Holy Pie! Pizzeria

Pizzeria Vittoria is always a solid choice whenever you are hanging out at Starland Yard and in…read moreneed of a bite to eat! Vibes are always perfect! They offer wood fired pizzas that have that perfect light charring to them. The ingredients are simple and fresh - the perfect paring to any afternoon in Starland Yard while enjoying a cold drink from the bar. There is a salad option on the menu... but why order a salad at a pizza place? Your payment information is held from when you entered the Yard and will appear on your tab when leaving. The staff is friendly and food service is pretty fast depending on the demand. Once your order is ready, they will send you a text that it is ready. They also offer carry-out services online without having to enter Starland Yard.

Very good when they are on, but that is very rare. I've been here multiple times when the said they…read morewere out of dough right after opening. I've also been here and they've been out of pizza sauce but still sold pizzas without sauce on them. For 17$ a pizza, this is not worth it for the inconsistency.

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Calzone

Vinnie Van Go-Go's

4.1(1.7k reviews)

6.5 mi

A great spot for a NY style slice. They have a walk up stand where you can order to go and that's…read morethe only way I've enjoyed their pizza. You can do a single slice with whatever toppings you want. I did a slice with mushrooms and black olives and it was the perfect temperature. The cheese was the perfect level of melty, toppings good and plentiful, crispy crust, and it was a filling slice. The staff is friendly and fun. It's a casual corner pizza joint and not pretentious in any way.

After a day of early drinking, a hot Savannah day, and A LOT of walking, we stopped at Vinnie Van…read moreGo-Go's after it was recommended to us--and it ended up being a great casual pizza stop. They offer slices, medium or large pies, and you can build your own pizza. We went with two slices: one topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, and green olives, and another with chicken and tomatoes. The pizza had a great crispy crust, wasn't overly sauced, and had just the right amount of toppings. Nothing complicated. The staff was friendly, and there's indoor and outdoor seating, plus a window for takeout. Definitely a convenient spot to grab a slice, sit back, and refuel while exploring the city.

Shot from the bar

Pepperoni slice, outside seating

See all

New York Style Cheese Pizza

Graffito Pizza

4.0(240 reviews)

6.6 mi

A favorite in Savannah, right on the river under Electric Moon. Delicious options like the RCK…read more(smoked bacon, caramelized onions, sausage and mozzarella), wonderful hospitality and a clean, urban artistry vibe. I've also tried their house made vodka pasta that was exceptional as well. A must stop if you're craving Italian!

Graffito is a chic Italian eatery. Our server, Hailey, was friendly and welcoming, and service was…read morequick. There was no wait. I started with an order of garlic knots and then ordered the Hot Honey Pizza, and the two came to $35. The garlic knots were okay, the bread was nice and soft, but the knots and the sauce needed salt. The pizza was a good combination of sweet and spicy, though my crust was a little soggy and not cut through enough. Ask for extra napkins with the Hot Honey Pizza, since mine was a bit messy.

Dining Area

Lemoncello Tiramisu

See all

Graffito - Private Dining Room

Screamin' Mimi's

3.9(558 reviews)

6.9 mi

My favorite pizza in Savannah, so many toppings to choose from. The best part it's consistently…read moregood.

Two words, not good. A friend from NYC recommended Screamin Mimi's. We're domiciled in the Boston…read morearea but spend 4 months or so in Savannah. This place's pizza can't compare with northern city options. Not close.

Coke products but no Diet Coke (boooooo)

Pepperoni

See all

Note door (I guess the last one was a window).

Holy Pie Pizzeria - Savannah

4.1(38 reviews)

7.0 mi

Pizza ordered and ready for pickup in 20 minutes! Counter service and dinning area available as an…read moreoption. The pizza won't be awarded "Best of Savannah" but was a great value and quick option. The hand tossed crust was soft and airy. No skimping on the toppings! Fun wall murals. Plenty of parking!

