Bahrs is just as good in the winter as the summer! Just had a terrific family dinner at our go to seafood spot. The food is fantastic and the atmosphere " old school " Jersey shore. Service is terrific especially if Roddy has your table. This is a one of a kind classic. If you like great fresh seafood and a great atmosphere on the water , this is the place. read more

Food was mediocre. If I'm spending $200 on a dinner for two I expect the food to be cooked properly. We ordered clams casino which were meh, lobster bisque had no lobster and was over salted. I ordered scallops, shrimp and crab over risotto. The risotto was so cheese it was just pure salt, shrimp was way overcooked and over seasoned. Crab meat was shredded, no lump. No flavor. My partner had the Captains dish, lobster tails were again over seasoned. His shrimp was ok. Safe your money and go somewhere else. read more

3/10/26: We stopped in Bahrs Landing for lunch. We had a lovely table by the window. The view of the water was mesmerizing. Donna was our wonderful server. Started out with a Boylans Diet Root Beer and Red Blend wine. Delicious complementary biscuits and butter were brought to the table. Entrees: We had Lobster Boss and Shrimp $26 and Navigator Shrimp $17. I ordered the burger med well. The burger came out medium rare. It was very pink in the middle. The small lobster tail that topped off the burger was tasted fried and overcooked. Anyway, the taste of the food lingered on till the next day. The Shrimp Navigator's combination of ingredients weren't balanced. I think Bahrs is best to stop in for drinks and the wonderful water views. Bahrs has a very cute gift shop. The shop has nicely scented soaps and sweat shirts with the Bahrs Restaurant logo. The restaurant has plenty of parking. read more

See all

Classic spot in a beautiful location on the marina. Outdoor seating with great views of the water, old-school decor if you sit in the main dining room, and generally prompt service (unless they're super packed). Their oyster happy hour has some great value dishes, alongside the $1.25 oysters of course! If you're looking for good quality seafood with a nice view of the Atlantic Highlands area - Bahrs Landing is the place! Since 1917, going strong. read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

Perfect location with gorgeous views! This is a solid family owned business that has been standing for over 100 years! Came here on a weekend and got seated quickly (though when I came back a second time we got lucky because a prior reservation cancelled and we got the table, otherwise it would have been a 40 min wait). I got the thai mussels which were very flavorful! My husband got the New England clam chowder which was a hit. read more

See all

What an incredibly cool historic place right on the water! So many things to look at from the outside all the way through the giftshop and restaurant! I've heard so much about the food and boy were they right! The best clamp chowder I've ever had in my life! The bread oh the bread! I really should've stopped there but I didn't I went on to the fish and chips my mouth is watering as I write this. It was the most delicate wonderful fish of my life! Oh and the key lime pie was knock your socks of delicious! Our waitress had been there for ever and was on it! Top notch service atmosphere and food! Outstanding!! read more

See all

This place is amazing, fresh seafood and authentic German dishes! It has indoor and outdoor seating directly at the water and the best part, they are super dog friendly. The service is great and the food even better. It has almost a museum like decor inside and a gift shop. My wife loves the steamers and steamed lobster here soooo much that we always come here when we pass by. read more

See all

Stopped in for dinner and sat by a window. Asked waitress for a new plate because we had a couple ants crawling on them. She didn't apologize and seemed as if she didn't believe us. So we later showed her the ants crawling on salt shaker... Again no apology, no offer to switch tables. She just said don't kill them because it could attract others. Ordered a broiled seafood sampler. Asked twice if it came with a side because none were listed. Waitress said mashed potato and vegetable.. No surprise that when it came out, there were none. I didn't bother to bring it to her attention because the meal itself was awful. Scallops were perfect, shrimp overcooked and hard, cod yasted like dirty dishwater and was not edible, fried clam strips bland. So disappointed. Also ordered NE and Manhattan clam chowder. NE was fine, the other had hard pieces of clam that you couldn't chew through. Complimentary biscuits, unremarkable. read more

