I wish I could leave zero stars. I took one bite of this and then called dominoes. This is literally the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. read more

We were staying at the Residence Inn in Durango and asked the front desk to recommend a good pizza place. HomeSlice Pizza was the immediate response so we decided to try it. Also we liked that they deliver to the hotel which is a definite plus during this time of Coronavirus. We chose the Koko's Greek and it was delicious! The combination of flavors was perfect (we added eggplant) and the crust was excellent! We will definitely try this place again! read more

It's just going downhill, it has been even before the pandemic. Sorry but guys really gotta cook your pizza more.

When I was in Durango this weekend visiting some friends they insisted we MUST check this place out. They even said it was better than Cafe Rio in Ruidoso - and if you've read my review for Cafe Rio you know that would be a hard thing to accomplish. My response, after eating the food, was that it is like comparing apples and oranges. Both have EXCELLENT pizza - but they are very different. Cafe Rio perfects the classic Italian pizza, while Home Slice take great pizza and gets creative with it. Home Slice has a crazy variety of pizzas that you won't find everywhere. For example, they had a pulled pork pizza, and a Thai pizza. I tried a veggie pizza slice and a southwestern pizza slice, along with a salad. Being with good friends I was able to try bites of the pulled pork pizza and a beef sandwich that was heaven. My favorite part of the pizza was the crust - it is seriously the flakiest crust I've ever had on a pizza. It was so yummy! It was like a pie crust (I mean like a holiday pie, not your typical pizza pie) that your grandma would make. Super flaky, but thick with a great flavor. Definitely worth checking this place out when you happen to be in Durango. Great way to top off a busy day of river rafting and drinking beer. read more

I've been sitting on this review for a while, hoping that I could have more than one experience with Home Slice to judge by. However, there are so many reasons that I haven't eaten here a second time: 1. I work too much, 2. There are lots of other new places to try in Durango, 3. I live a ways outside of town and am too lazy to drive in for dinner most of the time, and, of course, 4. I am poor. As always. So I will go off the one time I have eaten here and then correct the stars depending on my future experiences. I first ate here back before I lived here. I was staying at the Holiday Inn so that I could do an interview (for my current job) and we were hungry. I wanted pizza but I did NOT want chain pizza. So E brought me here. I'm just going to list off the toppings on my pizza. If you think they sound heaven-sent, you can keep reading. If you think they sound gross, sorry. Ok, here goes: coconut curry sauce, shrimp, pineapple, bell peppers, thai chili sauce, basil, and cilantro. It's their Kow Thai pizza, and may I say, from a Thai lover, it's damn good. It's like they took my favorite curry and put it on a pizza crust. The shrimp were perfectly bite sized and the chili sauce left an awesome impression on my lips but wasn't enough to be over powering. We got it to go and brought it back to our hotel room and devoured it. Seriously. It's one of their specialty pies, which means it only comes in 12", and we just absolutely stuffed ourselves. They have lots of interesting combos, and I want to go back! I'm sure the opportunity for pizza will present itself soon, and I know just where I'm going. read more

Everything about this place was perfect- food, drinks, atmosphere. Jennifer and her crew were friendly, kind, fun and professional! Awesome experience, definitely worth a stop! read more

I almost feel bad for giving three stars, because the food was ok. I was really excited because they had some amazing topping options: like fresh rosemary and goat cheese. The pizza also only took like ten minutes, I was surprised. I am not sure why they call their pizza NY style, it is way to thick and dense. I felt like it could have been cooked a little more. I loved that they used fresh rosemary, but sprigs were just thrown on the pizza and I broke it up myself. I still enjoyed my pizza but it wasn't anything I would write home about. Staff was friendly and the place had a laid back vibe (maybe too laid back). However, my reason for three stars is they only have like five tables inside and all of them were dirty, including mine. I would understand if they were busy but they weren't. Not one of them were clean while I was in there, and I was the only one dining. The cashier figured stocking Parmesan was more important. The manager or maybe even owner even stopped by and didn't say anything, except asked the girl to box her up a slice! The cook was outside as I left smoking. I don't understand why they have 4.5 stars. Maybe just because not enough people have eaten here. read more

