Stopped in one night during the Immerse event. It was right next to one of the stages I was frequenting, and I wanted a quick slice, so in I popped. Ambiance was really fun. The thinnest place I've ever seen. Only room for two lines of people in the main area, one line for ordering, one line for picking up. Behind the counter was quite the operation. Pies being baked in one oven, being put on display, and then another oven jam packed with slices being warmed for the customer, along with their accompanying garlic knot. Every slice comes with a complimentary knot. I'm pretty sure I saw whole pizzas going out with eight included knots. The service was pretty good. Efficient, friendly enough workers. There was an aura of hurry up, what do you need, but with a line out the door literally all night, I do not blame them one bit. And the slice factory line got you in an out as quickly as it possible could. As for the slice itself, it was pretty ok. Good crust, foldable slice. Very cheesy, which is needed for most clientele who are in the middle of downtown in need of munchies. Slim toppings, though, and even after the heating process, the slice was kind of cold. Overall, for the convenience and the price, this place was good. I'll definitely come back under the right circumstances. read more

Unfortunately, I can't recommend Gitto's Pizza based on my experience. I understand they were very busy and there was a long line, but that didn't justify the way I was treated. I asked if they offered a military discount, and the employee told me they did. When I presented my military ID, he refused to apply the discount and then attempted to take my government-issued military ID out of my hand to inspect whether it was legitimate. That interaction really caught me off guard and made me uncomfortable. Regardless of the store's policy, there are more respectful and professional ways to handle that situation. I still purchased my food and ordered a standard cheese pizza, hoping the food would make up for the experience. Unfortunately, it was pretty average. The bottom of the pizza was pale and seemed undercooked, so it lacked the crisp texture I was expecting. The ambience, however, did seem really nice. They have upstairs seating that overlooks the street, which could make for a nice spot if you're dining in. Overall, I understand busy shifts can be stressful, but customers should still be treated with courtesy and respect. Better customer service and more consistency in the quality of the pizza would go a long way. Based on this visit, I don't see myself returning. read more

Pros: Ambiance was fun. Quick get em in get em out place that can get you your pizza in a hurry. The pizza was pretty ok. A nice thin crust, good amount of cheese, and plentiful toppings. Cons: That quick service left a little to be desired. The garlic knots were cold cold. Kind of wish they weren't there. Tips: Get super drunk before coming here. That's pretty much the status quo here anyway. Lol. read more

Small, hole in the wall, quick service pizza place in downtown Orlando. I've been coming here since I was in college and I probably stop by anytime I have cocktails in downtown Orlando. Don't expect stellar customer service, expect to get served a good slice of pizza, quickly! read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Gitto's Pizzeria in downtown Orlando has been a go-to spot for years and is often mentioned as one of the better pizza options in Florida. What keeps it interesting, though, is how the atmosphere continues to evolve while staying true to its roots. At its core, this is classic New York-style grab-and-go pizza. You order by choosing slices through the glass, with plenty of options that go beyond traditional toppings--standouts like chicken bacon ranch and buffalo-style slices are clearly crowd favorites. The atmosphere is where Gitto's really shines. From the outside, it looks like a simple hole-in-the-wall, but once inside, there's more personality and energy than you'd expect. The complimentary garlic knots were an unexpected and appreciated bonus. The dough is flavorful and familiar--exactly what you want from a NYC-style slice. I ordered the chicken bacon ranch, and it delivered: not overly sauced (which is key, since ranch can easily overpower), perfectly cooked bacon, and solid chicken that didn't taste frozen or pre-made. Pizza is subjective, and this is just my experience--but it's important to judge Gitto's for what it is. This is New York grab-and-go pizza, not Italian, Chicago, Detroit, or a big chain like Papa John's. If you know the style going in and set your expectations accordingly, this place absolutely delivers. read more

See all

Been here a few times and overall the pizza has been good. Definitely one of the better spots downtown but stay away after 10 when the clubs open. It gets a bit crazy inside. It has a nice sitting area upstairs with a little bar as well. It's a counter service pizza joint so it's basic service but it's easy to order from the display cabinet. read more

Gitto's Pizza - Upstairs seating area - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Tried a buffalo chicken slice along with a chicken bacon ranch slice and they were delicious. Each slice comes with a garlic knot, pretty cool. Service was great. They offer seating upstairs if you want to dine in, I got my slices to go. Gitto's has very good pizza! read more

See all

Perfect spot for soaking up the alcohol for those in the area! We spotted the place during the day & said we knew we'd have to come later that evening ! It was PACKED! I liked that they had a small upstairs bar that you can go to. They even had some specials going on. It was very crowded but they was sure to try n keep the line flowing . For every pizza slice, they offered a garlic knot. I was too sleepy & forgot to eat mine though . read more

