My husband and I ate at Heirloom for the first time earlier this month. It came highly recommended for serving southern comfort food with a big city twist. The recommendation was well deserved, because we both loved the food, service, and atmosphere. And, the prices were very reasonable for the quality that we received - we were pleasantly surprised, considering the food was terrific and we both left so stuffed we could barely walk (thanks to the southern comfort aspect!).
The restaurant is tiny (so reservations are almost requisite), and it is snugly situated in picturesque historic Midway (quaint and home to some of the most beautiful scenery in the Bluegrass State). The interior is very nice and reflects a more upscale dining experience (but seemed kind of lackluster to me, since the hearty but gourmet food itself and the natural beauty of Midway outshines any big city trappings).
Our server was a very sweet girl who gave just enough personalized attention without overdoing it. She was familiar with the food preparation and answered all of our questions accordingly (i.e., I'm not a big fan of servers who don't know anything about the menu, or who assert unhelpful comments like "I don't like fish so I don't know"). We both had salads: I had the warm spinach salad and my husband had the roasted beet salad. We loved my warm spinach salad, which was pungent with vinegar and creamy goat cheese - and it was HUGE. We could have easily split the salad. We also shared the crab cake with "sweet corn veloute, avocado, corn-cotija salad, sriracha honey." This appetizer was heavenly - the velvety sauce under the tender, golden crab cake was addictive - I ate it with a spoon! And the crisp sweet corn was just a lovely touch of texture. My husband isn't a fan of crab cakes (madness, I know) and he loved the dish as well.
For entrees, he ordered the filet mignon with a veal glaze, and I had beef short rib on grits topped with a jicama slaw. I don't see either dish still on the menu, which is a travesty! They were both sexily prepared and throw-your-hands-up-and-holler delicious! My husband's steak was perfectly cooked and the veal glaze topping it was just ridiculous. And I loved my dish: the meat was fall-off-the-bone tender, the grits were luscious (I love me some grits, and loved that they made an appearance on a 'fancy' menu) and the jicama slaw was a perfect and crunchy topping. I truly hope that these entrees will make a reappearance again, because we fully intend to return Heirloom!
Our sweet server also had the chef special prepare me an Irish coffee upon my request (something they don't normally have on the menu), since we were both so stuffed - we couldn't finish our entrees or have dessert - and I didn't think I'd make it home without a jolt of caffeine. The Irish coffee was perfect, and the chef had hand-whipped some cream on the spot (they should seriously put this permanently on the menu, as my man did a good job improvising). The final check (glass of wine, Irish coffee, two salads, appetizer and two entrees) was about $120 - very reasonable, considering we have spent that much per person in Cincinnati alone. And, we both agreed that Heirloom easily rivals any of the big city restaurants we've dined at...and, I'll say it, for the price, quality and portion sizes, I think Heirloom trumps my favorite fine-dining Cincinnati restaurant, Boca (gasp!). We definitely found a new favorite and will return the next time we want to splurge a bit. read more