Where has this been all my life, and why is it tucked in a small food court in a bowling alley!? I ordered the Wild West Tater and honestly was expecting a fairly satisfying, but ordinary, baked potato with toppings. What I received was an amazing blend of super tender pork in a slightly sweet but tangy BBQ sauce, mac n' cheese, and a perfectly cooked (not hard or dry), very generously sized potato (big enough for two). On a chilly day, when you're hungry, this absolutely fits the bill. Warming and savory, but well balanced, and not greasy. After some bowling or billiards? Perfect. I was thinking this was probably the best flavor, when I saw the rotating ad for....a spaghetti potato pie. Will have to come back and try other varieties. The cashier was very helpful and patient explaining the menu. Checked the website and looks like they update the menu with new options too. They say they're "dedicated to perfecting the art of the baked potato," and they're doing exactly that. Along with it, they're also serving up one of the best craft-style fountain sodas, Stubborn Soda. Don't hesitate to make a little detour (or order delivery) to try this place. TIP: Located inside the HomeGrown Bowl center: from the main entrance, head down the hall to the right past the arcade; also near a side entrance. read more

See all

We grabbed takeout from here after hearing good things. Overall, a worthy fast service addition to the area. We called in to place an order for pick up. Welp, you can't do that. They told us not to order over the phone, only online. OK, fine, but it seems like you shouldn't turn away business just because we used a phone. We got our order placed online instead. My wife received a confirmation email and then an email saying our order was ready for pickup. She arrived at the restaurant, and the lady working said she had never gotten an order and hadn't started on it. So my wife waited for the food to be prepared and finally got it home. The food was good. The mac and cheese potato is really good. The mac and cheese was a star. The shepherd's pie was ok, but a little shy on the meat and needed some more seasoning. At least the portions are large, and you'll likely be able to split an order into two meals unless you're super hungry. The inside of this place is small and located inside the bowling alley building. Nothing special about the ambiance. Takeout is probably the way to go. This place should be 3 stars. However, I am going to cut a little slack and assume it was a one-off experience. So for this review, I am sticking with 4 stars. When I return, I hope the food is up to par, and the service improves. I would love to write a 5-star review for this small local business. read more

Hot Potato Pie - Mac & Cheese Potato - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

See all

Hours say it is open until 9:00 PM on Mondays. It was closed at 7:40. What is the point of posted hours if you don't follow them?

Found this cute lunch spot inside a bowling alley. The potato's were delicious and creative with the toppings, and they serve Stubborn soda. ++. The customer service was great. read more

Stopped in here yesterday for lunch with a few friends. It's located inside the bowling alley building. There are a few eateries inside. Kind of like an indoor strip mall. I've never had a potato pie before so this was my first experience. The place was small with limited seating. There wasn't enough room for all of us but there were tables and chairs outside to sit in. The weather was good that day so it was perfect. These were a lot of potato pie options on the menu. I ended up getting the Yurika steak potato pie. It was huge. I didn't know they came in an 8 in pie tin. I could only eat half of it. This was totally something different. It was actually really good. So much flavor and texture. I kind of liked the burnt potato skins at the bottom of the pie. I know it sounds weird but it tasted good. I could've eaten it all but I would've been overstuffed. Oh yah, the pies are hot and fresh. It takes a few minutes to get your order because they're made to order. My buddy ordered the lasagna pie. That seemed like it took twice as long. So if you ordered that, be prepared to wait a little longer. It seemed like most people that order food there get it to go. The service was great and the people were very friendly. I'm looking forward to trying a different pie on my next visit. read more

Hot Potato Pie - Yurika steak pie. - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

This place is so freaking good!!!! We put in an order at 8:25pm online and it was ready right after we arrived. We ordered one of the chili frito potatoes and one of the tuna and both were so delicious! I even saw the employee taking the tuna out of the can!! We will definitely be back! Unfortunately it seems like a lot of places don't survive in these shops but I hope this place is able to make it!!! Also, on their menu it says they have salads coming soon. read more

Hot Potato Pie - Tuna-Topper Baked Potato - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

