We usually do deilvery. Alawys courteous driver. Amazing pizza. Great cinnamon bites. read more

We have friends in Caldwell that think their Garbanzo's has great pizza. We decided to come over from Star and try the Middleton location. It was a Monday night about 5:45 pm. There were very few people in the restaurant. However, they seem to do a great takeout and delivery business. There were probably 6-7 people working, and it seemed like it might be a family operated restaurant. the Interior is basic wood tables and we sat on a kind of pew bench. Comfortable. There is not great lighting, and the salad bar does not have any light over it, so it is difficult to see what you are grabbing. The young man that helped us with our order was nice and friendly. We ordered a medium pepperoni pie and two salad bars. The salad bar wasn't bad but it wasn't great, either, though I did like the bleu cheese dressing. We sat and ate our salad, then waited for the pizza. The tall, blond woman that brought out our pizza just put it on the table and walked away, unsmiling. Later, we noticed her smiling and joking with the other workers. They all seemed to have a good time, but they weren't paying any attention to the customers. The pizza was hot, the pepperoni ample, and the cheese melted. The flavor was just OK, as was the crust, which is something other reviewers seem to really like. When we finished, we said thank you to everyone working behind the counter, but not one person looked at us or said anything. Maybe they didn't even notice us. We have a few pizza places in Star. I think we'll just do takeout in Star, or go to one of our favored places in Eagle or Meridian. read more

Visiting from CA and gave Garbanzos a try. Their pizza is amazing!! Definitely underrated here on yelp. Love that the pizza isn't soggy and saggy when you pick up a piece. We ordered a thick crust pizza and a cauliflower crust. The best we've had in a while! read more

Great family pizza restaurant We have enjoyed every wonderful pizza we have ever bought. Favorite place in town. read more

I often order from this location and usually have a good experience but unfortunately last night i received breadsticks with MULTIPLE strands of hair cooked into them... just gross and goes to show that they don't prioritize cleanliness read more

This place needs work. Came in at 6:30pm on a Tuesday night with my family. The place was empty but 5 employees were working behind the counter. None of them greeted us, instead gave us a look like we were interrupting or they were about to close. We asked if they were about to close, they said no. Ordered the XL pizza and garlic bread. The pizza was ok but the garlic bread was an insult to any Italian. It was bread with cheese and garlic powder. Dry and bland. My ancestors are rolling in their graves. Chop up some garlic or worst case use jarred garlic but garlic powder...C'mon Service was terrible. Ambiance = terrible... put some music on and greet your customers. read more

Garbonzo's Pizza - Dry garlic bread. No flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Middleton, Idaho

Pizza was a good taste and grandkids liked it too, we chose to have a delivery. Delivery was about 45-50 min but was overall a good experience read more

THOSE ARE NOT FRIED WINGS!! I ordered wings a couple nights ago thinking they would be fried like most wings at any other pizza place.. so I added "extra crispy please" in the added requests. Nope. These are OVEN BAKED. It doesn't say that ANYWHERE when you order. So if you are expecting to get crispy fried wings, you won't. Waste of money. They went in the trash. read more

I wish I could give it half stars, but I rounded up. It's the only pizza place here in Middleton so it is always very busy. However, even for a Friday night it only took about 35 minutes to pick up and bring home. I feel like the pizzas are getting smaller too. To start off, their crust is amazing. It's always perfectly cooked and flavorful. Anyway, the Hawaiian was just okay, it didn't seem like Canadian bacon but smoked ham. The pepperoni and mushroom was pretty good. I think the sauce on the pizzas could use a little work. Long story short, not the best pizza in the world but it does do the trick. read more

See all

I can't believe how amazing this pizza is. We are new to Caldwell, but not the Treasure Valley. We have tried all sorts of pizza joints some good, some not so good. But this place... Wow... The pizza was so good. My kids who are super picky absolutely devoured it. I highly recommend this place. The staff is super friendly and helpful, and their prices are just right. read more

Garbonzo's Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Middleton, Idaho

See all

Worst pizza I've ever had! Order a thin crust large, crust was soggy, vegetables looked like they were hacked apart by a serial killer. Just pure crap!! read more

Good pizza and service. The younger kids working there need better training as they forgot two ingredients on my pizza. But the taste was great. They told me twenty minutes and it was ready in 20. All in all a good experience read more

Due to an unfortunate event at home I had to fimd the closest laundry mat to Star which happened to be in Middleton. Around the corner is Garbonzos. Now when I walked in a got the plesant feeling because it's like a hometown pizzeria vibe. They had a small buffet, TV, and some games for the kids. Service was good there was one kid working at around 12 so he said it would be about 30 min for carry out which was fine since I was doing laundry. I took the pizza home to the carbage disposals also known as my children. I ordered one pepperoni and one Hawaiian. The ham on the haiwaiian was still cold. They put an excessive amount on and I was not happy with the entire pizza. I tried to force down another piece but at the end of the day I wasted $20 because it went in the trash. The pepperoni was okay but I've had better frozen. It's very unlikely I ever walk in to this place again. read more

Been in here three times. Each time I went in I ordered my pizza and waited for 45 minutes, went up to the counter to ask them why it was taking so long and they said "Oh, we haven't started it yet." I hear it's good pizza, if you can get served. Three strikes and you're out. I'm never going to another Garbozo's Pizza again. read more

Best pizza in Idaho! Whenever we visit we order from them. Reminds us of east coast pizza. Very tasty - delicious - great topping choices. Their specialty pizzas are awesome and not expensive. read more

Great pizza and friendly employees in a clean establishment. I never have a problem. The pizzas are cheaper and bigger than Mountain Mike's.