See all

Downtown staple ... Large slices and so many options I always go for the white pizza and of course a garlic knot. I usually take to go but they have a large upstairs area to enjoy your pizza and also a small bar. Lunch specials are great you can get 2 slices with a drink and a garlic knot for under $12 I haven't yet tried the tiramisu but that's next . Definitely check out Gittos even better grap a late night slice! read more

From the street, this place looks like a broom closet. It feels like you're standing in one as you are ordering your food, but don't fret. Just walk up the stairs and you will find a decent sized area to sit and eat. Or just take your slice to go and eat it on the sidewalk. I came with a fairly large group of mostly teenagers before a show at Dr. Phillips. I didn't expect much, but was pleasantly surprised with my veggie slice. Thin crust that was nice and crispy and hot and gooey on top, just as it's intended. The other members of my party that ordered slices with chicken were not impressed and ended up trashing what they ordered. I would personally come again because my slice was very good, but I may be going in alone. read more

Gitto's Pizza - Cheese New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Chicken Bacon Ranch: White Breast Chicken, Bacon, Ranch, and Mozzarella. Chicken Caprese: Chicken, Fresh Tomato, Basil, Balsamic Glaze, onion, Fresh mozz, Shredded parm. HUGE pizza slices with so much flavor! And the garlic knot was the perfect topper. However, it's really cramped on the first floor, and it does take a little bit to get the slice. Also, there's not great parking. BUT upstairs is a bigger area with lots of seating read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Pretty good NY style pizza in downtown Orlando. Perfect for a quick drop by lunch which is what my coworker and I did or even as a pit stop during a downtown bar crawl, or before a concert/show near by. Space is very narrow and small in the main counter area so expect to just be in and out. I did their weekday pizza lunch special which was 2 pizza slices and a drink for $10.95. Well worth it in my opinion as my coworker and I had a slice each. You could also do one pizza slice and a drink for $6.95. Loved the flavor of my pizza and felt fresh as they reheated it in their pizza over per order and includes a garlic knot with every order. read more

Gitto's Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Pizza was fair and that's even after a few drinks. Free garlic knots with each slice and a seating / bar upstairs which was nice. Fairly priced and the desserts were good. We got a tiramisu slice and was better than expected read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Quick and great service, bar is upstairs and had no clue of seating area as well. Great ambiance for family weekday pizza night of out with friends. Seasonal Pizza skill was my try for the night and I recommend the buffalo chicken for sure! read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

While the guy taking our order was very kind I doubt I'd ever return here. It was a cute place to sit at after being out late downtown, but this expensive piece of pizza was bland and tasteless. The garlic knot came with it for free but it actually had no flavor at all. It tasted like barely cooked dough. This was very much so cardboard pizza. And for $6.25 a slice, I was hoping something a tiny bit better. read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pepperoni New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Delicious pizza, but customer service has really fallen apart. I ordered mozzarella sticks with my pizza tonight and asked for ranch and was told okay, but when delivered all I got was red sauce and when I asked about it was made to pay an extra $1+ for the ranch. It was just the point...should of been told on ordering. I've been buying pizza from Gitos since 2017 and never been treated this way. They have great pizza, but need more caring staff. I'd give it some time but hopefully they can recover. read more

I just love holes in the wall. When going in, you havw a narrow walkway to get in. While I was there, it was soooooo busy. The slices are big. I had the lasagna pizza. Absolutely Yum . The pizza was hot and fresh. As busy it was there, I got my slice and a sweet tea in 6 minutes of ordering. Great choice wile at Proper Orlando three doors down. Happy Yelping! read more

JUST SAD AND HORRIBLE. We use to eat here all the time . Got a few slices that were the closest to a New York slice In all of Orlando. Craved this pizza. We moved away are in town on vacation . Ordered a lg pizza , got to the hotel , when I tell you it was absolutely disgusting pizza. Thick crust, sauce tasted off, cheese wasn't even melted, under cooked .it just broke our hearts . I guess good things don't last forever. read more

Best pizza in all of Orlando. Went to Cocktails Screams for Shrek Rave and got very hungry so decide to stop here. My friend had a slice of cheese and I swear it's the biggest slice of pizza I've ever seen in my life. He said it was really good at so next time we go I'm definitely gonna have to get a slice. They have ordering downstairs and seating upstairs. The service was really quick and really cheap. The ambience of this little pizza place is reminds me of an old-school pizza joint. 10/10 Definitely recommend read more

See all

I have had the pizza before and it's been good. Today, I ordered a large with chicken. The sauce was awful. It was like they added water to make the sauce go further. Extremely disappointed and won't be ordering it again. Had meatballs as well and took a photo. You can see the water in the sauce! read more

Gitto's Pizza - Water in the sauce!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Great pizza, fast and convenient. We often stop bu when running late to shows at the dr Phillips center read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This is one of the best pizza establishments I've have ever eaten at. The staff is very kind, it's clean and the pizza is . This will always be my go-to pizza spot when I'm in Orlando. Vince was amazing and deserves a raise! read more

