Seven of us ate here and the food was hit or miss. Burger was good but definitely watch how you order it it was on the undercooked. Would not recommend the sampler platter the nachos are skimpy and half the stuff on it, as well as the kids meals, were all over cooked. The breaded tender strip bites and Monte Cristo were really good. The server very nice but had a tracj him down a couple times. read more

Servers are always friendly and the food is delicious. Love the atmosphere also. Great variety of drinks. The service is the same whether you're sitting at the bar, or at a table. read more

We ordered take out and online. Day was Thursday. Chicken wings (naked w/ "hot" sauce), buffalo chili (a cup), and waffles. Pickup was to be at 7:20pm. Likes: Chili was good, with beans. Waffles were tender and sweet. The pickup service was friendly and quick. The meal was ready a few minutes ahead of schedule. Dislikes: The wings were a disappointment. The chicken meat had an "off" flavor, and the sauce was sparse and managed to be very hot but not tasty. Other: It was a Thursday night, good weather, and the place was pretty empty at 7:15pm. read more

What a fun spot! We got the appetizer sampler and tried the pretzels, pickle chips, cheese curds, and mini corn dogs. It was all delicious, but the pickle chips and cheese curds are particularly amazing. I ordered the fried green tomato blt. It was good, (a blt always is) but the tomato was a bit squishy, so the texture is different from a normal blt. The french fries were amazing! We went axe throwing afterward and it was quite the experience. All in all a very entertaining spot! read more

Left campus today before the football game started. Stopped here to watch the buckeyes play. Bison chili - which is some of the best chili I've ever had. We tried the firecrackers which were tasty. My wife really enjoyed her chicken wings. This is a great place to eat and watch sports. read more

The only reason I'm giving this place 2 stars is the fact that our server was awesome! We had a huge party(13) that included 4 young children and a baby. She was efficient and friendly and we never had to track her down. Unfortunately, my meal resembled 4 day old leftovers that probably sat under a heat lamp for a good 20 minutes before it reached the table. Their "grilled shrimp" were basically salad shrimp on a skewer with a touch of seasoning salt. The green beans were definitely from a can(which I don't mind) but I do prefer that they at least heat them up. The loaded baked potato was average. Once again, the server was great. I was also impressed that they were able to seat our large party immediately. But for what they ate charging for dinner I would much rather hit up a drive-thru for half the price. read more

Went to Hungry Buffalo for dinner last night and it was good. Our server Starr was fantastic, she was extremely kind and attentive. She got our drinks and food out fast. There is a gift shop and AXE THROWING connected to hungry Buffalo so you can play, shop & eat. Loved it! The only thing I would change was we ordered macaroni and cheese and green beans for our sides and they were both cold. Also there drink menu does not have prices on it so you have to ask every time you want a different drink. There are lots of options from steak, shrimp skewers, meatloaf, wings, fried green tomatoes and so much more!! Worth the stop. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Inside - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

Our experience was disappointing. The Apple Bourbon chicken was salty. The rice tasted like Uncle Ben's and the vegetables tasted frozen. My daughter's burger was better but the serving of fries were very small. The wine from the Local winery was good and saved it from being a total bust. read more

So, I saw so many negative reviews on this place that I was honestly skeptical on coming here. Well, I'm here to say that we greatly enjoyed our time at the Hungry Buffalo. The food was delicious, the service was top notch, and it was incredibly clean. We got a monte cristo (epic!) and a bacon bacon burger (equally as epic). If you're stopping in around Logan, don't let the bad reviews fool you, this place is affordable and worth the trip. read more

We stumbled on this establishment after traveling from northern Ohio to Hocking Hills for a mini trip! Everyone from the cute little "general store" to the restaurant were very friendly and helpful! We chose to sit outside on the covered patio, and everything was very clean and spacious! Highly recommend stopping by the Hungry Buffalo on your way through! We will be back for sure! read more

