This place always seems to have whatever I need. I'm not the most comfortable person in hardware…read morestores, and often have a hard time describing what I need, but somehow they're always able to help me! Over the years I've gotten screws, hooks, sink pipes, and basically every supply I needed for painting my hallway and bedroom. They're really friendly, helpful and attentive. Most of my trips in are usually 5 mins or less, they're that good!

Was super helpful and found everything I needed in less than 2 minutes…read more Purchased: packing Tape Rubber Hammer

Thanks Brithers Hardware! I was in a pinch and you carried exactly what I needed. You have all…read morethe essentials to keep someone working.

Jimmy went out of his way to help me solve my problem! In a city where customer service is all but…read moredead, it's nice to know that there's a place that still seeks to treat the customer like more than a dollar sign. I'll be spending my money here from now on. Even if it means braving midtown.

Was looking for a key kiosk. I had search 10min on Google & Yelp for nearest key kiosk, rite aid…read morewith kiosk, home depot, and local key locksmiths. Found a place and follow directions to a place that no longer have key copy it closed during Covid. Someone pointed out the hardware store across the street- Lucky! Great service and good pricing. Is cheaper than Rite Aid Key Kiosk.

Price gauging animals, should be called schemers and grant. Stay away from here !!! They are rude…read moreand their prices are insane. I will never shop here again.

Had to get copies of my apt keys made, which are hard to copy (could never get it done at Home…read moreDepot with their automated machine). They were able to make the copy right away for $10 per key. Little pricey, but cheaper than a locksmith if I got locked out. Guy was pretty nice as well.

Went to get duplicate keys made for my apartment. Was in and out in 20 mins. Everything I could ask…read morefor from a hardware store.

Extremely reasonable prices, excellent quality key copying, highly recommend recommended.read more

This was the best locksmith I could find. Their prices were reasonable, and their service was…read moreexcellent.

We are so lucky to have Garden Hardware and Supply right around the corner. So helpful and…read morefriendly. These brick and mortar stores are gems in each and every neighborhood and should always be visited before ordering something online that will take 3-4 days to arrive and 9 times out of 10 have to be returned.

Best hardware store and people ever. This is my goto place for everything. I stop here first before…read moretrying any other venue. I always say to the wonderful, friendly, helpful, engaging owner: "You have everything." And he always responds: "Almost." His assistant is wonderful, resourceful, pleasant, responsive. Truly great place and experience. Everyone seems happy when they're there and when they're leaving cause they got what they came for and at a decent price.

I give Garber's Hardware four stars even though I find nothing negative about it. I went there…read moreyesterday on January 4, 2025 to get replacement screws for my computer office chair and the owner checked and found 'em. Cost was a very reasonable $3.45 for four screws! This is a dependable business in the West Village and so very needed.

Got what I wanted - a small, cheap, accurate thermometer that is suited for indicating the…read moretemperature in my apartment ... (so I know whether the landlord is sending the right amount of heat up). Not just that - it is a veritable antique : an object with a wood frame, a glass tube with mercury in it, .... and that's it! No batteries (requiring replacement), no inessential electronic gadgetry (radiating electromagnetic pollution) - just the basics : like, "What is the temperature here now?

The people there are nasty- short tempered and vile…read more Much of the merchandise is beyond the customers reach- you need staff to get it for you. And the staff is nasty. There are long waits at checkout- and a lot of attitude. On the upside it's open 24 hours a day.

Never experienced such rude and demeaning staff at a hardware store. I was laughed at and mocked by…read moremultiple staff members for a simple question.