This pizza was awesome! We are in town for the weekend and I'm 8 months pregnant... The pizza craving hit me hard! We got half Behemoth and half Autumn Blossom... They both were amaze balls but the Autumn Blossom was lights out. I've never had walnuts or apples on a pizza and I can see this being a serious craving for a longtime! read more

This pizza was absolutely delicious, baked perfectly, crust was delicious and the toppings were generous. Staff was nice during pick up and although we didn't dine in, it looked cool. Highly recommended. read more

After a terrific day on the Durango Silverton Railroad we found this local pizza shop through Yelp and could not have had a more perfect evening. The pizza topping options were endless but we stayed with simple toppings because of our young children. We ate outdoors and enjoyed a cold beer while watching the sun set over the Rockies. Months later we still talk about that meal. read more

5 * for excellent handmade sausage pizza pie. 3* for the wait on a recent visit - 45 min for a to-go order with a slight delay. The variety of pizzas offered is beyond comparison... read more

Over all the taste of the pizza was like a 3 star. Could not see and taste the sauce. I gave it one star because within my second bite I found a hair between the cheese and the dough. I lost my appetite, no thanks! Disappointed! read more

Really good! Best pizza in Durango. All sorts of unique que combos to be custom mad.... lots of stuff already laid out, from traditional, to kinda new-shy-west-coast.... love it! read more

See all

New to Durango... 1st visit - the cash register and the girl operating it did NOT like our credit card (no chip). It declined and she said go next door to use the gas station ATM - which I did and paid the ATM service and bank fee! That was a real buzz-kill! 2nd visit (just me) - female bartender was all business and it wasn't even crowded. She is the "typical" Durango wait staff ... not friendly at all. I assume they have NO regular customers and it's all tourists. I had a slice of GOOD pizza and a couple beers. It was me asking for refills, she never asked me! I also noticed, she ran short of beer glasses, and kept washing them --- even telling several customers she was OUT OF GLASSES! This was a WED night ... I hate to see what she does on a FRI or SAT night! Anyway, good pizza, dog friendly (outside only), I suppose good prices. Hope to have a different (maybe male) bartender next time! Plenty of staff to go around. I also noticed a "local" sitting 2 chairs down from me and he was perturbed when she asked him to pay up-front for his beers. read more

Would do zero stars if possible. Was it the food? We wouldn't know because we never got it. We arrived at time designated for a pick up. Was told it was going to be 30 minutes late. We left and came back in 30 minutes only to be told it would be another 25 minutes AND half our order was being cancelled as they ran out of garlic knots. AVOID this place. read more

Deeeeelicious! The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is bc their ordering system is crummy & the swiss-miss girl in the food truck was quite a jerk, especially when I said - this is my first time here, how does this work? Apparently that wasn't a cue for her to dazzle me and make a good impression. Meh ... The bar took FOREVER to get service and it was clear the bartender played favorites to the regulars. I would have drank a lot more if it didnt take 3 years to get a beer. The food though ... oh, the food. Man it was good! our group ordered several pizzas and the bread and we all shared. There wasn't a one I didnt like. Their dough is delicious! Even the kids suddenly wanted to eat their crusts. When I'm back in Durango next year, I'll be sure to go back. I may not drink but I'll bring my appetite. read more

