We felt the wings were way overhyped. Ours were very dry and the sauce was just ok. Our bartenders on the other hand were great. The parking is terrible and it appeared to be a little rougher part of town. read more

Old Bill Baileys - Bar - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

Here with Spare Change drinking some of the best busch lights in my life. Spare Charge changed my life.

I will gladly play by rules if I l'm given the rules. Last week we tried to order for pickup and told they weren't doing pickup. This week, we called ahead and verified they were accepting pickup orders. Half hour later we called to order and told NO! If you don't accept pickup orders after a certain time, JUST ADVERTISE THAT!!! This is Horrible customer service. read more

Reminds me of the bars from my hometown. I've been here twice and the wings are great. They fry then grill them. Makes a huge difference and the sauces I've tried have been fantastic too. read more

Great atmosphere and staff as well as having the best wings in Lancaster! Large patio for outdoor dining and often times have live music featuring local musicians! read more

Love this place! Stopped in here to join friends for a fun Friday evening. It took awhile for us to get a waiter to our table to order food. But the food was delicious and it was quick too. The portions were bigger than we expected. Fun little place to catch up with friends too! read more

Absolutely the best hole-in-the-wall I have found in Ohio!! And believe me, coming from California, I have been looking! Michele is incredible at handling the bar, music and making everyone feel like a local. Speaking of locals... Mel (resident local) greeted me right away and recommended the wings, but raved about the HUGE nachos and everything else. Anyone who knows me, knows I will find the best wings anywhere I am. Bill Bailey's has got the wings! read more

Old Bill Baileys - Wings and fresh cut fries are awesome! - Bars Near Me - Lancaster, Ohio

Classic hole in the wall with the best wings on Earth! About 6 beers on tap and a typical bar menu. Great for a power lunch.

Solid hangout if you're in downtown Lancaster, and in the mood for beer and good bar food. Clean and spacious, there's a few dart boards in one corner, and a 21st century "jukebox" (put in money, scroll and pick the songs you want from the extended library on the touch-screen). A few TVs playing sports games. The bar is decent size, and the staff working it were friendly and efficient. I tried their wings - plain with no sauce. They were decent, but had no flavor to the skin. They were pretty juicy, and fairly meaty, but a little on the tasteless side. With a sauce, I'm sure they'd rank higher with others. read more

See all

I drive for Uber and Lyft and find a lot of interesting places to go, this is one of them. The guy I dropped off here the other day went on and on about how good the wings are here and.... he wasn't lying! Wow these are the best wing. They run them over the grill after they put the sauce on and give them that little grilled spark. The wing are big and meaty great quality meat. Now...the building is old brick beautiful architecture, the inside is old not updated but not worn out or run down clean smells good a little mom and pop bar, with the best wings. read more

See all

Went in for to go wings. The bartender was really nice and got my food promptly. The wings are very delicious along with their loaded fries. You have to try this place! read more

Heard great things about the wings there but unfortunately the night I went they must not of had enough people working. I ended up waiting about 20 minutes and then leaving. read more

Fun little bar in Lancaster. Always clean and staff is always friendly. Food is also good. Not a bad place to grab a quick sandwich for lunch. read more

Called in to place a takeout order and the person answering the phone was very rude!! Said they were too busy to answer questions about their menu!! Service is slow and bartenders are rude!! Needless to say we didn't order anything read more

We've known they have the best wings. but tonight we tried the chicken wrap and their homemade nachos.... the wrap was delicious... the nachos are OMG great! Best nachos we've ever had. read more

Old Bill Bailey's has the best chicken wings in Lancaster and not to mention Nachos on Thursday nights! The staff is wonderful and the patrons are awesome. It is one of my favorite places in Lancaster!!!! read more