See all

Got three different plates...chili cheese, bacon Mac (added broccoli) and the sweet potato. Couldn't decide which one was best. The gal at the counter was so sweet and polite. I had asked the guy in the cooking window where the bathroom was and she quickly followed me to tell me the code for the bathroom. She's so attentive and very concise when speaking with her coworker. The restaurant itself had super cute & punny potato signs. Felt very homey read more

Hot Potato Pie - Bacon Mac with broccoli Chili Cheese Potato no onions Sweet Potato Marshmallow Delight no chocolate - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

Tried this spot while vacationing in Nevada and it actually surprised me with how good it was. I didn't really think much of it given the fact that it was located inside of a bowling alley, but I have to say my assumption was completely wrong. The potato was perfect! Sometimes I get baked potatoes and they are way too dry. The bacon on top was crispy, the buffalo chicken was my favorite and had just the right amount of spicy to it. My least favorite was the grilled chicken, only reason is because some of the pieces of chicken had tendon in it and it just grosses me out when I'm eating chicken and all of a sudden it's super chewy lol. It's probably just a me thing and some others may like it. Did not get a picture but I did try the side of macaroni and it was also delicious. For the dessert I got a slice of pecan pie and it was amazing! It was a pretty big size enough for two to share for sure and it was topped with plenty of whipped cream. Unfortunately I do not have a picture of the pecan pie either. Overall this place was great and if I was ever in the area I would definitely stop by again! read more

Hot Potato Pie - Baked potato with grilled chicken, buffalo chicken, shredded cheese, bacon, and ranch - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

My daughter had the Birria and I had the Steak and Pico...second time and still feeling the vibe from here...fun, fast and delicious A++++ read more

See all

The restaurant was immaculate, super clean. It is hard to find because it's inside the bowling alley and not a ton of signage. We ordered 3 potatoes for take out. They were all pretty good with VERY generous portions. Our favorite was the fiesta, then the buffalo chicken (but the chicken was a little rubbery). Next time I want to try the sweet potato marshmallow dessert! read more

See all

We came here for mothers day since My husband knows how much I love bake potatoes. We came in and the area isn't huge but it's good for about 3 families to enjoy their meals. The staff greeted us and were very friendly. They went over the menu and all the options. We tried the bake potato with brisket and Mac and cheese and our daughter got the Taki baked potato. They were nice sized and so soft. They were so filling that we took the rest home to enjoy another day. The area was bright and full of different potato decorations. We really enjoyed it and will be back for more. They even let our daughter design a possible new potato option and said they would name it after her if they went with it. Such a nice and fun experience. read more

See all

Hot Potato Pie did a great job catering for us. The food arrived hot and fresh, and they kept in communication with me the whole time. They separated toppings like sour cream, cilantro, and onions, and labeled everything clearly. They even helped set up and explained what went with what. We served about 100 employees and didn't get a single complaint, majority just asked if we could cater with them again. read more

See all

Food was great! I feel guilty purchasing something from a restaurant that I could easily make at home so I think portion size is the most important thing for me but overall it is delicious. I loved it. I think bigger portions are always appreciated. read more

Hot Potato Pie - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

See all

Hot Potato Pie is now open and it does seem quite popular now. We all love a new restaurant! It's located inside the little mall where the bowling alley is in south Carson over by Aloha Liquors. I arrived just after noon and there was quite a line already. Having looked at the menu online, I had an idea of what was on offer. I did notice the posted menu didn't include all the selections on the website, but some were available even though not listed up on the board. Basically they serve baked potatoes with various toppings and fillings, ranging from the basic butter and chives to steak with cheese and sour cream and even birria pork. Prices range from $6.99 for a basic potato to most of the loaded selections at $12.99. $13 bucks for a baked potato seems a little on the high side, but I guess prices are what they are these days. No french fries if you were wondering. We stood in line and placed our order of the Bacon Bacon potato and the Steakhouse potato, made with beef, onions, cheese, bell peppers and sour cream. Every order is packed to go, even including a big paper inside plastic bag. The interior is sort of small, so this seems more of a to go order place, rather than a sit down place. There are a couple of tables and bar stools at a counter to sit. The food didn't take too long to come out. Upon taking off the to go covers off our potato containers, my friend exclaimed, is that all the bacon I get? The potato didn't look as well stuffed with goodies and bacon as the picture on the website would lead you to believe, but hey, what fast food burger actually looks like the advertisement photo? He was a bit disappointed. Mine was the steakhouse potato. It was just OK, but could have used some pepper and salt, but there was none available at the tables or pick up counter. If you got this to go you'd just be outta luck on that! My potato had cooler spots in the center and really could have been kept hotter before served. The meat was just OK, lacking and grilled or charred flavor. Overall it was just an OK, experience and I probably will not return. Maybe give them some time to fine tune the operation and give it a try. You do gotta be brave to open a restaurant these days! read more

