I know, I know...pineapple doesn't belong on pizza but regardless of that - this was a great deal & a tasty pizza. 2 Med 2 Toppings for less than $17. Sauce is flavourful and there is ample toppings. A great go to for homemade pizza from a nice "non-chain" pizzeria in the New Bern area. read more

Gina's Pizza - 2 Med 2 toppings for $16.65 - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

The worst! They screwed up my order. I live 40 minutes away. I willl never go back. When I called they said they would refund me for something they screwed up. Horrible customer service read more

Of the few pizza places in this area Gina's is our go to. Great pizza sauce... Wonderful Stromboli and Calzones.. read more

Good food, great pizza. Back to it's original glory. Also reasonable speed, and effort.

Awesome pizza in James City! Appetizer: Cheese Stix- awesome appetizer & comes with a marinara dipping sauce. The positive: Delicious consistent pizza. $7.49 large two topping carry out special. The negative: Difficult to get to/ leave during rush hour. Open: Monday - Thursday 11am-9pm Friday - Saturday 11am-10pm Overall I recommend Gina's pizza in James City to all locals and tourists! read more

Gina's Pizza - Pepperoni Gina's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

This used to be my "go to" place for a good pizza. Sorry to say, not anymore. Once it changed ownership, quality went out the door. It's a crap shoot on whether your pizza will be even fully baked. Raw dough, practically unmelted cheese. Even when I put it in my oven, the cheese never gets that little bit of browning. I swear they are using imitation cheese. I gave them one last shot. I ordered my usual pepperoni and green olive pizza. I got pepperoni and green peppers. The person proceeded to argue with me over what I ordered. Never again will I order from there. NEVER read more

Gina's pizza was great but the new owners have raised the prices and there pizza is not as good.

This is probably the best delivery I have had while in New Bern. I am surprised there are not more reviews on this place. The pizza was really good! It was neither a think nor thin crust and the cheese was great, not greasy. The pricing was really reasonable and the delivery was only $2.00. The sauce was delicious! The chef salad was plentiful and also really good. If you are in the area looking for great delivery, this is your place!! read more

Gina's Pizza - Small cheese pizza $7.50 - Pizza Near Me - New Bern, North Carolina

See all

Gina's is back. Everything tasted great. I want to tell everyone, if you stopped going to Gina's because of the last group that was running it tried to fix something that wasn't broken. Try them again. You won't be disappointed. Thanks to the new crew. read more

Great pizza, fast service!!! We were traveling thru the area and so glad we found this place!!!

Gave them another try a few years after initially giving them a go. Same song. Pizza was terrific. Staff was rude, incompetent, lazy and just bad on the phone. Tried to tell me address (less than a 3 miles away) was too far to deliver. Waited 1 hr for delivery, which they warned me beforehand. Food was cold and overpriced. Delivery guy was nice. read more

Great pizza and staff! Specials everyday really cheap and hot! Good for the holidays when your short on cash but need good hot food! They have really awesome pizza that is made fresh every time you order! read more

See all

Really sub par compared to the past. Skimpy toppings and not up to the usual standard. Always loved them but i might not return.

The pizza wast ok remains me of Pizza Hut but not as good! I ordered a chef salad n they didn't have any low fat dressing n it was mostly peppers not good I really don't think I will go back ! I had to go back because they forgot an order of my wings n they said if I wanted them it would take 16 min ! I said no thank u my pizza would be cold they did credit my card read more

I will be spending about 6 weeks this summer in New Bern at my parents' recovering from leg surgery. To keep myself amused, I've decided that my mission is to find the best pizza possibilities of New Bern. An appetizer + pizza to be ordered from a local establishment every Friday evening. Gina's is first on the list. Positive reviews on Yelp! Found their website with a menu & coupons! They deliver! I ordered a dozen hot wings and a large pizza with 3 toppings (using a coupon for $10 Any Large Pizza) There was a delivery charge of a few bucks so the total was just over $20. Quite the deal! Verdict as follows. The driver arrived in the 30-40 minutes as promised. The wings were meaty, spicy and at a good temperature for serving. 2 bleu cheese packets provided. Pizza didn't quite seem like a "large" but, the crust and sauce were quite tasty. Definitely channelling the NYC-style! My only mention is that the toppings were kinda sparse and the slices were cut unevenly and not all the way through (Disproportionate pizza slices have caused many a fight in my family growing up, so this is near and dear to my heart when rating a pie !) My review for Gina's is very favorable. For the price, the wings and pizza are getting the job done! But maybe your "large" should be called a "medium?" read more

