Felicia with Sift Cakery is amazing! She did an absolutely amazing job with the cupcakes and the…read moretwo tier cake. The cake was impeccable and everything was so delicious. She made an incredible gluten free options that were every bit as delicious as the non-GF options. She delivered the cake and set everything up to perfection.

From the owner: Custom Designed Wedding Cakes- Based in the Hocking Hills in Logan, Ohio, Sift Cakery specializes…read morein creating beautiful and delicious wedding cakes. Owner Felicia Dodge is a formally trained chef and event planner, and has earned degrees in both culinary arts and baking. With a passion for customer service and over 20 years of experience, Felicia takes the time to offer her clients a fully personalized, tailored experience from beginning to end. Whether it’s a classic collection of cupcakes, a simple buttercream wedding cake, or a tiered work of art, she is here for you. Request a consultation to start planning your custom wedding cake today! Service areas include: Lancaster, OH; Logan, OH; Athens, OH; the Hocking Hills and surrounding area

I'm so thankful that I found a local cake artist and baker whose prices were reasonable and whose…read morework was so spectacular. Even better, it was DELICIOUS. I've had issues before with cake artists and bakers whose work wasn't very good when they delivered it and whose cake and icing/fondant tasted horrible. I was SUPER pleased with how beautiful my cake was and how big it was! I was especially happy when my family and I ate the cake and it was delicious. We loved it and were so happy that it delivered on taste and appearance. I also commend her communication with me and with answering my questions and meeting the deadline I set as well as adding in the additional details I wanted. It was all a wonderful experience and I couldn't be more happy with it!!! If I could give this business 10 stars, I would. Would definitely recommend and will definitely use again!! Thank you!!

I'd followed this bakery on social media for a long time and they posted the cutest cutout cookies…read moreso I stopped in and bought a dozen +1 for me--the dozen being for a meeting I was attending later. They had a great inventory and I was waited on quickly. I got in the car and broke into the bag with the single cookie...big bite and OMG, this is perhaps the worst cookie I have ever tasted. I spit the bite out into the bag and deposited the dozen in my trash as I went in my house to find another treat to take to my meeting. I'll never go back.

Beautiful and delectable treats from this locally owned business! Our go-to for every special…read moreoccasion. The cake and cupcakes for our son's wedding were beautiful and delicious! Some favorites: Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes (okay - ALL the cupcakes!) Cake pops almost too cute to eat Cinnamon rolls like Grandma made The most perfect buttercream frosting.

The best cranberry scones I've EVER had! Please give Lisa's a try you won't be disappointed!read more

Absolutely amazing. Everything they make. Tastes like a slice of heaven, although high potential of…read morebeing addicting.... These treats are well worth the calories!!!!

Pattycake Bakery was great to work with on the design of my son's smash cake! It's exactly what I…read morehad envisioned and not only did it look awesome, it was one of the best cakes I've ever tasted!

Adorable bakery, super friendly to food allergies being vegan, nut free, soy free and with plenty…read moreof gluten free options as well. I got a blueberry muffin and an orange sticky bun. We picked out a cake to go for my birthday, were provided with detailed instructions for how to best keep the cake good for a few days.

Just realized it's been 5 years since my last review so I thought I'd give an update one. First and…read moreforemost I've been coming here since I was kid and I know this bakery very well. Our Order: A bakers dozen (for a family get together) 2 jelly filled, 2 honey glazed, 2 apple fritters, and 6 white iced cream filled donuts. Execution of Our Order: Every donut was made fresh that morning. All the donuts got outstanding reviews from those who ate them. I absolutely love their donuts they were flaky, sweet, and tasted amazing. Seating: There are no seats here you will have to take the goodies to go. Staff and Services: Staff are always sweet and very welcoming. Their also very helpful if your not quite sure what you might want or if you wanna try something new. Drink Menu: They don't serve drinks here Food Menu: They have a very nice sized displays with multiple options. There is something for everyone here. They even have vegan options. Prices: $ Cleanliness: The establishment is always super clean Ombiance: Quiet and relaxed Overall Experience: Amazing Rating: 10/10 Recommendation: I definitely recommend if you're in it near circleville to come visit this amazing bakery you will not be disappointed. Family Friendly: Absolutely Stroller/Wheelchair Friendly: Yes