See all

As a local I am really sad that neither of these sister restaurants (hungry buffalo & millstone) are any good. My daughter and I went on a Sunday evening. She ordered a grilled cheese from the kids menu which seems about the easiest meal to cook ever. This was just two slices of unmelted American cheese between bread. Luckily on Sundays kids meals are $0.99 so we did not complain. I ordered the meatloaf with mashed potatoes and green beans. I guess I expected it to be real green beans not smashed green beans from a can in juice. The meatloaf said covered in "red sauce" on the menu. The red sauce was just ketchup squirted straight from the bottle all over the place. I had two bites. The mashed potatoes were ok but the rest of the meal was awful. I was surprised we weren't asked if everything was ok by our server since over 80% of our meals were on our plates when we paid. There were only 3-4 other tables in the restaurant so it can't be blamed on being busy. I would recommend you skip this one. read more

I had such high hopes for Hungry Buffalo as I had heard great things about it. It's very nicely decorated inside and the staff was friendly enough, but it wasn't a great experience. Four out of the five of us ordered a highlighted sandwich. I ordered it as a burger done medium and the others ordered it as chicken. Two people in my group said it was not very good as a chicken sandwich. My mother ordered it completely plain with no bun, but they melted cheese on it. It took them quite some times to remake it, and when it came out again, they still put sauce on it which my mother found to be way too sweet. I thought my burger was fine and cooked as requested, but definitely not the best burger I've ever had. My boyfriend ordered the Bison Burger cooked medium rare, and they cooked it well done. He was incredibly disappointed. We also ordered the appetizer sampler which was good but nothing to write home about. For the troubles we had with the inaccurate orders, nothing was removed from our bill. The general store attached was way overpriced and it was off putting when there were many condescending signs accusing the guests of stealing. The last sign on the exit seriously said "Last chance to pay for the merchandise before it becomes a crime". I understand that they may have a problem with theft, but that's not the way to handle it. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Appetizer Sampler - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

The Hungry Buffalo was the first restaurant I tried in Logan, OH, and I would recommend it to anyone planning to travel to the area. There are a nice variety of options to choose from, and the portions aren't so huge that you feel like you barely touched your food, but depending on what you order, you can still be happy you'll have some leftovers to take with you. The apple bourbon chicken was surprisingly delicious, with sweet and savory flavors and a well-grilled chicken making for a nice dinner after spending the day on the road. The chicken was also one of the most well-portioned meals I've had at a restaurant, being a nearly perfect size for a small eater like myself. And I would highly recommend the Monte Cristo sandwich to anyone looking for a new taste experience. Never in my life would I expect a food that combines a jelly donut with a sandwich to be good, but it is delicious! The dish is perfect for any meal of the day, and it reheats rather nicely. And the chocolate chip brownie for dessert is a classic, simple, yet yummy way to end a meal. Personally, I disliked the giant TVs on the walls, but I like that the volume wasn't overpowering conversation in the restaurant, and the rest of the rustic atmosphere of the restaurant was cute. The rice that came with the bourbon chicken also tasted very mediocre to me, but the rest of the good food helped me overlook that. Overall a good restaurant and I'd definitely go back again if I get to travel to the area again. read more

Stopped by on a whim while on a weekend trip in Hocking Hills. I was impressed with the place. Awesome beer choices and great menu items. My wife absolutely loved her bison burger. As it's a wing place, I had to get the wings. I'll say they were good, but not great. I'm not a fan of giant sized wings. Everything else was good including the service. I'll definitely return if I'm up this way again. read more

Service was fine aside from everyone being somewhat miserable and trying to do the bare minimum. I swear my whole meal was microwaved. I'd truly rather order a baked potato from Wendy's than eat this one again. The green beans were certainly bland and the bacon in them was rubbery. The shrimp skewers were absolutely frozen and quick thawed. All of the floors are sticky. Never again :) read more

The burgers are great and so is the steak and all the people there are nice I would recommend this restaurant to anybody in Hocking County or coming through Hocking county read more

