Wow, this pizza place is like California Pizza Kitchen on crack...tons of awesome pizza flavors, fun sides and great service! Inside is homey and has a nice rustic, woodsy yet modern, edgy style. This isn't your average pizza joint...It's a special little nook of heaven. Ordered a medium cheese pizza with sausage, extremely twisted sticks, kickin' chicken (chicken marinated in a spicy ginger Thai sauce, peanuts, green onions, Swiss, Fontina, fresh cilantro, mozzarella, peanut sauce and shredded carrots) and a small baseline garden salad with ranch dressing. Baseline came out first and was a very generous size for a small. Every ingredient, the tomatoes, onions, lettuce, carrots and croutons were fresh and crafted to perfection. The ranch was a nice texture and flavor. Next came the Extreme Twisted Sticks, cheese sticks with marinara. Only downside is that the marinara was cold, but the twists were nicely baked with ooey-gooey cheese inside. Next came the pizzas. Each pizza had a nice thin-ish crust, crispy and nicely salted, with generous toppings on each slice. You can tell that the people who make these items care about what goes out to the customer. We loved our time there and even our friends from New York said that they loved this pizza...and that says a lot! We can't wait to go back. read more

See all

Food mad great, lots of choices and the salad was fantastic! Prices seem fair and atmosphere is great... this place has minimal tables and chairs great for a party of 6 or less! Excellent choice for pizza and friendly great service! read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Just an empty box to remember! - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

We finally found a pizza place that is amazing! Seriously, everything we got here was so good, so fresh and so flavorful. We ordered for pick up and it was ready quickly for a Friday night, which was awesome too. My son picked up and he said they were super friendly and the location was nice as well (at Indian Creek plaza). Since we picked up we really can't say too much about the vibe, but I'm sure it's great too. The price point was great, especially for the size and quality. We got the hot honey pepperoni, the BBQ chicken and another one with white sauce that we added pepperoni to. We can't wait to order again. If you're looking for great pizza, definitely give them a try. read more

I was actually pretty impressed with the pizza! They did forget to bring us our fresh tomatoes in the side but happily brought them when we reminded. The lobby is not very big, about 7 tables and some stools at a bar height counter-- which is also cool in itself because the windows along that counter are actually a garage door, so the whole side opens up! Surfer/skater vibe with the decorations and music was playing but at a good level. Our only "complaint" is that they don't serve fountain drinks. Have to purchase a bottled drink if wanted. This would be a great option for dinner during any of the activities that take place in the center! read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Yard Sale pizza with a couple of mods-- no mushrooms, no onions, add pineapple and pepperoncini. - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Extreme Pizza has "by the slice" pizza, which is great if you're hanging out at Indian Creek plaza. We love the unique offerings and quick service. Not a huge amount of seating- mostly to-go here. You'll pay a little more than a fast chain style place, but the quality is definitely there! Worth trying them out if you're in the area. read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Bogus Basin- potato, bacon, green onions oh my! - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Had their pizza at a work function and had to seek their complete menu in Caldwell. I did not have enough belly room to try the entire menu but I highly recommend their "Drag it thru the Garden" and " Everest"!!!! I just need more belly room! read more

It's nice to have a pizza place at lunch where you can just buy a slice, not a 'personal' pizza. Until today, I've only had the pepperoni, which has always been good. Their lunch special now includes a salad. It was a nice fresh salad that I didn't want to stop eating. They're also offering various specialty slices and I took advantage of that by ordering Hawaiian. I'm glad I did! The ham was better than your average ham on pizza. Stop in when you're in downtown Caldwell. It's worth a stop! read more

Extreme Pizza was pretty average--not bad, but nothing outstanding. That said, I really appreciate that they offer so many dairy-free options! It's great to see a place accommodating different dietary needs. I ordered it to-go, and it was ready right on time for the scheduled pickup, which I definitely appreciated. read more

We love their pizza! It's very good and has artisan options. Owners are awesome. However, don't go on a Friday unless you have time to wait. I got my small pizza after 45 minutes and my husbands well after 60 minutes so we didn't get to really enjoy them. His is sitting in our car because didn't have time to eat it. So the visit was a bit of a bust and we wasted time and money. My husband left while I waited for his. Since we already paid, they didn't offer us any compensation and we couldn't leave. Call in orders were getting priority, so next time we will order in advance. read more

Delicious ingredients & amazing combinations. Highly recommend if you're looking for unique flavors or the traditional ones.

