Great spot! I love all the attention to details in the upstairs bar. The drinks were delicious and so was the food. We will definitely be back. read more

Love the pizza at Goodfellas. We had six on a Saturday afternoon. We dined in and ordered a large pepperoni. I don't think I've ever waited this long for a pizza here ( or anywhere else for that matter) for as long as I waited today. It was a forty minute wait, It's delicious and I love this location because they have multiple aesthetics for dining in, but that wait was a tad long. I still recommend this place. I think their staff working just has trouble moving at a pace higher than 1st gear. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Not the best shot of a large pepperoni but as you can see the slices are oversized. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Here for $5.00 Ild Fashion night and friends! And of course-pizza by the slice! Ambiance is great at Wiseguys upstairs! Celebrating a happy day with old friends and new and the bartenders never disappoint us with great service, great personalities and good hospitality. We love coming here with friends. read more

See all

First time at this location and absolutely loved it. This bar always has a cozy laid back feel but stays really classy and high end. The cocktails are always excellent and the staff is always friendly. Highly recommend visiting around the holidays when it is extra charming! read more

See all

This spot is your usual pizza joint downstairs, with a more sophisticated, intimate bar vibe upstairs. Parking can be a bit of a challenge if it's a busy night in the neighborhood. They have the classic New York-style cheese and pepperoni slices ready to go when you walk in and a nice selection of specialty pizzas. I ordered The Don, which took about 40 minutes but was worth the wait and very delicious. It honestly has me reconsidering whether New York-style might be my favorite over Chicago deep dish. We dined upstairs, which has both indoor and outdoor seating. We also stumbled upon an empty back room past the bathrooms with a TV and games which was fun. The bartenders were super attentive and made great cocktails. Santa's Night Cap was my favorite as it was perfect for the season. Can't wait to come back with a group of friends! read more

See all

Drinks were apothicly Created. Pizza and atmosphere comforting service was attentive and sociable. We will be back.

I highly recommend the Smoked Old Fashioned - it's very good, and fun to watch the bartender make. Love this space - they have a great variety of seating, I especially enjoyed sitting on the couch in front of the fireplace. The pizza was good. Great place to meet people. read more

Tuesday night , We decided to go to Goodfellas to get two slices of cheese pizza. We were walking around for the evening & said why not get a slice of pizza cheese @ that . Where ? Goodfellas . Once again it's always a pleasure to stop in get fresh pizza to sit or to go with a nice drink & just relax . Appreciate always the staff, Chelsea, & the whole team bartenders & all. Keep up the great work & loving coming into a place where the setting is always great and the food and drinks are awesome. Just happy to have you here close instead of going into the city or over to Kentucky. Thanks again Steve S read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Cheese pizza with marinara sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

if you're a bar, advertise as so, not a late night pizza place. i came to this location hoping for a slice before heading home from a concert. i was met with a rude bouncer outside refusing to allow me and my boyfriend entry into the establishment. we attempted to ask questions about why we were ID'ed and why we (20 year olds) couldn't buy pizza at 10pm. the bouncer did not answer any questions seriously and instead gave us snarky responses. i would not recommend this establishment to anyone my age. read more

Waited an hour and a half for a slice of pizza that they had made. Expensive food and not worth the price or waiting for at all.

Good follow up and communication. All sports fields are represented in there product selection.

Reese was cool. I appreciate him a lot. He was so silly at the end of the night. Great pizza and great drinks.

There are very few places to get pizza by the slice in Cincinnati, especially slices of this size. I love getting a pepperoni pizza slice with a giant breadstick on the side. I've never had bad service at any location. They also have a rewards program that's great. I got $5 off for my birthday! I think all locations of Goodfellas are great, but this one has the most seating options. More of a family-vibe rather than drunk-2am vibe. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I got a 12 inch wise guy and it was the best pizza ever!! Joey, chelsea and Corey were the staff absolutely amazing!!

Greasy greasy pizza tonight. Also the service at the bar couldn't be slower. Plus the bar back is standing behind the bar on his phone while five people are in line. Drinks were good but not eager to return. read more

Goodfellas has the best customer service and pizza in town! The pizza slices are giant and they have the biggest bread sticks I've ever seen. 10/10 recommend! read more

Cool vibe in the restaurant and it's nice that you can get pizza by the slice here. Service is order at the counter and I think there's a bar upstairs you can take the food too. As someone from New York I was excited by the prospect of New York style pizza here in Cincinnati. I was unfortunately sorely disappointed. We got the largest size pizza with sausage. Overall, it was okay. The crust was not remotely crispy. It was quite thick and doughy. We'll probably try them again since they get such good reviews, but so far it did not meet expectations. read more

I know you think pizza , but you need to know the cocktails are the best! I love that I can patron this place as much as I want because it's close to home. I don't know why I'm finally doing a review but here we are. Service is great rather you get a pizza or go up stairs for drinks. I went on a Wednesday and it was $5 old fashions. They change menu seanallu which keeps me coming back. It's family friendly, and doesn't like huge slices of pizza in warm thin crust? Well I'm sure there are some people out there , but I'm not one of them. Get to pleasant ridge. read more

See all

The bar here is amazing! It's tucked away above the pizzeria and they have it decorated perfectly for Halloween! I went for the bar crawl! It was nice to see the staff dressed up for Halloween too! The craft cocktails were amazing! read more

The pizza was average. I've had better. The service was very slow not a very friendly atmosphere. The ambience was not much to brag about. I will not be returning to this establishment and would not recommend. read more

Great food as always! Love the bread sticks!!! And the big and best surprise is the bar upstairs. Bar tenders are really good and know what doing. read more

Excellent staff. I picked up some pizza for my wife who just gave birth and they went out of their way to make it special. Seriously love this place! Ayrton was the manager (may have misspelled) but so sincere. Thankful some places still work hard on their product and this place deserves 5 stars read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Cheesy Bread - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Had THREE different strands of hair on one slice i ordered. I know that kind of stuff happens some times, but three long strands of hair? Absolutely disgusting. read more

Great food! Wonderful service! Big pizza of cheesey goodness hot and ready food! Nice seating!

