The first time I drove my car after Hank May's did work on its engine, my car caught fire and burned to a point of being totaled. It is out of sheer luck alone that the fire did not harm my children, or burn down our home. Not only would I recommend avoiding Hank May's for any work involving a car's engine, I would avoid Hank May's at all costs.
Details
The Car:
It was a 2004 Audi allroad 2.7T manual transmission, with 175k miles. While older, this car (nor any Audi's that I'm aware of) has no history of spontaneously catching on fire. Besides a check engine light, it was in otherwise perfect working order for an older car.
The Work Done by Hank May's:
In order to pass an emissions test as a new CT resident, Hank May's said they needed to replace the car's PCV valve. Two days later they said it was ready for pickup, and recommended I drive it for three days on the highway, then bring back to pass inspection. I drove the car a very short distance back home (less than 10min, no highways) with no issue.
The Incident:
The next time I drove the car was two days after it was picked up. I drove to get my children from their grandmother's, an hour drive including highway miles. I picked them up and drove to a nearby playground. About 30 minutes after exiting the car, I noticed smoke coming from the parking lot. As I walked back, I saw dark smoke coming out from underneath, and from the hood of my car. Within another minute there were flames, and as I was on the phone with the police, the entire front end of my car became engulfed in flames. The local fire department came to put out the fire. Luckily there were no other cars around, and no one was injured, but that is simply sheer luck. A police and fire report were filed.
Hank May's Response:
When I informed Hank May's of the event, I spoke to their manager. As I described the incident, the manager provided an unsolicited opinion that, given the job that was done, it was likely an electrical issue that caused the fire.
At that meeting, I gave Hank May's an itemized list of expenses for what it cost me to get back to driving a car again, and let them know I expected to be reimbursed. I was not seeking a new car, simply for them to cover the expenses that I never would have had to incur if my car did not burn down. Over the phone, the business owner said she would, "Do the right thing to make up for this unfortunate incident."
What that entailed was having their insurance company do an investigation. The insurer concluded the fire, "...originated in the left front area of the vehicle, where the electrical components are situated...was not related to the workmanship performed by the insured."
This conclusion directly conflicts with the shop's manager who suggested that if the work was not done right, that an electrical issue could have caused the fire.
Hank May's provided a refund for the work they did, and in doing so made sure not to admit they did anything wrong.
The Facts:
This car had never caught on fire in the past. These cars have no history of catching on fire. The very first time the car was driven on a highway, two days after being serviced for the first time by Hank May's, it became engulfed in flames as my children watched in shock. Hank May's own manager suggested that if the work was not done properly, an electrical issue could have caused a fire. This is exactly what the insurer says caused the fire, yet they concluded it was unrelated to the work done, and Hank May's was not legally responsible.
The What Ifs:
It was out of sheer luck alone that my children (8&10) and were not in the car when the fire started. We could have just as easily been stuck in traffic on I-95 when the flames broke out. Even worse, we could have come home, parked and gone to bed, only to have our house slowly catch fire with us all inside, asleep. It is only out of sheer luck that this event, following a visit to Hank May's, did not kill a young family. That sounds dramatic, but both scenarios were entirely possible.
Conclusion:
Given my experience, I would not trust Hank May's Discount Tire & Auto to do any engine-related work on a car. The owner can point to the insurance company's investigation to say, that while unfortunate, Hank May's had nothing to do with this event, and that I am upset. Yes, I am upset, but that does not change the facts of the incident. The only thing I have to gain from this review is to protect consumers from this business. I will be filing a complaint with the BBB, and informing the CT DMV of the details of the event. read more