Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Hickman Bar & Grill

    4.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed

    Hickman Bar & Grill Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Hickman Bar & Grill

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of David K.
    193
    104
    28

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Hickman Bar & Grill

    You might also consider

    West Sports Bar - Steak Philly wit cheese

    West Sports Bar

    3.0(27 reviews)
    1.2 mi
    $

    The 3 of us ordered salmon with a bourbon BBQ glaze. It came with broccoli and rice…read more The salmon was overcooked and the glaze was all over the plate. The rice and broccoli was swimming in the glaze and therefore tasted like it. We also order zucchini planks. They were well presented but were way too salty and I like salt! It was noisy as happy hour was going on. We had hope to be in the dining area which has an outdoor dining area. Our server was efficient and very nice. That was the only thing good about the experience. The 2 people I brought were unimpressed and said they won't be back. I will as I know the salads and sandwiches offer some good choices.

    Choose another place! Ambiance is five star for sports fans yes. Place was freezing inside, most…read moreof us ate with our coats on. Service? Well our waitress was funny and seemed adorable. We tipped her well. Our food, yes we had eight people with simple orders but over AN HOUR wait? The restaurant was empty and bar had 4 people drinking beer. I mean not one person eating in restaurant area. While waiting AFTER we ordered approx 4 other families came in, ordered, got drinks, got soup and salads, then food... then our food came. None I mean none of our food was served warm. How sad. This is bar food...That's my pet peeve. My dad's fish was so well done that it was black and he couldn't break it in half with his hands hardly, the worst ever. We couldn't understand HOW COULD the COOK send it out like that ??? So dad got to watch us all eat. When we were done, his came out. Nope, NEVER Again. We went out of our way to go there. So disappointed. I chose the place for my dads and sisters birthday celebration - HUGE mistake.

    Photos
    West Sports Bar - Cheese Fries with Bacon

    Cheese Fries with Bacon

    West Sports Bar - Fried pickles were excellent!

    Fried pickles were excellent!

    West Sports Bar - Rib and tenders basket - only $14.95. Really good.

    See all

    Rib and tenders basket - only $14.95. Really good.

    Trace Chophouse

    Trace Chophouse

    4.8(15 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    When AI tells you the best steakhouse in the area is the Chophouse at Oglebay Resort, you have to…read morecheck it out! We were not misled. Danielle was our server and Matt the manager. Service was a 10+! Danielle was excellent and Matt checked on us during our dinner. The food was outstanding. We had the Lollipop lamb for an appetizer, omg they were the BEST lamb pops I have ever had. We ate half so we could snack on them the next day in our car ride to PA. Just finished them off and again, we were delighted how delicious they were cold the next day. I need to comment on the bread also. My husband doesn't even eat or like bread. He had a piece of bread last night and said it was the best bread he had ever had. And where on heavens earth did that butter come from?? I think I could just eat that by the spoonful. Best butter ever!! He had the sirloin steak with the mushrooms and it was very good. I had a filet and it was tender and perfectly cooked. We ordered the mushroom risotto and it was delicious. The table next to us had lobster mac n cheese and i had been torn between those two. The mac n cheese looked amazing too. Loved the risotto, not over or undercooked, creamy and delicious. Almost tasted like some truffle oil could have been in there but maybe that was just the mushrooms. I had the old fashioned and it was smoked and delicious! We each had a glass of Earthquake cabernet also. There was only 1 wine per wine type that you could order by the glass. More choices of wines by the glass would have been nice, but it was a nice glass of wine. I really need to know what kind of butter was that?? Wow! Excellent meal and service! Thank you Oglebay Resort! Trace Chophouse is definitely tops!

    From the moment we were greeted to the sweet lemon chocolates at the end of the evening we couldn't…read morehave been more satisfied. Both Matt the host and our server were fantastic! We ordered filet mignon and they were both cooked to perfection, tender, and juicy. The atmosphere was romantic and classy.

    Photos
    Trace Chophouse
    Trace Chophouse
    Trace Chophouse

    See all

    Hickman Bar & Grill - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...