Food is ALWAYS bomb ! Definitely the go to for this late night munchies. The staff in here are always in point and hustle like no other with the late night crowds. Shout out to David and Alex. Always great to see them behind the line. They are extremely professional and attentive. Great vibes! As a bonus, this place offers a 10% military discount to all veterans. Thanks Gitto's read more

This place brings the ambience of New York City to Orlando! A cultural hidden gem with fun staff and some of the best pizza around. read more

Gitto's Pizza - Small half Marg & Hawaiian w sauce - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Best Pizza in Orlando and I won't accept a counter argument!! Best after-club (drunk) food too

I love eating at Gitto's! Fast and friendly service, tasty food and pretty good prices. The ambiance is very casual and it is a bit loud. They also have great specials. read more

See all

Came in specifically for their pizza skulls this season! (And of course... garlic knots!) Gitto's is a great downtown spot for a quick slice, and I like their seating area upstairs! The pizza skulls come in 3 different flavors - pepperoni and cheese, chicken bacon ranch, and Buffalo chicken. We got both pepperoni and Buffalo chicken, and while the pep was the crowd favorite, I appreciate that they did different flavors! The skulls are nice and soft and stuffed with a good amount of pepperoni. Worth checking out for spooky season! Eating 2 was filling, especially with the knots, which are tasty as well! Everyone was kind when I picked up my order. If you're not already out downtown, parking here can be a challenge, but I was luckily able to find a shirt-term spot right out front. read more

See all

Pizza, wings and beer! Large slices, great daily combo with 2 slices and a drink. Plenty of classic options in addition to the in house specialties. Check it out yourself read more

This is the best pizza spot ever. They are open late night and during the day and alwayyyys busy. The food is made fresh and top tier pizza!! Staff is great, ample seating up stairs, and fast casual dining. Take advantage of their Valentine's Day special, and definitely get their pizza puffs!!! They are to die for! read more

Gitto's serves a NY style pizza just as good as any in New York. It has the same feels too. Even if the line is long, they are quick. I look forward to stopping by when I'm out at night downtown. read more

Staff is nice. Aesthetically, it certainly has the NYC Look. Location is always prime and it's always busy. That's where the 2 stars come from! Sadly, this was a huge miss. * expensive * we ordered a Sicilian pie. $28.99 * wings $10.99 * cheese and sauce was horrible. Papa John's, or frozen pizza would have tasted better. * cheese tasted like imitation cheese * dough was too much * sauce had no real taste. Very disappointing! * wings- tasted just ok. Sadly this was a waste of money and since they are open late they were the best choice at the time. The garlic bread knots were not tasty. It was a very poor representation of NYC best pizza. Not good at all! read more

Gitto's Pizza - Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

The security here is extremely unprofessional and the overall experience was very disappointing. I understand they deal with a lot of different people downtown, but that's no excuse for treating people poorly. I hope the company takes these reviews seriously and makes real changes, because the way they're operating now isn't acceptable. read more

Workers were nice. The pizza was fine but just reheated from the glass. If you order something that has to actually be made, like a pasta dish, be ready to sit and wait. My wife got her pasta and mozzarella sticks after the three people who got pizza were done eating. read more

A really great lunch special 2 slices and a drink combo! Great downtown location with cool mural read more

Gitto's Pizza - Lunch combo - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Great pizza, I really like the great atmosphere! Thanks Ashley! I will definitely return!

The lasagna pizza was meaty and spectacular. The pic does it zero justice. It's a massive slice, NYC standard wide-wedge slice sitting across two paper plates! Wife devoured her Margherita pizza slice with glee. Among the best pizzas we've had in a long time. This joint has been open for 35 years in the same location. Wowza! Charming lady assisted with our order. Upstairs dining area gave us the retro NYC or Chicago dining experience, up a narrow stairway and into a wonderfully surprising, spacious eating area. We took the "window" seat and could look "down" over the edge and watch the pizza dough toss and prep. read more

Gitto's Pizza - Upstairs dining area, bar, sports tv, etc. - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Was in the downtown area for the Nude Nite event and wanted something quick to eat before heading home. See that the line wasn't too bad so we went in. Had a pepperoni and meat lovers pizza and it was as good as I remember from Years ago. The size of the pizza slice was good and fulfilling and it comes with a garlic knot. read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pepperoni New York Style Pizza Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This NY style pizza joint is located DT Orlando. A cute little upstairs seating area and bar. The pizza was beyond delicious! read more

Gitto's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Food was so good! Great knots and crispy wings ! Loved the spot and so much space upstairs

Try and try 5 different times to order on line kept getting a opps something went wrong . Call the place got to different people telling that it was because they were closed at the time I was placing the order. By the way the system knows they were close that's why it ask you to schedule the delivery . Not helpful at all . Well they don't need my money. I don't need their pizza . Mind you I was doing something nice for my daughter . Thanks for nothing . read more