Greenwood Pier is open for business under new ownership and management! We went there last night for our 30th wedding anniversary as we had stayed at Greenwood Pier Inn (the old name for what is now Sacred Rock Resort) 23 years ago before we had our first baby.
The restaurant has been open only for a month now and they're definitely working out the kinks but I am giving them four stars for the excellent ambiance in the restaurant and the attentive, high-quality service in particular. We were seated right by the windows which have a view out to the ocean and the interior of the restaurant is beautiful with high ceilings and woodwork, the tables are inlaid with mother-of-pearl/abalone shells, seats are very comfortable.
Our server Derek (sp?) was very attentive and appropriately inquisitive about our experience with the restaurant, and due to our experience (see below) with one of our orders, comp'd the entree and perhaps because it was our anniversary or perhaps because of the issue with the entree also gave us a free dessert. So four stars for ambiance and service, and now onto the food.
I don't like dinging new restaurants and think they have a good chance at working out the menu as they gain more experience. My husband enjoyed his mojito and his glass of chardonnay. We both enjoyed the artichoke hummus with hard tack (little kick to the hard tack) appetizer from the somewhat limited menu. Each entree came with a petite salad of kale, strawberries, and feta cheese with an agave jalapeno vinaigrette - with a bit of a kick to it as well. Having had the hard tack followed by the jalapeno dressing made for a spicy experience, but I like things hot so that was okay, but others might find it overwhelming.
Husband ordered saffron halibut with heirloom tomato which he enjoyed - I thought the halibut was a bit dry, despite swimming in a lot of sauce and that the choice of saffron sauce (yellow) and a yellow heirloom tomato made for an aesthetic that was monochrome for his dish.
I ordered a beef and reef for $52 which came with four delicious broiled shrimp and about six ounces of ribeye encased in a baby bleu cheese over a bed of something like seasoned breakfast potatoes. Unfortunately, the ribeye was very well done, whereas I had ordered it medium rare. Derek quickly responded and ordered a new steak, which came out medium rare and with two more broiled shrimp (I had already eaten the other four!) He waited until I had cut through my steak to make sure it was done to my liking.
Derek brought out a complimentary strawberry tart with vanilla ice cream dessert. The strawberry filling and ice cream were delicious, however, the tart crust was doughy and not crisp as I expect tarts to be and we shared this feedback with Derek who was eager to know how they can improve.
Our final check did not include my beef and reef or the dessert - so a five for service for Derek!
I'd say give Greenwood Pier a chance - I overheard the next table over with four folks say they all enjoyed their meal, so worth giving them a try for the beautiful ambiance, attentive service, and they'll do their best to make it right on the food! read more