See all

Ordered the Chicken, Bacon, Ranch potato on the two for one deal through DoorDash. Becca and Leticia fixed my order today and they were so awesome as to give me extra butter on the potatoes before they put the toppings on. 10 out of 10 on both potatoes!!!!! If you haven't tried it yet, then you gotta try it!!!!! This place is ten stars not five!!!! read more

Good price and the meal was huge! It easily stretched to 3 meals for me and it was very filling!

Rich, the owner, was very helpful to us as we read the menu. This is a baked potato BOWLFUL and more than one person can eat, we split one. Hot, tasty, clean restaurant, nice staff...and so yummy! We'll be back or over to try Hot Potato Pie #1 in the Carson Lanes Bowling center. read more

Hot Potato Pie - Too bad it's all gone! - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

Second time here. First time had the pleasure of meeting the owners and getting an amazing potato. Daughter wanted to return for the same Smokey Pork and Baked Bean. This time received a potato with just beans. Went back to discuss with the two employees who stared that is what i got! Not friendly and unwilling to listen that the previous time we ordered the same and had a pile of pulled pork and a BBQ sauce drizzle. Unfortunately not pleased with the product nor the employees the second time around causing a quality issue that the owners are going to need to fix! read more

Hot Potato Pie - #2 Smokey Pork and Baked Bean - American Near Me - Carson City, Nevada

It's a small hole in the wall place that the popcorn place used to be. It's nice. Small amount of indoor seating though but alot more of "outside" seating. The baked potato was awesome. I had the meat lovers and Mom has plain with butter. Both of us enjoyed ours. They have Stubborn soda which is good though a bit pricey. Got some chip cookies but haven't tried them yet...too full, lol. Service was awesome and even though we weren't inside the store they still brought us our dinner. So nice. Overall, an awesome time. I will be back. read more

I'm a huge potato fan so, this place was a definite must-try! Their birria version had well seasoned beef instead of the traditional goat. Very good. I went back and tried the Carne asada, too. Fresh jalapeños in their pico de gallo added the perfect amount of heat. They play cooking shows on the TV, which is how I personally choose to eat at home. It's a small spot inside of a bowling alley but, the flavors are solid and consistent. Be sure to try their fountain sodas. The cream soda is the best! read more

See all

Hot potato pie is amazing. This restaurant is one of a kind. Eureka assisted me and she is the best customer service employee I have ever met. Hot potato pie is a family oriented place to be. They have items for the whole family. read more

If you love potatoes, this is the place to go has some great food tons of variety of potato flavored dishes. The only thing I will critique is I need to get a ketchup stand. Aside from that, this has been a great first experience read more

See all

Counter service. Only 4 seats at a counter. 4 seats at table outside of door to business. Baked potatoes were very good. Ready promptly. I would regard this as take out only. Ambiance 2 stars. read more

Finally a baked potato spot! I tried 3 different types of potato's (Buffalo chicken, pizza, and birra) and they were all delicious, portions was large, they gave lots of topping (not stingy), the price was affordable $12 well worth it. I waited 10-15 min for 3 potatoes. Service was good. I will be returning. read more

See all

Amazing food and reasonable prices! Portions are huge so you can most likely split one pie between two people like my boyfriend and I do.