We came here for lunch thinking it was would fast and good.... Nope. We ordered our lunch at 1:00…read moreand I went up to the front at 1:37 and the had just started working on our order after I reminded them about our order. While we were waiting two people went up and ask for a refund because they had to leave. The lady up front was very rude to them both. After they left the lady called them both a "b****" which was very unprofessional. I asked about our food and she turned around and walked away. Once it was done she put my bag down and pointed at it and turned around and walked away. The food was tasteless and very bland, I wouldn't come back ever every thing cost $37 not worth it at all.

Order counter

Meat and Lean

See all

Smoked Chicken Pecan Salad

Treylor Park Pizza Party

4.2(100 reviews)

6.5 mi

Sooooo glad they recovered after the fire. I'm completely gobsmacked ( first time using that…read moreword!) and relieved by the quality of the restoration. It's actually like nothing happened. We had lunch there today. Our server, Justin, ( inside-ish joke, but he'll answer to Jason with good cheer), was the perfect example of an attentive, charming, and knowledgeable. The food- yom to the 10th power. My partner's chicken sandwich was a great combo of crunch on the outside and moist in the inside. He doesn't usually finish a meal but he did this one! I am vegan and def got what I was looking for as I was starving. The variety of tastes was on point, but even tho I could have stopped there, I had to have a side of the refried butter beans. Too good not to! Again, so happy for our community, the employees, and the owners that Strange Bird has opened up her cute little nest to us all. She was missed!

The food was average, the service was really nice. The atmosphere was kinda cozy and throwback ish…read more Bathrooms needs some TLC. The thing that kinda caught me by surprise was the price at the end of it all. 1 smash burger, 1 cheesy bread and 1 chicken parm with 2 drinks was $65. I guess with it being a tourist town could explain the price. It seemed very steep.

Pizza Party bar

Popcorn shrimp

See all

Smash burger

Treylor Park

4.3(4.8k reviews)

6.8 mi

Fun place to eat with unique dishes. We started with PB&J wings. So good. Peanut butter sauce with…read morepecans. Peach jelly on the side. Such a great combo. The wings were cooked perfect. These are a must try if you like wings. Chicken and pancake tacos were delicious. Pancakes had a touch of sweetness. Fried chicken inside with a spicy mayo. Topped with a strawberry salsa that worked well. 3 of these were very filling. Fun and very good. Son had the double wide footlong. Topped with sloppy Joe. After that the 2 sides were different. One had fried banana peppers. The other side more classic with toppings. Son said it was really good. Others had the ahi tuna salad. Tuna was perfectly rare. Salad was good and the wasabi dressing had great flavor without being too spicy. Service was quick even though jam packed. Also very friendly.

Treylor Park was probably exactly what we needed at 11:30 at night…read more It's somewhere between a diner and a sports bar, but the decor is what makes it. The whole place is designed to feel like the inside of a trailer--spray-painted antique chandeliers, old pictures of different trailer parks, and random little details everywhere. It's kitschy, but very intentional, and honestly pretty cool. We came in late after a 4h drive into town after work, and the staff was still super friendly and accommodating. No "we're about to close" energy, which I appreciated. We started with the creamy collard dip, which is basically their take on spinach-artichoke dip, but with collards. Really good. I do think the chips were a little too heavy for the dip--a thinner chip would've been perfect--but that's a small note. The chicken pancake tacos were probably my favorite. The chicken was fried perfectly and still really moist. And at this point, I'm convinced Savannah just knows how to cook chicken. Everywhere we went, the chicken was consistently good. My partner got the grilled apple pie sandwich, which has fried chicken, grilled apples and bacon. He's not even a big pork person, but that bacon was so crispy and the whole combination just worked. Even the waffle fries were good--crispy, fresh and actually seasoned. We had the Grateful Dead and Wicked Kiwi cocktails, plus a couple of shots, and the drinks were strong, good and reasonably priced. Honestly, I don't have a ton of notes here. It's not trying to be some elevated dining experience. It's just a really good late-night spot with good food, strong drinks, friendly service and a fun atmosphere. We sat inside because Savannah in August was not about to have us sitting on anybody's patio. Definitely recommend, especially if you're looking for somewhere to eat late. It was a vibe, the food was good, and it did exactly what it needed to do.