Tough one to review. I think they were having a rough evening. Completely overwhelmed by customer demand. We got there and the patio was full as was the dining room but no one in the dining room was eating - just waiting. We ordered slices, rolls and salads. The house salad was a plate of spring mix, shredded parmesan and a crustini for $5.00. I guess it's supposed to be a special dressing? It was oily balsamic. I would never get that again. The slices were good. I got one with salami or some other salted meat, tomatoes, and pepperoncini it was really good. Thicker crust than I usually like but not too thick, and fluffy. Husband got a margherita but it had cheddar - that didn't work for me. The boys had cheese and pepperoni - they loved it. We had beer - I don't know what it was but it was refreshing. The best part of the meal was their bread. They gave us rolls that was apparently a mistake or burnt. They were amazing, yeasty rolls with a wonderful tomato dipping sauce. We also ordered the garlic knots and they were great too. We got our food fairly quick but everyone around us was so unhappy waiting for their pies, some for over an hour, it made it a stressful dining experience. At one point a woman behind the counter tells a man getting utensils: "those are the only knives I have right now". There was one. I don't know if someone didn't show up to work tonight or the summer crowd did them in or all these great Yelp comments has made their business to big to handle. I bet this is really good pizza and nice people but weak salads and needs a growth plan. read more

It's not a gourmet pizza place but it gets the job done if you want a slice. Cheese had way too much cheese and the pizza was soggy. Garlic Knots were awesome though read more

First time to Durango and we were looking for a great pizza for the family and LOVED the pizza at Home Slice. The dough was perfect and the toppings were generous. Used very high quality ingredients. My son and I shared a large pepperoni and my wife and daughter had a loaded medium veggie pizza. Both pizzas were outstanding. The location is not the best or most beautiful but it is worth it. read more

This was the second time visiting family in Durango and ordered pizza to go. We've never dined in but the pizza is excellent. Would highly recommend it. read more

Food was decent but could've been better. My stromboli was so burned on the bottom I couldn't cut through it. I finally pulled it apart & it tasted pretty decent. The main problem was lack of managemet. A guy started harassing us by getting in our faces then whispering in hubby's ear. He got pushed away & came back screaming obscenities. We were masked, he was not. The bartender stood and watched the entire encounter & did nothing. She did run after the guy when we got on this bicycle. She asked him if HE needed any help. We will not go back. read more

This place is the worst. While I'm sure many have had good experiences at this place, I can't say the same for mine. I ordered a "take home and cook pizza" which took well over a half an hour to prepare. When I finally got this diabolical deformation home, it looked like someone slammed their fist into it and then emptied their trash over it. So I put this turd in the oven and waited and hoped for it to magically form into a pizza. When I took it out of the oven and labored through the first slice, I noticed there wasn't any sauce on it. How do you forget sauce on a pizza? Whoever made this failed experiment must have been sniffing glue. I would rather drink my grandfather's colonoscopy bag than dine at this cesspool again. I wouldn't recommend this place, but I doubt any of you will care. read more

Rolled into town late on 2/1/2021 and this was the only non fast food place open. The pizza was delicious and the service was excellent. Lots of choices AND a full bar! read more

Came here for a rainy night pizza left happy and definitely not hungry. The Grandma Junes was excellent. Nice atmosphere friendly staff. A little outside of downtown but worth the walk. read more

Poor service they forgot our order took over an hour to get our pizza. Not very kid friendly. The parking is terrible

I stumbled on this place as I was looking for a spot for lunch close to my work. They have pizza by the slice and they are consistently good. The little bread rolls are amazing with the homemade marinara sauce. I go here at least once a week. They have a great menu with lots of selections. Location is awesome with plenty of parking. I highly recommend this place especially if you love Italian food!!!! read more

Pizzas are just outstanding. The Chicago deep dish crust is perfect. Nice fresh ingredients. Beautiful patio seating area with hops and grapes growing over head for shade. Best pizza in Durango that I've found so far. Ska Brewing Co. beers on tap also a big plus. read more

The pizza was almost the worst I've ever had, besides my hotel covid quarantine pizza in Mexico. The half inch cheese came all the way off the doughy break clean with barely any sauce. I put multiple packets of red peppers on each slice and still couldn't eat it. I recommend dominos 100/100 times before here. read more

