Holly must be some sort of witch, or have a special power for making sandwiches. What appears to be a typical sandwich shop / deli from the outside and in, drastically changes when you interact with the wonderfully kind staff, and then taste the food. I can specially highlight the breakfast bowl (eggs, bacon, cheese, veggies etc) and the California wrap (turkey, avocado, tomato, cress (sprouts for you Americans)) The breakfast bowl is ridiculous. It's the best breakfast I've had anywhere on the cape. The scrambled eggs were fluffy and generous. The mushrooms wonderfully grilled. The California wrap though...is what inspired this review and why I'm suspicious of Holly's power. Not quite sure how some basic sandwich ingredients can come out tasting like that (12/10!) but I think it's best you keep your secrets Holly, that would be too much knowledge for the world to know. Thanks for making our summer holiday meals so delicious - and to the employee (maybe Holly!?) who is travelling to Europe and England for the first time next year, safe travels!!! We'll see you next summer!! read more

Holly's Deli - California wrap. - Delis Near Me - West Dennis, Massachusetts

Good subs and salads. Subs were small, salads were generous portions. Nice variety of fresh baked cookies. Cooler had other prepared foods for purchase. Friendly staff, clean dining area and rest rooms. Great option for lunch read more

See all

Very good subs. Service is awful. Takes forever to get your order. Single turkey sub took 30 minutes. I have not been here in a while because of the slow service. Thought I would give it a try again. No improvement read more

Great place! The staff are friendly. The sandwiches are fresh, yummy and delicious!!

I'm so happy Holly is back with her amazing hard working staff. I enjoyed the Saturday meatball sub deal $5.99 which is the deal of the century. Call and place your order this place was very busy. The menu offers a great selection of subs and salads. They also offer to go meals in the fridge next to beverages. As always the seating areas is clean and inviting. read more

Holly's Deli - Homemade meatballs, cheese, marinara sauce and a soft sub roll - Delis Near Me - West Dennis, Massachusetts

This was the worst food experience. We stopped at Holly's deli around 8:00am on a Friday on our way to West Dennis beach. It has tables and a tv if you wish to dine inside. It's a clean, older building that could use some updates. The gentleman behind the counter was very nice and quickly greeted us and took our order. I ordered a hummus wrap and my husband got a turkey wrap. My hummus wrap was gross. It was basically lettuce, a slice of tomato, avocado, and a sprinkling of sprouts in a damp, paper thin and tasteless wrap. The avocado had a weird taste and consistency. How do you make a hummus wrap and leave out the key ingredient? After forcing myself to take 3 bites I still didn't taste a hint of hummus. I threw it out. It was terrible. Either they are super stingy with their portions of hummus or he completely left it out. My husband's wrap was ok - he found the wrap itself to be a weird consistency and super thin. For my meal alone I'd like to give this place one star but I'll be very generous and give them 2. read more

See all

Is it the 1950s? I think it is at Holly's Deli. Tried the cheesesteak without ordering the extra $1 onions and peppers. Great roll. Lots of steak and cheese. You order, you wait and wait some more, then voila--a tasty hot sandwich to go. Lots of nice baked goods and their refrigerated prepared chicken parm and lasagna looked quite good. Will try their lobster roll next time. read more

See all

Make sure you check the Facebook site for daily specials. That said the reuben was amazing. They do have prepped meals for dinner. I tried the speghetti and it was okay. But the sandwhiches they make are awesome. read more

I came in very cute little place never been wanted a quick bit to eat before going back to work I ordered a turkey stuffing sandwich very delious only one there and it took the kid 20 mins to make the sandwich he wasn't friendly but i was surprised it took him that long to make a sandwich but again the sandwich was delicious read more

We stumbled on this lunch spot and ordered the 1/2 sandwich and soup combo! Excellent quality food was provided. Sandwiches were excellent and fresh ingredients. Haddock chowder was tasty and flavorful but a little lacking of fish and potatoes. Perhaps it was at the end of the batch. The atmosphere is a cross between a diner and store but spacious and clean. Overall, we really enjoyed this stop and appreciate the great service. We would definitely return! read more

Holly's has great sandwiches and subs. Nice people and a variety of things to choose from. Would recommend picking up to go orders. I think my biggest pain point with Hollys is the fact that their website is on Facebook. It's just not a website when people who don't use Facebook can't see it!! read more

On Saturdays they have meatball subs for $5 you can't beat it for the price, the place has a small Hometown feel to it

The prepared foods are a little pricey but delicious! We just love both the macaroni and potato salads. We think they are the best in the area. We had the chicken pot pie tonight and it was very good. Our favorite is the American chop suey! We get at least two full meals for two out of the one larger pan. They have a wonderful variety of prepared foods. Sandwiches and cold cuts are also available. read more