See all

We stopped for lunch with our 4 children ( all 10 or under). Service was quick and the kids got their food before us as requested. My wife had the fried seafood platter and lived it. She said the lobster was done perfect! I had the grilled monkfish and was very happy with that also. read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Seafood platter. - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

See all

Great food! Everything is cooked well and very flavorful. The mashed potatoes were a perfect consistency but the vegetables looked like they were frozen and cooked to death. Prices can be a bit high, but that can be expected with a seafood place. Plenty of land lubber non-fish dishes as well and a great view of the marina/bay. The hostesses were super sweet but our waitress wasn't super attentive. read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Broiled Fillet of Flounder Platter - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

Happy hour oyster deal!!!! I originally came for the happy hour $1.25 oysters (only at bar no takeout), but stayed for the .75$ clams. The little neck clams were phenomenal and only .75$. The oysters were decent, east coast style so not too salty. I prefer a saltier oyster. The only caveat is that you have to find seating in that area. Lady at the bar was quite rude, didn't greet or acknowledge me, despite greeting every other person in the establishment so I had to wait for the guy. The guy was perfect! read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Clams on the 1/2 Shell Local - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

See all

Such a lovely Saturday afternoon to sit at their outside bar. The weather couldn't be more perfect to stare at the ocean and enjoying some delicious Bloody Mary and some Calamari. The Bloody Mary was so tasty and the calamari came with a generous portion. I really enjoyed my visit in this place last time. read more

See all

Love this place! 1st time and so worth it. The pictures do it no justice. We were seated near the panoramic window. Beautiful view can't wait to go back in the summer. The restaurant lived up to its great reviews. Started with Manhattan clam chowder. Wow!!! So creamy and tasty! Main course was lobster pot pie and grilled salmon, I ordered the bourbon bbq sauce topping. So fresh and delicious!!! And for dessert Bahrs Blueberry Crumble with vanilla ice cream The menu has lots of different seafood. Will definitely be back! Highly recommend if you're in the area! read more

See all

My family came in for lunch. We've been visiting for many years. Today, we had calamari chopped salad, Admiral's Grill, and a soft shelled crab sandwich. The food was fresh and tasty. Their biscuits are quite good, too. I had a great zero proof drink. Our server was upbeat and attentive. We enjoyed a lovely view of the river at our window-side table. We'll be back again as soon as we're in the area! read more

See all

DANNGGG THIS PLACE IS good. I don't even like oysters and I got the Oyster Po Boy. I am now willing to rethink my opinion on oysters. Super cute and friendly place with the best decorations. Happy Hour every day! read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Oyster Po'Boy Sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

See all

Outdoor in the summertime is an awesome spot! They have a bar you can get drinks before while your table is getting ready. The view is nice near the boats and water. The parking in the summer time is a little hectic, but the food is what makes it all worth it. The bread is so good in the beginning and highly recommend the shrimp scampi but over rice. read more

See all

We decided to try Bahrs after a morning at the beach in the "offseason." It was nice to get here without any hustle and bustle associated with the summer months. The service was great and made our kids feel very welcome. They ordered burgers which were huge! So they probably give Bahrs one million stars out of five. Bahrs offers a nice house IPA that accompanied the fry basket very well. The fried items themselves were very good, especially the scallops. I also had a seafood chili that did taste a bit fishy (literally) but nonetheless was enjoyable. After all that there was no room for dessert. I am sure we will come here again in future beach seasons. read more

A friend and I ate lunch off the lunch menu today at Bahrs. What was good? He service and pleasant, prompt and professional. We were able to sit inside looking out at the bay and watch terns fight. It's a beautiful, calming view. If I go back, it will be for the view. What's so-so? The food, which is unfortunate. I had a Half Jersey Roll Combo Lobster salad - Arugula, tomato, celery, mayonnaise on toasted brioche which is served with a choice of soup or salad, $25. The lobster bisque soup was innocuous and, came in a cup, as promised. The toasted brioche and lobster salad was actually quite good. But if this is half a sandwich, the the whole sandwich must have been the size of a dinner roll. A small dinner roll. If this was $15, maybe it would be okay, but at $25, no way. My friend had a whole crab sandwich, which seemed to be about normal size with sweet potatoes fries. She said it was good but not outstanding. The pricing was similar. So, it's a pleasant setting with good service and satisfactory. The food varies but the pricing is high for what you get. read more