Gina's is awesome! They have great pizza. They have worked with Eastersealsucp foster care program to create some memorable events for our foster children. This is a local business who supports its local community. Can't ask for much more. Support this local business and enjoy some great pizza! read more

Honestly my favorite pizza place in the James City area. The prices are reasonable and the pizza is very tasty. I don't care as much about the ambiance of a take-out place- AGAIN, it's take OUT. But I love the taste of the Gina's pizzas sauce and dough. Two thumbs up. Errrr...rather 5 stars, hands down. read more

The past two times we have ordered from here, we have had terrible service. We are told that the pizza will be delivered in 45 minutes but an hour and a half goes by and still no delivery. We then call to check the status and both times are told "sorry the driver is having issues. We are going to remake your pizza and send it out".... so we then wait another 30 minutes and when the driver arrives he is rude. No apology for being late, no discount taken off the pizza, nothing. By the time it arrived we aren't even hungry anymore. Needless to say we will not be ordering from Gina's again. read more

Thank you for opening a place here in Pamlico! We've been subjected to that average, overpriced Little Italy for much too long. Your pizza is delicious and well priced. We will be coming back often. read more

Ordered a puzza with sausage, mushrooms and onions, a chef salad and breadsticks. Everything was delicious. They put plenty of toppings on the pizza. Will definitely go back and would recommend to others. read more

Large cheese for around five bucks! Cheap and awesome pizza. Other menu items are good too. We always get good food and friendly service here. read more

Pizza was outstanding. Really fair price for the size of the pizza you get. Not a real big menu but what they do have is delicious. Staff is really friendly. Inside of store is a bit weathered but don't let that sway your decision to try it out. I was skeptical at first but glad I ordered from there. read more

Horrible customer service!!! Man taking phone order hung up on my Mom when she called it in, the order was delivered without cheese sticks and the manager STILL wouldn't make it right. Give your money to someone who appreciates your business. read more

Great pizza! I always enjoy a good pizza, and get tired of the chain restaurants. And they deliver to my house! Doesn't get better than that.... I ordered an x-large pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon for our family. It was delivered in less than 30 minutes. It was excellent. It fed me, my husband, and my two daughters, and we had half a pie left over. The only downside, the pizzas are expensive. But no more than ordering 2 large pizzas from Pizza Hut. I can't wait to try one of their speciality pizzas, and create my own. read more

I attended night classes in 2009 and had many Chef Salads from Gina's esp when it was the special free |r gu I UK night. They were spectacular. I haven't ordered one since graduation until last night. Ginas must have listed to too many Panero Bread commercials about their "clean" salads. As opposed to ..dirty? Nails on a chalkboard. The salad greens were totally Romaine, flat, not old but not like a crispy mix with iceberg. The onions and green pepper looked to have to have been choppedChopped and frozen used to be a nice sliced ring,many times red. Tomato and.,the meats were a basic ham with a basic turkey, w/sliced mozerella and a lot of sliced black olives. Good for me, I like them butbut fax 0) ₩₩ not everyone does. I have not called to complain. Pick up a pizza and then you watch. I didn't my food wasn read more

Home of the New Bern's famous $5 pizza. Yep, you read that right, a five dollar pizza that tastes good. One topping large. At $5 it's in my budget every day of the week. And they make it with the extra, extra sauce I like that no other joint in town can seem to consistently get right. It's my favorite pizza in town, but my hubby likes 37th street better. Honestly, at 3x the price, I can't see it.. I just love Gina's. Try it and see. My only complaint is they are closed Sundays. read more

Come on man! Im in a hotel... no plates.. no napkins? Your dude didn't even know I pre-paid. I felt bad for him. Pizza is pretty good!

I will NEVER order pizza from Gina's Pizza in James City EVER again! They messed up my order, I called to find out what was wrong and the OWNER(???) told me to shut up and leave her alone!!??? I've been ordering pizza from here for years and have never been treated like this. Thanks for messing up my Valentine's Day, Gina's. read more

We quit going there because of messed up orders and sloppy looking pizzas. We decided to try it again and what a difference. My son says it was because they brought back Neal. I don't know him but if that much difference is because of Neal. PLEASE keep Neal there. Since Neal is back we have not had any problem with pizza, subs or anything else. Grandkids love the pizza again! read more

This pizza and wings had better be died for good because they are at least 30 minutes over the stated delivery time!!! And this is a Thursday! What??? The woman (actually stupid clueless girl) can barely answer a phone, much less tell u with accuracy what is going on. At this point I would give 0 stars if I could!!!!!!! Again, if I could give this a 0, I would. Just puked my guts out. Had 4 wings and 1 slice. Stomach still churning. Guessing the horribly long delivery time did it...... read more