Fast service, fair prices, great lunch. They load up their subs w meat. We got Italian mix, chicken cutlet sandwich, and turkey subs. All excellent. read more

Picked up a couple of six ounce lobster rolls. They were delicious. The bun was toasted and was jam packed with lobster meat. The price was very reasonable for how much lobster meat was packed into the roll. I This was my first lobster roll of the season and it did not disappoint read more

This is the best cheesesteak I've ever had!!! Worth the 25 min wait! I would wait in a 1 hour line for this places s&c . I'm fat and have eaten 100's of these and know my stuff! My gf got the Gobla type thanksgiving sub and she loved it. read more

The Thanksgiving sandwich on a wrap is amazing! It's my once a week treat! Never had anything here to wasn't yummy.

hollys is a must in the cape, by far the best thanksgiving sandwich i've ever had! highly recommend read more

Holly's Deli - thanksgiving sandwich - Delis Near Me - West Dennis, Massachusetts

A great sandwich and excellent service. Always find Holly's a go to place in Dennis.

I went to Holly's for the first time on a late April Friday for lunch around 12:30. I was very, very pleased with my experience there. Even though I was doing take out, the restaurant is large and spacious and if I had wanted to dine there, I would have been comfortable. It's informal, with ordering at the counter. Service was good and very efficient. When I was there, they were having a very busy lunch "rush", but the three people working behind the counter were calm and focused, and I was impressed by the operation. I watched as the chef appeared to take great care with each order she prepared. My lunch was definitely worth the relatively brief wait. I ordered their Guacamole sandwich which was grilled and included my choice of bread, three types of melted cheese, tomato, and a generous portion of freshly sliced avocado. It was absolutely delicious and was exactly what I had been craving. I drove to a nearby beach and enjoyed a perfect view overlooking beautiful, peaceful Nantucket Sound. When I first entered Holly's Deli, I was greeted by their large refrigerated case filled with prepared foods and meals to go. Very impressive assortment that included stuffed shells, stuffed bell peppers, ham salad, chicken salad, egg salad, American chop suey, macaroni and cheese, and many more. All sorts of "comfort food offered at reasonable prices. Additionally, they have a variety of fresh bakery items like muffins, cookies, brownies, sweet loafs, Whoopie pies, etc. I very much look forward to my next trip to Holly's. P.S. credit cards are accepted; however, gratuities can't be added to credit card payment, so bring cash for the tip ;) read more

They are meatballs subs on Saturday are out of this world. Everything is delicious there can't go wrong.

It's counter service with a strong local/regular feel... don't go for the atmosphere. The 9 oz lobster roll was excellent. Was large enough to split, then shared half of a steak and cheese, which was very good too (splurge for the peppers and onions!). Solid offerings on the menu and the prices are very fair. Mid-summer, Mid-week, mid afternoon visit. A long wait for lunch, but was worth it. read more

Yup, the pastrami sandwich is my fave, then the steak n cheese. Will definitely return cause want to try their take n bake stuffed shells. The eating area is clean and the ladies room is too. True deli vibe. read more

Great local shop with good food and great prices. Prepared food for heat and eat is great as well.

What a marvelous little place. We stopped by on my way to see my mom and wanted a quick bite. We had a couple of fresh made sandwiches and the clam chowder. Every thing was spot on tasty and fresh. they were having problems with one of the coolers so the drinks weren't cold, but they told be up front, so I have no problem with there service. In the freezer case they have meals prepped and ready to go for a quick fix it dinner if you need it. Everything looked fantastic. I love little places like this, people who take pride in what they do and try to make you feel at home. Well done all around. read more

Holly's Deli - Yummy sandwiches also take and bake meals - Delis Near Me - West Dennis, Massachusetts

This place is a definite go to. Sandwiches are varied and delicious with all fresh ingredients. Her prepared meals, especially the Italian ones are almost as good as mine and a whole lot easier to cook! Along with her homemade desserts this is a great lunch stop. More of a sandwich shop but there are a few tables for eat in. read more

Great food, mediocre service, and be prepared to wait, wait, wait. Even pre-covid the service was slow, now it's a crawl. There's no apparent organization to the kitchen and the attitude is they really don't care that you have a limited amount of time to get lunch and get back to work. 25+ mins to wait for a sandwich is unacceptable. read more

Solid spot for sandwiches. Long wait during rush. Big menu . Turkey club was packed. . read more

Wow! You would not expect this place to be as good as it is! It's a little old but they have great prices and great sandwiches! Expect a little wait if you place an order there but it's WORTH IT! I got a lobster roll. For this day, the 6oz was $25 and the 9oz was $30. Decent prices and delicious food! Had people asking me where to get it while on the beach and happily sent them to Holly's! Definitely will be back! read more

I always heard a lot of good things about Holly's and finally had the opportunity to give it a try. The prices are reasonable and I submitted two orders - one for a pocket and another for a sandwich on a sub roll. The pocket was not made according to what was requested but honestly they sounded busy when I called. It was also not filled well and had a lot of empty space. The sub was made correctly but the bread did not appear fresh as it crumbled into small pieces while eating it. The potato salad was decent and the container was filled. Overall Holly's has reasonable prices and I would give them another try before crossing them off my list. read more

This place is a hidden gem! I've driven by it a million times and didn't realize what I was missing. I have tried the breakfast sandwich and a chicken cesar wrap (enjoyed on the beach a few hours after ordering) both perfect. Definitely using fresh and high quality ingredients. They do just about everything you'd expect at a deli. I haven't tried it, but the lobster rolls are always flying out of the place making me think they must be really good (I'll be going back soon to find out!). They are busy at lunch times in particular and have a relatively small team so in person orders will take time, if your not in a hurry there is plenty of space to wait but if you can't hang out for ~10 min or so I'd recommend calling ahead. read more

Their lobster rolls are extraordinarily good. SUCH A GENEROUS portion and legitimately delicious. They toast and butter the bun which is such a perfect slightly crunchy and salty complement to the cold lobster. Would highly highly recommend. read more

Tried out the 6 ounce lobster roll, super yummy! I had the cold lobster roll and it was perfect, not too much Mayo! Make sure to request hot or cold, not sure if both options are offered. Kind employees too. read more

My wife and I tried out Holly's Deli for lunch today. She had the Reuben and I had the All American Burger. Oh, and I ordered a cup of clam chowder. And we were both very pleasantly surprised. The place is still laid out like it was last year when it was still Krista K's. So, it doesn't look fancy. But, the food is hot, delicious, and tasty. And the prices were reasonable. It has tables, indoors and outdoors, making this a great spot to grab lunch. We're adding it to our list of places to eat when we are visiting Cape Cod. And we'll recommend it to family members who visit, too. read more

Holly's Deli - Chowder and All American Burger (in the foreground) and Reuben (in the background). - Delis Near Me - West Dennis, Massachusetts

Very fresh!!! They have a wide assortment of chips, drinks, premade food and desserts and a large sandwich menu to decide from. Made to order. And not super expensive!!! Love this place. read more

We heard about this place and was told to us it was great. But we found it to be poorly ran, and not up to standards. It took over 35 minutes for 2 basic sandwiches. As we watched the woman making them, we noticed, even though she was wearing, it was below her nose. I guess she thinks the virus only transmit through her mouth. Also , as we were waiting, we counted 18 - 21 missed calls of other people wanting to give her business, but they could of cared less. I guess they don't need the money or the business during these hard economic times. read more

Saw a sign for 12.99 lobster rolls. Decided to stop. Amazing lobster sandwich. Quick service. 6oz of lobster seemed like 8 and the lobster was allowed to stand out as the star in this lightly buttered roll. 10/10 will be back again. read more

Nice people and ultimately solid food. But two complaints here. One, holy crap was this place slow. We walked in at 1140 AM. It probably took us 20+ minutes before we made it to the counter and there were only 2-3 parties online in front of us. And then, I kid you not, it took 35 minutes before we walked out with four basic sandwiches, all of which were ordered from their "featured sandwiches" menu. An hour to walk out with four sandwiches is ... nuts. The second complaint may be a matter of preference, but we ordered two "roast turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing" sandwiches. The whole Thanksgiving on a roll concept is great and done lots of places. But if it's advertised as roast turkey, I've only ever had it with, you know, roast turkey, as opposed to the mountain of sliced deli turkey on these sandwiches. I give three stars for friendly service, and the roast beef and chicken parm sandwiches we got were solid. But if you, like me, are leaving the cape and looking to grab and go, look elsewhere. read more

From all of the reviews here I do not see what the fuss is all about. Maybe it is better to dine in or pick different sandwiches that what we had but who knows. I had the chicken parmesian. It was one of the smallest I have ever had. It tasted decent except that the red sauce was somewhat bland. There was not lots of chicken on it either. My wife had the chicken salad sandwich and thought pretty much the same. Decent and not very hearty. Oh well. read more

I never thought I'd find the best meatball sub I ever had on Cape Cod. But Holly's takes the crown.