This place is great! The service was amazing! Super nice waitress serving us and totally understanding when I ended up ordering my steak a little too rare and they sent it back and cooked a new one free of charge. The entrance was hard to find though because you enter down a long road in the back. A sign pointing down the road would be a good idea. The hostess did seem bored and didn't smile or anything but I understand if you don't really enjoy the job you're not going to be ecstatic to be there. 10/10 all together! read more

Hungry Buffalo - onion rings - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

Overall, a decent spot. Nothing was great, nothing was bad. Beers are cheap (Yuengling is a big deal for this guy, who can't get it in Michigan), good service and food. Had the bacon burger and it was certainly a burger. Prepared perfectly, not messy, good quality beef. The only complaint was the wait. I know that things aren't running at full capacity right now, so that's not a knock. They were actually a lot faster than the quoted time, and we were seated way before another place that we had put our name in at the same. There's not much around here, but this is a decent spot for lunch or dinner. read more

Nasty food. Salty salty salty. Everything was so salty. We told the waitress that the pickles were extremely salty, her response was "yeah, they usually are". Like WHAT? I'm so disappointed. Never coming here again. People only come here because milestone is packed. read more

After waiting for 30 minutes to get a table and 30 minutes to get our food, my chicken quesadilla came out burned. I was so hungry that I ate half of it, which has caused indigestion. They took it off our bill, but I would not go there again. The cheese curds and potato skins weren't that good either. See photo. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Burned chicken quesadilla. - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Fries were cold and my burger was overcooked. Cheese curds and chilli were good though.

We were seated outdoors and had to wait over 2 hours to get our food. During that time, the sun went down and it was pitch dark outside. We requested the outdoor lights be turned on and they told us no, yet they wouldn't move us indoors?! We had to use our phone lights to eat. Also during our over 2 hour wait, the waitress never once checked on us to see if we needed refills or anything. Worst service/ experience we have had in a long time. McDonald's would have 100% been a better choice. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Eating in the dark.... - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

Stopped by during a business trip. The place was clean and service is fine, however the food is lacking. I ordered the 12 oz Ribeye with a shrimp skewer and two sides which were fries and seasonal vegetables. The steak was thin and tough, the connective tissue wasn't broken down. In addition it lacked seasoning so salt was necessary. Honestly I've had better steaks at Applebee's, which are rarely good. The fries and vegetables were fine. My server was nice and attentive, definitely the best part of the meal. read more

Ax throwing can be fun. Food is just ok. Cheap beer Mon and Tues is good but after you see and smell the nasty urinal you loose your appetite to eat!!(see pics) From the urine build up I would guess it hasn't been scrubbed for months! read more

Hungry Buffalo - Dirty urinal never been cleaned for months and smells great! - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

The shrimp on the skewers were absolutely tiny. We didn't receive and when we did it was filthy we asked for a manager a teenage boy came over offered a discount and to bring us a spoon and neither ever happened back in order chili which was awesome as well read more

Great food and service. The menu isn't very large, but it's tasty. Dependable place, and walkable from a few hotel nearby.

Your typical local family friendly restaurant! Was at Hocking Hills for a getaway and wanted to head to Logan for some food and to watch the OSU game. I can't speak to the main menu but we got wings and beer to eat while watching the game. We ordered onion rings to start as an appetizer - spot on. A full basket to preface some chicken wings is how I want to fake watch football. The DEAD BUFFALO WINGS ARE NO JOKE. Man, I'm not sure what I was thinking getting the hottest ones, but my eyes we watering. Embarrassing. They load up that sauce too, which I love. You can split some of the sauces per number of wings (I think 5?). We also got the Millstone's Sweet & Tangy bbq to try since they had the bbq place right across the street. These were my favorites!! I love a sweet bbq sauce, but they usually end up being overly sweet - the Millstone's bbq sauce was the perfect amount of sweetness to add to the savory wings. There were a bunch of people there watching the game and eating, so it was a cool communal environment feeling - I'm sure they get that with other games. Overall, a solid choice for a lunch in the area without breaking the bank. I'll be craving those wings until I return. read more

We stop here quite often sometimes weekly after hitting the trails in Wayne National Forest. We've yet to find something that wasn't good. My go to is the chef salad which is HUGE but the prairie fire chicken and the burrito are both great too. We have never gotten bad service at all everyone is always wonderful! My only complaint is even in July it's cold in there lol read more

Such a great place. Friendly staff. Delicious food. Cheese curds sent me to heaven and back. They have mini corn dogs on the menu...what more could you ask for? Oh idk...axe throwing??? Well they have that too read more

Good service and a great atmosphere. However, the food could have been a lot better.

