gift shop, and axe throwing. The fried sirloin bites are a must try. i like them to be fried to a medium or medium well temp, so it would be worth mentioning to your server. read more

I never get only 1 star but I could give 0, I would have! Seriously, RUN don't walk away from this restaurant. We were told only a 30 minute wait, we waited over an hour. Then our table didn't even have enough seats, we had to put the men at the bar. We ordered immediately upon sitting down and we waited for over an hour with no food. 3 of our people got small salads which tasted like the lettuce was washed with dirty water. Salad wasn't even touched but it wasn't offered to take off our bill. The service and the food were terrible, the ambiance was cute but couldn't save it! read more

We stopped in for lunch with a group of 7. Service was excellent, browns game was on, good choice of music playing. Prices were decent. My wife got soup and salad and she really enjoyed it. The blackberry vinaigrette was really good. I got the 100% Buffalo burger. It was good, but the patty was thinner than I was expecting. I originally ordered it medium but changed it to medium well bc I thought the patty would be a bit thicker. I should have stuck with medium bc it came out well and with any wild game that dries the meat out. Not complaining just giving a heads up in case you are expecting a thick patty. read more

The server was amazing. Dinner was meh. We started with the tortilla chips with chili queso. The chips were really stale which was disappointing. My husband ordered the fish sandwich and the fish was a standard battered filet, but my husband really didn't like the bun it was served on. He said it was almost sweet tasting and then grilled like a garlic bread that didn't go with the batter. I had the meatloaf with seasonal veggies and green beans. The green beans are canned and the seasonal veggies are microwaved frozen broccoli and carrots. I know it was microwaved because the runner forgot them when he brought out the dinners, and then came back and laughed "they were still in the microwave". The meatloaf is advertised as "served with a red sauce." It's ketchup. Plain ketchup. read more

One of a few recommendations from the locals here was Hungry Buffalo. There was a 45 minute wait for our 9 person group. The restaurant is connected to a gift shop and an axe throw place too. We tried to get into the Axe throw while we were waiting; but that was busy too. They gave us two tables on the patio and with the weather being beautiful it was quite lovely. Some of the drinks we ordered were bloody mary, mango margarita, green lantern. Kids ordered chocolate milk. For appetizers we went with the Nachos, Potato skins and fried green tomatoes. Personally I liked the Potato skins and the nachos but some in our group liked the fried green tomatoes. Everyone liked their drinks. For our entrees the kids ordered mac cheese and chicken tenders and I ordered the grilled shrimp skewers, (but they came out as fried shrimp ) My sides were good with Sweet potato fries and steamed veggies. Some of the other entrees were - the Tennessee Jack Black, BLT, Southwest Salad, Prairie fire chicken. It took quite a bit of time for our food to come out, which was ok this time as we weren't in a rush and were enjoying the evening. There was a Saloon out back that we could walk to from the patio that looked very beautiful but the sign said we couldn't take any alcohol beyond the patio. All in all a good evening experience but I think there is opportunities for the food and the menu to be in sync and also on the taste and cooking a little bit. read more

See all

This restaurant made me download Yelp. Probably the worst food I've ever had - the only edible thing was my salad. Appetizers were tasteless and soggy, the chicken was likely boiled, and everything was gross and sticky. Wow, this place left an impression. My party of 6 was seated in a corner and forgotten about for 15 min... then the waitress/(manager?) was visibly flustered serving us upon realizing that (understandably). And came out to a bill that was more than the $20 per plate (no drinks!!! Just a single appetizer and individual meals...) This was my first time at a Hungry buffalos so I'm not sure if they're all this bad... I've had worse service, but never worse food... and paired with bad service and high prices... (and the cherry on top with bad service and no comp!) that's a 1/10 for me. Jeez. read more