Inside from the front door

Fish and chips!

See all

Kids chicken tendies!

Bella Napoli Italian Bistro

3.9(864 reviews)

6.7 mi

Beautiful resteraunt with the kindest staff! My husband and I visited on our last night of our…read morebabymoon and it was perfect! The food was absolute incredible - I loved the romantic vibe and cozy atmosphere.

Always a fantastic meal to be had at Bella Napoli. They have an extensive wine selection and we…read moreenjoyed a bottle of something new to their menu. They serve warm fresh bread to each table with oil and vinegar for dipping. This time we ordered the Veal Piccata and the Pappardelle Bolognese for our entrees. Both were delicious. And then ended our meal with a slice of tiramisu that's rich in flavor but light and mousse-y. The servers all work on a team and they are friendly and give great service. The restaurant itself is small and intimate. You end up sitting close to your neighbors at some tables. They can only take parties of four so if you have more than that be prepared to split up, no exceptions. It's a quaint combination of hole in the wall and perfect date night spot. I love this spot for celebrations and even just dinner out where you don't have to get all dressed up but you can if you want to and either way you fit in.

Inside

Squid ink pasta with seafood (overcooked seafood)

See all

Corks from wine bottles on the borders all over

Hop Atomica

4.3(178 reviews)

6.6 mi

This is truly one of my favorite spots in Savannah! Stacey makes the best cocktails, and always has…read morea smile on her face. She makes everyone that walks through Hop Atomica's doors feel welcome and special. Thank you for that Stacey! It is a relaxed atmosphere that is fun, and the food is incredible!! I let everyone know to go here for the best pizza, food and service in Savannah! Brad A.

Enjoyed ipa flight. Hot mess pizza amazing. Stacey great bartender easy to park and findread more

See all

Bar Julian

4.4(209 reviews)

7.4 mi

This is a really delightful spot! Nice views of the city and river from the roof and pleasant…read moreindoors seating too. While I'd advise you to slip staying in the hotel where this restaurant sits, the restaurant itself (and the other one downstairs, fleeting) were bright spots in an otherwise lackluster hotel stay. We enjoyed breakfast here a few days. The service is fantastic (we saw Miranda a couple times and she made us feel like regulars, remembering our order and offering some sight seeing tips), all staff was friendly, fun and knowledgeable about the menu. The food is well done, with a Mediterranean influnce. We enjoyed the shakshuka (highly reco you add the kefta and ask for oven bread instead of the sourdough) and the Turkish eggs (also reco asking for the oven bread with this one), both dishes were flavorful and well executed (and we try shakshuka everywhere we see it!) We also had evening snacks one night and enjoyed the hummus with the mushroom add on and some of their signature drinks. Staff In the evening was also strong and didn't disappoint. If we ever find ourselves back in Sav we won't stay at the hotel Thompson but we will stop into Bar Julian!

Wonderful location for people new to the city. Perfect spot to watch sunset and get beautiful views…read moreof the city, the river, and passing ships/boats. Highly recommend the whipped feta. All of the drinks were great!

Restaurant

Julian breakfast

See all

Savannah @ night from Bar Julian

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Matt P.

4 years ago

One bite and I had to stop to write a review. HOLY. FREAKIN. CRAP. Cheesy, meaty, melty, ooey, gooey, goodness. I happened to be on this side of town and was about to starve so I figured I'd slip on in and check this place out. I am so glad I did. Now open a store in Effingham my man and you'll stay open just from my family alone!! Big props to the owner, super chill and warm greeting when I walked in. The girl at the register was sweet. I'm ready for another Stromboli boss! read more

D'Jillisser K.