Came here on a recommendation and it did not disappointment. The restaurant is right next to the water which provided a nice view. Our server was very attentive. We started off with the popcorn shrimp. I had the linguini and clams as my entree. We really enjoyed our meal. The drinks were well made. It is a little pricey but you're paying for the location. I would return read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

See all

The food and experience weren't what I expected for a $38 dinner. It's the little things, like the subpar iced tea and the possible use of margarine instead of butter with the bread. I suspect I was treated differently as a solo non-local. Strong points on the sampler were the clam strips and shrimp. I'm agnostic about the fish and wasn't into the scallops. Counterintuitively, Bahrs might be a place where the basics are less safe than the complex entrees, as some of the more glammed-up dishes were at least visually impressive, one being the mahi. Scenic location, good collection of ocean-themed memorabilia. read more

My husband and I stopped at Bahrs Restaurant several days ago, and sat at the bar and ordered from the happy hour menu. I had the salmon club, which was all dried out and tasteless. My husband's flounder platter had vegetables that were all dark green and hard. Everything looked like it was laying there in a refrigerator for a long time. The bar maid was extremely rude. However, the male bartender was very nice and accommodating. We paid the bill and left, never to go there again. read more

Such a beautiful evening, and a beautiful atmosphere! The parking situation is a little confusing, as this seems to be quite a big and popular restaurant. There are many different kinds of seating, but plenty of them have a beautiful view wether you sit indoors or out. This is a perfect place for a date, a family get together or a slightly larger gathering. My party of 12 sat indoors. Full bar with cocktails and wine was essential. A hefty menu with something for everyone! I was between a few items, but there are little stars next to what Bahr's think they do best, so ultimately I took a chance on the summer special tuna tataki. It was absolutely delightful, and only just caught! We were able to taste a wide variety thanks to getting a smaller lobster and a few appetizers. Everyone was very pleased with their meal, our only thing to note is that the broiled scallops seemed a little lightly cooked. Our server, Roddy, was absolutely delightful. He was very kind, attentive, and told us a little bit about the boat that had caught the tuna for my order! We've been talking about the food and the restaurant for days, definitely some of the best around. We are already looking to come back out! read more

See all

Bahrs Landing is perfectly situated adjacent to the Sandy Hook bridge and on the water. It has plenty of indoor, outdoor, and outdoor bar seating. It has very appealing nautical decor and historical framed pictures adorning many walls. As always, we were treated very well and enjoyed another memorable meal. Every item that was presented was delicious, well seasoned, and required a to-go box. On top of providing flavorful food, we also perused their gift shop, and picked up a comfortable pair of pj's, just in time for Shark Week.   :-) Bahrs will always be our primary eatery, when in the Sandy Hook area and I'm glad that they ALWAYS come through with flying colors. read more

See all

We went to Bahr's Landing for Valentine's Day lunch and the food was horrible. HORRIBLE. The scallops on a broiled seafood sampler were stringy and had a strong chemical taste. The shrimp were barely edible, and the fried clam strips were soggy and flavorless. Mashed potatoes were so cold that whipped butter wouldn't even melt on them. The side veggies were a raw, charred mess. The stuffed flounder was rubbery and salty. Look, we are not people who go out looking to complain. Dining out is expensive, and we dressed up looking to have a beautiful meal out. The view at Bahr's is amazing and the waiter was friendly. We chose not to complain because it's obvious our meals were par for the course there. That food is acceptable to Bahr's to serve, maybe because it's a tourist destination. I will add the New England clam chowder was good and we made the best of a sunny day with pretty views. But this was one of the absolute worst meals we have ever eaten (picked at). read more

