Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Headwaters Tavern

    4.5 (2 reviews)

    Headwaters Tavern Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Headwaters Tavern

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Yo O.
    2
    93
    69

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Brickhouse 40

    Brickhouse 40

    4.0
    (380 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $$

    This was probably some of the best service i've ever had at a restaurant. We quickly got seated and…read morewe were quickly greeted with our server, Marie. I'm telling you, she was the SWEETEST server. This was our last day of vacation, and she definitely left us on a high note. Our food took about 25 ish minutes. And it was sooooooo good. And my family also said they really liked their food. And to add to that, their dessert was delicious. Also, the temperature in there was perfect. Not too cold, not too hot. Thank you so much!

    Where do I even begin??? First off it says reservations are suggested. Absolutely FALSE! It's not…read morethat good and there were plenty of seats. You could even sit at the bar......if you wanted to get sucked into a conversation with a middle aged man that was drunk, baseball hat bill flipped up like he's 18. Oh yeah and he's recently divorced. How do I know all this???? Because he was louder that SHIT, drunk and seated 40' away from me. None of the staff told him to quiet down, NOPE, just kept serving him mimosas. Know I know why he was divorced. Good for the ex-wife!!! Let's get to our waitress.....Marie. Holy hell! She came over and took our drink order, probably high! We ordered drinks and she forgot about us. It took 20 minutes for us to get our drinks and they were delivered by the busboy. She came back 10 minutes after we got our drinks and said....."where did we leave off?" Are you FU@KING KIDDING ME???? Once we reminded the stoner that all we have is drinks and we were ready to order she pulled out her digital ordering pad. First thing we ordered they were out of. Great, she even recommended it? I'm thinking to myself, how the hell did we land the female Spicoli as our waitress??? Shit! Whatever we order, she ain't getting it right. Meanwhile the two tables around us are verbally getting pissed about Stoner Marie's lack of memory. Let's just say the food was ok, service was HORRIBLE. Don't waste your time. Not work the money!!!!!!

    Photos
    The bar is a great option if there are no tables.
    The bar is a great option if there are no tables.
    Wings and fries
    Wings and fries
    Burger

    See all

    Burger
    Maverick's Grille

    Maverick's Grille

    4.0
    (294 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $$

    NOT ONLY IS MAVERICKS AMAZING WITH AWARD WINNING GREEN CHILE but they also have the best waitress…read moreever, ATHENA!!! We got seated in a nice quiet area around 7pm on a Sat; I just wanted to try the world famous Green Chile and Rocky Mountain Oysters which did not disappoint!! Ask for extra sour cream if the green chile is spicy but I thought it was amazing as it is! Rocky Mountain Oysters were deliciously creamy and crispy. Loved that Mavericks has rotating local draft beers so definitely ask for what they have on tap. Athena was really attentive and gave us great suggestions for us to explore Rocky Mountain National Park, Granby and other sight seeing highlights. We topped off the night with her favorite dessert recomemdation; bourbon pecan pie with ice cream!! Absolutely delicious!! Thank you Athena, Mavericks and Granby for making our first day in CO such a wonderful and memorable time! Love the cozy environment, decor and very easy parking.

    Burgers were actually decent, but my party of 5 got all of their burgers at different times. One…read moreburger took an additional 20 minutes than everyone else's. From sit down to orders being brought out was over an hour. And in that time our order of chicken wings came out but they were ice cold. Imagine waiting an hour for food to be served cold. I'd avoid this place. Service was bad as well, in the hour that we were here we got one refill. Sorry for any typos, I'm a little dehydrated typing this up.

    Photos
    Decor
    Decor
    1/2 lb Bacon Cheese burger.
    1/2 lb Bacon Cheese burger.
    Rocky mountain oysters

    See all

    Rocky mountain oysters
    Grand Pizza

    Grand Pizza

    4.3
    (181 reviews)
    13.6 mi
    $$

    This is a tricky one to rate. Yes, the pizza was very good, but the price for pizza felt a little…read morehigh, even considering the location. As I took our pizzas to go, I have no opinion about the service itself. Ordering at the front desk was easy enough. No issues there! From looking at the place, it is a bit small. Nothing too fancy. Honestly, seems a bit dingy. I was happy with our decision to take it to go so we could enjoy being outside on a great Grand Lake day. We got a cheese pizza (14", $21) and the pesto chicken specialty pizza (16", $36.70). Both were very tasty and not overly greasy. The dough is very soft with the appropriate amount of chew--very dangerous as it was so yummy! They didn't skimp on the toppings, too. So, overall, it is a very good pizza. The value proposition here, though, is tough. There's a sliding scale of pizza value, and I think this ends a bit on the expensive side, even when making considerations for location. At the same time, I do think this is the best pizza you can get in the area. You just don't have many, quality options in this area, so the lack of competition might be keeping the prices higher here (not to mention it being a mountain town). I would come back here after trying other food in town.

    Greetings While visiting beautiful Grand Lake we ate at…read moreGrand Pizza twice because it was so good. We ordered the large Antipasto salad and it was so fresh and crunchy. This is a big salad be warned. We ordered a 14 inch pizza the first visit and a 12 the second, these pies are well dressed with the toppings of your choosing and baked perfectly. The manager Kelsey was very nice,cheerful, attentive to her customers. Our server was also wonderful. The atmosphere is typical of a pizza restaurant but, I was there to eat and not critique their ambience. If you're in Grand Lake and hungry stop on in and enjoy.

    Photos
    Entrance
    Entrance
    Standard pizza has amazing crust, just be sure to add some honey when it's hot
    Standard pizza has amazing crust, just be sure to add some honey when it's hot
    Colorful and tasty pizza. Could use a little longer time in the oven as the bottom crust was doughy.

    See all

    Colorful and tasty pizza. Could use a little longer time in the oven as the bottom crust was doughy.
    White Buffalo Pizza

    White Buffalo Pizza

    3.6
    (96 reviews)
    13.5 mi
    $$

    When you pay $47 for a pizza, you expect it to be at least somewhat decent. I should have read the…read moreother reviews first because my experience was almost identical to theirs. I was told 15 to 20 minutes and arrived right at the 20 minute mark, but it was obvious the pizza had been sitting there much longer. It was served up ice cold. Even the dollops of ricotta tasted like they were added after the pizza was made, straight from the refrigerator. I am not exaggerating when I say ice cold, despite parts of the pizza being burnt. The edges of the crust were burnt, not in a good wood fired way with flavor, but just hard, overcooked, and inedible. While the toppings were generous, the pizza itself was extremely dry, just like others have mentioned. As I waited, I could see into the kitchen and noticed they were using pre made crusts, basically the kind you would grab at a grocery store when you do not feel like making your own. Charging $47 for that? No thanks. I hate wasting food, but we could not even finish this pizza. It was that bad. That is on me for not checking reviews beforehand. We should have just stuck with our usual spot, Grand Pizza, which happened to be closed for mud season. The difference in quality is night and day. I just want to warn others before they make the same mistake and waste their money like I did. Definitely will not be back.

    Our food had great flavors and the salad was fresh and crunchy. Bar with canned beers and good…read moreselection! It's nice to slow ourselves down and eat somewhere good and local. Local food is always worth the wait! Good music too!

    Photos
    White Buffalo Pizza
    Fried Ravioli
    Fried Ravioli
    White Buffalo Pizza

    See all

    Headwaters Tavern - desserts - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...