Great service from Lacey. Loved the bison chili burrito. The Caesar salad was good. Big screens everywhere, same thing playing on all of them? read more

Outdoor seating was quick and comfortable, especially since we had our dog with us. Cocktails and drinks were served politely, but sloppily..they spilt while our waitress was trying to do as much as she could since they were obviously understaffed. Everyone was helping each other out, politely! Food was mediocre, nothing noteworthy to mention. We were STARVING after a long day of hiking, so it filled the void. The restaurant, outdoor seating area and restrooms where very clean and comfortable though. read more

The food was just ok especially given how much we paid for it. The service was just ok as well. Our actual waiter was helpful but not exactly attentive and the rest of the wait staff seemed more interested in each other than the guests. Overall I'd probably find somewhere else to eat although there aren't a ton of options in early January in Logan I guess. To be fair, we are out of owners and maybe they were just heading an off night but judging from other reviews I tend to think not. I got the cajun shrimp basket with fries and my husband got the bourbon burger. read more

Hungry Buffalo - Cajun shrimp basket - New American Near Me - Logan, Ohio

See all

The loaded potato skins are my favorite and a tall draft beer. All the menu items I have tried are excellent. You can even do axe throwing and some shopping while you are there too. Outdoor patio is super fun in the nicer weather. read more

First time here because we just found this gem. i was expecting decent food. We received GLORIOUS FOOD. It was terrific--I felt the need to rave about it before even finishing my meal, and I hardly ever do this. Our server Brittany was excellent and her recommendadtions were right! My wife had Filet tips; I had chopped steak that was way more flavorful than I expected! This is a MUST place to eat in the Hocking Hills area. It didn't hurt any that the wife paid. okay, it's a joint account, but still... read more

Service was ok- it was busy, so that contributed... but, the food was not good. We ordered 3 types of chicken and all of it tasted like frozen chicken microwaved- very rubbery and bland. Hamburger was good, but small. Fries were bland and also rubbery. Overall- not worth $50. Ps a male server kept pinching the hostess's ass- she looked annoyed... as I would be. A conversation on sexual harassment might be useful. read more

today I ate at the hungry buffalo restaurant on January 14 2025 and my waiter was robin Jenkins. are food was great. are waiter was very respectful and made sure we had everything we needed and keep checking in on us to make sure are food was great and if we had all everything needed. so I wood give this place a 10-20 stars if I could cause you never find a great waiter at Just any restauran. thanks Jessie pennington read more

We ordered the sampler appetizer and the food came out lukewarm. The nachos didn't have the cheese all the way melted and the cheese curds were cool to the touch. The only item that was hot was the pretzel and when we dipped it in the cheese dip there was a film at the top of the cheese. We got the wings and waffles with the tenders. They came out and the size of the chicken tenders were good but the quality of the chicken was not great. Including waffles in the name of this dish os a bit of a stretch as the total waffle that you get is about half the size of an eggo waffle. I did equal bites waffle and chicken and was able to eat 1.5 tenders before there was no more waffle. Service was not their saving grace either as we only saw the waitress when we ordered and paid. My glass was empty for most of the meal. All in all this was a waste of $50 and I don't suggest that you try it. read more

We are visiting the area and decided to come here to eat! It was soooo delicious! We got the combination plate for an appetizer and I got the Buffalo meatloaf! My boyfriend got the Tennessee Jack Black burger! Everything was sooo good! The service was great! There is alittle shop next door to look in while you wait for a table! Great stop and will be coming back if in the area! read more

My server, Ian was one of the best servers I've had in a long time. The bison burger and boneless wings were amazing. Will come back soon