Great quality of pizza, but mainly giving 5 stars because of the quick and friendly delivery. Would definitely go back and actually eat in the restaurant. read more

The pizza (and the service) is good if you go into the restaurant. But if you want delivery, protect your heart (and appetite). Allow up to 3 hours for their delivery, especially on weekends. And when they are 1.5 hours + late, don't plan on an apology, empathy, a comforting hug, or even a remote shit given from their manager/employee/phone answerer Jordan. Never, never, never, never order Homeslice for delivery. I have been burned 5 times, and last night, when 10 pm rolled around and the pizza still wasn't here (that was supposed to have been delivered at 8:34 pm), I threw together dinner for my hungry kids and made myself a promise: never again. read more

Very good pizza. Had pepperoni extra sauce. Recommended the extra as it is really tasty. Cute little place.

I have been frequenting Homeslice for 13 years and it makes me sad to give them such a negative review; however, Homeslice has gone from being one of my favorite local eateries to one of my least favorite. What used to be a unique local pizza place has become a corporate shit-zzeria that used to serve wonderful, unique slices and now serves nothing inspiring. People used to love working there and you could count on knowing the staff, now you're lucky if the current employees have worked there over a month. Cooks used to enjoy and thrive on pizza creativity and now you're lucky to find some interesting slices for lunch. Once a gem, now not worth a visit. Local spot ruined. If you want good pizza go elsewhere. read more

I'll first preface this by saying that we are very low maintenance patrons. But it was Literally the worst service we've ever had. The food was terrible at best. Charcoal burned pizza, the driest, grossest, stringiest, hardest chicken wings we've ever had (that took 45 minutes) after our other food came, too many issues to name. And non-existent service. We bused our own table before sitting down because we were completely ignored. We aren't from Durango. We travel a lot and have never had such an awful time. And we paid $100 for it. It was a nightmare. read more

Homeslice has definitely become a Durango staple for us. They have a wide selection of pizza options, and I usually really like the HudSucker or Fiona Apple as they are pork free and still tasty! The location on college, which is closer to downtown is kinda small with a equally small beers on tap selection. The location on Main however has a full bar with a lot of brews from Ska which (obviously) pair awesome with pizza. The only downside is that the parking lots for both locations are limited! read more

Cheese pizza by the slice for less than $3, and they are big. Filled up my 9 year old boy., Nice hipster vibe. Pizza was tasty & salads were fresh. Staff was friendly. read more

Pizza was awesome!!!! I love it! It was worth walking for! IPAs are the best! I'll be coming back soon!

Never been disappointed in their slices. I've loved them all, especially their spicy buffalo chicken, the veggie and BBQ chicken are also great. I'm sure in time I'll work my way through my menu. Their patio is super cute and a great place to eat a pizza and drink a pitcher. read more

Service is prompt, courteous & just plain awesome w/ a welcoming atmosphere full of friendly locals at both locations. Decor is glum, the one on N Main is roomier, more inviting w/ a full bar and a nice fireplace outside. Pizza had a fairly good flavor and plenty of cheese though there was hardly any sauce and too doughy. We got the NY style. No No aaaand No! Not even close. Sorry Homeslice, you have some good pizza but, NY style it is not Thin out the crust by 2/3, add more sauce, fire up the oven a couple of notches and grease, gotta have that yummy Italian-e dripping grease. Then...you will be a little closer. Other than that, it was good for Colorado pizza! read more

A nice hole in the wall pizza joint. The restaurant is clean and the service is good. You walk up to the counter to place your order and pay. Unless you're getting a beer, the water and soft drinks are self serve. We sat outside and I ordered a slice of pepperoni. The pizza is very good and freshly made. The crust is really good dipped in honey. I would return. read more

Visiting my Brother in town and this is his favorite pizza place. I can see why!!! We ordered one of each of their available slices to-go, a side of marinara + ranch..... Pizza Heaven! read more