Elite 26

177

398

1840

3 years ago

I embarked on a road trip to Savannah, Georgia, and while en route to my ultimate destination, I yearned for a swift and satisfying meal to fuel me up . As I made my exit from the highway, I spotted Holy Pie's location and opted to give it a shot. I'm absolutely delighted that I did. I chose the personal pan meat lovers pizza, and it turned out to be so deeeelicious! The pizza's crust was generously laden with cheese, leaving my tastebuds completely satisfied. read more

Deb A.

4 years ago

If you love everything about pizza - the crust, the sauce, the cheese, the fixin's if you use them - there is no pizza in Savannah like Holy Pie Pizzaria on Dean Forest Rd. It's not a big restaurant, it's not touristy, is just plain has the best pizza, calzones, strombolis, and wings around. It's ten minutes outside of downtown and an equal distance from the airport. So if you're a lover of all things pizzarias, this is your place! read more

Joanna B.

5 years ago

Holy Pie is a fantastic new pizza place! The pizza, pasta, garlic knots, and cookies were delicious! It was "certified bussin" according to our kids! Best part is they have the friendliest staff! The outdoor patio seating is great too! read more

Holy Pie! Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Holy Pie! Pizzeria also viewed

Costanzo's Pizzeria

3.9

(119 reviews)

I've been meaning to review this pizza spot for sometime now. For local good pizza this the place…read more Especially if you don't want to travel downtown. It's Jersey style as mentioned in the window but certainly is right next to NY style and glad I found something comparable. Service is great and there's a few tables to dine in. I do have to mention their delicious Stromboli. I got chicken and onions being it already comes with cheese, I added two toppings. Soooo tasty it's worth a try, not to mention filling and good for two or three people.

4.5/5. A very nice hole-in-the-wall vibe to the place that gives South Savannah a great pizza…read morechoice. The wings were a bit on the small side but had a great char to them. The Tomato Basil Pizza was delicious and with a side of marinara sauce for the crust. The crust seemed appropriate for Jersey style like they advertise as the crust was thin and on the crispy side. I did order online which said ready in 45 minutes but by the time I picked up, I think the order was ready a good little bit before that time so wasn't hot hot by the time I got home 10 mins away. Will most likely be back to try more options.

Vincenzo's Pizzeria

4.2

(79 reviews)

Hit or miss, I guess they sometimes miss. My wife and I just got 2 large pizzas here and they were…read moreover cooked and super dry, like hurt my gums dry. Last time we got pizza is was really good but this time, if I wasn't super hungry I probably would have thrown it away. I did call to tell them to let them know thinking there might be a temp issue or something with the oven and I didn't get an apology or anything, just "ok I'll tell the owner" click. Guess it's back to ordering from your pie in sandfly.

Fast and delicious Italian food, with lots of variety to choose from. Pizzas are great with lots of…read morechoices. Top notch service and great prices.

Pizza Chef & B And R BBQ

4.3

(16 reviews)

Hands down my favorite pizza in town! The BEST dough and you can't go wrong with any of the…read moretoppings. The wings are fire too and I just love their customer service. You walk in and it's like they knew you forever.

In town for some fun with the Savannah Bananas....we decided to check Yelp for the coolest pizza…read morearound. Up came Pizza Chef and B and R BBQ. They had a special for 2 large pizza with 1 topping each for $19.99. Cool, a deal! Plus I wanted to try their "Hot sticks", basically cheesesticks with jalapenos on and IN the dough. It was the other side of town, so the food was a bit cool when we got home, but man was it packing flavor!! We picked thin crust with mushrooms and regular crust with black olives. Both were spectacular! The "Hot sticks"? I'm thinking they hit the dough with jalapeno juice before cooking...because it was throughout. Loved it! The BEST part? When re-heated in the oven....all the original flavor came back, even 3 days later! 5 star food! Service? It was late in the day, but service was great by the staff. Parking is in front, but there is a lot a few steps away if needed. I'll be back when I'm in the Guyton area!!