My man and I came to Indian creek plaza in Caldwell last night to see the Christmas lights and we decided to give extreme pizza a try for dinner since we could smell the pizza outside and it smelled great! There was a HUGE crowd of people so of course this little pizza establishment was packed so we got our pizza to go. Customer service here was a little funny, and by that I mean there was just young kids working here and the ones at the register were definitely odd... the guy who took our order was friendly but I ran into a slight issue as I have one of those rare payment cards that you can't tap or insert, it needs to be swiped so he excused himself to go to the back of the kitchen area to get a kid who looked at least a few years younger than to come up to the register and that guy proceeded to turn the register screen towards me and had me input my entire card number and info... not sure why he needed someone else to flip a screen to me and then have me do the majority of the work myself but okay. Then that second kid said "okay, we'll make that now and it will be ready in a few minutes" to which my fiancé replied "a few minutes? Like 5 min ?" Then he just awkwardly smiled and giggled "like 20"... okay then, so not a few minutes. Aside from that strange encounter though, the pizza was awesome ! We got the ghost wave and it was phenomenal! I really enjoyed the sweet and spicy flavors with the ghost pepper cheese and the honey, and I look forward to returning for it again. This will be our go to spot for food when in the area. All in all, I'd give it 4.5/5 stars just based on out first experience taking everything into consideration. read more

Never not been excellent. Whenever I have people stay with us from out of town I get a Mr Pestato Head and some pizza with meat and it's always a crowd pleaser. Great staff and high quality every time. read more

Good food, great prices, and owners are awesome. This place supports local organizations so be sure to support them. The location is awesome no matter what time of year. The Plaza is the place to be. But their sandwiches are perfect for take out too. read more

Absolutely love extreme pizza! I have never visited and had a bad experience. The staff is always friendly, and any time they make a mistake, they would quickly remedy the problem. My favorite is their combo pizza and shockingly, they legit use fresh veggies as toppings. Extreme is on the pricey side but absolutely worth it. read more

Food and Service was excellent they went above and beyond by fixing a dish that was on yelp but wasn't on the menu at this location. read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Up the creek pizza, I ate the Afterburners before thinking about taking a photo. - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Great pies, nice firm crust on the bottom and tasty dough. I got a slice of the Everest Pizza and a drink for 8 buck. The slice was about the size of a personal pizza and had tons of meat on it. It was hard to finish, actually, but I couldn't help but do it. I also got a side Caesar salad which was great. Not real big inside, but I heard the owner say he is adding two more tables. Speaking of the owner, he came out and checked to see how we liked the food. We don't make it out to Caldwell that often, but will definitely be back. read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

This was our first time trying this place, my wife's friend had recommended it. Looking at the menu I was a bit skeptical, but though why not. And boy am I glad I did, this is probably the best pizza in Caldwell. Everything about it was near perfect, from the chewy wood-fired crust, to the cheese and sausage. I will definitely be eating here again. read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Indian Creek Bread - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

See all

They make yummy pizza! Their gf pizza crust is also really good. We highly recommend checking them out.

Amazing pizza for a great price. This has become a family favorite. Flavors and quality of ingredient are both great! You can also grab your pizza to go and eat outside on the plaza. Lots of awesome ice cream options walking distance for dessert. read more

Pizza was average at best. Very average. Really it was average. Quite average. Did I mention it was average. Not recommended.

Terribly disappointed!!! We placed our order online. And we're instructed to pick up the order in 25 minutes. When we arrived to pick up our order, they couldn't find the order. They indicated they hadn't received the online order, which we had confirmation of. They told us they would make the order right away. My husband was there for an over an hour, waiting for the order to be ready. We will not be back. read more

The pizza was great. The combinations were creative and the pizza came loaded with toppings! I was most impressed with their salads. I thought ordering salads from a pizza joint meant getting wilted greens with sorely lacking flavors. Not here!!! The spinach salad my friend had was loaded with bacon, feta, tomato's, and the spinach looked so fresh! Oh the portion was good too. I'd definitely go back next time I'm in the area! read more

Ordered from here for the first time in December for a birthday party. Love the flavors and the staff is really kind. We plan on ordering for our wedding because they're affordable for how large they are! read more

I've lived here a long time and this was my first TRUE experience in Caldwell. I literally never go there. That should change because the areas I saw, I really loved. I know Caldwell can be iffy, but I loved what I saw and the downtown are was super nice. We did a Pound Fitness event in the town square? Is that what they call it? Haha! Anyway, that's where we were. Many stores offered free this and free that to promote their businesses to everyone who was at the Pound event. Extreme Pizza gave us all a free slice...well, the first 30 who arrived at the event. Sorry, just remembered that part lol. I was excited to try it because so many people rave about this place. As many of you might recall, I'm a pizza snob hahaha! So I can be super judgey when it comes to pizza. This place was very good. Was it the best? Nah. Would I go back and recommend it, absolutely. Often times, single slices have a different taste to them for some reason vs getting a whole pie. Either way, it was super tasty and hit the spot because I was starving. The staff was super friendly, hardworking people who get your food to you fast and their nice about it. So hard to find friendly people in retail/restaurants anymore lol. These guys and girls were great. One plus, the pizza wasn't overly salty. So many times they are. That's one other reason why people should check it out. The restaurant itself was cute af too. Reminded me of a classic pizza shop with a modern twist to it. I liked it. When/if I go back to Caldwell, probably next Summer hahaha, I'll eat here again. Thanks for reading, Yelpfolkers! Cheers! read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - a man eating pizza in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

