Cancel

Open app

Search

Lucy Blue Pizza OTR

4.5 (8 reviews)
Closed • Closed
Updated 3 months ago

Order Lucy Blue Pizza OTR Takeout or Delivery

Lucy Blue Pizza OTR Photos

Business Info

LUCY BLUE PIZZA OTR ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Good for groups
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Lucy Blue Pizza OTR

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Wow! Wonderful pizza and breadsticks and great priced! Atmosphere was great and super fast!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Lucy Blue Pizza OTR

The Davidson - Pork chop with kale and squash

The Davidson

4.4(212 reviews)
0.6 mi•Downtown
•$$$

I really enjoyed myself here. My friend and I went to an event in Hamilton then took an Uber to The…read moreDavidson. We had reservations and ended up there a bit early and they had no issue with it and took us to a table. Even the fact that we added two extra people to our party did not faze them. We were seated quickly and with a smile. Our waitress came out pretty quickly and explained the eggplant dish to my friend who asked about it. We brought another couple with us so 4 of us dined for dinner on Saturday night. I ordered a cosmo to start and a Seared Yellowfin Nicoise Salad. For my main I ordered the Bread & 3 Butters along with the Cannelloni. The salad was super fresh and an excellent way to start my meal and the whole grain Dijon mustard vinaigrette definitely hit the spot, I ate every bite. Next up a big helping of fresh made pasta! The Roasted Tomato Cannelloni was a rich dish and I absolutely LOVED it. Roasted garlic tomato sauce and not in an overpowering way along with Swiss chard and ricotta filled cannelloni tubes. Again I ate every single bite of this dish with part of my bread and it was a lot to eat for me. Would definitely order this again. I also tried a bit of my friend's eggplant even though I am not a fan of eggplant and it wasn't too bad, she loved it. Can't speak to how easy it is to park there as we came in an Uber but I am sure that nearby there is parking lots if you cannot find street parking. I did not partake in dessert this time as nothing on the menu appealed to me but maybe next time we come as I want to try a couple other menu items. Do not hesitate to go as it is straight up good food and great service.

Took my wife to Davidson's Sunday at noon. Service was slow and not very friendly. The manager came…read moreout to apologize for a problem with cooking the hamburger. Appetizer of tomatoes and mozzarella was tasty. Wife's burger was ok but nothing great. I ordered Rigatoni with Vodka sauce. It had been sitting around for a while during the time they were redoing the hamburger. It was dry and not very favorable. It was supposed to have Italian sausage in it but there was hardly any. Portion was pretty small also. When we came in, we had reservations. They put us next to the kitchen. The place was empty so we asked to be put near the windows. They did it but we obviously really upset the hostess which made for an uncomfortable start. Maybe she didn't want to sit us near the windows because it was plagued with flies from hell. I won't recommend and I won't go back. $150 for a burger and dried pasta and some drinks that upset my wife's stomach.

Photos
The Davidson - The Davidson, with a chocolate, olive, paprika, and gold color palette, was quite inviting.

The Davidson, with a chocolate, olive, paprika, and gold color palette, was quite inviting.

The Davidson - Scallops

Scallops

The Davidson - Espresso Martini (look at the detail)

See all

Espresso Martini (look at the detail)

Northstar Cafe

Northstar Cafe

4.4(107 reviews)
9.8 mi
•$$

Northstar has figured out the balance between a relaxing lounge and upscale restaurant. The service…read moreis friendly and attentive. The leadership is impeccable. We've been to the Kenwood and Liberty Township locations and the consistent nature of their excellence is impressive. From the bright Pad Thai with grilled chicken to the comforting banana pancakes Northstar is Ohio's benchmark for elevated hospitality. Ps Great taste in music Sufjan Stevens was a nice touch.

Northstar Cafe never disappoints. Seriously, this place is stamped in our book…read more The service is almost always A1, and even when the food takes a little longer than usual, they usually make up for it somehow or throw us a comp card, which we definitely appreciate. I also LOVE the setup here. You pay first, get your food second, and everything just seems to run smoothly. No unnecessary waiting around trying to figure out what's going on. My wife and I usually rotate between the pancakes, the hash, the Northstar Burger, or the potato hash. Honestly, you really can't go wrong with any of them. The food is always fresh, portions are good, and everything comes out looking like somebody actually cared about what they put on the plate. We probably go once or twice a week, especially for brunch. At this point, Northstar is basically family. And if you're like us and pretty picky about where you eat, this is definitely one that gets the stamp of approval. Great food, good atmosphere, and consistently solid service. One more thing: I believe they play jazz after 6 PM Monday through Friday, which is always a nice little bonus. Overall, definitely recommend if you're looking for good food with a nice ambiance. Northstar has a permanent spot in our rotation!

Photos
Northstar Cafe
Northstar Cafe - Cast-iron steak and enchilada

Cast-iron steak and enchilada

Northstar Cafe

See all

Green District - Fountain Square - The What About Cobb salad all of my coworkers rave about it & now I see why it's so good & fills you up for the rest of the day

Green District - Fountain Square

4.2(43 reviews)
0.5 mi•Downtown

Ordered through DoorDash and everything was correct…read more If you love salad and like to create your own then this is definitely the spot for you! I did the build your own salad with Iceberg Romaine, Herb Pulled Chicken, Ghost Pepper Jack Cheese, Banana Peppers, Broccoli, Carrots, Edamame, Croutons and Avocado Ranch dressing. It was one of the best salads I ever had.

This Green District location seems hellbent on vaporizing the term "fast casual" from the American…read morelexicon. Because "fast" is an unknown word at this place. The good first, though: Whatever the flaws in its business model, Green District still turns out well-conceptualized salads that always seem fresh and tasty. The Hide & Go Greek is a very nice chicken one with a robust, terrific dressing. The Thai One On salad is (you guessed it) an Asian-influenced one with shrimp, lots of cabbage and cilantro, and a kind of generic but fresh-tasting Asian-style ginger-heavy dressing. Also very good. Fortunate thing you can order online and don't have to verbalize those unwieldy salad names to a fellow human. (But if you think those names are bad, another one wants you to hold its beer: the Tequila Mockingbird.). Anyway, the food gets this to three stars, but only barely. Alas, the service at this location is a shambles. Count on at least a 35-minute wait, even if you order right after 11am, when things presumably ought not to be backed up. And it looks like chaos back there--just not enough employees back there, most likely. Last time it took this restaurant an incomprehensible 50 minutes to get my salad out. (Who with a regular lunch "hour" downtown has time for this?) Credit to the unflappable and put-upon young fella at the end of the line; he kept doing his job steadily and kept cheerful about it. The manager is always madly rushing about and isn't nearly as cheery (but it almost certainly isn't her fault, either). It astonishing that the food can be is good as it is in this environment. There's something very wrong about this restaurant's business model when the family-run lunch spot down the street (seemingly just as many orders) can crank out your to-go salad (as good as here, for the most part) in three to five minutes and be as friendly as they can be about it. Whoever came up with the plan has some major issues to resolve.

Photos
Green District - Fountain Square
Green District - Fountain Square - Ricky Bobby-Q wrap

Ricky Bobby-Q wrap

Green District - Fountain Square - Interior

See all

Interior

Lucy Blue Pizza OTR - pizza - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...