I can't believe I forgot to review this AMAZING place when I noticed the photos on my phone…read more I went during the pumpkin show and my advise is to go early or not during the show because in my photo, you'll see a big line wraps out the door and down a long ways. Worth the wait, though. Amazing doughnuts that are so soft and makes you wanna eat a full dozen before you leave.

I can't remember how I found her, but I'm so glad I did. Kelly made my wedding cake AND a…read moregorgeous, detailed groom's cake for me. She was willing to do a "fake layer" to help keep cost down and said she could do just about anything I wanted. I'm not a big "sweets" person, but after the first tasting, I kept thinking and dreaming about that cake. And the chocolate frosting--you can taste the cocoa. The groom's cake was a replica of Neyland Stadium, and the level of detail was amazing. Everyone at the wedding was impressed with the look and taste of both cakes. I will definitely be contacting her for other special occasions. Her prices are very reasonable and she took the time to listen to what I wanted. Highly recommend. I will post pics when I get the chance!

Kelly's Cakery is simply delicious! I've had the pleasure of enjoying her cupcakes on several…read moreoccasions and have yet to be disappointed. The cake is wonderfully moist and the buttercream icing is rich but I could eat it by the spoonful.

I always feel bad posting reviews for bakeries because I'm not big on sweets. But nevertheless,…read morehere is my review of the place and the cream puff. The place is clean, cute and nicely decorated with some fun stuff for kids to play. There is plenty of parking right outside and the lady in the store was friendly and helpful. Unfortunately, there weren't many thing on display, which, to me, is a part of the fun of visiting bakeries. Cream puff was nice and big and heavy! LOVED the outside crust-flavorful, crunchy, airy and yum! The custard wasn't too sweet and you can taste the good egg flavor. It was really good and I would buy it again, though I wish there was a bit less custard. I had to leave some over because it was too much. However, maybe I felt that it was too much because I'm not a big dessert person. You might find it a balanced ratio, but either way, worth the try!

We were in desperate need of a birthday cake at short notice. I like to use local (not grocery…read morestore chains) when it comes to baked goods and called Friday for a cake to pick up Saturday. They were very accommodating over the phone and the cake was picked up at the appointed time which was terrific. Unfortunately I was very disappointed in the product. The appearance and taste of it was very amateurish, frankly I could've done better myself and I was actually surprised that a professional would have allowed it to leave the bakery. I will return and try their pies and other products before I completely write them off, but would never order another cake from them.

Cake Tasting Cake included the following: * Chocolate…read more* White Almond * Red Velvet * Vanilla * Small Water Bottles (2) * Forks (2) * Napkins The staff that gave us the cakes was pretty nice. Shauna was prompt with emails. Ambiance was of a typical boba/bakery place.

Cute shop, yummy cupcakes, and great friendly service!…read more I was driving through the area and decided to bring some cupcakes in for my parents. After a quick search I found High Five Cakes that was on my way. Upon arrival I found meter parking close by. The shop was crowded for a Sunday (always a good sign) and I was warmly greeted when I walked in. There was a variety of cupcakes in the display cases and I picked up 7 cupcakes (a box of 6 and 1 for the road). I selected the Confetti, Death by Chocolate, Coconut Cream Egg, Strawberry, and Sugar Cookie Dough. Price point is $3 a cupcake which is a higher price point than I pay at similar shops in my metro area but was worth it. Besides love supporting small businesses and it's a really nice little shop. High Five cakes have boba teas, macarons, and other treats as well. Definitely would recommend.

Great cookies Ordered for graduation party, it was quick…read moreand easy to order and they were nice and professional. Will definitely order again and recommend to others, thanks!