Screamin' Mimi's

3.9

(558 reviews)

My favorite pizza in Savannah, so many toppings to choose from. The best part it's consistently…read moregood.

Kay's Pizza

3.2

(124 reviews)

Pizza was incredible!!!! Quick service, in and out in 5 minutes and was all around a great…read moreexperience. They are open late so a great option at all hours.

4.5 Pizza 4, service…read morea 5+. Easy late night pizza by the slice, warm and good. Great vibes and service- best welcome and example of good people making work fun. Pizza by the slice- huge, and whole pies. We had cheese and pepperoni- both good and just what we needed for an easy and quick dinner. Thanks again for the music and laughs- will be back.

Pizza On Wheels

3.8

(95 reviews)

Good pizza and the guy working here was a hoot! We were out this way on vacation and noticed this…read morespots sign and tried it. Not too shabby!

No delivery. They should rename themselves "Pizza Without Wheels." Pizza is pretty terrible. No…read moreambiance.

Midtown Pizza

3.4

(5 reviews)

Ate here after a soccer game 2/26/22. Both of our kids got sick (serious diarrhea within 45…read moreminutes) after eating the small pizza they shared. I'm guessing it was something in the crust, but neither said they "liked" the flavor of the pizza. The staff was very friendly but unfortunately we didn't like our pizza in the least.

I don't mean to drag down a new business so I'm hoping this review will be one that is helpful to…read morethe business. My sister and I came here for lunch as we know it's new. The service was quick today so no complaints about that. When we got the pizza it looked like a carnival pizza or ones that you see in an elementary school lunch cafeteria. Seems like they put cheese, toppings, and then more cheese on top. My sister LOVES cheese but this was too much even for her. For me, I got pepperoni and it made my pizza so greasy, I had to use a few napkins just to dab all the oil out of it and there was still some oil dripping as I ate it. This is a personalized small pizza type of place, but is nowhere in the ballpark in the quality of pizza as places like Your Pie delivers. $8 for a 10" pizza and a drink. If you're not much of a soda drinker like us, I would suggest going to Your Pie or elsewhere instead as you get more toppings and better quality pizza. I heard the management comparing it to dominoes and honestly, dominoes is far better. If you Iike to eat pretty healthy and are debating using this as a cheat meal, I would not recommend. They do give some type of sauce on the side, which we thought was garlic sauce but it was just oil and it had no taste. Thumbs up on giving more marinara sauce on the side though. Highly suggest re-creating the way the pizza is made. Good luck! UPDATE: few hours after we had our pizza, we both had stomach aches. Absolutely do not recommend.

Graffito Pizza

4.0

(240 reviews)

Savannah Pizza

4.0

(6 reviews)

We've had 3 of their large pizzas. All 3 were delicious with perfectly cooked crust, the best pizza…read morewe've had in town. The "Kickin' Bourbon" BBQ wings are absolutely scrumptious too! Service is quick and friendly. When your order is ready, they keep it warm in a delivery bag even if you're picking-up. On one occasion, I accidentally left my debit card in the card reader while I was being handed the boxes. When I figured out what had happened, I called them and found that they had saved my card for me under their cash drawer. That is awesome customer service! We love the fact that the franchise is owned and run by a local family, too, a true Mom & Pop (and kids) business. It's also great that they're open 7 days-a-week. Our only complaint is that it's from 4:00-10:00 p.m., so no pizza for lunch. Highly reccommended!

Just moved to area & was surprised to discover a pizza place that would deliver to Ellabell…read more Ordered the cheese sticks, pesto pie, and super BBQ pizza. All were excellent! Their garlic dipping sauce is legit as well. We will definitely be ordering often!

Lighthouse Pizza

3.5

(2 reviews)