Loved the speakeasy concept. I also loved that the kitchen stays open pretty late; we went at about 10p on a Monday. They offer an array of inventive cocktails which is really neat. The bartender was nice and our drinks were good. The pizza came out hot and fresh. This was just an overall pleasant experience. read more

Order at the counter and stay in or take it to go. However, the best way to enjoy is upstairs in the Wise guys lounge. Pizza is great crust has a good crunch when fresh. I would recommend the forgetaboutit! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Wise guy Lounge - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Wise guys in pleasant ridge is one of the best Italian pizzeria and speakeasy I have ever been to! When you first walk in you are greeted immediately and offered everything from pizza by the slice, to meatballs and calzones. Then once you wrap up busting the last button on your pants from stuffing your face with a canole go down the hall and up the stairs for a hidden gem. When you walk upstairs you walk into a fully stocked bourbon bar that you don't typically see everyday with some if the most common to most rares bourbon! Make sure to bring your friends and a cigar when it's nice out! Come check this place out!​ read more

We came in at an off time in between lunch and dinner. We did choose two different slices from the case that were warmed up. The slice was good and I bet it was excellent if fresh out of the oven. We also had a bread stick. It could have been fantastic if the sauce to dip in was warm. It was cold. We definitely will be back. read more

My best friend and I went into goodfellas right after the gym, we were a little down because of the weather but we were greeted by a guy named Reece and he was beyond kind. He was so nice and welcoming to us and made our experience so amazing!!! His coworker, Joey and him really made the place light up. It was good food, good vibes, and great service. Thank you so much Reece and Joey!!! read more

Great place! Pizza was great and loved the bar area and balcony upstairs! Perfect for our small group event.

You will be hard pressed to find a better pizza place in the city. Excellent food. Excellent atmosphere. Excellent staff and customer service. The guy working behind the counter was just an all around good guy and made sure we had a good experience. read more

My Mr and I have been eyeballing this location for awhile. I've tried Goodfellas at the Over the Rhine location and was pleased. Freshly Hand Tossed New York Style Pizza. We decided to order online for pickup. Ordered: -Wiseguy- green peppers, red onions, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes -Margherita- marinara sauce, basil, and fresh mozzarella Both small 12" pizzas. Got there and the order was ready at the time we requested online. Got home and enjoyed every bite. The sauce and crust were amazing and I loved that they were not selfish with the basil. Very great taste and fresh. I tried a bite of my Mr's pizza and was impressed. Besides pizza, they have other items from the menu. I was especially looking at the desert section. Next time I'm ordering the Cannoli. Yes... they have my vote and sold. You know I'm returning! Great addition to the Pleasant Ridge area! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

The pizza was not only a decent price but the setting was amazing! I was able to get two giant slices and a drink for $10. The staff were kind and the service was quick. The lighting was great and I loved the decorations. Check out ice cube! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - a picture of a man on the machine - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I was denied service at the Pleasant Ridge location. My party walked in at 10:25 pm, the male pizza maker was on the phone taking an order, once he got off the phone he refused to take make our order which was for one large specialty pizza. He was very rude and also making pizzas as we were ordering. The posted closing time is 11pm, what is the point of being open if you will not service your customers until that time. I'm not sure if it was racially motivated but a party of the opposite race came in as we were leaving and were not turned away immediately as we sat in the adjacent lot for a period of time. read more

Went to another pizza place around the corner that closed their dining room at 8pm on a Friday! No worries Goodfellas in Pleasant Ridge made up for my disappointment. Love when staff are excited to share the different masterpieces they created! Friday night pretty busy but clean! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Ice cube anyone? - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

This pizza slices are big but average. It's chewy but will get the job done if you're looking for a quick meal. The lunch deal is a pretty good price for the amount of food. If you're looking for real pizza this isn't the place. read more

Goodfellas is great. Especially during a night out but if you do go to goodfellas, best time to go is during the lunch special. You get a slice of pizza with a drink and a breadstick! Such a great and delicious deal. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

First time eating goodfellas since my brother was at OU back in 2002. I remembered this pizza being deep dish back then but apparently it's New York style? Gheeez, I've been missing out. The wait times are a bit longer but we used that time to run upstairs to the bar. My goodness, I've really been missing out. The library room is cool and you can rent it out for private events. You can also rent out the New Orleans style patio which was very cool. The bartenders were so nice and helpful. My cocktail was very very good. PR is close enough to my house that I can get here easily. Pizza is my second job so I will be back. Nice job PR Goodfellas. I was definitely impressed. Some of you yelpers are especially hard on this gem. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Sunkissed something, can't remember - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

pizza was just ok, lots of cough not covered by cheese or pepperoni, very little sauce. Unable to receive payment by phone which is unheard of. do yourself a favor and order a real pizza from italianette! read more

The pizza here is solid but this review is for drinks. First of all I love the theme and the vibe of the upstairs bar. I had drinks here on a Wednesday night, which happened to be $5 old fashioned night. The bartenders were very nice, knowledgeable and attentive. I also tried a Wooden Nickel and although it's a little too sweet for me I loved the smoky finish! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Wooden Nickel - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio