Girls Cafe

This is one of those local real authentic type New Jersey diners basically on the main street of a…read morelittle town The kind of place that has counter with barstools right when you walk in where most of the guys know the servers and vice versa One of our new Golden spots when we're in the area!!

I went on a crazy hike and was starving. This breakfast wrap hit the spot! Husband got a pastrami…read moresandwich and cheese fries and loved it! The server was sweet. Loved the quaint and simple ambiance

Tuna club

See all

Grilled cheese with avocado and tomato!

Sissy's At the Harbor

4.1(104 reviews)

2.4 mi

Fantastic service with a smile! The highlight of our experience was definitely the pleasant,…read morecheerful, and quick service from the staff at Sissy's At the Harbor. We were seated outside because it was a beautiful day, but it quickly became windy. Even though we were outside, we had multiple staff check in on us to make sure we were doing ok-- unfortunately not an experience I have with a lot of restaurants that have split seating . I'm so thankful for Sissy's staff for being so attentive and caring of their customers! I ordered the Broccoli and Cheese omelet and it was so delicious and it was probably one of the best omelets I've ever had! Keep in mind that this restaurant is cash only!

I have been going to sissy's at the harbor for years. It has always been a staple in my rotation…read more It is a classic spot in the Atlantic highlands with a perfect view of the marina. Today we went for lunch and got a chicken caesar wrap and a Philly cheese steak. The service was fast and easy just like it always is. Food is always served with love here. In addition this place is CASH ONLY.

See all

The Chubby Pickle

4.1(164 reviews)

0.7 mi

A fun place to stop into for an after dinner drink. Friendly bartender, lively patrons, and quirky…read moredecor. Even bought a tank top with their name on it as a souvenir.

Haven't tried the food but came here with some friends for drinks. The bar is open until 2 AM…read more(sidenote I noticed that the clock by the bar is 10 minutes ahead). Classic dive bar feel, staff was friendly and knew/had good conversations with a lot of the regulars. FYI they are quite strict with the close time and shuffle everyone into the small vestibule/ make them go around the back to exit.

Live music and radio feed

Chicken sandwich with orange and bre cheese

See all

Atlantic Highlands Town Diner

3.7(7 reviews)

Chicken, piccata, and chicken franchise #The goated…read moremealGoToThisplace now ok btw eat your vegetables!

Have been here a few times. Overall it is clean, food is good, and staff is friendly. Have come…read moreboth times with my family and the wait staff was very accommodating with the kids taking their orders. Food is good, but don't expect Michelin star food, it is good dinner food. Pretty good range of selections on the menu and haven't gotten anything that was bad. Prices are very reasonable as well. Would recommend when you are in the area.

See all

Finished everything

Hudson Cafe

4.6(94 reviews)

Cute little spot here. We were attracted to it with some good music coming off its porch thay had…read morebenches and umbrellas. Besides selection of coffees, they had a really refreshing pink lemonade, tasty! I would come back if visiting Keansburg, and Highlands again

Great little lunch place. You can sit outside on the big corner and watch the neighbors go by, or…read moresit inside if you feel it's too warm out. Their Tina is really good. Everything is homemade with a limited menu, so it's consistent. The servers are attentive but it gets quite busy around lunchtime. So if you only have an hour, be considerate to let them know and you won't have any problems.

Freezer and pastry shelf.

Fried Two Eggs, any Style

See all

Front

Proving Ground Waterfront Dining

3.8(427 reviews)

0.5 mi

Went on a date night to Proving Ground on a beautiful summer night…read more We started with some sushi getting the shrimp tempura roll. It was delicious I was surprised they even had sushi. For mains we ordered the truffle mac and cheese and the steak sandwich. The steak sandwich was on garlic break, the steak was cooked perfectly and the added fries were a plus. The mac and cheese was also delicious not overly cheesy just an all around good meal. Definitely worth checking out we sat outside and admired the boats and sunset. The food came out quick and hot. Service was polite and genuine.

I'm not usually a fan of dishes with a lot of tomato sauce, and unfortunately, I didn't enjoy this…read moreentrée as much as I had hoped. Maybe I misunderstood the description, but I expected the Creole flavors to come through more. Instead, the dish tasted heavily of tomato and seemed to be missing some of the additional seasonings I was expecting. The orzo was also overcooked, which made it very soft and easy to break apart. That said, the lobster bisque was absolutely divine, and the fries were perfectly crunchy. Despite my meal not being my favorite, the restaurant itself is beautiful. It was pouring outside during my visit, but the waitress was incredibly kind and attentive, which definitely added to the experience. I would still love to return and try some of the other items on the menu. I especially want to experience their outdoor seating--it looks absolutely gorgeous with the lighting! Overall, it's a beautiful restaurant with a lovely atmosphere, and I'm looking forward to giving it another try.

What a View!

See all

Fort Hancock on sandy hook

The Atlantic House

4.3(121 reviews)

Two story shore restaurant…read more The seating areas on both floors are comfortable. The cocktails are tasty. Some of the menu items are ambitious. For example, the Scallops with Risotto and Corn had good texture but lacked flavor. The service was attentive. There was a 3.5% service charge for credit cards.

Here's a refined, "elite" Yelp review that also subtly reflects the photo:…read more If you're looking for a spot that nails both presentation and flavor, Atlantic House is absolutely worth the trip. We ordered the fish tacos, birria tacos, and kettle-style potato chips--and every plate came out looking as good as it tasted. The fish tacos were beautifully assembled, piled high with crisp, fresh slaw that added the perfect crunch to the tender, flaky fish underneath. Light, clean, and balanced. The birria tacos were the star of the table. Rich, deeply seasoned meat tucked into perfectly griddled shells, served with a savory dipping broth that takes each bite to another level. Messy in the best way possible--and completely worth it. Even the kettle-style potato chips stood out. Thick-cut, golden, and topped with just the right amount of flavor to make them more than just a side--they held their own next to the tacos. The overall experience ties everything together: polished yet relaxed atmosphere, attentive service, and dishes that clearly have intention behind them. It's the kind of place where you can tell care is put into both the food and the experience. Atlantic House isn't just a good meal--it's a spot you'll want to come back to, and one I'd recommend without hesitation.

Grilled cheese brisket I believe

See all

Blueberry cider from beach bee

Bahrs Landing Restaurant

3.4(792 reviews)

0.8 mi

•$$$

I have selected Bahrs Landing as my yearly visit for Soft Shell Crab (most commonly blue crabs that…read morehave recently molted their hard outer shell to grow. Caught immediately after shedding, the entire crab can be eaten...shell and all. They offer an intensely sweet, rich flavor and a delicate, crispy texture when cooked). Bahr's Landing prepares this sautéed crab with capers, mushrooms, lemon & butter, mashed potatoes and vegetables. My go-to appetizer is always the Grilled Cauliflower (Topped with tomato pesto, quinoa, and wild rice blend). The crispness of the cauliflower....brushed through the surrounding ingredients.....makes this the perfect starter. Aside from enjoying the mouth-watering food, you'll also feel as if you're dining on a ship, have great views of the pier, water, and the bridge leading into Sandy Hook Beach. Don't forget to visit their gift shop and view all of the maritime decor and beautiful woodwork.

What a disappointment...been living in Monmouth County for over 45yrs...for most those years, my…read morefamily has dined here numerous times. Most recently, my older daughter, after college, married a young man from Long Island and moved there. My son-in-law and I have a friendly banter regarding who has the better seafood. They visited for the week and prior to them heading back to LI, I recommended going out to Bahrs, before they get on the parkway...easy and to prove my point, who has the better seafood...well, needless to say...my point was mute. First, let me set the stage, it's 4 adults and 3 children (7,5,3)....ordered steamers, mug of NE chowder, calamari, Caesar salad, linguine w/clam, kids cheese burger, pasta with butter, side of meatballs, fried founder and a Lava cake (baby girls bday-they were out of) replace it with a couple of scoops of ice cream...with a candle (best part). Mug of Chowder- $13 came out cold Caesar Salad- $15 couple of pieces of romaine, wishbone is a better dressing Linguine w/clam- $29 sauce was so think, uneatable (gave enough clams) still couldn't eat it Calamari- $17, only rings and rubbery, Costco has better frozen Kids cheeseburgers- $14.50 each, 4oz burgers It was a slider at best...no taste Pasta with butter- $14.50 dry, forgot the butter Steamers- $27....sandy and rubbery What has happened to this place...staff is summer help...inexperienced...it's not the fault of the help, it's the fault of the owners and management. For the record, we didn't complain to our waitress..it's not her fault. We tip her 25%, (my children worked locally, during the summers, not at Bahrs) Bill was over $300 with drinks...I'd rather spend that where I can get quality. There are many more options...guessing location plays a part...but, I'm a local and not a tourist. Sorry Bahrs, not returning......

Inside

Bahrs Blueberry crumble with vanilla ice cream

See all

Off The Hook Restaurant and Bar

3.8(216 reviews)

0.7 mi

Great area Delicious food…read moreWait staff was amazing Anthony that does the Friday night trivia was fun and very interactive with the customers!!! It was a fun night

We like this place! It was hoping on Friday night! We got the last table. Still, the service was…read moregreat. Not a fancy place. But the food is good and reasonably priced. We had chowder, a fav. It wasn't real thick but very tasty. I had oysters on the half shell. Nice size and icy cold. Delish! Followed by the Voo Doo Shrimp and Scallops. It's an appetizer but I eat it as an entree. It is DELICIOUS!! He had Mahi Mahi Tacos which are filled with large pieces of fish. You can have them grilled or blackened. He too one home. Live music in the back room. Love the atmosphere. There is an upstairs if you want quiet.

See all

Great fresh sea air view.

Barnacle Bill's

3.9(466 reviews)

2.3 mi

Had a nice lunchnon the patio overlooking the water. We went with the steamers to start. Little…read morepricey, nice size streamers. Water was hot to keep them warm. We follwed with sharing a Salad and a Tube steak. (hotdog) They were ok The relish was plentyful on the side with a pickle and Potato chips on the side. Nice place on the water with a nice atmosphere. Great indoor bar scene. Sorry no pics!

Walked in and was told it was about 45 minutes for the outside area. We ended up hanging out at the…read morecar with a drink, and the table was ready much sooner. We got a burger with their famous cheese sauce, which was awesome. We asked for a side of fries, probably didn't need it because the burger was huge. Also got the linguine and clams which was pretty good. They seemed busy. I like that they had Adirondack chairs outside so you could hang out with a drink and wait for your table. The view was awesome. Definitely would be back.

Best burger ever !

See all

Outside in the winter

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cynthia B.

189

1

0

8 years ago

Food was amazing, service was fantastic, it was a great experience for the family ! Thank you for the personal service and our reservation for 5. read more

Ken O.

14

7

0

13 years ago

These "girls" are a riot, addressing everyone with "darlings" and "honey buns". The food is decent; the pancakes are great.

Girls Cafe - diners - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Restaurants near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Cocktail Bars near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Parking near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Shopping near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Desserts near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Coffee near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Things to Do near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Breakfast near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Thrift Stores near Girls Cafe

BEST of Highlands, New Jersey Brunch near Girls Cafe

Best of Highlands

Things to do in Highlands

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Girls Cafe also viewed

Red Bank Diner

3.7

(94 reviews)

After reading the reviews, I wanted to give this place a try. We came here for lunch and managed to…read morefind parking right in the front of the diner, just like in the movies! LOL. We were immediately seated after arriving. The diner is medium in size, with the seats in the front being booths that seat 3-4 guests at a time. However, the booths in the very middle are elevated, so guests need to take a step before sitting. The place follows a light brown color scheme, though the booth cushions are a reddish-burgundy color. Coffee beans sit on a mounted shelf on the wall and mirrors covered in artwork adorn the walls near the front. Regular tables can be seen near the back and counter seating is available as well. We ordered the following: Daughter ordered the Bleu Cheese Burger with tomato and onion and potatoes. She ordered it rare and was disappointed because it came out medium well to well done and it was hard to chew. It's funny how when you order it rare and get it well done! I figure it's because they're worried about cooking it rare and they don't trust their meat. So, she didn't feel like returning it back. It's not the first time and it won't be the last. The burger came with fries and that wasn't expected because the menu said that it came with potatoes. If she knew that she was going to get fries, she said that she would've gotten it well done. Hubs got the Red Bank Diner Omelette with grits and multigrain bread. The omelette came with roasted red peppers, mushrooms, avocado and Swiss cheese. Daughter thought the grits were good. Hubs thought it was nice to see grits for a change but it was a little under seasoned. He liked the mix of vegetables in the omelette but thought it was overcooked and tough. Lastly, I ordered the 2 eggs over easy with English muffin and liked it. This was ok. Service was quick and friendly. I've been wanting to try this place for a while and glad that we got a chance to try to this place!

I really wanted to love this place. It was so cute but it was average the potatoes that we ordered…read morewith onions had no other seasoning at all and the bacon I've never seen bacon that sliced so thin it was like three little sheets of paper so yeah, just average at best.

Fair Haven Diner

4.5

(15 reviews)

I had the Fair Haven Diner on my radar and we finally made it today. We were lucky with timing and…read moresat right away. Our server, Rachel was friendly and gracious. Food was very good. They are a new addition to Fair Haven- will be one year in May. Eggs over corned beef hash Kids meal- pancake, egg, meat The pancakes are excellent and so is their coffee. A nice spot for breakfast or lunch.

Fair Haven Diner is a spacious and great-looking diner located in close proximity to several shore…read moretowns. I visited solo a few weeks ago, midday around 2. The restaurant was well-staffed with smiling faces. My order was Pepsi/no ice and a tuna sandwich plus onions. A quick trip to the rest room and returned to a soda with ice on the table. No biggie, I felt. My sandwich took 20 minutes, a bit long for a diner that had only a few customers at the time. The sandwich came out with tomatoes, not onions, and had to be fixed. The sandwich was eventually quite good. Three stars as it's a nice place, yet my experience ordering two simple things was a bit off. I would try again and compare visits.

Blue Swan Diner

3.3

(193 reviews)

This is a cozy place for its size and a very well ordered machine. We never had to wait for…read moreanything. The servers all seemed to work as a team and helped each other out as if service was their main goal. They were all very pleasant and attentive. The food was ... well, it was breakfast and breakfast done well. We were a party of four and all quite pleased with our meals. Nice size parking and access from both sides of the building - easy in and out. They also appear to do a huge take-out business. It was a great find on our visit to New Jersey.

Food was very salty. Had a taco salad. Service was meh. My server was not attentive at all. I…read morehad to ask for refills. It was not a busy time at all. Mostly empty.

Edie's Luncheonette

3.9

(74 reviews)

We came back to this great local diner feel kind of place. Parking is limited in front, with street…read moreparking nearby. We had the chx, burger, and a few other things. Also enjoyable and the staff is very nice. We will be back when we can again. Enjoy

I've been going for years because of the great breakfast and lunch. My favorite is the eggs…read moreBenedict Great start to a Sunday funday

The Breakfast Club

3.8

(29 reviews)

Great pancakes and sausage. I have breakfast there at least…read moretwice a month. It definitely has a local hometown atmosphere and the servers are very nice and efficient.

Great food, reasonable prices, friendly atmosphere. Nice people; customers and staff. (Hi Chrissy!)read more

Felicia's Kitchen

4.6

(41 reviews)

Felicia's Kitchen brings on the homey familiarity of good food and personable owners. It was…read moreobvious, friends & family are familiar with the menu. Guests are treated as family. I ordered a swiss and spinach omelette- w.potatoes & WW toast, a black tea w.milk. Simple, clean food. Both Felicia & Sam were on premises, chatting w.customers, Sam was up to his elbows in dishwashing went I went back to the kitchen to thank for the meal. Felicia declared to a table of family and friends she was waiting for Netflix to come and make her famous. Felicia, you already are! I'll be back!

Had my mom in town and we desperately needed some morning grub after running errands -- luckily…read moreFelicia's was close by and the reviews lured me in. This was, hands down, the best breakfast I've had since moving to NJ. Not only were the eggs perfectly fluffy, the potatoes perfectly crispy and the toast -- an often forgotten about afterthought of a diner meal -- was fresh and flavorful. To top it off, we got to engage with queen felicia herself (an absolutely adorable fireball of well warranted sass) and Sam (photographed below in portrait form with my mom who shares the same name). I will be back, I want Felicia to adopt me as a son and I wish them nothing but the best moving forward.

Highlands Cafe

5.0

(8 reviews)

I'll addicted .... This is my go to spot for breakfast but…read moreI'm falling into a rut because what I order is so good! The croissants are amazing either with pork roll or bacon Avocado available as an add-on too

Stoped here for two meals. 1 dinner was off the hook. Great…read morestaff amazing food. 2 we had breakfast and my sausage egg and cheese sandwich was fresh and home made. I highly recommend stoping here for your food needs. It's awesome.

Beach Grille

4.1

(58 reviews)

I've stopped here for breakfast a few times. The place is somewhat seedy, but makes a great…read morebreakfast. One of the problems with breakfast, for me, is a lot of places drench everything with butter and salt... which most people seem to like. Not me, I like healthy, natural flavors. I have a couple times ordered their Jersey Girl omelette (tomatoes, asparagus, mozzarella, green onions), and it is made to perfection. Tasty, healthy, and not greasy. Just wonderful. The only thing that prevents me from rating 5 stars is that I was a little surprised that the eggs, which came with toast and potatoes (I had a banana instead), did not come with coffee, for which they charged $3.50 (hey, even Starbucks with their outrageous pricing charges only $2.45 for a cup of plain old coffee). But I would definitely recommend Beach Grille for an eggsellent breakfast!

Everything is freshly prepared with love! Tasty dishes and great staff! Fran makes some of her own…read morebakery items and caters for special events in Long Branch! She is and her staff are always welcoming and accommodating! Seating is abundant inside and out during the warmer months. We love supporting our local businesses and Fran is definitely one of them!'

Americana Diner

3.2

(263 reviews)

Great Jersey diner, the potatoes had great flover, everything was great, great serviceread more

Classic diner vibes .. good service... loved their mozz sticks and fried lunch foods. Wasn't really…read moreloving the pancakes and breakfast foods, the grease or grill taste was too much. Would go back for lunch / dinner tho!

Miller's Luncheonette

3.7

(36 reviews)