The would have been a five-star review, except they couldn't explain why they had take and bake instructions when they don't offer take and bake when you order it one the phone. read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

The menu at Extreme Pizza is fantastic. When my sister and I stumbled upon the establishment, we stopped in for some pies. I asked the cashier for some recommendations. As a vegan, she said she could pick just about any pie on the menu, take away the meat, and have a great meal. I ordered the Mr Pestasto Head. While it was unusual to order a pizza with potato pieces on it, I wasn't disappointed. The flavors and textures of this pie melded together for an amazing meal. I highly recommend this pizza joint in the heart of Caldwell. read more

Such a vast improvement from my original review. Two weeks ago on a Saturday afternoon I went in with my 7 year old granddaughter to for some lunch. The service as top notch and friendly. The restaurant was very clean and sanitary. The pizza was extremely good with good quality toppings. Thankfully, the tomato sauce was not the 'candied' too sweet sauce of other pizza places in the valley. A great experience and a fun place to sit and eat and talk. read more

Hands down worst pizza I have had in the Valley. The sauce was bland, the crust was thin and flavorless and wasn't crispy. It reminded me of pillsbury pizza dough you bake yourself, but not as good. I waited 45 minutes and was extremely disappointed. I tried this place based on the Yelp reviews and the lines out the door. This time the Yelp community let me down. I can't for the life of me understand who is a fan of this extremely low quality pizza, and what all the hype is about. read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

Always delicious pizza and quick even when they're slammed. My whole family loves their pizza sauce and crust!

Quick service, friendly staff, good pizza. Location is awesome, right next to the splash pad in Caldwell, so bring the kids for a play in the water day. Relatively bust, so calling in your order is a good idea. They've got beepers, so if you are sitting outside, you don't need to wait inside. They have a generously portioned daily slice that rotates, Wednesday was the all meat Everest, which was delicious. read more

Extreme Pizza - Caldwell - Everest slice! - Pizza Near Me - Caldwell, Idaho

The personal size pizza is perfect for kids. The credit is soft and yummy. The options are delicious ranging from make your own to specialty pies. I also love the sauce and cheese. The wings are a 3 star because they are small. The wing sauce is good. The staff is friendly and the service is pretty quick. It is also in a perfect location to order and enjoy there or take it out to the plaza. The ambiance is family friendly. read more

I am impressed! And, so happy to see this place in Caldwell. We need more variety. I ordered through door dash. My food arrived quickly, hot, crusty crusts on the pizzas and slightly charred cheese. The ingredients all looked fresh. The flavors are really good. The hummus platter has a wonderful variety of accompaniments like artichoke hearts, kalamata olives and much more. The Hanoi Fever pizza is SO good. It reminded me a bit of a pork banh mi. I also love that they have vegan options. And the price doesn't break the bank. Try them! You won't be disappointed. Five stars and I will definitely be back! read more

See all

I had their pizza a few times lately and is so good! Nice fresh toppings. The only thing I would want better is on the bigger pizzas with lots of toppings needs cooked longer. Needs a more crispy under crust but other then that top notch! read more

I have been searching for a pizza place for two years. Some were okay but not to my taste. Not only is the pizza really good and they lots of crusts options you can eat your pizza at Indian creek square which is a nice environment read more

Great spot. Several options besides pizza. Order ahead or online and beat the line. Small interior, okay for group of 6.

So yummy!! Friendly staff and environment. Just wish they were open a little later. Otherwise it rocked and we will definitely be back

Thought I made a review for this place a great pizza very friendly staff and the salads and pizzas are one of the best we've had in Idaho.

Awesome idea to have the little buzzer to tell us when our pizza was done while we were outside and it was HOT and FRESH! Great pizza! We ordered some today to bring out for our group at the Indian creek plaza while the little ones played at the splash pads! Such a fun day!! read more

We ordered our pizza from Nampa and was driving to Caldwell. we arrived in Caldwell 15 minutes later and BAM!! our pizza was ready, fresh and hot. We love love love this location and the employees working there. Many times we have gotten a pizza and went to Wine down next door to relax. read more

My favorite pizza in Caldwell. Reasonable Prices. And it on the Creek. We go here almost every Tuesday during music nights.