Can not in good conscious even recommend.....food didn't even remotely look like advertised....I ended up vomiting and diarrhea for most of the night....called the owner Richard and he could only ask if I had a receipt....didn't want any thing but acknowledgement of the problem but he was more concerned about a receipt/refund.....I guess customer service is not a priority.... Just went to Hot Potato Pie with my receipt and was cursed out and told to never come back ...doesn't seem like they don't like negative feedback....truth hurts!!! PS....1/14/26 10:51am $5.37 read more

Our first time going there. We each had the Tex-Mex potato. Cruncher. Very, very good. Next time, and there will be a next time, we will order one potato pie and split it. We brought home enough for 2 more meals!! read more

I was really excited to try this place. I have never been to a restaurant specializing in baked potatoes before and I appreciate the novelty of it. First off - I don't like the AI-generated images on the online menu. They're very misleading. For instance, the mac and cheese potato photo featured what appeared to be white cheddar mac and cheese. What I received in my to-go bag was definitely bright orange cheddar. The menu doesn't specify what kind of cheese is in the mac and cheese, however, so I guess I took a risk with that one. Regardless, I'm immediately skeptical of a restaurant that doesn't have photos of its own food online, but this is still a new restaurant so perhaps they are working on getting photos and are using the AI images as placeholders. I hope that is the case. Now, onto the food - again, I had the mac and cheese potato. It was tasty enough. I'd give it a 3/5. The other members of my party had the buffalo chicken potato and the birria potato. Buffalo chicken was rated 3/5, birria was rated 4/5. Every single potato was perfectly cooked and fluffy, I will say that. But, every potato was also saturated with butter. Don't get me wrong, I love butter, but we all had to tip our potato tins and drain the butter out because there was just so much of it. This is still a new restaurant ironing its kinks out and I'd probably give it another try. But, for now, I think it was just okay. read more

BBQ pork and beans potato was the bomb. I loved it. Wife's was shepherds pie and she loved it. Potato was fluffy and buttery. Nice and hot. Will be back soon read more

Amazing baked potatoes! The birria one is a must try! Service was also great! I'm hate that they are all the way in Carson but they did say they are making their way to Reno. read more

Me and my daughter stopped here because she loves baked potatoes and she wanted to try it. I will say the potatoes were absolutely delicious! She got the bacon Mac and I got the chicken bacon ranch. The ONLY thing I was disappointed in was that they have bottled ranch, thankfully I had them hold the ranch before it was ruined. They would get 5 stars from me if they had homemade ranch to complement the delicious potatoes. read more

Nice idea. First menu prices online do not match in store. Salads, which look purchased from the store or Costco cost more than $10.00 No water, not even a cup of tap water. That is so silly. Food, while a food idea, was so greasy it leaked through aluminum foil container and paper bag. Next time we will just get a large pepperoni pizza from Costco. Was so hoping this would be great. read more

The food was really good. Not your normal baked potato. I had the veggie potato because I was looking for a healthy option. This restaurant is inside the bowling alley in South Carson, so I wasn't surprised to see a little slow around lunchtime, but the service was great. Had a nice lunch, visited with a friend, it was affordable, and we were out of there in time to get back to work. read more

Amazing food and amazing people!!! Becca and Manny were amazing!!! Manny put the right amount of extra sauce on my Potato and becca is just super sweet!!! We love them and love the food!!! read more

This was a great place for to-go order for a working lunch group, items where nice & hot and great variety to satisfy everyone's tastes.

Amazing, if you love potatoes like me this is the place. Fast and friendly service. Easily enough to split depending on the plate. Just simple potatoes and toppings, perfect if you want something filling and satisfying. read more

Please bring back the Birria potato. Its the absolute best potato so yummy, a chef's kiss.

Becca is my favorite person and I love her. She is the best and is super amazing. Manny was super sweet as well. He made my potato just perfect. read more

The potato pies are super yummy. The owner is very kind and the girl Rebecca that she has working for her is very friendly as well. So the service is fantastic too. read more

We tried the Bacon Bacon Potato and the Veggie Potato--both were absolutely loaded with cheese! Each one was big enough to share, definitely a generous portion. Can't wait to go back and try some of their more savory options like the Buffalo Chicken and Birria. read more