Great pizza. Our go-to if we want delivery or takeout. Online ordering is an option, as well.

Been going there for decades and it's still a great place. Their pizzas are always good and they manage to hire a great young staff. Ever had any issues. read more

The garbanzo's pizza in Middleton is fantastic everything is delicious the chicken fettuccine alfredo is the bomb be sure to order extra sauce it is the best I've ever tasted and I've tried a lot of them read more

Incredible pizza!! The staff are all friendly and very capable. My order is correct, timely and oh so tasty every time!

Just wanted to say, Tom is awesome!!! I dont need to tell you he makes the best pizza in Middleton. But what you need to know is his great customer service. I ordered pizza during busy holiday rush and went to pick it up. I showed up and paid, then waited. And waited. And waited some more. Finally Tom handed me the pizza and BEFORE I spoke.... he said "That pizza should have been out 20 minutes ago, I'm very sorry. There is a credit on your account". I was shocked AND pleased. My gosh, did I happen to tell you this is the best pizza place in town?! read more

Great thin crust my local favorite. Delivery food still hot when it arrives. Price is higher than others but quality is better then others... fresh toppings read more

Too many young kids working the kitchen. Total chaos results in botched orders and unnecessary delays.

Rude staff, which I'm pretty darn sure it was the owner. Pizza was undercooked and soggy. Restaurant was dirty and needs a really good deep clean, and staff with longer hair should be wearing hair nets. Won't be back! Try Poppi's! Great service, yummy pizza, super clean place! read more

Very friendly staff and excellent delivery. Easy to deal with and pizza arrived hot. A little bit hidden in a strip mall, but ample parking is available. read more

We tried this place on 1/22 because we heard how good the country chicken pizza was. We heard they also had a salad bar so we went about 430. Two tables were occupied so we went to the salad bar and it was mostly empty and the outer edges had food all over it specifically pepperoni. It was disgusting so we walked out. On a Friday nite one would expect more. Whomever the manager is should be fired for allowing this to happen. Doubt we will be back and will pass this around. Shameful. read more

Garbonzo's is one of my favorite pizza places in the Treasure Valley. I do have a few more I like but they are my go to. Love the everything pizza and that they are very generous with the toppings unlike a lot of other places. I highly recommend Garbonzo's if you haven't tried them yet. read more

Very friendly and courteous Staff, ordered a large pepperoni mushroom and anchovy pizza. Having it delivered to tractor supply store.

I really like their pizzas, but no mask, no gloves no social distance. We are not going back for awhile. so disapponted. read more

Absolutely delicious pizza. We also had the cauliflower crust pizza and it is the best I've ever had anywhere. It was crunchy and full of flavor. Do yourself a favor and try this place. read more

Garbonzo's Pizza - Hands down THE BEST cauliflower crust pizza I've ever had. It was crunchy and full of flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Middleton, Idaho

The crust and toppings were amazing. The sauces are somewhat average. We had a split enchilada and everything. It was very good regardless of the sauces. read more

Every time I've gotten the pepperoni pizza it's been the greasiest pizza I've ever had. It just taste like grease and basically have to use a whole roll of paper towels to clean your hands. read more

New York style hand tossed pizza with fresh made sauce and a cheese blend. If you know pizza then you know what I mean. It isn't deep dish and it isn't gourmet. It's good fresh recipe hometown taste will be back!!! It was free because of a mix up but it was delicious. We will become regulars thanks guys!!! read more

The first time we ordered from here, the pizza was not cooked all the way. This time, they cranked out some really great pizzas. The crust was cooked perfectly, and they screwed around and put fries on it. Lots of fun. It tasted like a big mac. All in all the pizza was great, but since it was the 35th anniversary, It was crowded and wasnt super clean. The interior could use a makeover, but it's not bad enough to turn me away. read more

Fun times at the 35th anniversary. Thanks for all your hard work feeding the crowd that came to celebrate with you. Great pizza and friendly service. read more

Two stars for the pizza because it was decent, but the service was terrible. Slow and incorrect each and every time. Definitely not worth the price. Would not return. read more

Good pizzas, nothing better the good home town hand tossed pizza. Everything is good and filling. but only down fall a large or aka XL pizza is $24 bucks if you want two it's $48 bucks. No value here but Tates good. read more

Our pizza was loaded with goodies and delicious! On-line ordering was easy and the facility is clean. Wonderful experience and a great staff! read more

Our group of 10 folks meet up every other Saturday to hang out and play games and eat lunch/dinner together at one of our homes. A few weeks ago, we ordered a few large pizzas from Garbonzo's and it was good! My wife and I had driven by their location a few times and I always wondered if their pizza was any good, I tend to be pretty picky when it comes to pizza and wife is even more so. That being said, I was pleasantly surprised when it arrived and everyone commented on how great it tasted. I'm really glad I gave it a try, the was fair and the pizza was much better than what I expected for that price. We'll defiantly order from Garbonzo's again the next time we are in the mood for a really tasty pizza. Have a great day folks:) read more

First time here. We did carry out and got the Everything Pizza. Was absolutely amazing. I normally don't get excited about pizza but they know what they are doing. Keep up the good work guys read more