Best authentic New York Pizza in AZ. One location, open 24 hours. Don't listen to the 2.5 star rating. Extremely misleading. Best ranch i've ever had, BTW. Amazing business. Thin, huge, delicious slices. Never disappoints. 10/10 read more

"SOME TASTY FOOD in TEMPE!" I really enjoyed their chicken pasta Alfredo And I saw others enjoy the gigantic 32inch pizza! For $40 bucks that's worth it if you can feed more than 10 people! Great place with great employees! And opened all night!!! I'll definitely be back. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

For 4AM pizza, and also eating it dead sober, this was VERY GOOD. It would be good any time of the day, but I'm especially impressed so late night. The size is huge and the ingredients taste fresh and it's clear the pizza was right out of the oven. I will definitely order again! I had the pizza delivered by door dash, so I have no idea what the ambiance is. But the service was quick and the food is delicious. So I'd give it a 5/5! read more

See all

It has been our family tradition for 35 years to go out for pizza on Christmas Eve, no matter where we've lived. We've been coming to Gus's on Christmas Eve the past few years because they are open 24/7. Not too many places are open late on Christmas Eve. The pizza is good enough and they sell a huge 32 inch pizza. It isn't fancy. Just regular booths, a self-service soda machine, and an order counter. There is a covered patio with several tables. There is a constant stream of people picking up pizzas and also sticking around and eating in house. The guys at the counter are nice. Gus's does the trick for us and has become our Christmas Eve place--first because of necessity because of the hours, and now because of tradition. It isn't artisan wood fired pizza, but it's good college-student-living-in-the-dorm pizza, and that's okay. read more

See all

Makes for a good quick stop, come in for quick pizza slice and choice of side, plenty area to sit dine in take out or delivery options. Service was friendly, Italian pizzeria vibes. Inside and outside seating. read more

See all

This place is a decent pizza shop! The slices are a good size! I usually only order out and when I do the pizza is usually fresh and comes out really good. Inside seems pretty decent actually and I wouldn't mind dining in one day. If you need pizza I'd definitely recommend this spot. It's not the BEST pizza I've ever had but it'll definitely hold you over read more

This pizza is subpar compared to other New York pizzerias in Tempe. Not only that, but they continue to slip pizza ads in my door even though there's a no soliciting sign. The last person that slipped a flier in the door was extremely rude. Will be putting up a no trespassing sign so next time I'll press charges. Can't recommend this place based off how they treat people and how their pizza isn't great. read more

So to begin the pizza is fantastic, although I bought a beer and wanted a soda with the same cup. no harm no foul but mr gus AKA the soda police said no to a free refill on soda. And then yelled at a guy just trying to get water. If you need help identifying mr gus, he is bald and short. If you want a free refill please be sneaky as he will detain you. P.S the other employees were super chill, even gave us free ranch without mr gus interrupting. read more

Came to Gus's with some friends and family after a late night of debauchery. Open 24 hours so its great for those late night hungers. Ordered multiple pizzas and they all were delicious. The chicken Wangs hit the spot too. If you can't finish they put premade boxes right next to the door. Workers seemed busy but attentive to your needs. read more

See all

After years of avoiding this chain, I am warming up to Gus's. It is not by any means the worst pizza in town. It is, more precisely, the most perfectly mid pizza ever made, with the appeal of being one of the last 24/7 businesses standing. You could convince me these huge, floppy slices have medicinal properties--have one before a night on the town and you will be protected from sugary, bottom shelf booze at nearby nightclubs. If you have room, pair it with one of their surprisingly good salads. It doesn't take long to get your food, and there's a bit of a sports bar vibe. This place will never be at the top of my list, but it's been so reliable for so long that I'm sure I'll be back! read more

Terrible customer service. Wouldn't be surprised if they closed down soon. The food is decent but not for the price and the atmosphere, pretty dirty even when there's only one or two costumers at night. read more

They make gigantic pizzas or you can just buy one slice. The crust is so good! Service is excellent and prices are good. We tried the Philly cheesesteak sandwich and it was great! read more

Great service and yummy giant pizza - If you can make a good giant pizza- you can certainly make good regular size pizzas. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Buffalo chicken and pepperoni 32 inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

This place was recommended by a colleague while we were here on a work trip. He had been here before and raved about it. It was decent. The pizza was good but the setting was crap. I love a hole in the wall, but this was a hole in the wall without the fun. The pizza, though - minimum size is a 14" so come hungry or come ready to split one with someone you love. The crust - chewy enough without being too doughy. The sauce - acidity of the tomatoes sweetened enough for a a good NY flavor. The toppings were well spread. Come here if hungry but don't expect great service or very cold beer. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Veggie Explosion Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

The food is good, but the customer service is very poor. They treat you like you're a burden, almost as if they hate being there. It's a good spot, but the service feels almost like prison treatment. The vibe is okay, but keep in mind it's located in the middle of ASU, so the atmosphere is usually very loud because of the college crowd. Like I said, the food is good, but I just hope they improve their customer service and overall attitude. If you're looking for a place where the staff makes you feel welcome and the food feels like it's made with love, this isn't the place for you. Sorry. read more

It's decent pizza but the 4/5 part is that I can order anything I want on my pizza and they make it, no complaints and they do a great job. Even with literally one or extra of everything they still get me a crispy buttery crust and great topping ratios. read more

Average Product, Pay with cash. My Card is still being charged even tho I haven't been there in 3 months . read more

The Greek salad with chicken is amazing, and the spaghetti is delicious! The pizza is mediocre but has lots of toppings! The garlic knots are too greasy and overcooked. All the breadsticks are absolutely disgusting with totally raw dough inside! read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Cheesy tomato bread - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