Love it here. It's the go to place after a nice day at the beach for us. The vibe is laidback and the outside seating is super chill and relaxing. Service is always great and staff is super friendly. We are never disappointed with the food or drinks! read more

Bahrs (pronounced "bars") is an institution. I remember once seeing a picture of Frank Sinatra pulling up in a boat to eat there. It's also been featured in The Sopranos and has been our go-to every time we visit the beach. You can dine inside or outside right on the dock with a view of Sandy Hook Bridge. We always sit outside in the summer. There's an outdoor bar too. I started with a lavender martini which was refreshing and delicious and their Manhattan clam chowder, a signature recipe since 1917. I also loved the Jersey lobster roll on a toasted brioche. It was full of lobster meat. Delicious! I was able to substitute the chips for a small Bahrs' chop salad too. Our young server was friendly and attentive. Overall, Bahrs fits the bill as a traditional seashore destination. read more

See all

Bahrs has been around since 1917, and today still offers great seating options both inside and outside. The bar outside was a great option for us to grab some drinks before heading inside for dinner. The building has large windows which makes every seat in the restaurant a great one. It perfectly reminds me of a typical Maine restaurant. The oysters and the hot lobster roll were some of the best I've had. Extremely fresh and light. I had the broiled scallops for my main which was also excellent. However, one of our guests was disappointed with the Blackened Yellowfin Tuna. It came out much later than all the other entrees, and was very overcooked. However, our amazing waitress, Heidi, was able to accommodate. I think this spot is definitely worth a try & I can't wait to come back. Such a cool vibe. read more

See all

Great spot right on the water. Outdoor bar area is dog friendly and has perfect views. The fact that the food is above average is a nice bonus. read more

See all

We came here for dinner on a warm day in October because we wanted to sit on the water. The vibe outside is lovely - you can sit at the outdoor bar, sit outside dining or indoors - and have a view of the marina. For appetizers we ordered a dozen oysters and the steamers - both were incredible! For mains, we ordered the Fisherman's Platter and the Surf & Turf and a side of the lobster mac & cheese. Overall good steak and seafood, the lobster tails were over and hard. The lobster mac & cheese was 15/10 delicious. We want to come by in the summer. Highly recommend their spicy margaritas! read more

See all

Service was very good. Quick and no bull. I do agree that the bread should come with real butter not margarine- and also same goes for any seafood. HAVE TO serve it with clarified butter, margarine is disgusting with seafood. All of the seafood was cooked to perfection (but all had the same seasoning). I get it...old bay is the best but I too was expecting more. I really liked the vibe and the comfort of the restaurant. Bar area is pretty relaxing. I will try it again and maybe go for a different dish like the lobster mac. read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Broiled Fisherman's Platter. - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

We were there to celebrate Thanksgiving. The others in my party ordered traditional seafood items from their regular menu, which were excellent as usual. I opted for their Thanksgiving Turkey Platter for $39. I was expecting freshly carved turkey meat, but was extremely disappointed when the waitress brought out my order. It looked and tasted like glorified food from a diner. Lesson learned. Never order turkey from a seafood place. read more

Bahrs Landing Restaurant - Thanksgiving Turkey Platter. - Seafood Near Me - Highlands, New Jersey

This is a great local favorite in Atlantic Highlands! It has a large menu and an interesting nautical themed dining area. They specialize in seafood, and have enormous Brazilian lobster tails regularly on the menu which are one of my go to items. The homemade biscuits they provide complimentary are family favorites as well. Definitely worth a stop if you are looking for a nice casual seafood restaurant with the family! PS - In October they have a special German menu for Octoberfest with some authentic German options too that are pretty good. The pretzel are enormous and the kids love them. read more

Came here for date night with my love and we were 100 satisfied with everything about this place. The view of the water was to die for and magical. As an appetizer we ordered shrimp cocktail. The size of the shrimp was amazing and it tasted great. Then for our entrees; I had fried shrimp basket which was absolutely delicious and he had the salmon which was also delicious. Oh yeah, they bring you biscuits as you wait which were 100% amazing and the butter they bring with them is also delicious. Everything about this place is just a vibe. The waitress was great and the hostess was very happy and welcoming as soon as we walked in. read more

