I've been waiting to go to this restaurant for a while, and decided today would be a good day for a family outing. Everyone who went remembers Garufa when it use to be Swensons. They have made a lot of changes, but the ambiance is very nice. It doesn't feel overcrowded and though the lights are low, it isn't to the point where you can't read the menu (which is a problem I've noticed at a lot more of the eateries nowadays).
The first thing that arrived was a basket or bread and and three dipping sauces, a salsa rojo, a white bean dip and a chimichurri. The rojo was a nice, not overly spicy salsa;the white bean dip had whole beans in a vinegar base...the flavor good and the beans were still firm and not mushy; the chimichurri had a good acidity to it and would be perfect accompaniment to a steak.
Next came our two appetizers. The provoleta came as a recommendation from the waiter. It was a grilled chunk of provolone with a roasted red pepper on top. In my mind, its hard to go wrong with cheese, so I thought was definitely worth the try. My small gripe is I wish it had been hotter and stringier. We also got an assortment of Turnovers. The beef, which I didn't try since I'm vegetarian, was good, but the tablemates weren't sure it was authentic because A-the crust was very flaky (which I prefer to a dense dough) and B- the last tame they had them they came with raisins and onions. That being said, they were still enjoyed by those who sampled them. They said it was a mix between an empanada and a gordita. Next was the Espinaca. The spinach and cream are a naturally good combination, which was enhanced by the hint of nutmeg. Finally, the best of the 3 was the Camaron. There were a lot of shrimp in the turnover and they weren't overpowered by the red peppers, tomato and onions..rather they enhanced their flavor.
Our lunches arrived soon after. My father ordered a 14 ounce steak and fries. While he usually complains about places overcooking the steaks, he didn't say anything about this one, which is always an excellent sign. My mother got a chicken sandwich which was so large that she could only finish half. The chicken in the sandwich had queso fresco and some of the chimichurri sauce. My sister ordered salmon that appeared to have been cooked well. She commented that the tartar sauce was not offensive like so many are. I had to agree; it was not to creamy and had a pleasant dill taste. My niece ordered the chicken breast, which was also more than she could finish. She said it was lightly marinated and needed a little bit more salt. I ordered the grilled vegetable salad and two more turnovers(queso and Roquefort). The vegetables were well cooked and weren't overly salted. Like the cheese before, I think they should have been served hot, however. The queso turnover was incredibly cheesy, I would estimate the inside was a baseball sized mass of cheese! Although I'm not a blue cheese fan, I decided to give the Roquefort a chance. The mix of the cheese, celery and pecans well-balanced each other out. The blue-ness of it was a bit extreme for me, but it is a definite for those who like that type of cheese.
Finally, we had deserts (yes, somehow we still had a little room for those, too). The apply strudel was good, but it was a bit sweet and reminded me of the pie filling from Village Inn. The Alfajor was a flaky biscuit type desert with caramel and pecans in it, a worthy desert. The panqueue de dolce de leche was a sweet crepe, with a cajeta-like taste, also good, but I wouldn't go out of my way to order it. The coffee flan was a big slice with a subtle coffee flavor. The consistency wasn't too eggy, which made others at the table happy. While all the other deserts were good, the best by far was the Copa Helado.... a glass of ice cream with pecans (which seem to be abundant in the menu) and whiskey...I'm not a whiskey drinker, but that desert could turn me into one.
All the food that we order (plus soft drinks and a bottle of wine) came to approximately $175 dollars (pre-tip), which for the amount we had I would say is reasonable. Post tip, we passed the $200 mark, but our server was definitely worth it. Enrico was attentive, but not clingy. He was there when we needed him, but we never felt like he hovered.
Although unique restaurants don't tend to last in El Paso, I'm hoping this is one of the exceptions. I can see my self making a monthly visit to have the Shrimp and Spinach turnovers with the Whiskey ice cream for desert. I recommend everyone try this restaurant at least once. read more