Went there for the very first time was in an Emergency room. We were really hungry and I was talking to the nurse telling him that we were from Philly and it's been really hard to find good Pizza So he told us about this place and he said it's Open 24 hours which that's crazy, It was like 12:30pm and we really don't eat late so we went over there and it was a couple people there. The service was great. The food was the bomb. I definitely liked the pizza. The only bad thing is that my Wife had to use the restroom and she said that it wasn't Clean...... but I figured it's late at night......They're Open 24 hours. They probably just didn't get a chance to get to it so I'm not gonna ding it so bad. But definitely that's a must because back where we're from if the bathroom is clean, the kitchen is clean! But I'll tell you one thing I'm definitely going back. The best Pizza since I've been in Arizona for six years read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Gus New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

They are deliberately trying to deceive you when you order online. Your ticket on the site will show the price, lets say a large pizza being 24.00, you click payment and it opens a payment window with a new price almost double, because get this, they charge $17 for delivery. NO THANK YOU read more

Best pizza ever. Came out fresh out the box, crispy undercarriage and hot gooey cheese. The toppings crop to perfection and ranch was the cherry on top. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Incredible spot. ESPECIALLY late night! Pizza is always top notch, service with a smile, what more can you ask for?

What a perfect place to go especially after a night of drinking it's great to know that they're open up late and the pizza is always fresh no matter what time you go. Not only did we get pizza we also got chicken wings we could've done without the chicken wings, so we wanted plain and they were extremely plain kind of lacking in seasoning but the pizza made up for it. Located right around the corner from the bars on Mill Avenue it's a spot you can't miss. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

I received Gus's pizza from my apartment complex. To my surprise I really liked the pizza. The slices are huge and delicious.

Great pizza and great service. It was cooked perfectly. I'm not a huge crust/bread person and the crust was amazing!!! Overall great experience. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Bronx Bomber Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Honestly I've never been at a restaurant that have such rude workers and screaming at me as a costumer please get new employees that don't scream at people. Not professional. read more

Full raw boneless chicken wings.. pizza was under done and had to cook at home too... waiting for the manager to call us back read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Raw chicken :/ - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

See all

Super Greasy Pizza If you're into greasy pizza, this place might be up your alley. Personally, I think the pizza is just okay--there are definitely better New York-style slices to be found in Tempe. That said, it's a solid option for a late-night order, and I'd choose it over the big pizza chains any day. However, if you're looking for the best pizza in town, you might want to keep exploring. read more

Perfect wings! Wonderfully seasoned and crispy. Dad said he hasn't had such excellent wings. Thanks Gus's New York Pizza!

Annoying solicitations constantly on the doors in our community. No one wants your awful food.

Picked this location as they are open 24 hours! Yes that is right! We were feeding a group of trademan a special lunch. This particular group gets up and starts work at 4am so lunch is at 9am. I ordered 4 32 inch pizzas the night before with the manager. We would have totally took advantage of delivery, but they don't have a delivery person available that early in the day. Ordering was easy. They had the pizza ready on time. The pizza was so hot and fresh it fogged up the windows inside the truck. Ha ha FYI 32 inch pizzas do not make it through a standard door. We had to bring them in through the dock door. Pizza was really good, but not the best out there. Everyone was still happy. 4x 32 inch pizzas fed 26 people. Easy nice pizza place to work with. Toppings could have been a bit more generous for the price they charged per topping. read more

See all

This is what they claim to be a Chicken Parmesan Sandwich. And from a place that claims New York in the title. This was very disappointing read more

Gus's New York Pizza - This is what they claim to be Chicken Parmesan Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Been to Gus's a few times, food was decent atmosphere ok. But don't come for food on holidays, they up charge and don't say anything. This time around we came on New Year's Eve for a 16 inch pizza and 10 wings, price came to $40 when normally would be around $28. And the pizza tastes like it wasn't cooked all the way. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Honestly the food is mid. The best thing about this place is that it is 24hours. Everything is mid quality and taste but sometimes when it's the only available option you do what you gotta do. read more

I usually don't do this but this business is SO inconsiderate & obnoxious it needs to be said. I've called, emailed, actually spoken to the pawn who comes and defaces my property every time their ad is plastered to my door, car, etc. And, this is the reason I will NEVER be a customer. Because they do not respect me or my property. I do not want your employees lingering around on a daily basis. I do not want your flyers plastered on my residence door, my vehicle, mailbox or wherever you choose to weasel in the next round. It is littering, to top it off. And, it's literally making every one of us you're targeting do the opposite of what you want. I have the worst impression of this place & would rather they cease than to have to deal with another garbage flyer! The trespassing & littering needs to stop- immediately. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - I get TEN of these PER WEEK! - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

I had ordered mozzarella sticks and after paying for mom food I recieved a pineapple pizza.... (which I am deathly allergic to) Upon the mix up I had called this location and they simply told me tough luck..... on delivering something to me that could potentially kill me if I wasn't careful DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE read more

The food was on point. An old-school burger cooked old-school way perfectly done crinkle cut fries. Nice and crispy and hot. Couldn't ask for better. The staff was nice and friendly and they ambience was perfect. read more

Gus's New York Pizza - Bacon cheeseburger - Pizza Near Me - Tempe, Arizona

Pizza was mid and they didn't add the vegetables I asked for... charged me extra for veggies I didn't want and took awhile. Will NOT be going back. read more

Lived in NYC for a decade. This ain't it, sorry. Flavor, crust, price, service, ambiance... read more

Love the food. Pizza great. Wings great. Pricing misleading. Came in at 12:09 after work and wanted wings. $12.99 turned into $16.62 after tax and credit card fee and AFTER MIDNIGHT CHARGE. I have never heard of this in any other restaurant. It's not posted anywhere in the restaurant. I will never be coming here after midnight again. I'd post a copy of my receipt but it's not itemized. read more