Though the vibe is enjoyable and the staff are kind, the food is abysmal. Raw oysters should have the briney flavor of the sea but the ones served tasted like tap water from Camden. Do better. read more

Can't hold a flame? Man, I can't even say that or compare cause this place refuses to even pick up a torch. When this place wants to be treated like a real seafood joint I'll add a real review. read more

My husband and I recently had lunch at Bahrs Landing, and it truly exceeded our expectations. Despite the fact that it was a blustery day, we were allowed to sit outside on the front patio with our dog, and our amazing server, Kostis, took such good care of us. He was so kind and attentive and friendly--truly the epitome of an excellent server. The restaurant itself is really cute and was pretty crowded even for an offseason midweek lunch, so I can only imagine how busy it gets during warmer months. We enjoyed an epic seafood feast: chowder, oysters, steamers, and lobster. Everything was beyond delicious and perfectly prepared. I admittedly have high standards for seafood given my New England upbringing, and I loved it all. The chowder had generous chunks of tender clam meat, which you don't often find at seafood spots in NYC. We are already planning to return in the fall with my father when he visits the area. Looking forward to it! read more

See all

Went last night for a friend's birthday. We were seated with a beautiful water view of the Sandy Hook. Waiter very attentive throughout our dinner. Wish i had gotten his name! Funny and helpful. Food was amazing. Birthday girl had stuffed flounder and we had Yankee pot roast. I took home for hubby pot roast and potato pancakes. Yum to all! Margaritas were generous Lava cake with a candle for dessert. I highly recommend This place has withstood the passing of time. Still has a great bar and a shop full of memorabilia. Please go! read more

I hadn't been to Bahr's since I was a kid, but since I'll be moving to the area soon I thought I'd drop in. I was very pleasantly surprised at our meal. We split a Bavarian pretzel and popcorn shrimp, followed by crabmeat stuffed shrimp and a NJ lobster roll. The apps were terrific-the pretzel soft and warm (beer cheese and mustard sauces), the shrimp tender and sweet. The shrimp were exemplary, not those food service type rubber nuggets you're used to getting. The lobster roll was excellent, the stuffed shrimp terrific. The warm biscuits with whipped butter were delicious as well. I figured Bahr's was going to be touristy and overpriced, and I'm thrilled to report it was neither. read more

Randomly found this place driving around looking for a place to eat after going to the beach. We both ordered hot lobster rolls and I had to try the NE clam chowder. Soup could have been a little hotter but overall flavor was pretty good, hot lobster rolls were filled with lobster meat and toasted bun was nice, liked the side of butter as well. Hot rolls were a nice addition and I liked that the Cole slaw wasn't super mayo-y. Service was okay, there was some confusion I guess and it took a long time for a server to come over and help us. When someone finally arrived they were great so it sortve made up for the long wait. read more

See all

This place has always been hit or miss. Right on the water, so no shortage of customers in the summer - even if repeats are rare, they've survived on their location. Now, I'm a slow learner, because a) we went back and b) forgot that ordering Octoberfest food anywhere other than Germany is foolish. Here's the low-down: The Good: Found parking, utensils were clean, service was prompt. The Meh: Table right near servers' station - and they weren't crowded; friendly male waiter, alas not ours; prices are reasonable. The Ugly: Requested one substitution - spaetzle instead of potato salad, sauerkraut and red cabbage. Not possible. We had to order the spaetzle separately and were charged accordingly. Sauerbraten as dry as straw and impossible to swallow. Noone at our table could eat it. Female waitress rudely took the plate away without apology or offering something else. She then told us the manager took it off the check. When we asked what he said, she said "nothing, our German food is the best and known all over and nobody every complained" - we were stunned. Dessert menu put down without offer of coffee or anything else. Not sure what her problem is, but I kind of regret leaving a generous tip. On our way out, the manager ignored us - unbelievable. read more